Cayman Islands' same-sex civil partnership law upheld by UK court
London's Privy Council, the final court of appeal for the British overseas territory, rejected an appeal that had argued the Caribbean islands' governor had no right to enact the bill, after lawmakers had rejected similar legislation.
The change in the law came in 2020 following a landmark court case brought by a lesbian couple - Caymanian lawyer Chantelle Day and her partner Vickie Bodden Bush, a nurse - after they were refused permission to marry.
While the Cayman Islands' courts ultimately ruled that the right to marry extended only to opposite-sex couples, they said that same-sex couples were entitled to legal protection "which is functionally equivalent to marriage".
A bill was brought to parliament to put that protection into law, but lawmakers rejected it in July 2020 by nine votes to eight. Then-governor Martyn Roper then enacted the Civil Partnership Law that September, allowing same-sex civil partnerships, saying the action had to be taken to uphold human rights.
Kattina Anglin, a lawyer based in the Cayman Islands, argued that Roper did not have the power to introduce the law under the Cayman Islands' constitution.
But her case was rejected by the islands' courts and her final appeal was dismissed by the Privy Council.
Campaign group Colours Caribbean, which backs the right for same-sex unions, said the ruling "brings much needed clarity that our Bill of Rights is enforceable regardless of the will of a majority in Parliament".
Anglin's lawyers did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside normal working hours.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
18 minutes ago
- The Independent
Watch: Rachel Reeves appears to cry at PMQs after Starmer refuses to guarantee she will stay on
Watch as Rachel Reeves appears to cry during Prime Ministers Questions on Wednesday (2 July), with Kemi Badenoch saying she looks "absolutely miserable'. The Chancellor sat next to Sir Keir Starmer whilst he took a grilling from the Commons on his watered-down welfare bill, which was passed yesterday in a crunch vote. Before the 30-minute session Ms Reeves appeared visibly upset, with Ms Badenoch saying that the Chancellor is 'toast' and a 'human shield" for Sir Keir's 'incompetence'. Ms Badenoch then suggested that the prime minister had failed to confirm whether Ms Reeves would retain her position, saying: 'How awful for the Chancellor that he couldn't confirm that she will stay in place.' A spokesperson for the Chancellor later said that she was dealing with a 'personal matter' and Downing Street quickly confirmed she was 'going nowhere'.
Telegraph
25 minutes ago
- Telegraph
BBC staff accuse corporation of ‘anti-Palestinian racism'
BBC staff have written to Tim Davie accusing the corporation of anti-Palestinian racism and of 'performing PR for the Israeli government and military'. They have called for the removal of Sir Robbie Gibb as a BBC board member because they alleged he has 'close ties' to the Jewish Chronicle. An open letter to the director-general signed by 107 BBC journalists – as well as celebrities including Charles Dance, Mike Leigh, Juliet Stevenson and Miriam Margolyes – claims that the corporation is 'an organisation that is crippled by the fear of being perceived as critical of the Israeli government'. The letter was signed by anonymous staff from BBC News, the World Service, BBC Arabic and Panorama, amongst others. One of the signatories is from the HR department. It has dismayed Jewish staff who fear there is an anti-Israel lobby within BBC News. The letter criticises the BBC's decision to drop a documentary about doctors in Gaza owing to impartiality concerns. The film will be shown tonight on Channel 4 instead. It singles out Sir Robbie, the former No 10 communications director under Theresa May, who is now a BBC Board member and sits on the editorial standards committee. 'We are concerned that an individual with close ties to the Jewish Chronicle, an outlet that has repeatedly published anti-Palestinian and often racist content, has a say in the BBC's editorial decisions in any capacity, including the decision not to broadcast Gaza: Medics Under Fire,' the letter reads. 'We believe the role of Robbie Gibb, both on the Board, and as part of the Editorial Standards Committee, is untenable.' In fact, Sir Robbie resigned as a director of the Jewish Chronicle last year. Sir Robbie and the newspaper have been contacted for comment. The BBC has been embroiled in numerous antisemitism rows including Saturday's Glastonbury coverage, when viewers saw punk-rap duo Bob Vylan chant 'death, death to the IDF' and 'from the river to the sea'. However, the letter claims that the true bias at the BBC is pro-Israeli. 'All too often it has felt that the BBC has been performing PR for the Israeli government and military. This should be a cause of great shame and concern for everyone at the BBC,' it says. The letter, addressed to Mr Davie and the BBC board, claims that the refusal to show the new Gaza documentary is 'just one in a long line of agenda-driven decisions' which 'demonstrates, once again, that the BBC is not reporting 'without fear or favour' when it comes to Israel'. 'As an organisation we have not offered any significant analysis of the UK government's involvement in the war on Palestinians. We have failed to report on weapons sales or their legal implications. These stories have instead been broken by the BBC's competitors. 'This hasn't happened by accident, rather by design. Much of the BBC's coverage in this area is defined by anti-Palestinian racism. The inconsistent manner in which guidance is applied draws into focus the role of Sir Robbie Gibb,' the letter reads. 'Failed to report the reality of the war on Palestinians' The staff claim that the BBC's news coverage ' has failed to report the reality and the context of the war on Palestinians '. Other named signatories on the list include William Dalrymple, the historian; Owen Jones, the Guardian columnist; Misan Harriman, the photographer favoured by the Duchess of Sussex; and Roger McKenzie, international editor of the Morning Star. The BBC commissioned the Gaza documentary, alternatively titled Gaza: Doctors Under Attack, but dropped it after concluding that 'broadcasting this material risked creating a perception of partiality that would not meet the high standards that the public rightly expect of the BBC'. The corporation previously released a documentary, Gaza: How To Survive A War Zone, without establishing that the child narrator was the son of a Hamas minister. A forthcoming report into the broadcast is expected to be highly critical of BBC News fact-checking. Responding to the letter, a BBC spokesperson said: ' Robust discussions amongst our editorial teams about our journalism are an essential part of the editorial process. We have ongoing discussions about coverage and listen to feedback from staff and we think these conversations are best had internally. 'Regarding our coverage of Gaza, the BBC is fully committed to covering the conflict impartially and has produced powerful coverage from the region.'
Daily Mail
41 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Rachel Reeves had 'altercation' before entering Commons as Downing Street responds to teary appearance at PMQs: Live updates
Chancellor Rachel Reeves had an apparent 'altercation' moments before she entered the Commons where she was seen visibly upset during Prime Minister's Questions. Tears streamed down Reeves' face during the session as Prime Minister Keir Starmer refused to guarantee her position following shambolic last-minute changes to the Government's planned welfare reform to stave off a rebellion by Labour backbenchers. Speculation over her future has increased after her emotional appearance in Parliament with a minister claiming she had an 'altercation' with Speaker Lindsay Hoyle.
