CDC's childhood lead program is still defunct, despite Kennedy's claims
The federal government's Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program is not operating, despite Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s claims that it's being funded.
The program's 26 staffers were placed on administrative leave in April, with terminations set for June 2, as part of a broader restructuring of federal agencies within HHS.
To date, none of the staffers have been reinstated, with layoffs set to take effect in less than two weeks, said Erik Svendsen, director of the Division of Environmental Health Science and Practice, a department within the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that includes the childhood lead program.
Kennedy had faced criticism in recent weeks from Democratic senators over the gutting of the program, which assisted state and local health departments with blood lead testing and surveillance.
At a hearing before the Senate Appropriations Committee on Tuesday, Kennedy told Sen. Jack Reed, D-R.I., that the program was still being funded. The week before, he told Sen. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wis., that he had no plans to eliminate it.
But Svendsen said his entire division was dissolved by HHS and can't be easily replaced.
'There are no other experts that do what we do,' he said. 'You can't just push a button and get new people because our areas of public health are so specialized.'
Staffers in the childhood lead program have not received direction about how to transition their work, according to two CDC scientists familiar with the matter.
Even low levels of lead exposure could put children at risk of developmental delays, learning difficulties and behavioral issues. The CDC program offered technical expertise to help under-resourced health departments prevent those outcomes. In 2023, it helped solve a nationwide lead poisoning outbreak linked to cinnamon applesauce. And it was in frequent contact with the Milwaukee Health Department this year after the city discovered dangerous lead levels in some public schools.
Kennedy told Reed on Tuesday that 'we have a team in Milwaukee' offering laboratory and analytics support to the health department.
But the Milwaukee Health Department said that Kennedy's statement was inaccurate, and that the city had not received any federal epidemiological or analytical support related to the lead crisis.
'Unfortunately, in this case, that is another example where the secretary doesn't have his facts straight,' said Mike Totoraitis, the city's health commissioner.
Caroline Reinwald, a spokesperson for the Milwaukee Health Department, said that the federal government's only recent involvement in the lead crisis was 'a short, two-week visit from a single CDC staff member this month, who assisted with the validation of a new instrument in our laboratory.'
'This support was requested independently of the [Milwaukee Public Schools] crisis and was part of a separate, pre-existing need to expand our lab's long-term capacity for lead testing,' Reinwald said in a statement.
The Department of Health and Human Services has said it will continue efforts to eliminate childhood lead poisoning through a newly created department called the Administration for a Healthy America. But Democratic lawmakers and environmental health groups question how the work can continue without reinstating staffers.
'Despite what you told me last week, that you have no intention of eliminating this program, you fired the entire office responsible for carrying it out,' Baldwin told Kennedy at Tuesday's hearing. 'Your decision to fire staff and eliminate offices is endangering children, including thousands of children in Milwaukee.'
HHS did not respond to a request for comment.
Kennedy did not offer new details about his agency's restructuring plan at the hearing, citing a court order that compelled the Trump administration to pause efforts to downsize the federal government.
Milwaukee's lead crisis became clear to health officials in February, when the city's health department identified dangerous levels of the toxin in school classrooms, hallways and common areas, due to lead dust and deteriorating lead-based paint.
Before the childhood lead program was gutted, the CDC had been meeting with the Milwaukee Health Department on a weekly basis to come up with a plan to screen tens of thousands of students for lead poisoning, Totoraitis said.
The city's health department asked the CDC on March 26 to send staffers to help, Totoraitis said, but the agency fired its childhood lead team on April 1 and denied Milwaukee's request two days later.
'This is the first time in at least 75 years that the CDC has ever denied an Epi-Aid request, so it's a pretty historic moment,' he said, referring to a request for the CDC to investigate an urgent public health problem.
To date, the Milwaukee Health Department has identified more than 100 schools built before 1978, when the federal government banned consumer uses of lead-based paints. Around 40 of those have been inspected, Totoraitis said. Six schools have closed since the start of the year due to lead contamination, and only two have reopened.
Around 350 students in Milwaukee have been screened for lead poisoning out of 44,000 identified as having a potential risk, Totoraitis said. The city has confirmed one case linked to lead exposure in school, and two more linked to exposures at both school and home. The health department said it is investigating an additional four cases, which may involve multiple sources of exposure.
Totoraitis said the department is accustomed to looking for lead in homes and rental units, but the CDC was supposed to help them scale that operation to inspect larger buildings. CDC staffers were also supposed to help set up lead screening clinics and investigate where kids had been exposed, he said.
While the health department is handling those efforts on its own now, Totoraitis said it may not have the capacity to screen everyone in a timely manner. He estimated that the department could manage around 1,000 to 1,200 cases of childhood lead poisoning a year. That includes testing kids' blood lead levels, treating lead poisoning with chelation therapy (which removes heavy metals from the bloodstream) and eliminating exposures in the home by replacing windows and doors.
Totoraitis said he's hoping to hire two of the terminated CDC employees for at least a couple of weeks to help address lingering questions about how to manage the crisis.
Better yet, he said, 'I keep hoping to get an email from them saying, 'Hey, we got our jobs back.''
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
8 hours ago
- NBC News
FDA grants limited approval to new Covid vaccine from Moderna
Moderna announced this weekend that the Food and Drug Administration approved its lower-dose Covid-19 vaccine for adults 65 and older, as well as people ages 12 to 64 with at least one medical condition that increases their risk for severe Covid. The approval, which is limited to individuals who have previously received a Covid vaccine, was granted by the FDA on Friday. Moderna said in a Saturday press release that the new vaccine should be available in the U.S. in time for the 2025-26 respiratory virus season, which starts in the fall. Moderna is also updating its original vaccine to target the LP.8.1 variant this fall. The company submitted an application in May for the FDA to approve the updated formula. The newly approved vaccine, mNEXSPIKE, contains one-fifth of of Moderna's original Covid vaccine dose, Spikevax. It is intended as an alternative for individuals who prefer a lower-dose option, not as a replacement for existing Covid vaccines. But young, healthy adults won't be eligible to receive it, despite their inclusion in Moderna's clinical trial. The FDA imposed similar limitations on Novavax's Covid vaccine when it approved the shot last month. But Friday marks the first time the FDA has greenlit a vaccine since the Trump administration's call for tighter restrictions on vaccine eligibility and approvals. The FDA said last month that it would limit its approval of updated Covid shots moving forward to older adults and younger people with underlying medical conditions. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. also announced last week that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention would no longer recommend Covid vaccines for healthy children and pregnant women. The CDC website appears to soften that recommendation, suggesting that parents can speak with a doctor about vaccinating children 6 months and older. The Trump administration has also said new Covid vaccines must undergo clinical trials with an inert placebo — meaning some participants would receive the new vaccine while others would receive an inactive substance like saline, to compare results. Many new vaccines are tested against older, approved versions, a method considered to be more ethical since using an inert placebo would mean withholding the benefit of a vaccine from study participants. Moderna's new vaccine was tested this way, using what's known as an 'active comparator.' In a trial of around 11,400 participants ages 12 and up, the new vaccine generated higher antibody levels than the company's original Covid shot, according to Moderna. The company also said the new vaccine had fewer local reactions, which typically include redness or swelling at the injection site. Systemic reactions, which may include fever, headaches or chills, were comparable between the shots. The main side effects of mNEXSPIKE were injection site pain, fatigue, headache and muscle pain, Moderna said in its press release.
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
New Covid variant 'under monitoring' after spike in cases and hospitalisations
First identified in January, NB. 1.8.1 is spreading quickly across multiple countries, leading to an increase in cases and hospitalisations, the World Health Organisation said A new coronavirus variant has been labelled as "under monitoring" by the World Health Organisation following a spike in cases and hospitalisations. First identified on January 22 2025, NB. 1.8.1 is a derivative of the Omicron strain. The variant is causing concern among health experts after being identified in multiple countries including popular holiday destinations like Egypt, Thailand and the Maldives. The WHO has warned that the new strain is now responsible for more than 10 per cent of all infections and is already the dominant strain in Hong Kong and China. The Centre of Disease Control (CDC) in the US has also identified cases in a number of states including New York, California, Arizona, Ohio, Washington, and Rhode Island. Despite saying that the variant is currently being monitored, WHO said in their report that the current risk to the public is deemed to be low - and currently approved vaccines are expected to "remain effective to this variant against symptomatic and severe disease." WHO said that despite an increase in cases and hospitalisations, currently there is no indication that this variant leads to more severe illness than other variants in circulation. Even though NB.1.8.1 has been found in popular holiday destinations, the WHO says there is no need for travel or trade restrictions at this time, Wales Online reports. The organisation urges countries to stay alert and adjust their responses as needed, but does not recommend closing borders or limiting travel. The official report states: "WHO recommends that countries remain vigilant, adapt to evolving epidemiological trends, and leverage Covid-19 management strategies to strengthen systems for all respiratory disease threats. Member States should continue offering Covid-19 vaccines in line with WHO recommendations." Health experts at the CDC say that symptoms may vary in accordance with the variant, however they will likely be similar to the typical symptoms of Covid-19. These include fever or chills, cough, shortness of breath or difficulty breathing, sore throat, congestion or runny nose, new loss of taste or smell, fatigue, muscle or body aches, headache, nausea or vomiting, diarrhoea. This week, Lara Herrero Associate Professor and Research Leader in Virology and Infectious Disease at Griffith University, said that thanks to multiple mutations, the new strain "may infect cells more efficiently than earlier strains." Professor Herrero explained: "It's possible a person infected with NB.1.8.1 may be more likely to pass the virus on to someone else, compared to earlier variants. The evidence so far suggests NB.1.8.1 may spread more easily and may partially sidestep immunity from prior infections or vaccination. These factors could explain its rise in sequencing data. "But importantly, the WHO has not yet observed any evidence it causes more severe disease compared to other variants. Reports suggest symptoms of NB.1.8.1 should align closely with other Omicron subvariants. Common symptoms include sore throat, fatigue, fever, mild cough, muscle aches and nasal congestion. Gastrointestinal symptoms may also occur in some cases." The WHO report reads: "SARS-CoV-2 continues to evolve, and between January and May 2025, there were shifts in global SARS-CoV-2 variant dynamics. At the beginning of the year, the most prevalent variant tracked by WHO at the global level was XEC, followed by KP.3.1.1. In February, circulation of XEC began to decline while that of LP.8.1 increased, with the latter becoming the most detected variant in mid-March. Since mid-April, the circulation of LP.8.1 has been slightly declining as NB.1.8.1 is increasingly being detected."
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
How different kitchen items can cause life-changing illnesses
Kitchens are usually home to the most delicious items in your house, but mounting research has revealed that almost every appliance can also make you incredibly sick. From countertops and sinks to refrigerators and microwaves, scientists have found some disturbing links between these items and conditions like cancer, dementia, and sepsis. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has estimated that 48 million people in the U.S. get sick from foodborne diseases each year, leading to 128,000 hospitalizations and 3,000 deaths. While food poisoning cases involving salmonella, listeria, norovirus, and E coli contribute to many kitchen-related illnesses and deaths, contaminated food is not the only thing people have to worry about. Here are 11 of the most concerning ways danger could be lurking in your kitchen. Countertops Kitchen counters can harbor a load of harmful pathogens due to poor cleaning habits and cross-contamination between different foods being prepared. Dr Darin Detwiler, a food safety expert at Northeastern University in Boston, recently told Daily Mail that the number of food poisoning outbreaks has continued to grow since the CDC's last full review of the problem in 2019. 'Each time you wipe a countertop or rinse a dish, you risk transferring millions of harmful microbes to your hands, cooking tools, and food,' Dr Detwiler added. Sponges The tool many people use to clean their kitchen counters may be an even more dangerous hiding place for germs. The moist environment of a sponge makes them notoriously one of the dirtiest items in the kitchen. Food safety expert Sylvia Anderson told the Daily Mail that a sponge's porous structure and ability to soak up water makes it an ideal incubator for microorganisms. 'Bacteria from sponges can transfer to dishes, counters, and hands, leading to foodborne illnesses or infections,' she added. In 2017 a study in Scientific Reports analyzed microbial communities in used kitchen sponges and found 45 billion bacteria per square centimeter of sponge. That same report revealed that these microbial colonies can cause skin infections, especially among individuals with weakened immune systems. Specifically, scientists have found that dirty sponges can carry Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, potentially deadly bacteria that cause skin infections if transferred to hands or open wounds. Sinks Another place where sponges are often used or kept, kitchen sinks are notorious traps for harmful pathogens that can cause food poisoning. They can become reservoirs for pathogens like E coli, salmonella, and pseudomonas due to food residue and moisture building up on the sink surface or in the drains. A 2016 study in Journal of Applied Microbiology found that kitchen sinks are often more contaminated than toilets, with biofilms harboring bacteria that can contaminate food or utensils, leading to food poisoning. Cutting boards Even if someone tries to stay safe by practicing good hygiene in their kitchen, germs will find you. Cutting boards are filled with harmful bacteria, and are perhaps the riskiest kitchen utensil when it comes to contracting infections. 'Cross-contamination is the biggest concern. If you use the same chopping board for raw meat and vegetables without washing it, bacteria like Campylobacter or E coli can transfer to ready-to-eat foods, leading to serious illness,' Anderson told the Daily Mail. One 2023 study by the UK's Food Standards Agency found about half of household cutting boards harbor bacteria. These pathogens include salmonella and campylobacter, which are leading causes of diarrheal disease. The study concluded that you may be safer opting for a wooden cutting board over a plastic one. 'Wooden boards are naturally antimicrobial but need regular oiling to prevent cracking. Plastic boards, while dishwasher safe, can develop deep cuts that trap bacteria, making thorough cleaning difficult,' Anderson warned. Dishwashers A new study has found that dishwashers may be a secret cause of the rising rates of dementia throughout the world. Scientists from the University of Queensland warned that placing plastic items in the dishwasher leads to the release of toxic microplastics, which can then contaminate other utensils. Microplastics are small enough to breach biological barriers such as the blood-brain barrier, raising concerns about their potential impact on human health and brain function. These particles have been linked not only to dementia, but also to cancer, heart disease, and fertility issues. The 2025 study found that a single dishwasher cycle involving plastic plates, bowls, cups, and cutlery can release nearly a million particles. Refrigerators According to Professor Judith Evans, of London South Bank University, and Oleskii Omelchenko, a PhD researcher at the Quadram Institute, your refrigerator could be a breeding ground for disease. Although this everyday appliance is meant to keep your food fresh and safe, fridges can help bacteria grow if the temperature is not right. However, the experts warn that even a 'well-chilled' fridge could harbor invisible dangers if you don't take the right precautions. A 2020 study in Food Control found that refrigerator temperatures above 41°F (5°C) can allow pathogens like listeria or salmonella to survive, potentially contributing to foodborne illness. 'Part of the problem is that many fridges lack an accurate, accessible way to monitor their internal temperature,' Evans and Omelchenko said in The Conversation. 'On top of that, every time you open the door, warm air rushes in. The longer the door stays open, especially if you're lingering while choosing a snack, the more the internal temperature climbs toward room temperature, creating a more suitable environment for bacteria to thrive.' Gas stoves According to Dr Ben Ewald, gas stoves are among the most dangerous household appliances today. 'Living with a gas stove is the health equivalent of living with a smoker,' he warned. Studies have shown that tiny but harmful nanoparticles, such as nitrogen dioxide, produced by the flames are the perfect size to flow into the human respiratory system and stick to your lungs, triggering several respiratory illnesses. Dr Ewald warned that breathing in these particles while cooking can lead to acute asthma, increased allergies, and even pneumonia. Scientists said the flames also release formaldehyde, which is another respiratory irritant, and tiny amounts of benzene, a known carcinogen. A 2023 study in Environmental Health Perspectives found that 12.7 per cent of childhood asthma cases in the U.S. could be attributed to gas stove emissions. Cookware As for the pots and pans you're placing on these gas burners, non-stick cookware is coated with chemicals now linked to severe hormone dysfunction. Scientists have repeatedly warned about the dangers of PFAS. These toxins are called 'forever chemicals' because they can linger in the environment for thousands of years. Multiple studies have been linked to everything from cancer to infertility. Dr Nathan Cohen, an expert in environmental medicine and public health at Mount Sinai Health in New York, said that these recent findings, 'should serve as a warning to women everywhere about the potentially harmful effects of PFAS when they are planning to conceive.' 'We can minimize PFAS exposure by avoiding foods that are associated with higher levels of these chemicals and by purchasing PFAS-free products.' Microwaves Microwave ovens can harbor bacteria if not cleaned properly, as food splatters create environments for microbial growth. A 2024 study in Frontiers in Microbiology investigated bacterial contamination in household appliances, including microwaves, and found bacteria like Staphylococcus aureus in uncleaned microwaves. These bacteria can cause infections if transferred to food or surfaces. S. aureus can cause severe infections, including sepsis, if it enters the bloodstream through contaminated food or wounds. Laundry machines Cancer can be caused by exposure to toxic chemicals, radiation, or environmental pollutants. Laundry machines can contribute to cancer risk by dispersing chemical residues from detergents, solvents from dry-cleaned clothes, or microplastics into the clothes you wear. Some detergents may also contain cancer-causing compounds that persist on clothes or in the environment long after the wash cycle. The 2011 Air Quality, Atmosphere and Health study confirmed that scented detergents and dryer sheets release cancer-causing volatile organic compounds like acetaldehyde and benzene through dryer vents, posing a potential risk of breathing in these toxins. Garbage cans Botulism is a rare but serious illness caused by the botulinum neurotoxin and produced by Clostridium botulinum, a spore-forming bacterium. It leads to paralysis, which can be life-threatening if untreated. Household garbage cans could contribute to botulism by harboring Clostridium botulinum spores in food waste, particularly from improperly canned or spoiled food. A 2018 case report in Journal of Medical Case Reports described two cases of foodborne botulism in Germany linked to home-canned green beans. The infections caused cranial nerve paralysis and descending quadriparesis - weakness or paralysis starting in the upper body and spreading to the legs - in a 47-year-old woman and her husband. The diagnosis was confirmed by detecting botulinum toxin type A in the woman's blood. Symptoms of the condition included dizziness, double vision, slurred speech, and breathing problems severe enough to need a machine to help them breathe.
