Dynasty or Democracy? Nurul Izzah's Comeback Sparks Uproar in PKR as Rafizi Cries Foul
Anwar Ibrahim is renowned for his out-of-the-box thinking, which has kept him politically resilient in Malaysia despite the many formidable challenges he has faced throughout his career.
His political journey took a dramatic turn in 1998, when he was abruptly dismissed from his post and subsequently jailed. This shocking episode ignited the Reformasi movement—a grassroots push for political reform—that steadily gained momentum and ultimately contributed to the downfall of Barisan Nasional in the historic 2018 general election.
Despite decades of political turbulence, betrayals, and backstabbing—common features of Malaysia's political landscape—Anwar remained a central figure. His persistence was rewarded in 2022 when he finally ascended to the prime ministership.
However, controversy continues to follow him. Within his own party, Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR), Anwar is now facing accusations of employing the very same political maneuvers he once condemned. Critics allege that he manipulated internal party dynamics to pave the way for his daughter to defeat the most serious challenger to his leadership, Economy Minister Rafizi Ramli—positioning her as his political heir apparent.
Yet, unlike past instances where his strategic moves garnered public support, this time, his actions within the party are not resonating with the electorate. This disconnect has cast a shadow over PKR and the broader Pakatan Harapan coalition, which now governs in an uneasy alliance with Ahmad Zahid Hamidi's Barisan Nasional.
To fully grasp the challenges Nurul Izzah faces in the months and years leading up to the next general election, it's important to consider the warnings Rafizi Ramli raised during his Hiruk campaign ahead of the recent party elections—an election he ultimately lost to Nurul.
The country now watches closely to see whether Rafizi will follow through on his threat to resign from his ministerial post in Anwar Ibrahim's cabinet following his defeat. His campaign had drawn massive crowds and strong support both online and at town hall meetings—support that Nurul currently lacks. Her political capital diminished significantly after she stepped away from active politics following her marriage to a Chinese-Malaysian analyst and her unexpected loss in the 2022 general election for the Permatang Pauh seat, a long-time family stronghold in Penang.
In the lead-up to the recent party elections, Nurul Izzah made a sudden return to the political scene. She reclaimed her title as the 'Reformasi Princess' and mounted a challenge for the party's deputy presidency, directly opposing Rafizi. Undeterred by accusations of nepotism and allegations of attempting to establish a political dynasty—given that her mother is an MP and her father is the sitting Prime Minister—Nurul pressed forward with her campaign. See also Key questions as flight MH17 remembered five years on
However, Rafizi has accused her of aligning with entrenched party 'cartels'—groups allegedly involved in money politics—who he claims manipulate internal elections by sidelining competent candidates and consolidating control within the party machinery.
Nurul Izzah will have to live with the accusations, especially as videos have surfaced showing individuals who voted for her allegedly spending money or making statements suggesting they were acting on instructions from Anwar. These videos imply that funds—reportedly sent by billionaires to the Prime Minister—were used during the party elections but were not officially recorded as campaign expenses.
But not everything is cloudy for Nurul.
A PAS leader in Kelantan, the bedrock of the Parti Islam Se-Malaysia or PAS, described the upcoming general election as an unpredictable battleground, warning that a united PH-BN coalition could lead to PAS losing up to 15 state assembly seats in Kelantan, excluding already vulnerable areas. He urged PAS to move beyond rhetoric, stay organized, and engage with the public to avoid defeat.
He urged PAS's Muslimat (women's wing) and supporters to prepare diligently for the 16th general election, stressing the need for proactive leadership to counter the PH-BN coalition. He cautioned against complacency, likening it to the hare that starts strong but fails in the race, emphasizing this as a real lesson, not a scare tactic.
He highlighted Nurul Izzah Anwar's election as PKR deputy president as a significant challenge, particularly for Muslim women, viewing it as a strategic political move with national implications. Mohd Amar noted the influential appeal of women in politics, especially among the majority female voters, warning that without vigilance, this could reshape the country's political landscape.
Despite significant backlash from PKR supporters on social media over Rafizi Ramli's ousting from party leadership, a key advantage for PKR and the PH coalition is their current position in power. Anwar Ibrahim hopes the new leadership, particularly Nurul Izzah Anwar, will generate fresh momentum for both the party and the coalition. With time being limited, there is optimism that Nurul Izzah will leverage her charisma to unite the party, rally supporters, and mobilize voters, positioning herself as a strong candidate for Malaysia's first female Prime Minister.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Independent Singapore
27 minutes ago
- Independent Singapore
Asia must stay flexible and avoid revenge moves, warns top economist
Monetary Authority of Singapore (Credit: MAS) SINGAPORE: Edward S. Robinson, Deputy Managing Director (Economic Policy) and Chief Economist at the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS), warned Asia's economies against getting involved in or initiating punitive trade measures as trade barriers surge all over the world. Speaking at the 12th Asian Monetary Policy Forum, Robinson advised that such reactions can do more damage than good, especially for Asia's tiny, open economies that profoundly depend on transnational trade, as reported by the Singapore Business Review. 'For Asia's small open economies, global tariffs pose a major challenge,' Robinson said. 'With trade dependencies in the region sometimes exceeding 100% of GDP (gross domestic product), the ripple effects may be severe: reduced production, and possibly, renewed capital outflows.' Tariffs hurt both sides of the trade divide Robinson stressed that isolationist strategies such as tariffs regularly do not carry their envisioned economic gains. Rather than fixing trade disparities, they escalate costs for households and businesses, and hinder economic productivity. He contended that the genuine drivers behind the deterioration in manufacturing employment rest in deeper operational deviations such as computerisation and ever-changing consumer behaviors, not trade shortages. 'Both the targeted and tariff-imposing economies suffer,' he said, underscoring the broader economic fallout from such policies. Call for integration and structural reforms Instead of engaging in trade wars, Robinson advised Asian legislators and politicians to exert more effort in strengthening regional trade integration and transition toward high-growth domains such as services and digital economies. He also underscored the necessity of systemic reforms, including workforce competency building, to better adjust to the changing international economic scenario. Robinson highlighted that régimes must prudently install and position the suitable policy mechanisms, steered by cautious and calculated forecasting, to direct the international economy toward a stable, well-adjusted, and sustainable fine-tuning path. He cautions that any unexpected or inept movements, labeled as 'fragmented impulses,' could undermine the international monetary structure. Such unsystematic moves, he warns, bring the danger of activating grave financial disturbances, possibly ending in a protracted and extensive global downturn. Thus, attaining stability requires not only the appropriate tools but also lucid and concerted global policymaking. See also N. Korea warns US-S. Korea drills will affect nuclear talks According to Robinson, 'These efforts will not only help manage short-term shocks but also build long-term resilience across Asia's economies.'
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
Jail for man who offered S$53 'kopi money' to officers who caught him selling sexual enhancement drugs
SINGAPORE: A man caught selling sexual enhancement medication in Geylang repeatedly tried to offer S$53 (US$41) in "kopi money'' to two officers so that they would not investigate him over the illicit activity. Chen Shaowei, who offered the bribe no fewer than seven times, said he was under the impression that - like officers from some other countries - these officers would "go away" once given the money to "drink coffee". Chen, a 39-year-old Chinese national, was sentenced to 14 weeks' jail on Tuesday (Jun 3), after he pleaded guilty to one count of corruption and one count of using criminal force on a senior security officer who seized his sexual enhancement medication. Another two charges of a similar nature were considered for his sentencing. Chen was spotted beside a makeshift table with what appeared to be sexual enhancement medication on May 31, 2023. The two officers who interacted with him then were Mr Mohammad Alfa Ramli, a technical specialist employed by the Health Sciences Authority (HSA) and Mr Chai Kit Wey, an Aetos Auxillary Police Officer attached to the HotSpots Operation Team of the HSA. The two were partners were on an operation to disrupt the sale of illegal health products at Geylang that day. Upon seeing Chen, Mr Alfa approached him and placed his hand on his shoulder. Chen tried to flee but Mr Alfa patted him on the shoulders and told him to sit down. As Chen could not speak English, Mr Alfa asked Mr Chai for help to obtain his particulars, but Chen refused to cooperate. He tried to deny that the medication was his and dithered when asked when he had arrived in Singapore. At one point, Chen took out S$53 in cash from his back pocket and offered it to Mr Chai. Mr Alfa pushed Chen's arm away. They warned Chen against bribery, but Chen persisted in offering the "kopi money", even after he was placed under arrest. "When the accused was later interviewed, he admitted that he had learned the word 'kopi' while in Malaysia and that he was under the impression that Mr Chai and Mr Alfa were like the officers in China and Malaysia – that is, that they would 'let (him) go' and 'go away' once he gives them money to 'drink coffee'," the prosecution said. Chen admitted to offering both officers "money for kopi" so that they would stop asking him about his stay in Singapore and about the medication. He was arrested and released on bail on Jun 1, 2023. PUSHED OFFICER About a year later, while on bail, Chen had another encounter with officers over sexual enhancement drugs. On May 24, 2024, officers from the Certis CISCO Auxiliary Police Force seized the medication from a red container in Geylang after a tip-off from a owner of a nearby store. At about 10.27pm, Chen approached the officers aggressively and tried to snatch the bag of medication. He shouted in Mandarin to ask why the officers were taking his drugs when he did not display them. One of the officers tried to hold off Chen, who then pushed him in the chest and upper arms while trying to grab the bag. He then shoved the officer holding the bag, grabbed the stash and fled. The incident was captured by a body-worn camera. Chen was arrested the next day and released on bail. Chen's lawyer John Koh from Avalon Law Corporation sought three months' jail for his client, less than the prosecution's proposed four-month jail term. Mr Koh said Chen had offered bribes in the "spur of the moment". Similarly for his client's charge of using criminal force, Mr Koh said the offence was in "the heat of the moment".
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
‘Warm' first meeting of Indonesia President Prabowo, Vice-President Gibran and political rival Megawati fuels rift-healing talk
JAKARTA: Politicians from key factions have welcomed a rare joint public appearance of Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto, Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka and rival leader Megawati Soekarnoputri, with analysts describing it as a 'symbolic' gesture of reconciliation. The national event in Jakarta on Monday (Jun 2) marked the first time the trio was seen together after Prabowo was inaugurated last October, although he and Megawati had a closed-door meeting in April. It was also the first time Megawati – chairwoman of the country's largest political party, the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P) – was sighted in public with Gibran after he and his father, former President Joko Widodo, were officially expelled from the PDI-P last December. They were at a ceremony to commemorate the birth of Indonesia's founding ideology, Pancasila, at the Pancasila Building in Central Jakarta. Prabowo served as the inspector of the ceremony while Megawati is the head of the steering committee at the Pancasila Ideology Development Agency. She was among the dignitaries seated in the front row along with former vice-presidents Try Sutrisno and Jusuf Kalla. Photos circulating of the event show Prabowo accompanying Megawati as they entered the building, with Gibran following behind. Megawati's PDI-P is the single largest party in parliament with nearly one-fifth of seats, but is still dwarfed by the Advance Indonesia Coalition, a super-coalition of parties aligned with Prabowo's Gerindra party. PDI-P is the only major party that has not joined the Advance Indonesia Coalition, also known as KIM Plus. Tensions have run high ever since Widodo did not back PDI-P's presidential candidate Ganjar Pranowo in the February 2024 presidential election. Instead, Widodo was widely said by observers to have tacitly supported Prabowo, whose running mate was his oldest child Gibran. PDI-P secretary general Hasto Kristiyanto was named a suspect last December in the bribery of former General Elections Commission commissioner Wahyu Setiawan from 2017 to 2022. Following Hasto's arrest in February this year, Megawati ordered leaders of her party to withdraw from a brainstorming retreat convened by Prabowo. In a sign of thawing relations, however, Prabowo visited Megawati, a former president, at her residence on Jalan Teuku Umar on Apr 7. They were running mates in the 2009 presidential elections, with Prabowo the vice-presidential candidate in Megawati's failed bid to defeat incumbent Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono. 'HEALING THE DEEP RIFT' Political analyst Hendri Satrio told Jakarta Globe that the visual cues on Monday of placing Megawati at the forefront were 'not just protocol' and carried a symbolic meaning. Another analyst told CNA the latest meeting on Monday reflects some effort by the administration to 'reconcile' with Megawati, 'a figure who represents the weight of the opposition force'. 'It is a first step to healing the deep rift that started when Jokowi backed his son Gibran for vice-president and Prabowo later for president instead of PDI-P's candidate Ganjar,' said Julia Lau, a senior fellow and coordinator of the Indonesia Studies Programme at Singapore's ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute. Widodo, Gibran and Widodo's son-in-law Bobby Nasution were officially expelled from PDI-P in December last year for 'openly going against the party's decision to back its presidential pair' and instead 'supporting the rival pair from the KIM'. The PDI-P had supported Widodo's rise in power from mayor of Surakarta to governor of Jakarta, then Indonesia's president for two terms from 2014 to 2024. PRABOWO SAYS MEGAWATI LOOKS 'THINNER' As Prabowo and Gibran greeted national figures at a waiting room prior to the ceremony, a light-hearted exchange was caught on camera between the president and Megawati. 'You look thinner now. That's amazing, your weight loss programme appears to be working,' Prabowo told Megawati, as quoted by Jakarta Post. Secretary-general of Prabowo's Gerindra party, Ahmad Muzani, who witnessed the interaction, described the atmosphere as 'warm, familial and full of laughter', Jakarta Globe reported. 'This is a beautiful image for Indonesia,' said Muzani, who is also the House Speaker and chairman of the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR). 'On a day when we honour the foundation of our nation, our leaders showed unity, exchanged greetings and sat together in a spirit of togetherness.' Pancasila Day is a national holiday usually celebrated on Jun 1 in Indonesia, but Muzani said the official ceremony was held on Jun 2 to accommodate Megawati. 'We adjusted the schedule for her,' Muzani said, as quoted by national news agency Antara. Deputy Speaker of the MPR, Hidayat Nur Wahid, told Antara the meeting 'will be seen as a positive signal for unity and a commitment to upholding the values of Pancasila'. Indonesia's national ideology comprises five principles: Belief in one God, civilised humanity, national unity, democracy and social justice. The PDI-P described the meeting as a display of statesmanship and a reflection of the longstanding friendship between the two leaders that goes 'beyond political considerations'. 'Their relationship has been well-established for a long time, both in political contexts and especially on strategic matters related to the state ideology of Pancasila,' PDI-P chairman Said Abdullah told news outlet Kompas in a written response. Their rapport, he added, was also reflected in Prabowo's speech at the ceremony, where he made mention of Megawati before other national figures. 'It was clear that President Prabowo accorded great respect to Megawati, not only as Indonesia's fifth president but also as a Chair of the Pancasila Ideology Development Agency Steering Committee,' Said said. Another interaction at the ceremony that drew attention was that between Gibran and former vice-president Try Sutrisno. Try Sutrisno was among the prominent figures who endorsed a statement in April urging a reshuffle of Prabowo's Cabinet and calling for Gibran's impeachment, citing the impropriety of a constitutional court decision that had paved the way for him to contest in the presidential election.
