Chhattisgarh high court declines to intervene in tata projects and CHiPS bank guarantee dispute
The petition concerned the encashment of a performance bank guarantee of Rs 167.46 crore by the Chhattisgarh Infotech Promotion Society (CHiPS), the nodal agency for driving IT growth and implementing IT and e-Governance initiatives in the state.
A division bench of Justice Narendra Kumar Vyas and Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad heard the petition filed by Tata Projects. The company sought restoration of the status quo ante, asking for the return of the Rs 167.46 crore to State Bank of India and the issuance of an identical bank guarantee. Alternatively,
Tata
Projects requested CHiPS to deposit the amount in an interest-bearing account until the dispute's resolution.
According to court records, CHiPS issued a Request for Proposal (RFP) for the selection of a Master System Integrator (MSI) for the BharatNet Phase-II Project in Chhattisgarh. A dispute arose between Tata Projects and CHiPS during the commercial contract.
Previously, Tata Projects filed a writ petition, in which a single bench of the high court on 2 July 2024, granted interim protection, restraining respondents from encashing the performance bank guarantee.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around
Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List
Undo
This writ petition was later disposed of on 30 April 2025, with the court re-delegating the parties to approach the Commercial Court.
Subsequently, Tata Projects filed an application under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The Commercial Court, on 3 May 2025, ordered an interim status quo regarding the invocation of the bank guarantee.
However, after the respondents filed their reply, the Commercial Court disposed of the application on 6 May 2025, vacating the status quo order.
The initiation of the bank guarantee encashment process led Tata Projects to approach the highcourt.
Senior Counsel Kishore Bhaduri, appearing for Tata Projects, argued that CHiPS's conduct was fraudulent and high-handed, misleading the court and misusing its power by attempting to invoke the bank guarantee.
Counsel for the respondents and the state argued that the writ petition was not maintainable, as Tata Projects had remedies available under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, or under the Chhattisgarh Madhyashtham Adhikaran Act, 1983.
The high court observed that an arbitration clause existed in the agreement and that Tata Projects already approached the Commercial Court. The court ruled that the writ petition was not maintainable at this juncture.
However, it granted Tata Projects the liberty to pursue statutory remedies before the Commercial Court. The court also clarified that the respondents were free to raise objections regarding the maintainability of any application.
The high court directed the Commercial Court to consider and decide any interim application or application under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, filed by the petitioner expeditiously and in accordance with the law.
The high court also made it clear that it did not express any opinion on the merits of the case, leaving it to the Commercial Court to decide independently.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
America's Stock-Market Dominance Is an Emergency for Europe
The London Stock Exchange overhauled the ceremony for welcoming new companies to its ranks last year, adding confetti cannons, slick videos and cinematic music. It has mostly been used for such events as product launches and anniversaries. So far this year, according to Dealogic, six companies have gone public in the U.K., raising $208 million, the lowest level in three decades of data. It isn't much better across the English Channel, despite surging stock markets. Initial public offerings in continental Europe have nearly halved in value compared with last year. Fundraising in the U.S., meanwhile, has jumped 38% to around $40 billion, while IPOs more than doubled in value in Hong Kong after a fallow patch. Tech stars such as the Swedish 'buy now, pay later' company Klarna and the British chip designer Arm are eschewing local markets to list in New York. And stock-market heavyweights are disappearing, either bought out by American companies or moving their listings stateside, where business is growing faster. Examples are Wise, the British payments company, and the sports-betting company Flutter Entertainment. 'For the Europeans who are responsible for the future, this is a material wake-up call,' said Stéphane Boujnah, chief executive officer of Euronext, which owns seven stock exchanges in the region. Europe doesn't want to 'be just a zone between America and Asia,' he added. Amsterdam and London pioneered the creation of public stock trading centuries ago, raising money for ship voyages to Asia, Africa and the Caribbean that forged Europe's colonial empires. Now, Europe's stock markets face a crisis of inactivity. Not only are listing volumes moribund—exchanges are shrinking too. Hastened by a global shift toward greater private ownership of businesses, the number of listings in London has fallen by a fifth in five years, to about 1,600. London's total market value stands at about $5 trillion, while Nvidia alone is worth $4.4 trillion. The exodus looks likely to continue. Next year Wise and the machinery specialist Ashtead are set to move their main listings to the U.S. from the LSE, which is part of the broader London Stock Exchange Group. Speculation has swirled that AstraZeneca—the largest company in the FTSE 100—could do the same. In a recent interview in New York, CEO Pascal Soriot declined to comment on whether he is considering moving the listing. 'We are very committed to the U.K.,' he said. 'But the reality is, over time, the investments are moving to the U.S.' AstraZeneca recently pledged to invest $50 billion in the U.S. by 2030. European leaders see the withering of these historic exchanges as an emergency—and one of the culprits behind Europe's economic stagnation, low productivity, and the widening wealth gap between its citizens and Americans. 'The wealth creation will happen to Texas teachers and California public-sector employees, not to European pensioners,' said Stephan Leithner, CEO of Deutsche Börse, operator of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange. Politicians fear the continent's inability to finance and keep exciting companies entrenches American domination over financial markets and reduces Europe's strategic autonomy. President Trump's 'America First' stance has added to the sense of urgency. A lack of investment hurts European businesses, and starts long before they go public. Startups struggle to get access to venture-capital funding, and many leave for Silicon Valley or New York. Those who stay in Europe often get investment from American firms, which then want them to go public in the U.S. or shift operations there. Some companies that make the leap have become more American over time simply because their U.S. businesses grew so fast. New listings are in the doldrums as other corners of European finance, such as the debt markets, shine. Trans-Atlantic dealmaking—one reason for Europe's shrinking stock market—is generating big paydays for selling shareholders and advisers, as U.S. acquirers hunt for bargains. Europe's problem isn't a shortage of money, but an underdeveloped and risk-averse system for investing it. European Union households save more than Americans, but their wealth has grown by a third as much since 2009, according to a 2024 paper by former Italian Prime Minister Mario Draghi on Europe's lack of competitiveness. Europeans hold $12 trillion of their savings, or about 70%, in bank accounts that typically have low yields, according to the European Commission. Unlike in the U.S., which cultivated widespread stock ownership through 401(k)s, they often rely on state pensions, paid out through government budgets, in retirement. Private pension systems—in places such as the U.K., the Netherlands and Denmark—invest mostly in supersafe assets including government bonds, or U.S.-focused global stock funds. Defense-spending pledges and aging populations are straining government budgets. Channeling more savings into high-returning investments would alleviate the pressure. Executives complain that tepid domestic investment results in lower stock valuations. The French oil producer TotalEnergies, its U.K. rival Shell and the mining company Glencore have in recent years raised the possibility of moving their listings, citing valuation gaps with U.S. peers, though none have made the jump. S&P 500 constituents have a forward price/earnings ratio of 22, compared with 13 for the FTSE 100 and 15 for Germany's DAX. Some Europeans argue that the premium on U.S. stocks is illusory, noting that groups such as the plumbing-supplies company Ferguson Enterprises failed to close the discount to American rivals after moving their primary listings to New York. Only three of the 20 U.K. companies that opted for a New York debut in the past decade have seen market value increase, while half have delisted, according to the LSE. Higher pay for U.S. executives is another draw. Peter Jackson, the chief executive of Flutter, which owns the betting platform FanDuel, nearly tripled his compensation after the gambling company moved its main stock listing to New York last year from London. European leaders have tried to reverse the tide, but with little to show so far. The U.K. has moved to deregulate, including by loosening restrictions on supervoting shares favored by tech founders. The government is launching a 'concierge service' to court businesses and backed an advertising campaign to encourage more retail investing. Speaking at a recent investment conference in London, Julia Hoggett, the CEO of the London Stock Exchange, urged attendees to be more confident. 'If we keep talking ourselves down…then we shouldn't be surprised of the consequences,' Hoggett said. The EU, meanwhile, has revived the painstaking work of knitting together its 27 members' capital markets. The project is already a decade and more than 55 regulatory proposals old. Deutsche Börse's Leithner was part of a working group that ended in a list of technical problems, such as tackling differences in national bankruptcy approaches. 'We need to make the leap from talking about technicalities to fundamental change,' said Leithner. 'If this doesn't happen, it will be a major shame. It would be almost a crime on the younger generation.' Write to Chelsey Dulaney at and Joe Wallace at America's Stock-Market Dominance Is an Emergency for Europe America's Stock-Market Dominance Is an Emergency for Europe
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Festive season & monsoon spike vegetable prices
Panaji: Prices of vegetables in Goa have been witnessing a gradual rise over the last couple of weeks amid an increase in demand due to the Hindu holy month of Shravan and the upcoming Ganesh Chaturthi. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Prices have also been affected due to quality deterioration of produce during storage and transportation in the monsoon. Tomatoes have seen a rise from Rs 40 to Rs 50 per kg, while onion prices have also spiked from Rs 30 to Rs 40 per kg. Potato rates have also increased from Rs 30 to Rs 40 per kg. As the festival approaches, the prices are expected to increase further. Burhanuddin Mulia, a vegetable vendor at the Panaji municipal market, said prices fluctuate frequently due to the rainy season and the demand for the vegetables. 'The price of tomatoes was Rs 80 last month. It was Rs 40 two weeks ago, and now, it has risen to Rs 50. It really depends on the quality we get and the demand,' said Mulia. A major part of Goa's vegetable demand is met by supply coming in from Belagavi. But due to various reasons such as the cost of cultivation, the prices of locally grown vegetables have also risen. Three small locally grown ridged gourds, or a similar quantity of bitter gourds, are now sold for Rs 100. Mohammad Haris, a vegetable vendor at Panaji, said customers are not happy with the quality of vegetables. 'And with the price hike, it doesn't justify the amount they are paying,' he said. Consumers said that for leafy vegetables like methi, raddish, coriander, etc, the prices may not seem to have been hiked, but the size of the bunches has significantly reduced. The state horticulture corporation, on its part, has said that it is supplying vegetables at subsidised rates, but the number of its stalls may fall short of the demand. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Satyender Chaudhary, a customer from Mala, said that high prices often lead him to buy vegetables in decreased quantities. 'The prices are always high. Even if it reduces by Rs 10, we still end up paying more for the quantity of vegetables we used to pay for before. It is unfair,' said a customer from Taleigao.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
New deadline for Curchorem Ravindra Bhavan
Margao: The much-anticipated phase II extension of Ravindra Bhavan in Curchorem is likely to be completed by Sep 31, the latest timeline set by the department of art and culture for completing all pending works. Official records reveal that while the amphitheatre and mini auditorium are structurally complete, interior works remain pending, preventing their immediate use. The project was plagued by multiple setbacks, including the Covid-19 pandemic's impact on manpower and material supply, design changes to the tensile fabric roof system for better structural stability, and contractor-related issues. Most significantly, the interior and allied works contractor was terminated in Dec 2023 due to poor performance, necessitating a fresh tendering process. Financial data reveals that the project's total cost escalated to Rs 27 crore, with Rs 24 crore already disbursed to contractors. The main civil, electrical, and firefighting works component, valued at Rs 20 crore, is 95% complete. However, interior works, originally worth over Rs 20 crore, remain only 50% finished under the new contractor arrangement. The audio-video systems installation is significantly behind schedule at just 30% completion, and doubts persist over its completion before the Sep 31 deadline. Notably, while major infrastructure components like CCTV systems and electrical metering are fully completed, the project's core entertainment facilities remain incomplete. The Rs 1.2 crore audio-video component has seen only Rs 75 lakh in payments, indicating substantial pending work that could further delay the project's operational readiness. The Goa State Infrastructure Development Corporation is overseeing the project through appointed project management consultants. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
