
Why global governance is failing
https://arab.news/8yy2p
The UN was established in 1945, succeeding the failed League of Nations, in a bid to pull humanity back from the brink of self-destruction. It was a bold experiment in collective security, designed to prevent another world war and manage conflicts through diplomacy rather than violence.
Yet, 80 years later, we find ourselves back on the precipice of disaster. Global temperatures have breached the 1.5 degrees Celsius threshold that scientists see as a Rubicon for reining in climate change over the long term. Public trust in institutions — and in democracy — is critically low and geopolitical tensions are rising. What happened?
The UN has, justifiably, drawn criticism for a variety of reasons. The composition of the Security Council is antiquated. Violent conflict and even genocide still occur with alarming frequency. And the organization has proven to be generally ineffectual, overly bureaucratic and unfair in its treatment of the Global South.
But the inadequately diagnosed problem is that the UN is bringing a 20th-century logic to bear on the 21st century's fundamentally planetary problems. Today's most urgent challenges — such as climate change, pandemics, artificial intelligence regulation, financial contagion and supply chain disruptions — do not respect national borders, yet UN institutions remain stuck in a framework of nation states jealously guarding their sovereignty. Our international institutions simply were not designed to address essentially systemic issues indifferent to national borders. The UN is not just slow, it is structurally incapable of tackling such problems at scale.
With even conventional governance structures faltering in the face of heightened tribalism and nationalism, any proposed new paradigm of planetary governance runs the risk of sounding utopian. Fortunately, the world already has a serviceable blueprint: the EU. For all its flaws, this bloc has demonstrated that a supranational federation can work, allowing previously warring countries to pool sovereignty in exchange for economic and political stability. Nor is this such a radical idea. In a 1946 Gallup poll, 54 percent of Americans believed that 'the UN should be strengthened to make it a world government with power to control the armed forces of all nations, including the US.'
In 2024, by contrast, 58 percent of Americans thought that the UN was doing a 'poor job.' This description suggests that the UN needs to take a bolder approach. Big, planetary issues like global warming are what philosopher Timothy Morton calls 'hyperobjects.' They are 'entities of such vast temporal and spatial dimension' as to require a fundamentally different kind of human reasoning. To change how we think about such problems calls for both an intellectual and a psychological shift — beyond the nation state, or what Benedict Anderson famously called 'imagined communities.'
The UN is bringing a 20th-century logic to bear on the 21st century's fundamentally planetary problems.
Antara Haldar
Intellectually, planetary thinking requires its own theoretical framework. This demand is not new. In the 20th century, John Maynard Keynes saw a need for a global currency and proposed the 'bancor' to replace the dollar-focused Bretton Woods institutions. Hannah Arendt also advanced her own vision of planetary politics. And Pierre Teilhard de Chardin developed his concept of the 'noosphere' (collective human consciousness). In more recent scholarship — from Johan Rockstrom's work on 'planetary boundaries' to Bruno Latour's description of our ecological age — the intellectual elements of a new planetary paradigm are beginning to come together.
Psychologically, we need a new narrative. The historian Yuval Noah Harari argues that human civilization is built on shared myths, such as nationalism and capitalism. If planetary governance is to succeed, it needs to tell a compelling new story, one that moves beyond outdated ideas about sovereign nation states to acknowledge humanity's interconnectedness.
To reach people where they are, rigorous planetary thinking must be accompanied by stronger local thinking. Improvements to our governance structures must look both 'up' and 'down,' as the Berggruen Institute's Jonathan Blake and Nils Gilman have put it. Global governance cannot succeed without resilient, empowered local structures. The nation state would remain one element, but cities, regions and local networks would be given more attention and integrated into planetary decision-making. This kind of nested approach could offer an alternative to the outdated system of nation states without requiring its wholesale dismantling.
The growing urgency of planetary crises — from the 2008 financial crash to pandemics and climate change — graphically illustrate the inadequacies of the UN in its current form. The UN itself emerged from the shell of the League of Nations and now it is time to build anew. Governance must pivot from the nation state-based logic of the Bretton Woods system to the planetary sensibilities of the bancor. Even if the UN had succeeded in uniting the world's nations, its current design would be unequal to a moment defined by inherently planetary challenges. It is time to imagine new communities centered on our planetary realities.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Arab News
6 hours ago
- Arab News
Lebanon committed to renewing UNIFIL's mandate, says PM
BEIRUT: Lebanese Prime Minister Nawaf Salam on Tuesday reaffirmed Lebanon's commitment to renewing the mandate of the UN Interim Force in Lebanon to support UN Resolution 1701 and maintain border security. His statement followed an incident in which UNIFIL peacekeepers reported being confronted by rock-throwing individuals during a patrol in southern Lebanon, and described repeated attacks on its troops as 'unacceptable.' Salam condemned the attacks on UNIFIL, calling for the perpetrators to be apprehended and held accountable. He warned that such actions threatened southern Lebanon's stability and national interests, directing security agencies to refer the assailants to the judicial authorities. UNIFIL spokesman Andrea Tenenti said a Finnish soldier was slapped during Tuesday's confrontation. The Lebanese Foreign Ministry echoed his sentiments, urging prosecution under Lebanese and international law while reaffirming its support for UNIFIL's role in preserving peace and security. UNIFIL urged the Lebanese government to 'take all necessary measures to ensure that its forces perform their duties without any threat.' The peacekeepers said they conducted their mission in coordination with the Lebanese army and based on UNIFIL's mandate terms. UNIFIL reiterated that freedom of movement was a fundamental condition for implementing its mandate, including the ability to operate independently and impartially, as outlined in UN Resolution 1701. 'Any restriction on this freedom, whether during operational activities with or without the Lebanese Armed Forces, is a violation of this resolution,' the statement added. A supporter of the Iran-backed Hezbollah slapped a Finnish UNIFIL soldier on Tuesday. The incident occurred while a UNIFIL patrol was conducting search operations in an area between the towns of Deir Qanoun Al-Nahr and Al-Halloussiyah in the Tyre District, south of the Litani River. The assault represents the most serious incident in two weeks of mounting tensions between UNIFIL peacekeepers and individuals Hezbollah describes as 'locals.' The assault, which was captured on video by the protesters themselves and shared across social media platforms, occurred during disputes over UNIFIL's right to conduct inspections without Lebanese army escorts. The controversy emerged as the UN prepared to review the renewal of the peacekeeping mission's mandate. The next renewal is expected to be considered by the UN Security Council in August as the current mandate, extended on Aug. 28, 2024, expires on Aug. 31. Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri, a key Hezbollah ally, characterized Tuesday's incident differently, claiming it represented 'a conspiracy against international forces designed to harm them, Lebanon, and the south.' Tuesday's violence occurred after two separate patrol incidents. First, Hezbollah supporters blocked UNIFIL forces from entering private property in Bedias town without the Lebanese army, forcing the patrol's withdrawal. Later on, another UNIFIL unit approached private land along the Al-Halloussiyah to Deir Qanoun Al-Nahr road, again without military escort. Locals quickly mobilized, surrounding the international patrol and demanding its departure. Tensions peaked when one protester physically struck the UN soldier. Lebanese army units later intervened to restore calm and immediately launched a hunt for the assailant. Local witnesses expressed alarm at seeing Lebanese soldiers potentially confronting civilians. UNIFIL later clarified that its 'personnel used non-lethal measures in order to guarantee the protection of the patrol members and others.' Lebanese Armed Forces quickly arrived at the site and the patrol resumed its duties when the situation was brought under control. A witness said an argument ensued between locals and the Lebanese army after the latter began to hunt for the man who slapped the peacekeeper. The protesters argued that UN forces should not operate independently of Lebanese military supervision, while UNIFIL maintained that its operations complied with established protocols. Fares Souaid, the head of the Lady of the Mountain Gathering, warned that 'the cost of beating a UNIFIL soldier will be very high.' He added that Hezbollah members were 'unaware of the harm the party is causing them.' The incident was preceded by an Israeli drone striking shepherds in the border town of Shebaa. The Lebanese Ministry of Health later reported the strike had killed 'the citizen Mohammed Kanaan and his son, Wael, a soldier in the army. His second son, Hadi, was injured.' The number of Israeli violations since the ceasefire agreement of Nov. 27 has now reached 1,643 on land, 1,774 by air, and 88 by sea, a total of 3,505. Hezbollah media reported that these had resulted in 172 deaths and 409 people suffering injuries. The ceasefire agreement, which sought to end over a year of hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah, allows only Lebanese troops and UN peacekeepers in the south of the country.


Asharq Al-Awsat
12 hours ago
- Asharq Al-Awsat
UN Peacekeepers Say Troops Attacked by Individuals in South Lebanon
United Nations peacekeepers said rock-throwing individuals confronted them during a patrol on Tuesday in south Lebanon, calling repeated targeting of their troops "unacceptable". The UN Interim Forces in Lebanon (UNIFIL), deployed since 1978 to separate Lebanon and Israel, sits on a five-member committee to supervise the ceasefire between Israel and the Iran-backed Hezbollah. In a statement, UNIFIL said peacekeepers conducting "a planned patrol" coordinated with the Lebanese army were "confronted by a group of individuals in civilian clothing in the vicinity of Hallusiyat al-Tahta, in southern Lebanon". "The group attempted to obstruct the patrol using aggressive means, including throwing stones at the peacekeepers," the statement read, adding that "one peacekeeper was struck" but no injuries were reported, AFP reported. The situation was defused when the Lebanese army intervened, allowing the peacekeeping force to continue its patrol. "It is unacceptable that UNIFIL peacekeepers continue to be targeted," the statement added. UNIFIL spokesman Andrea Tenenti told AFP a Finnish soldier was slapped during the confrontation. A witness, who requested anonymity due to the sensitivity of the situation, said an altercation ensued between locals and the Lebanese army, who were searching for the man who slapped the peacekeeper. One man opposing the army was injured and hospitalized, the witness said. In a statement, Lebanese Prime Minister Nawaf Salam said he "strongly condemns the repeated attacks" on UNIFIL forces and called for the attackers to be stopped and held accountable. There have been several confrontations between people in south Lebanon, where Hezbollah holds sway, and UN peacekeepers in recent weeks. Confrontations are typically defused by the Lebanese army and rarely escalate. In December 2022, an Irish peacekeeper was killed in a shooting at a UN armoured vehicle in the south. Hezbollah surrendered a man accused of the crime, but he was released around a year later. The November ceasefire agreement, which sought to end over a year of hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah, states that only Lebanese troops and UN peacekeepers may be deployed in the country's south. Israel is supposed to have fully withdrawn its troops from Lebanon according to the deal, but has remained in five positions it deems strategic and has repeatedly bombed the country.


Arab News
12 hours ago
- Arab News
UN peacekeepers say troops attacked by individuals in south Lebanon
BEIRUT: United Nations peacekeepers said rock-throwing individuals confronted them during a patrol on Tuesday in south Lebanon, calling repeated targeting of their troops 'unacceptable.' The UN Interim Forces in Lebanon (UNIFIL), deployed since 1978 to separate Lebanon and Israel, sits on a five-member committee to supervise the ceasefire between Israel and the Iran-backed Hezbollah. In a statement, UNIFIL said peacekeepers conducting 'a planned patrol' coordinated with the Lebanese army were 'confronted by a group of individuals in civilian clothing in the vicinity of Hallusiyat Al-Tahta, in southern Lebanon.' 'The group attempted to obstruct the patrol using aggressive means, including throwing stones at the peacekeepers,' the statement read, adding that 'one peacekeeper was struck' but no injuries were reported. The situation was defused when the Lebanese army intervened, allowing the peacekeeping force to continue its patrol. 'It is unacceptable that UNIFIL peacekeepers continue to be targeted,' the statement added. UNIFIL spokesman Andrea Tenenti told AFP a Finnish soldier was slapped during the confrontation. A witness, who requested anonymity due to the sensitivity of the situation, said an altercation ensued between locals and the Lebanese army, who were searching for the man who slapped the peacekeeper. One man opposing the army was injured and hospitalized, the witness said. In a statement, Lebanese Prime Minister Nawaf Salam said he 'strongly condemns the repeated attacks' on UNIFIL forces and called for the attackers to be stopped and held accountable. There have been several confrontations between people in south Lebanon, where Hezbollah holds sway, and UN peacekeepers in recent weeks. Confrontations are typically defused by the Lebanese army and rarely escalate. In December 2022, an Irish peacekeeper was killed in a shooting at a UN armored vehicle in the south. Hezbollah surrendered a man accused of the crime, but he was released around a year later. The November ceasefire agreement, which sought to end over a year of hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah, states that only Lebanese troops and UN peacekeepers may be deployed in the country's south. Israel is supposed to have fully withdrawn its troops from Lebanon according to the deal, but has remained in five positions it deems strategic and has repeatedly bombed the country.