Heartbreak as luckless Rabbitohs star suffers huge blow on his return from injury and here's why footy fans are filthy about it
On a day where Tom Trbojevic showed signs of returning to his best playing centre, Smith suffered a medial ligament tear that Souths expect to sideline him for eight weeks.
Smith's right knee was hurt when Matt Lodge's weight fell on it in a tackle late in the game, as the Rabbitohs spiralled to a sixth straight loss on Sunday to sit second-last on the ladder.
'He's done a medial ligament, it will be six-to-eight weeks from that tackle,' Bennett said.
Smith was playing his first match since early September, after moving from the Sydney Roosters earlier this year.
Asked whether he believed the contact from Lodge was of a hip-drop nature, Bennett suggested Souths were unlucky not to get a penalty from it.
Brandon Smith suffered a suspected MCL injury - contact mechanism on outside of lower leg fairly textbook for MCL/syndesmosis damage.
Early assessments from the Rabbitohs suggest he will miss 6-8 weeks - likely moderate to high grade injury. Rough in his first game back. pic.twitter.com/JoEL09EiwZ
— NRL PHYSIO (@nrlphysio) July 6, 2025
'It's up to them to decide, but we're not playing with a lot of luck, and we didn't get any there from that decision either,' Bennett responded.
'I'm frustrated by a lot of things right now, but it's not going to do me any good.'
Lodge was not penalised for the contact and Smith's injury overshadowed what was a vital win for Manly, albeit against a severely undermanned Rabbitohs.
Bennett wasn't the only one who appeared frustrated by the lack of action by the officials.
Fox Sports commentator, Warren Smith, said: 'That's a hip drop tackle.'
Steve Roach agreed, before Smith began to rant about the tackle.
'He had contact with him, came from one side of the tackle to use the hip or the body on the other side to make contact with Brandon Smith,' he said.
'It's a play we haven't rubbed out of the game and the suspensions need to be six weeks, eight weeks, 10 weeks to get rid of it.
'That technique didn't need to happen right there to effect the tackle. Who knows how serious the consequences might be for Brandon Smith?'
Some fans on social media hit out at the tackle technique.
'Manly fan here, Lodge should miss a minimum of six weeks for that,' one wrote.
'Hip drop no doubt, how's the bunker missed that,' another wrote.
'Refs are a joke for saying play on,' one added.
'Hip drop tackle but nothing done on the field. Shameful reffing and watch the NRL apologise for getting it wrong.'
It was only two weeks ago that the walls were closing in on coach Anthony Seibold, but the Sea Eagles are now back into the top eight after back-to-back wins.
Two games into his shift from fullback to centre, Trbojevic scored a double and set up another as Manly went out to a 24-0 lead.
Fans have taken to X to hit out at the tackle technique and also slammed referees for not penalising Lodge
Seibold will consider whether to keep Trbojevic at centre after next week's bye, after initially moving his strike weapon to the edge in a bid to get his confidence back.
Trbojevic appears to have at least done that, running with power again in what was easily his best match since March.
He regularly played a roaming role in attack, popping up on the left of the field to give Manly an extra number on that side of the field in attack.
The 27-year-old set up one try in that fashion when he linked with Lehi Hopoate to send Reuben Garrick over, before scoring another himself after forcing an error on a kick.
It was Trbojevic's second try after the break that showed the most promise, when he again took a ball on the left, charged infield and beat three to score.
'The way he was able to inject himself on both sides of the field is not something a lot of centres can do,' Seibold said.
'He's done it at elite level, hasn't done it at club level. But I've really liked what I've seen.
'I want to have a look at (whether we're a better team with him at centre). My gut feel is it was another step in the right direction.'
Garrick also scored a double in the win, while Manly are confident fellow winger Jason Saab only suffered a cork after limping off late.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE I took steroids for almost a decade due to peer pressure. They led me down a dark path and changed my body irreversibly... But I still miss them
A powerlifting coach who took steroids for almost a decade has warned the drugs take a toll on users' bodies and mental health - but their use will never be stopped. Anabolic steroids, a type of performance-enhancing drug (PEDs) related to testosterone, have long been controversial in the fitness world. Even the mention of PEDs can be divisive, with figures like Aussie swimmer James Magnussen criticised for participating in the 'Enhanced Games', where the use of drugs was encouraged. Anabolic steroids are illegal without a medical prescription in Australia, but that hasn't stopped people increasingly using them for means other than better health. Gus Cooke, 36, trained using anabolic steroids for bodybuilding and powerlifting competitions over 10 years while living in Brisbane - but gave them up in 2023. 'When I initially started taking them, I didn't really want to, but it was a bit of peer pressure,' he told Daily Mail Australia. 'The sport kind of created this need to keep up and do what everyone else is doing, and so you are led down a dark path. 'Rather than sending you backwards, like a party drug, it's making you perform better. 'It's an addictive feeling. Winning is addictive - but then you start to realise the health concerns.' After his last competition two years ago, Mr Cooke decided it was time for a change and came off steroids before moving to Phuket, Thailand, with his wife. But that is when the difficulties really began. 'If you've been on them for a long time, you're going to have neurochemistry changes. (It) starts to impact your mental health,' he said. 'Then, it starts to get paired with muscle loss quite quickly. 'After long-term use, you've got quite a bit of suppression, meaning that your natural production (of testosterone) has slowed down.' Mr Cooke is now taking TRT, Testosterone Replacement Therapy, which is a legal, medically prescribed drug. 'My maturity and sensibility is stronger than the desire to want to go back on (them) but it doesn't mean you don't miss it,' he said. 'I do miss taking it (but) I never will again. I don't see any need.' As a coach, he now focuses on mitigating the risks of his clients who do take steroids. 'I know so much about training and more effective ways of managing performance enhancement to the degree that you can perform better if managed at much lower dosages. 'You can't stop the use. You never will stop the use. There was no point criminalising it because all you do is create an underground subculture of steroid use. 'If I demonise it, (my athletes) will go do it behind doors and, because there is little support, I need to be that support for them.' While the use of anabolic agents in Australia is illegal without a prescription, there is a trend of increasing non-medical use. The Australian National Drug Strategy Household Survey recorded that non-medical anabolic steroid use almost tripled in the 18 years between 2001 and 2019. Experts have also raised concerns about the link between social media images and the use of steroids. Research published in the American Psychological Association in 2024 highlighted the link between social media-influenced body image concerns and behaviors such as anabolic-androgenic steroid use among men. While the findings were mixed, there were some damning conclusions made. 'It was clear that appearance-related social media use is related to a more negative body image and greater odds of anabolic-androgenic steroid use in men,' it said. Mr Cooke said steroid use by social media influencers led to two issues - some people promote it as a 'magic pill', while others do not disclose that their gains are influenced by drugs, leading to followers becoming disappointed. 'With the people who are more public about it, you've got this high performer who's also, at the same time, using it to make it look "cool",' he said. 'And people see it as that magic pill.' Meanwhile, Mr Cooke warned that the second group are seeing an idolised image that is 'unrealistic'. 'You've got people who've been doing this for a really long time showing their results, and people get disheartened because they're not given the context. 'The reality is that anything worth getting in terms of a really chiselled physique isn't attainable without anabolic steroids. 'It can be done naturally, but doesn't look the same.' What is the answer? For Mr Cooke, if steroid-use is inevitable in the industry, it needs to be managed rather than banned. 'There needs to be both infrastructure to keep the market accountable and infrastructure for athletes to feel safe, to get help,' he said. 'There only needs to be basic knowledge out there to reduce so much harm. 'It's so underground no one knows what to do, and people need access to medical facilities to test if there's contaminants, to test what they're taking and then how to safely use it.' The proof of the point seems to have been made in Australian world-first research, with Griffith University running a steroid testing trial which was paired with education. Anonymous users submitted steroids for a composition analysis, including for purity. According to the results published in May this year, almost a quarter of the substances tested contained unexpected steroids. Over half were incorrectly dosed. The trial also revealed more than 80 per cent of participants would change or reduce their use of steroids after being shown the results of the research. 'Criminalisation and stigmatisation have led to these individuals turning to peers, social networks, online forums and drug coaches,' lead researcher Dr Tim Piatkowski said at the time. 'These strategies are a form of folk pharmacology or 'bro science' and can sometimes lack appropriate oversight from medical professionals.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Remorseless Australian bowling onslaught blows away West Indies in second Test
The second Test in Grenada finished like the first in Barbados, with a batting performance as shambolic and uninspired from the home side as their bowling had been impressive. Everybody is bored of the eulogies for West Indies cricket: we've all been reading them for 25 years, and some of us have been writing them for what feels as long. But it doesn't matter how many times you've seen The Shawshank Redemption, you still feel a pang of sadness when Tommy Williams steps out to meet Warden Norton for a midnight chat. Australia shot down West Indies with as little remorse, all out for 143 in less than 35 overs on day four, the visitors winning by 133 runs at the Grenada National Stadium and going 2-0 up to win the series. It's not that the scoreline is a surprise, given the resource disparity between the teams and administrations, but it still feels wrong to feel that a Test side has no chance of chasing once a target approaches 250. West Indies had bowled well when Australia resumed at 221-7 to begin day four, with the two Josephs, Alzarri and Shamar, collectively having Pat Cummins nick behind from his first ball of the day, trap Alex Carey for only four additional runs to his overnight score, then knock Josh Hazlewood's stumps out. All up Australia had added 22. But the key part was that a few balls kept low while still offering lateral seam. With 277 to get, nobody had confidence in the West Indies' batting, least of all the West Indies batters. John Campbell forgot that feet can move and was nailed in front by Josh Hazlewood before most people had resumed their seats. Kraigg Brathwaite in his hundredth Test went nowhere, poking around to add seven to his first-innings duck before nicking Beau Webster's medium pace. Keacy Carty got a fierce working over, fingers turned into cevapcici by repeated blows to the gloves, before nicking Mitchell Starc. Brandon King got a Pat Cummins special, angled in, beating the outside edge to hit off stump. Hello, 4-33, goodbye contest. It's strange that a region where life revolves around the ocean should produce a team that is so far out of its depth. But it's not for lack of trying. Caribbean long-form cricket is an afterthought domestically, and the cupboard is bare. The best first-class average in the squad is 34. Braithwate is surely at the terminus of a long decline, but has kept being picked on experience for want of a competitor. Campbell, Carty, and King are short-form players trying to adapt. Shai Hope had some Test triumphs in another life, but has returned from the white-ball Pet Sematary possessed by the accursed spirit of a desperate slogger. Roston Chase had a few moments in his 34, including a mango-sweet flick off the pads that took six runs from Starc, but the captain's 38-run stand with Hope was as good as it got for his team, and if anything, Hope's innings of 17 looked worse than some of the knocks worth fewer. After a few bits of galloping nonsense, he pulled Hazlewood straight up the chimney for the bowler to wait underneath. Starc swung his way past another Chase flick, and at 86-6 that was it. A No 8 slogging two sixes from his first two balls might spark excitement with 50 runs to get, but it only speaks of desperation when there's 180 to go. The very next ball after Alzarri Joseph's opening clouts against Lyon, Starc produced a shooter on the angle to get his third, Justin Greaves stranded as it smashed his front pad. The Josephs and Jayden Seales hit six sixes from Lyon, but he got them all out to end the game, and now is two wickets from passing Glenn McGrath's Test tally of 563, with his average at a 13-year low of 30.14. Sign up to The Spin Subscribe to our cricket newsletter for our writers' thoughts on the biggest stories and a review of the week's action after newsletter promotion It was a very even bowling performance, both innings with nobody taking more than three wickets or less than one. That's easier when the opposition don't have the tools to counter your own, and any move will work eventually. In a low-scoring series, Australia are still having their batting struggles, but West Indies would give anything for batting that only struggles that much. In a scheduled pink-ball Test in Jamaica, one more humiliation is on the cards. The only hope is that being this low eventually creates the drive, at home and in the international community, to decide on a path towards something better. It's a long way off. West Indies may have to swim through a river of filth to come out clean.
Scotsman
3 hours ago
- Scotsman
Scotland's Pacific roadshow heads to Fiji - and plenty of respect is granted
Townsend knows what to expect in Suva Sign up to our Rugby Union newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Scotland are returning to Fiji for the first time in eight years and the aim is to embrace fully the local culture in a country where rugby is a powerful force for good. The two nations will meet in the capital, Suva, this weekend but, before that, Gregor Townsend expects his squad to immerse themselves in the community. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad It's the second game of Scotland's Pacific tour and they made a winning start in New Zealand on Saturday with a hard-fought 29-26 victory over the Māori All Blacks. Fiji, meanwhile, were unlucky to lose 21-18 to Australia in Newcastle, New South Wales, as Wallabies captain Harry Wilson scored the winning try a minute from time. Scotland's Stafford McDowall (R) and Maori All Black's Daniel Rona (L) in action. | SNS Group / SRU Townsend's squad travelled to Fiji on Sunday and the head coach is relishing a return to the island nation. Scotland lost 27-22 on their last visit in 2017 and this Saturday's game is likely to be just as tough a test against opponents ranked ninth in the world, two place below the Scots. 'It will be a new experience for the majority of [the squad],' said Townsend. 'There was a couple that were there eight years ago but for the majority it will be the first time they've gone to Fiji and it's a very friendly culture. 'Fijian people are very welcoming and then as rugby players to see people playing in fields, to see the knowledge they have for the game and the joy they'll have seeing us being over there taking on their team, will be brilliant. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Fiji is a unique place for Scotland 'We really want to get out into the community and go to schools and maybe do some coaching sessions with the kids. It is a unique place, there's a huge rugby culture in New Zealand but Fiji is different. They just love the sport so much and they're obviously very skilful because they've played it since a young age and continue to play sevens and fifteens all the way through to Test level.' While sevens has been the traditional bedrock of the game in Fiji, the national side is enjoying a fruitful spell in 15-a-sides. They reached the quarter-finals of the last Rugby World Cup, beating Australia to progress. They were edged out by England in the last eight but Steve Borthwick's side needed a late penalty and drop goal from Owen Farrell to win 30-24 in Marseille. Fiji lost 57-17 at Murrayfield in November but they were without many of their frontline players and will be a very different proposition at home. Their performance on Sunday, in which they scored a first-half try through debutant Salesi Rayasi and a brilliant second-half score created by Jiuta Wainiqolo and finished by Lekima Tagitagivalu, saw them fall just short of a first win over the Wallabies in Australia since 1954. Arron Reed was among the try-scorers against Maori. | SNS Group / SRU The heat and humidity are also likely to pose problems for the Scots. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Fiji is mid-20s to 30 degrees,' said Josh Bayliss, the Scotland flanker who was one of the stand-out performers in the win over the Māori. 'So, another challenge for us. But I think everyone's really excited to go over there and rip into another Test week and then see what we can do next weekend. 'It's going to be probably another game where we maybe go to the set-piece to try and get a foothold in the game and then see where we go from there.' Backs' speed so vital for Scotland The tactics in Whangārei were more about utilising the pace of the backline, and the Māori struggled to cope with the little kicks in behind, particularly in the first half when Scotland scored three tries through Harry Paterson, Arron Reed and George Horne, all converted by Adam Hastings who also added a penalty. The hosts had taken the lead through Sam Nock and Isaia Walker-Leawere scored a second try but the Scots led 24-12 at the break and moved further ahead early in the second half after Horne finished off a brilliant move. But the Māori came back strongly and converted tries from Kurt Eklund and Gideon Wrampling brought them to within three points of the Scots who had to withstand a late barrage as the game continued into the 87th minute. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Townsend was pleased with the defensive effort and felt his leaders - skipper Stafford McDowall and vice-captains Bayliss and Horne - stood up when it mattered most. Scotland beat Fiji at Murrayfield last autumn. | SNS Group / SRU 'I think when you look at our captains and vice captains, Stafford was excellent in a leadership role,' said the coach. 'He carried well, defended well, and I thought Josh Bayliss was outstanding. 'George Horne too. George had two great finishes for tries but equally impressive was his high-end box kicking and we were getting the ball back, with Arron Reed in particular getting up there. 'There was a lot of control about our game. We are having more of a focus on pressurising teams with our kicking game and our set-piece on this tour, and we showed that we can do that against a really dangerous outfit.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad For Bayliss, Saturday's game against Fiji will be the chance to continue a strong end to a season which was disrupted by injury. The Bath back-row forward impressed for Scotland during the autumn series but missed the Six Nations due to a groin issue. He returned for his club for the domestic run-in and came off the bench as Bath beat Leicester Tigers in the Premiership final at Twickenham. Memories of 2017 won't be too far from the surface as Scotland look to win in Suva before returning to New Zealand to face Samoa in Auckland in the third and final tour match.
