'Poor management': regulator in the dark over water use
Western Australia's auditor-general found that the Department of Water and Environmental Regulation (DWER) was not enforcing the conditions on the more than 12,000 water licences.
Often handed out for free, the licences allow more than four trillion litres of water to be extracted annually - enough to fill more than 1.7 million Olympic swimming pools.
"DWER is not doing anywhere near enough to adequately protect our water resources, with compliance activities in recent years reactive and ad hoc," Auditor-General Caroline Spencer said.
"Poor management, over extraction and illegal taking of water all threaten the long-term sustainability of our groundwater supplies and create an uneven playing field for operators who are doing the right thing."
The report, tabled in state parliament on Wednesday, said the department's compliance checking activities have decreased over the past three years.
Most are desktop reviews of unverified meter readings, with information reported by licence holders.
On-the-ground inspections decreased by 67 per cent during the audit period from July 1, 2021 to June 30, 2024, weakening the department's understanding of compliance.
"Only five per cent of licence holders were visited in that time (and) in 2023-24, half of the regions saw no inspections all," Ms Spencer said.
There is also no effective deterrence of future non-compliance because they are not prioritised for investigation.
It's the third report by the Office of the auditor-general that has found issues with the planning and monitoring of water use in WA.
During the three years of the reporting period, 87 per cent of potential incidents of non-compliance were never assigned to a staff member to investigate.
There was also no effective guidance to help staff assess the severity or impact of non-compliance.
The report said this risked inconsistent outcomes or ineffective enforcement options."(The regulator) needs to improve its enforcement approach, including more timely actions to address potential incidents of non-compliance and to better deal with and deter future breaches," Ms Spencer said.
The opposition accused the government of negligence.
"This is a staggering failure of oversight ... the government has no idea whether it's being used lawfully or sustainably," water spokesman Peter Rundle said.
The department has been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
2 days ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Trump's latest Olympic edict effectively closes US border to transgender athletes
That order, made in February 2025, is prefaced by saying that ' In recent years, many educational institutions and athletic associations have allowed men to compete in women's sports. This is demeaning, unfair, and dangerous to women and girls, and denies women and girls the equal opportunity to participate and excel in competitive sports '. The effects have been swift and stark. Almost immediately afterwards, the US's National Collegiate Athletic Association amended its policies to limit competition in women's sports to athletes assigned female at birth only. Last month, the US Olympic and Paralympic Committee amended its policies to ensure consistency with that February 2025 order. What was missed back in February was the order's intent to prevent from entering the United States any person whose intended entry enlivens section 212(a)(6)(C)(i) of the United States' Immigration and Nationality Act. That provision says, ' Any alien who, by fraud or wilfully misrepresenting a material fact, seeks to procure (or has sought to procure or has procured) a visa, other documentation, or admission into the United States or other benefit provided under this Act is inadmissible.' In context, what Trump's order is directed atis preventing entry to the United States by any person who asserts that they are anything other than the gender they were assigned at birth. Given the legal position in the United States is that '… It is the policy of the United States to recognise two sexes, male and female. These sexes are not changeable and are grounded in fundamental and incontrovertible reality …' a transgender woman applying for a US visa would be committing a fraud if using a passport denoting their selected gender as opposed to birth gender. Trump has already declared Department of Homeland Security officers will forbid entry to any transgender athletes attempting to pass through LAX to compete at the 2028 Games. Because the Trump Administration won't countenance 'men' beating female athletes. There's no precedent I can conjure here. Even the Third Reich didn't impose a blanket ban on black or Jewish athletes competing at the Berlin Olympics in 1936. The question as to the participation of transgender athletes in Olympic and international-level elite athletic competition is increasingly answered by the exclusion of such athletes. Loading Major international federations such as World Aquatics have adopted policies deeming transgender women ineligible in female competition. The exception is where they never experienced male puberty, or unless they had their male puberty pharmacologically stopped before their 12th birthday. World Athletics has recently enshrined in its rules a one-off gender test, which must be passed for an athlete to compete in female competition. The International Olympic Committee itself must set clear and unequivocal policy to protect the integrity of female athletic competition. But while it's the responsibility of the IOC and the international federations to traverse this minefield, it's wicked that the US president considers it within his domain to dictate who can and can't compete at the Olympics. Unless the US Congress can override Trump's orders – or unless the Supreme Court rules them unlawful – the grim future for US transgender athletes and indeed any transgender person seeking entry to compete in sporting competition in the United States is plain. But what is truly frightening is the prospect Homeland Security might round up international transgender athletes coming into America; asserting criminality. When the 2028 Games to were awarded to Los Angeles in 2017, the US Olympic Committee noted that the IOC had relied on the US Government to respect the Olympic Charter. Trump was US President in 2017. The provisions of the Charter are entirely inconsistent with the bold concept of arresting any athlete for attempting to enter the host nation to compete.
The Age
2 days ago
- The Age
Trump's latest Olympic edict effectively closes US border to transgender athletes
That order, made in February 2025, is prefaced by saying that ' In recent years, many educational institutions and athletic associations have allowed men to compete in women's sports. This is demeaning, unfair, and dangerous to women and girls, and denies women and girls the equal opportunity to participate and excel in competitive sports '. The effects have been swift and stark. Almost immediately afterwards, the US's National Collegiate Athletic Association amended its policies to limit competition in women's sports to athletes assigned female at birth only. Last month, the US Olympic and Paralympic Committee amended its policies to ensure consistency with that February 2025 order. What was missed back in February was the order's intent to prevent from entering the United States any person whose intended entry enlivens section 212(a)(6)(C)(i) of the United States' Immigration and Nationality Act. That provision says, ' Any alien who, by fraud or wilfully misrepresenting a material fact, seeks to procure (or has sought to procure or has procured) a visa, other documentation, or admission into the United States or other benefit provided under this Act is inadmissible.' In context, what Trump's order is directed atis preventing entry to the United States by any person who asserts that they are anything other than the gender they were assigned at birth. Given the legal position in the United States is that '… It is the policy of the United States to recognise two sexes, male and female. These sexes are not changeable and are grounded in fundamental and incontrovertible reality …' a transgender woman applying for a US visa would be committing a fraud if using a passport denoting their selected gender as opposed to birth gender. Trump has already declared Department of Homeland Security officers will forbid entry to any transgender athletes attempting to pass through LAX to compete at the 2028 Games. Because the Trump Administration won't countenance 'men' beating female athletes. There's no precedent I can conjure here. Even the Third Reich didn't impose a blanket ban on black or Jewish athletes competing at the Berlin Olympics in 1936. The question as to the participation of transgender athletes in Olympic and international-level elite athletic competition is increasingly answered by the exclusion of such athletes. Loading Major international federations such as World Aquatics have adopted policies deeming transgender women ineligible in female competition. The exception is where they never experienced male puberty, or unless they had their male puberty pharmacologically stopped before their 12th birthday. World Athletics has recently enshrined in its rules a one-off gender test, which must be passed for an athlete to compete in female competition. The International Olympic Committee itself must set clear and unequivocal policy to protect the integrity of female athletic competition. But while it's the responsibility of the IOC and the international federations to traverse this minefield, it's wicked that the US president considers it within his domain to dictate who can and can't compete at the Olympics. Unless the US Congress can override Trump's orders – or unless the Supreme Court rules them unlawful – the grim future for US transgender athletes and indeed any transgender person seeking entry to compete in sporting competition in the United States is plain. But what is truly frightening is the prospect Homeland Security might round up international transgender athletes coming into America; asserting criminality. When the 2028 Games to were awarded to Los Angeles in 2017, the US Olympic Committee noted that the IOC had relied on the US Government to respect the Olympic Charter. Trump was US President in 2017. The provisions of the Charter are entirely inconsistent with the bold concept of arresting any athlete for attempting to enter the host nation to compete.
News.com.au
3 days ago
- News.com.au
El Salvador plans 600 mass trials for suspected gang members
El Salvador plans to hold around 600 mass trials for the tens of thousands suspected gang members who have been detained without charges in the country since 2022, the Central American country's attorney general said Thursday. Over 80,000 Salvadorans have been detained -- some of whom human rights defenders maintain are innocent -- since gang-busting President Nayib Bukele declared a state of emergency three years ago that allowed arrests without warrants. The government accuses the detainees all of being gang members, but with scant evidence or due process, no one knows for sure. "Approximately 300 prosecutors will be responsible for presenting evidence before appropriate courts in the approximately 600 trials that need to be initiated," Attorney General Rodolfo Delgado told a congressional security committee. Delgado also suggested changes to the country's law against organized crime that could see the detainees remain in jail without charge for up to three more years. The committee gave a favorable opinion on Delgado's suggested changes, which included giving him two more years -- with the possibility of a third -- to file charges. "A considerable amount of time will have to pass for a judge to make a decision," Delgado said. He did not provide details about when the trials could start -- or the crimes the detainees could be charged with. The changes to the law are expected to be approved by Congress, which is dominated by Bukele's party, on Friday. That would be just days before a two-year deadline runs out for the attorney general to file charges. Bukele's hardline approach to El Salvador's powerful gangs has made him one of the world's most domestically popular leaders, even as human rights defenders sound the alarm over arbitrary arrests and growing authoritarianism. He recently made headlines by taking in migrants from the mass deportation drive of his ally US President Donald Trump and putting them in a maximum-security prison, where some have reported mistreatment. A report released by the US State Department this week declined to criticize El Salvador, saying there were "no credible reports of significant human rights abuses" in the country and instead noting a "historic low" in crime. Lawyer and human rights activist Ingrid Escobar warned that thousands of innocent people have been thrown in jail. "The innocent will pay for the guilty," she said, adding: "Even dead people will be convicted."
