Man City sheikh was ‘shadow owner' of hospital tainted by fraud, claims EY
Manchester City owner Sheikh Mansour was 'effectively a shadow owner' of failed hospital operator NMC Health, EY has claimed.
The Emirati royal had links to two Emirati businessmen accused of stealing billions from the former FTSE 100 company, the accountancy giant has alleged.
It was claimed his connections to NMC Health saw it shielded from proper scrutiny, meaning banks ignored 'red flags' to lend billions to the London-listed healthcare giant before its 2020 collapse.
EY made the claims in submissions to the High Court as it seeks to defend itself against a £2bn lawsuit brought forward by bankruptcy administrator Alvarez & Marsal.
The 'big four' firm claims Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan had close ties to two of NMC Health's top shareholders, Saeed and Khalifa bin Butti.
They are accused of stealing billions from the healthcare company alongside BR Shetty, its founder.
More than £3bn secret debt
The three shareholders, who together owned two thirds of all shares in NMC Health, are accused of defrauding the company by borrowing more than $4bn (£3bn) worth of secret debt.
Dr Shetty has instead claimed he was the victim of a wider fraud. The High Court subsequently froze Dr Shetty's assets in 2022, including a luxury London penthouse.
EY claims fraudsters inside NMC Health used their links to Sheikh Mansour to secure loans from banks, who were willing to lend billions to the chain headquartered in Abu Dhabi because of the Emirati royal's 'name' and credibility.
The accounting firm's submissions to the High Court say: 'The evidence ... suggests that Sheikh Mansour stood behind the Bin Buttis in some informal way, making him effectively a shadow owner of NMC.'
Sheikh Mansour's links to NMC Health were 'well understood in the region,' EY's submissions add.
It claimed that banks conducted due diligence with the 'lightest of touches' due to the credibility given to the company by the Emirati royal.
NMC Health's lenders 'failed to take obvious steps to protect their own interests by conducting proper due diligence on the loans they were advancing to the NMC Group,' EY's submissions to the High Court say.
Sheikh Mansour is a member of Abu Dhabi's royal family, and is currently the United Arab Emirate's vice president. The Emirati billionaire is also the owner of Manchester City Football Club.
The accountancy giant says Alvarez & Marsal have also 'shied away' from pursuing the Bin Butti brothers, because of their links to Sheikh Mansour.
EY's submissions to the High Court say: 'No serious attempt seems to have been made to pursue the money stolen by the Bin Buttis.'
The claims come as EY is accused of 'extremely serious' failings in its audits of NMC Health that resulted in the accountancy giant allegedly missing one of the biggest frauds ever involving a London-listed company.
Alvarez & Marsal claims EY's accountants 'never even opened the books' at NMC Health. EY said it was a 'principal target and victim' of the alleged fraud.
Lawyers for the accountancy firm separately accused Abdul Rahman Basaddiq, the former head of EY's Abu Dhabi office, of having enabled the fraud. At a hearing on Wednesday, lawyers for EY told the High Court that Mr Basaddiq was 'plainly a fraudster'.
The Bin Butti brothers did not respond to Telegraph requests for comment. Khalifa bin Butti told The Times in 2020 that 'any suggestion that I have been involved in wrongdoing is categorically rejected'.
Abdul Rahman Basaddiq did not respond to requests for comment.
An EY spokesman said: 'This was a complex, pervasive and collusive fraud, and responsibility for it lies squarely with its perpetrators, including NMC's owners, directors and the treasury and finance team.
'This case is without merit and the full extent of this unprecedented fraud – of which EY was one of the targets – will be exposed during the course of the trial.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
My daughter Lauren Patterson was raped and murdered in Qatar - she had wanted to leave the country and we still don't know what has happened to her killer
The mother of a woman who was murdered in Qatar still has no idea whether her killer has been released more than a decade on from the tragedy. Lauren Patterson was teaching at a primary school in the Qatari capital Doha when she went missing after going to a party in October 2013. Her body was found in the desert after she was raped and murdered by Badr Hashim Khamis Abdallah al-Jabr in a brutal attack. Lauren's family were told he would face a death sentence after being jailed for the 'heinous and shocking' attack in 2014. But in May 2018, the decision was overturned and he was instead given only ten-and-a-half years in jail, while Lauren's family were offered just £200,000 compensation. More than seven years on, Lauren's mother Alison, 60, is clueless as to what has happened to her daughter's killer - most crucially, if he has been freed. The loving mother, who lives in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, has tried for years to find answers from Qatar's authorities, but has been blocked at every turn and was even accused of plotting to kill al-Jabr. This wall of silence has left Alison unable to move on from Lauren's death, while the situation has also been a burden on the 24-year-old's friends still living in Qatar and fearing they could bump into al-Jabr at any moment. 'We have written personally to the Emir but never had a reply. We gave letters to the Qatari embassy but heard nothing,' Alison told The Sun. 'You don't move on, but you're putting a line under one part of it, you're coming to terms with he's out.' She has asked the Foreign Office and the Qatari Government to tell her whether al-Jabr is still behind bars but has been met with a 'stonewall of silence'. Alison was even accused of plotting to kill al-Jabr after she received a text message from her lawyers in Doha, saying: 'Good morning, we were accused to set up a trap to kill him when will be released.' The outlandish suggestion is rendered the more ridiculous, as she said she did not want him to face the death penalty when he was convicted of Lauren's murder. But she was later horrified when the charge was dropped to manslaughter and al-Jabr was sentenced to just ten-and-a-half years in jail for killing her and burning her body before hiding in the desert outside Doha. She and her husband Kevin, 62, believe he was released in the months leading up to the 10th anniversary of his crime and is enjoying his freedom. The couple fear he could easily run into Lauren's friends who still live in the capital - or worse, he could kill again. In the months before her death, Lauren had been thinking about moving jobs to another country as she had become 'uncomfortable' living in Qatar. 'She was feeling a little bit apprehensive, there were things she wasn't comfortable with. The school was good, she really enjoyed that. It was other things,' Alison said. When Alison's mother became seriously ill, Lauren had sought to leave the country to visit her, but was denied permission to leave by Qatari authorities. Sadly, the young teacher missed the opportunity to say goodbye and was eventually granted leave to attend her funeral. She flew back to Qatar the day after on October 11 and immediately after arriving back in her flat, her friend suggested they go out for a few drinks. Lauren barely had time to unpack her suitcase and planned to do so the next day. Tragically, she would never get the chance, as later that night she was abducted by al-Jabr and his accomplice, Muhammad Abdullah Hassan Abdul Aziz. The pair had offered to drive Lauren and her friend home after they were unable to find a taxi. The two women were on friendly terms with them both and had no idea of their vile intentions. Lauren's friend was dropped off at her home first, despite living further away than her. Lauren was raped, stabbed multiple times then taken out into the desert where she was burnt beyond recognition. Alison began to worry when she nor Lauren's friends had heard from her. They began a desperate search for the 24-year-old, which sickeningly al-Jabr also joined in with. Her body was eventually found when two falconers noticed something odd when their birds failed to return to them in the desert miles outside Doha. They went to investigate and found Lauren's burned remains with a knife still in her body. Her killer and his accomplice used petrol to set her on fire before fleeing back to the city believing their crime would never be discovered. Al-Jabr was already a suspect - he was the last person to see Lauren alive and had scratches on his face. But Qatar police believed in the adage that a killer always returns to the scene of his crime and staked out the desert spot where Lauren was found. Jabr and his Rayban-wearing accomplice Mohamed Abdallah Hassan Abdul Aziz were arrested when they drove out to the desert to check on their gruesome handiwork. While she may never get any answers, Alison is adamant to shine a light on what she believes to be an example of Qatar's shameful human rights record. She made headlines in 2022 after criticising former England soccer captain David Beckham who was paid tens of millions to back the World Cup in Qatar. Then she wrote to every footballer in the squad along with manager Gareth Southgate asking them to highlight Lauren's death by making an L-shape with their hands on the pitch. She did not receive a reply. But she and Kevin, who live near Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, remain unrelating in the quest for justice for Lauren no matter how long it takes.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
‘TikTok addicted' mum-of-two, 29, who stole £300k from her firm to spend on ‘tokens' for favourite creators is jailed
A SOCIAL media "addicted" mum who stole £300,000 from her employer to blow on TikTok "tokens" has been jailed. Katherine Greenall was in tears in the dock yesterday as she was told she'd be locked up for pinching the vast sum from a car company where she worked as an accounts manager. 3 3 3 The mum-of-two, 29, spent the vast majority of the cash on TikTok tokens, which users can gift to their favourite creators. However, the court also heard Greenall also treated herself to holidays, hotel stays and Amazon purchases during her year-long "voyage of fraud and misadventure", reports the Manchester Evening News. The thief claimed she now has only a few hundred pounds left in her bank account. Liverpool Crown Court heard on Friday afternoon, Greenall began working for St Helens-based New Reg Ltd, a technology firm which specialises in purchasing vehicles for clients, in a lesser role in April 2021. The mum, of the town's Gloucester Street, was promoted in December 2022, giving her access to business bank accounts. Prosecutor Christopher Taylor was considered "vital" to the growing firm and described as "both trusted and respected" before it was found she was siphoning off the funds into her own accounts. Analysis of Greenall's bank statements showed during 2023 she received 53 unauthorised deposits totalling £57,036 from her employer. During this period, she also began increasing her spending at supermarkets, as well as other food outlets, sports retailers and Amazon Prime. The court heard she also used the funds to pay for a family solicitor. Her spree ramped up in the early months of the following year, boosting her bank balance by another £196,364.26 by April 2024. Such large sums going missing raised suspicions amongst Greenall's superiors and were put to the defendant in a meeting with the company director on May 1. She pledged to investigate before making a "final deposit" of £20,000 immediately after and then left the office claiming there was an illness in her family. Greenall would later admit criminality during a meeting six days later and she was arrested on May 13. She told detectives she had been "living a lavish lifestyle" and had only £700 in her bank account. The mum said initially she'd been using the stolen money to pay for household purchases before she began funding her TikTok"obsession". Tokens on the platform can be bought with real money and exchanged for virtual gifts that users can send to creators during live streams, which can then be exchanged back to real cash. Greenall said the crime spree came "at a time when she was low", the court heard. Overall, she pinched £443,523.26 out of the company over 121 separate transactions, and spent £301,162.55 on TikTok tokens. Her actions jeopardised the future of the firm and placed over 30 former colleagues at risk of redundancy. Paul Becker, defending, told the court that his client "may have been suffering from a form of addiction to TikTok", but stated that she had "no formal diagnosis to such an addiction". Greenall's two children, an 11-year-old boy with severe ADHD, and a six-year-old girl, are anticipated to be looked after by their mum's sister. The defendant admitted one count of fraud by abuse of position and was jailed for 28 months. One of her supporters told her "I love you" from the public gallery as Greenall was led away. Judge Neil Flewitt KC said: "It is a tragedy that those children are going to suffer as a result of your dishonesty. "I have taken the view that there is simply no way to avoid what I am sure you have been advised is the inevitable sentence of imprisonment.
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Lebanon aims to bring tourists back to its beaches as travel bans finally lift
In a bid to revive Lebanon 's tourism sector, the Tourism Ministry recently hosted a retro-themed event at Beirut 's St. Georges Hotel. Fireworks illuminated the night sky above the Mediterranean Sea, while classic hits from the 1960s and 70s played in the background. The event aimed to evoke the "golden era" before the civil war of 1975, when Lebanon was a prime destination for wealthy tourists from the Gulf, drawn to its beaches, mountains, and vibrant nightlife. The event hopes to promote the upcoming summer season. In the decade after the war, tourists from Gulf countries – and crucially, Saudi Arabia – came back, and so did Lebanon's economy. But by the early 2000s, as the Iran -backed militant group Hezbollah gained power, Lebanon's relations with Gulf countries began to sour. Tourism gradually dried up, starving its economy of billions of dollars in annual spending. Now, after last year's bruising war with Israel, Hezbollah is much weaker and Lebanon's new political leaders sense an opportunity to revitalize the economy once again with help from wealthy neighbors. They aim to disarm Hezbollah and rekindle ties with Saudi Arabia and other Gulf countries, which in recent years have prohibited their citizens from visiting Lebanon or importing its products. 'Tourism is a big catalyst, and so it's very important that the bans get lifted,' said Laura Khazen Lahoud, the country's tourism minister. On the highway leading to the Beirut airport, once-ubiquitous banners touting Hezbollah's leadership have been replaced with commercial billboards and posters that read 'a new era for Lebanon.' In the center of Beirut, and especially in neighborhoods that hope to attract tourists, political posters are coming down, and police and army patrols are on the rise. There are signs of thawing relations with some Gulf neighbors. The United Arab Emirates and Kuwait have lifted yearslong travel bans. All eyes are now on Saudi Arabia, a regional political and economic powerhouse, to see if it will follow suit, according to Lahoud and other Lebanese officials. A key sticking point is security, these officials say. Although a ceasefire with Israel has been in place since November, near-daily airstrikes have continued in southern and eastern Lebanon, where Hezbollah over the years had built its political base and powerful military arsenal. As vital as tourism is — it accounted for almost 20% of Lebanon's economy before it tanked in 2019 — the country's leaders say it is just one piece of a larger puzzle they are trying to put back together. Lebanon's agricultural and industrial sectors are in shambles, suffering a major blow in 2021, when Saudi Arabia banned their exports after accusing Hezbollah of smuggling drugs into Riyadh. Years of economic dysfunction have left the country's once-thriving middle class in a state of desperation. The World Bank says poverty nearly tripled in Lebanon over the past decade, affecting close to half its population of nearly 6 million. To make matters worse, inflation is soaring, with the Lebanese pound losing 90% of its value, and many families lost their savings when banks collapsed. Tourism is seen by Lebanon's leaders as the best way to kickstart the reconciliation needed with Gulf countries -- and only then can they move on to exports and other economic growth opportunities. 'It's the thing that makes most sense, because that's all Lebanon can sell now,' said Sami Zoughaib, research manager at The Policy Initiative, a Beirut-based think tank. With summer still weeks away, flights to Lebanon are already packed with expats and locals from countries that overturned their travel bans, and hotels say bookings have been brisk. At the event hosted last month by the tourism ministry, the owner of the St. Georges Hotel, Fady El-Khoury, beamed. The hotel, owned by his father in its heyday, has acutely felt Lebanon's ups and downs over the decades, closing and reopening multiple times because of wars. 'I have a feeling that the country is coming back after 50 years,' he said. On a recent weekend, as people crammed the beaches of the northern city of Batroun, and jet skis whizzed along the Mediterranean, local business people sounded optimistic that the country was on the right path. 'We are happy, and everyone here is happy,' said Jad Nasr, co-owner of a private beach club. 'After years of being boycotted by the Arabs and our brothers in the Gulf, we expect this year for us to always be full.' Still, tourism is not a panacea for Lebanon's economy, which for decades has suffered from rampant corruption and waste. Lebanon has been in talks with the International Monetary Fund for years over a recovery plan that would include billions in loans and require the country to combat corruption, restructure its banks, and bring improvements to a range of public services, including electricity and water. Without those and other reforms, Lebanon's wealthy neighbors will lack confidence to invest there, experts said. A tourism boom alone would serve as a 'morphine shot that would only temporarily ease the pain" rather than stop the deepening poverty in Lebanon, Zoughaib said. The tourism minister, Lahoud, agreed, saying a long-term process has only just begun. "But we're talking about subjects we never talked about before,' she said. 'And I think the whole country has realized that war doesn't serve anyone, and that we really need our economy to be back and flourish again.'
