Meaning of ‘woman' goes beyond dictionary definition, court hears as Giggle for Girls appeal concludes
Giggle for Girls and its CEO, Sall Grover, are challenging Justice Robert Bromwich's August 2024 federal court judgment that found Roxanne Tickle, a transgender woman, was indirectly discriminated against when she was barred from the platform in September 2021. The case was the first gender identity discrimination case to reach the federal court.
Much of the proceedings, which concluded on Wednesday, centred on the definition of sex, woman and what it means to be a woman.
On Wednesday, Celia Winnett, the barrister for the Sex Discrimination Commissioner, who acted as a friend of the court, said the definition of 'women does include transgender women'.
The full court of the federal court heard Giggle for Girls and Grover argue that the Sex Discrimination Act bears the 'ordinary' meaning of men and women.
But Winnett said that ''woman' does now have a broader ordinary meaning … informed by its use' and that the meaning was 'broad enough to include trans women'.
'There's no need for ordinary meaning to hinge or rely on dictionary meanings,' she said.
On Monday, Grover's barrister, Noel Hutley SC, told the court that 'even today, the Macquarie dictionary defines the word 'women' by reference to what I have called 'natal' woman'. A natal woman is a term used to describe a person who was assigned female at birth.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
Giggle for Girls and Grover argue the app was allowed to discriminate against men because it was a special measure that redressed historical disadvantage between men and women. Grover has persistently misgendered Tickle and claims she did not know Tickle was a trans woman when she barred her from the app.
The words 'opposite sex' were replaced with 'different sex' in the Sex Discrimination Act in 2013, when amendments made it unlawful under federal law to discriminate against a person on the basis of sexual orientation, gender identity or intersex status. Man, woman and sex are not defined in the act.
Ruth Higgins SC, acting for Equality Australia, on Wednesday told the court that transgender people experienced unique forms of identity discrimination and that 'sex' included social recognition and personal identification.
'Sex is way of classifying people along a scale between a man at one end and woman at the other,' she said. 'Sex at birth is but one conception of sex.'
A purely biological definition relied on a 'false simplicity', she said, questioning whether biological meant anatomical, chromosomal, hormonal or a balance thereof.
The Lesbian Action Group was also given leave to intervene in the appeal. Its barrister, Leigh Howard, referred to the For Women Scotland case, when the UK supreme court in April issued a historic and definitive ruling that the terms 'woman' and 'sex' in the UK's Equality Act refer only to a biological woman and to biological sex.
He said 'sex is a biological condition, not an identity' and urged for the word 'woman' to be given the same meaning throughout the act.
Georgina Costello KC, Tickle's barrister, said Giggle for Girls' policy to exclude transgender women from the app disadvantaged transgender women – and that those women could face gender identity discrimination because of a discordance between their appearance and their identity.
Because Giggle for Girls required users to have a gender identity that appeared consistent with their gender identity at birth, direct discrimination – rather than indirect discrimination as Bromwich found – was a 'better fit', she argued.
But her opposition said it could not have been parliament's intention, when writing the Sex Discrimination Act, for protected measures – such as gender identity – to prejudice special measures for women.
'It would be an extraordinary by-blow of this exercise that expanding protection in effect undermines the ability to set up measures to achieve substantive equality,' Hutley said.
Over the two-and-half-day appeal, the court heard Tickle was seeking $40,000 in damages and that she was treated as a 'hostile invader' when joining the app.
A finding is expected by February.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
12 minutes ago
- The Independent
‘This is America': New Jersey gym teacher told Egyptian Muslim student she'd be in ‘jail' by 16 during bullying campaign, lawsuit alleges
A student who recently graduated from a New Jersey high school was bullied by a former gym teacher over her Egyptian heritage, dark skin, and Muslim faith, a lawsuit claims. Jana Gadalla, 19, has named the teacher, Kathie DeBonis, Bridgewater-Raritan High School principal Vincent DelPriore, and her school district as defendants in her suit. Gadalla alleges that DeBonis — who was also a longtime girls' lacrosse coach and health teacher — made numerous insulting comments to her about her ethnicity and religion during the 2022-2023 school year. The Independent has requested comment from DeBonis and the school district. On one occasion, DeBonis allegedly told Gadalla that "this is America" and that "by the time you are 16 you will probably be in jail anyway." DeBonis allegedly told the girl during Ramadan that "if I were you, I would just go drink alcohol" and allegedly asked, "Do you think you're going to go to hell or something?" Gadalla also claims that DeBonis called her obese and assigned her a three-page paper on obesity that she had to finish before she was allowed to use the bathroom. During another Ramadan-related incident, DeBonis allegedly told Gadalla, 'It's good that you're fasting during Ramadan, maybe you'll lose some weight.' According to the lawsuit, Gadalla went to the principal and her school counselor about her treatment, and she was moved out of the woman's class. DeBonis allegedly asked, "Who snitched to the principal?" when Gadall was being moved from the class. The lawsuit claims that Gadalla suffered 'physical manifestations of emotional distress as well as personal hardships including anxiety, adjustment problems, sleep disturbance, humiliation (and) mental pain and anguish," stemming from the interactions. It further alleges that DeBonis' behavior was targeted, noting that she did not 'mock, shame or make inappropriate comments to light skinned non-Muslim, non-Egyptian students.' The district has to respond to the lawsuit by August 29. According to DeBonis retired in the 2023-2024 school year and is now collecting an annual pension of $70,000.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
What is Guan Yin Citta Dharma Door, the Buddhist group at the centre of an alleged spy case in Australia?
A controversial Buddhist organisation, at the centre of an alleged Chinese espionage case in Australia, has raised concerns about Beijing keeping tabs on Chinese diaspora overseas. Guan Yin Citta Dharma Door is an international Buddhist organisation with multiple chapters in Australia. This month, a Chinese-born woman was charged with reckless foreign interference, accused of spying on the group's Australian branches and its members on behalf of the Chinese Communist party's intelligence organs. Australian police have said the investigation is ongoing and more people could be charged. Guan Yin Citta practises Mahayana Buddhism, the most common type of Buddhism in China. But the organisation is controversial. News reports have detailed unusual and fringe beliefs the group promotes, and the history of its late founder, Master Jun Hong Lu, who died in 2021. It has been banned in China, and people warned to steer clear of it. The organisation claims to have 10 million members worldwide, with 5 million in China, but the Chinese government says it is just 50,000. State media has accused it of being a cult with 'evil theories', and officials have vowed to crack down on it with 'an iron fist'. In 2016, a Henan province follower was jailed for five years for printing 100,000 copies of an 'unauthorised' Guan Yin Citta journal. Before his death, Lu had been banned from entering China. It has been criticised by Buddhist groups in China, Hong Kong and Malaysia for allegedly distorting teachings, and Master Lu of abusing Buddhist scriptures and mantras and 'using the illusion of supernatural powers to mislead believers', according to a 2015 letter by 16 Malaysian Buddhist groups. Nevertheless, Guan Yin Citta is legal in Australia, and while the controversies around the organisation muddy the waters a little, allegations of surveillance support claims about the CCP's intolerance of religious groups outside its direct control. Sign up: AU Breaking News email John Fitzgerald, a historian of China, says that under the increasingly authoritarian rule of Xi Jinping, all things that could threaten the party in any way are seen as equivalent. 'There's almost no calibration any longer,' Fitzgerald told the Guardian. 'Anything that threatens the august and unrivalled authority of the party, no matter how trivial, is treated as a grave threat.' Fitzgerald says the CCP looks at religion as a cultural signifier of ethnicity, something that has to be managed inside both China and diaspora communities who could influence the domestic population. Under the strict political rule of the Communist party, China is officially an atheist state. The government officially recognises Buddhism, along with Catholicism, Islam, Protestantism and Taoism, but the practise of those religions is strictly policed. Buddhism, Taoism and some folk religions are generally treated less harshly than Islam and Christianity, analysts have noted, but believers across all religions have faced repression and persecution by the CCP – most notably the Muslim population in Xinjiang, and Tibetan Buddhists. 'The CCP leaders know that it is not easy to completely eradicate these religions out of China. (There are even CCP members who are secretly following these religions),' says Julie Yu-Wen Chen, a professor of Chinese Studies at the University of Helsinki. 'The best strategy is to sinicise them to make them suitable for the Chinese society and then to control and monitor the practices on the ground.' Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion The CCP will often use suitably sinicised practises for its soft diplomacy. Much of it is driven by China's state administration for religious affairs, and the Buddhist Association of China, which seek to work with Buddhists globally in pursuit of the CCP's goals, often hosting international Buddhism conferences and making targeted foreign investments through Xi's flagship overseas investment regime, the belt and road initiative. 'They recognise religion as subversive,' Fitzgerald says. 'They're not going to allow that subversion to happen in China or anything like that. But they will take full advantage of it in any other community.' As China's security apparatus expands, reaching across the world with extraterritorial security laws, extensive espionage and infiltration networks, and rising rates of transnational repression, it has become an unavoidable national security issue for other countries like Australia. Religious groups and practitioners, dissidents, lawyers and journalists are among those frequently targeted. Foreign interference has affected bilateral relations. Last week Australia joined other nations in condemning China's persecution of exiled Hong Kong pro-democracy activists. Meanwhile, across the world, Uyghurs have been harassed, surveilled and deported en masse to Xinjiang, and nations reacted with alarm to revelations of a network of secret overseas Chinese police stations. 'There's far greater awareness now in Australia of the implications of this thing for national security,' Fitzgerald says. Additional research by Jason Tzu Kuan Lu
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Scorned ex-girlfriend of Mark Latham's explosive revenge plot texts leak - where she threatens to expose the SECOND woman in his life: 'I am outing her... Get in the mud'
A woman who was dragged into a 'toxic' feud between Mark Latham and his ex Nathalie Matthews has revealed the stunning lengths a 'scorned' Matthews was prepared to go after accusing her of being 'in bed' with Latham. The Sydney woman, who the Daily Mail has chosen not to name, said Ms Matthews became 'absolutely wild' with rage after learning she had struck up a relationship with Latham before her own relationship with the politician fell apart. In a series of text messages obtained by the Daily Mail, Ms Matthews warned a close associate that she 'might tell a journo about' the woman, after recent allegations against Latham were made public. 'Why not? She was in bed with pig - get in the mud too,' she said. 'I don't believe her bulls***,' she wrote, adding: 'I am outing her.' After the woman was spotted at Latham's side at a racing event, she claimed Ms Matthews took to social media to question why a man with a 'beautiful young girlfriend' would choose to 'date an old wrinkly one'. On a separate occasion, she said Ms Matthews discovered a picture of Latham at the races alongside an 'unidentified blonde' and followed up with a post to Instagram with a caption along the lines of '#upgradeblonde'. The woman, who is married, told the Daily Mail that she was stunned to learn Ms Matthews, with whom she had never spoken, held any ill feelings towards her. . Behind the scenes, she was told Ms Matthew's had gone 'absolutely wild', demanding Latham name the mystery woman he had been spotted with at the races. 'Apparently, she went on and on and then he told her and she looked me up on social media and she then had my name in her head,' she said. 'She had it in for me and I don't know why... I was no threat to her, but she obviously thought I was.' Ms Matthews is seeking an AVO against Latham after alleging he inflicted a 'sustained pattern' of psychological, financial and emotional abuse against her. The former federal Labor leader has denied all abuse claims made by Ms Matthews, alleging the pair's relationship was consensual. The woman claimed Ms Matthews' ire only grew when she went through Latham's phone and found some innocent pictures of the pair attending lunch together. 'I think she blew it out of proportion. I don't know if he made it out that I was more of a threat than I was, I don't know,' she said. The unnamed woman recalled meeting Latham at a racing event in August last year and, after learning who he was, became 'star-struck'. She said the politician was 'quite persistent' in getting her number and she soon began attending regular lunches with him over the next few months. 'Look, I did go to the Fullerton (hotel) but it wasn't what it seems... And there was certainly no defecating either,' she added. Among the accusations levelled against Latham in her AVO application to the NSW Local Court, Ms Matthews alleged he defecated on her before sex and refused to let her wash. In his affidavit, Latham accepted he did perform the vile sex act on Ms Matthews on one occasion but said he only did it 'because it turned her on'. The second woman said her relationship with Latham was a 'confidante kind of companionship', adding the pair would often discuss Latham's frustrations with Ms Matthews, whose work often took her abroad. 'I could see there were a lot of problems in that relationship,' she said, adding Latham would tell her 'everything'. 'He longed for a normal relationship… he said that they had an open arrangement because she had people in Dubai, and that she came and went as she pleased and he wasn't happy with that,' she said. The woman decided to cut ties with Latham a few months into their relationship after sensing she had become a pawn in a 'toxic game'. 'I was starting to get feelings back, during the months we were having lunch, and I didn't want to go when I realised what was going on with him and her, (so) I ended it,' she said. 'I said: 'Look, I can't keep, I don't want to be in the middle of your guys' games' and so we stopped having lunch.' She added: 'They obviously had a very toxic game going on.'
