Hamas' iron grip on Gaza is slowly slipping as residents protest
Speaking out is dangerous. Hamas has never tolerated dissent. Moumen seems undaunted, writing a furious column for the Washington Post at the end of March."To support Hamas is to be for Palestinian death," he wrote, "not Palestinian freedom".Wasn't it dangerous to speak out in this way, I asked him."We need to take a risk and speak out," he replied without hesitation."I'm 30 years old. When Hamas took over, I was 11. What have I done with my life? My life has been wasted between war and escalating violence for nothing."
Since Hamas took control of Gaza in 2007 by violently ousting political rivals, a year after winning national elections, there have been three major wars with Israel and two smaller conflicts."Humanity demands that we raise our voices," al-Natour said, "despite suppression by Hamas".Hamas may be busy fighting Israel, but it's not afraid to punish its critics.At the end of March, 22-year old Oday al-Rubai was abducted by armed gunmen from a refugee shelter in Gaza City.Hours later, his body was found covered in horrific wounds.The Palestinian Independent Commission for Human Rights said Oday had been tortured, calling his death "a grave violation of the right to life and an extrajudicial killing".
Al-Rubai had participated in recent anti-Hamas protests. His family blamed Hamas for his death and demanded justice.Days earlier, a frightened al-Rubai posted a dark, grainy video on social media in which he expressed his fear that Hamas militants were coming for him."Gaza has become a city of ghosts," he said, glancing over his shoulder."I'm stranded in the street, not knowing where to go. I don't know why they're after me. They destroyed us and brought ruin to us."At his funeral, a small crowd demanded revenge and repeated demands for Hamas to get out of Gaza.
Last summer, Amin Abed almost suffered the same fate, following his decision to speak out against Hamas.Masked militants beat him senseless, broke bones all over his body and damaged his kidneys. Abed survived but had to seek medical treatment abroad.Now living in Dubai, he's still involved in the protest movement, and believes that Hamas' authority is diminished."Hamas' power has begun to fade," he told me."It targets activists and civilians, beats and kills them to scare people. But it's not how it was before."Before the ceasefire collapsed last month, Hamas fighters seemed intent on highly visible displays of power.But now, with Israel once again attacking relentlessly, the same gunmen have retreated underground and Gaza's civilians have been plunged back into the misery of war.Some of the more recent protests suggest that civilians, driven to the edge of madness by a year and a half of Israeli bombardment, are losing their fear of Hamas.
Beit Lahiya, at the northern end of the Gaza Strip, has seen some of the most vociferous opposition.In a series of voice notes, an eyewitness – who asked not to be named – described several recent incidents in which local residents prevented Hamas fighters from carrying out military actions from inside their community.On 13 April, he said, Hamas gunmen tried to force their way into the house of an elderly man, Jamal al-Maznan."They wanted to launch rockets and pipes [a derogatory term used for some of Hamas' home-made projectiles] from inside his house," the eyewitness told us."But he refused."The incident soon escalated, with relatives and neighbours all coming to al-Maznan's defence. The gunmen opened fire, injuring several people, but eventually were driven out."They were not intimidated by the bullets," the eyewitness said of the protesters."They advanced and told [the gunmen] to take their things and flee. We don't want you in this place. We don't want your weapons that have brought us destruction, devastation and death."
Elsewhere in Gaza, protesters have told militants to stay away from hospitals and schools, to avoid situations in which civilians are caught up in Israeli air strikes.But such defiance is still risky. In Gaza City, Hamas shot one such protester dead.With little to lose and hopes of an end to the war dashed once more, some Gazans direct their fury equally at Israel and Hamas.Asked which side he blamed most for Gaza's catastrophe, Amin Abed said it was "a choice between cholera and the plague".The protest movement of recent weeks is not yet a rebellion, but after almost 20 years of rule Hamas' iron grip on Gaza is slowly slipping.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
Israel to continue with Gaza City offensive despite talks to free Hamas hostages
Israel will resume negotiations with Hamas for the release of all hostages captured during the October 7 attack, Benjamin Netanyahu has said - but its military will continue its Gaza City offensive despite international outcry. The remarks from Israel's prime minister are the first since Hamas agreed to a temporary ceasefire proposal. Talks will also be with a view to ending the war, but Mr Netanyahu said it must be on "terms acceptable to Israel". In the meantime, the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) have begun calling medics and international organisations in northern Gaza to encourage them to evacuate to the south ahead of the expanded operation in Gaza City. Many of Israel's closest allies have urged the government to reconsider. Some Israelis fear it could doom the remaining 20 or so living hostages taken by Hamas-led militants in the 7 October 2023 attack which ignited the war. Israel plans to call up 60,000 reservists and extend the service of 20,000 more. Speaking to soldiers near Israel's border with Gaza, Mr Netanyahu said he was still set on approving plans for defeating Hamas and capturing Gaza City. "At the same time I have issued instructions to begin immediate negotiations for the release of all our hostages and an end to the war on terms acceptable to Israel," he said. "These two things - defeating Hamas and releasing all our hostages - go hand in hand," he added. The latest ceasefire proposal drawn up by Egypt and Qatar is almost identical to an earlier one that Israel accepted before the talks stalled last month. The proposal would include the release of some hostages in exchange for Palestinian prisoners, a pullback of Israeli forces and negotiations over a lasting ceasefire. 'Don't tell us where to build' Israeli strikes killed at least 36 Palestinians across Gaza on Thursday, according to local hospitals, including at a tent camp in Deir al-Balah. Meanwhile, Israel's ambassador to the UK, Tzipi Hotovely, was summoned to the Foreign Office in response to a controversial West Bank settlement plan which has been given final approval. The project, known as the E1 settlement, would effectively cut off the occupied West Bank from East Jerusalem and divide the territory in two. The UK and 21 international partners have released a statement to condemn the decision "in the strongest terms" calling it "a flagrant breach of international law" and "critically undermining a two-state solution". Ms Hotovely gave Sky News her response to the meeting: "I said we wouldn't tell the British where to build in London. Don't tell us where to build in Jerusalem, our capital. We see E1 as part of Greater Jerusalem." 11:50 UK warns of 'horrifying starvation' The UK has also responded to comments from the head of the UN Palestinian refugee agency UNRWA that famine in Gaza is "deliberate" and being used as an "instrument of war". Minister for the Middle East, Hamish Falconer, has called for a "comprehensive [peace] plan to end this misery and get to a long-term settlement". "Israel must immediately and permanently lift all barriers preventing aid reaching the people of Gaza to prevent the horrifying starvation in the Strip continuing," he added. Demand for Gaza media access The Media Freedom Coalition, which includes the UK and 50 other countries, has called on Israel to allow foreign media access into Gaza. In a joint statement, the coalition, which is a partnership of countries working to defend media freedom, urged Israel to "allow immediate independent foreign media access" and "afford protection for journalists operating in Gaza". They said this was in light of the "unfolding humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza".
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Israel launches ANOTHER explosive attack on Anthony Albanese: 'Something is wrong'
The diplomatic stoush between Australia and Israel has cranked up another gear, with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu using a television appearance to blast Anthony Albanese 's leadership record. Mr Albanese has flagged that Australia will join other Western nations, including the UK, France and Canada, in recognising a state of Palestine at the United Nations General Assembly in September, in response to the worsening humanitarian crisis in Gaza. A furious Mr Netanyahu unleashed on Mr Albanese during an interview on Australian television on Thursday night. 'I'm sure he has a reputable record as a public servant, but I think his record is forever tarnished by the weakness that he showed in the face of these Hamas terrorist monsters,' Mr Netanyahu told Sky News. 'When the worst terrorist organisation on earth... which murdered women, raped them, beheaded men and burnt babies alive in front of their parents and took hundreds of hostages, when these people congratulate the prime minister of Australia, you know something is wrong.' Diplomatic ties hit an all-time low this week after the federal government denied a visa to far-right Israeli politician Simcha Rothman from entering the country for a speaking tour, following provocative comments. Israel retaliated by cancelling the visas of three Australian diplomats who cover the Palestinian Authority. 'When Prime Minister Albanese and the leaders of France and Britain and others, when they say we'll give them a Palestinian state, they are actually rewarding terror, they are saying it doesn't matter what horrors you people do,' Mr Netanyahu said. '(Australia and Israel) had a great relationship over the years. I think it's gone astray because leaders did not show the strength and conviction they should have, when we're fighting the war of Western civilisation against these barbarians.' Mr Netanyahu's broadside came as the Israeli military maintains pressure on Gaza City with heavy bombardments ahead of an offensive to seize the enclave's largest city. The military has called up 60,000 Israeli reservists. Mr Netanyahu hinted that the conflict could soon be over. 'We are on the verge of completing this war... when that happens, I think we will have tremendous opportunities to expand the peace,' he said. 'We will win.' Earlier this week, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke said Israel was increasingly isolated on the international stage. 'Strength is not measured by how many people you can blow up or how many children you can leave hungry. Strength is much better measured by exactly what Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has done,' he told ABC Radio National on Wednesday.
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Netanyahu is now gambling with more than just hostages' lives
If the prime minister of Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu, possessed anything like the qualities of statesmanship demanded at a moment such as this, he would by now have seized the offer of peace deal from Hamas, agreed a ceasefire, begun the long and difficult process of winding down the pitiless war in Gaza and, of enormous immediate benefit, secured the return of about half the remaining 20 hostages thought to still be alive, as well as the bodies of others. The worst sufferings of the families affected would be that much closer to a conclusion – and the much wider pain and hardship, including hunger, being endured by innocent Palestinian civilians would also be relieved. The ceasefire deal is by no means a perfect offer, and – it bears repeating – there was never any reason for the Hamas terrorists to take any hostages or commit any of the atrocities that occurred on 7 October 2023. According to Qatari sources who've been involved in brokering the talks, the deal suggested by Hamas and now put forward to the Israeli government is 'almost identical' to an American proposal that the Israelis had previously accepted. And yet Mr Netanyahu seems intent on finding excuses and distractions to avoid making peace. He has not yet explicitly rejected the deal – but asked by Australian television if Israel planned to take over all of Gaza and eliminate Hamas even if the group agreed to a truce and hostage deal, he was clear: 'We're going to do that anyway. That there was never a question that we're not going to leave Hamas there.' Simultaneously, he now wants to restart negotiations with Hamas aimed at returning all of Israel's remaining hostages – but is clear he wants to end the war on Israel's terms. The prime minister's spokesperson says, despite precedents, that the Israeli government is not interested in "partial deals". It wants all the hostages back, and is prepared to pursue the military option, despite past failures and with no guarantee that the hostages will come out of renewed fighting alive. No one should be surprised that, unlike some of his more far-sighted predecessors, Mr Netanyahu isn't prepared to take a risk for peace, but rather views with equanimity the prospect of none of the hostages making it out alive after almost two years of ruthless warfare. He is prepared to gamble with their lives. As if to make sure that there's no prospect of even this minimal peace agreement becoming reality, Mr Netanyahu has ordered yet another military offensive, in the already devastated Gaza City, and has called up 60,000 new reservists and extended the tour of duty of 20,000 others to undertake the currently expanded operation. No less grievously, the government, driven by its most extreme elements, is determined to expel more Palestinians from the homes and lands on the occupied West Bank. One aim is to annex territory to the state of Israel and isolate Jerusalem from the rest of the West Bank, part of a wider scheme to render the creation of a viable independent sovereign Palestinian state impossible. It is a scheme that has been long in the offing, but until now has not been pursued with the explicit backing of the state. Now, Israel is going beyond its shameful actions in the illegal settlements and is turning this lawlessness into official policy. The Palestinian Authority pleads that it will destroy the possibility of a two-state solution. That outcome, of course, is entirely to the liking of Mr Netanyahu and his allies. Like the continuation of the war in the face of any and every offer of peace, it is a cynical exercise in continuing Mr Netanyahu's time in office, staving off the days when he will have to face the Israeli electorate and resume his trial on corruption charges. More than ever, indeed, Mr Netanyahu is emboldened to pursue his personal interests before peace. International pressure isn't working. He is already indicted at the International Court for crimes against humanity, and countries previously friendly to Israel and who defend its right to exist and defend itself are ostracised by the way its leaders have conducted the war in Gaza. Hence the momentum that has built in Britain, France, Australia and elsewhere to formally recognise the state of Palestine. Its Arab neighbours cannot make peace with a nation that behaves in the way Israel has. The fact is that, despite the destruction, probably temporary, of Iran's nuclear programme, and the rout of Hamas, Israel is now realistically less secure than before this disproportionate war was launched and Mr Netanyahu decided to lash out – much as Hamas desired. The UN is treated with contempt, its aid agencies driven out of Gaza, and substituted with a US-Israel-backed body whose guards allegedly use children for target practice. Depressingly, there is only one power in the world that can restrain Israel and steer it back to obeying international law, honouring humanitarian norms, and securing its long-term stability – and that is, of course, the United States. To the extent that what Israel has done has happened as a result of the consent of Joe Biden and then, even more enthusiastically granting a free hand, Donald Trump, the disaster engulfing the entire region is almost as much the fault of America as Israel. None of that, though, and no military action or drive for illegal settlements on Palestinian territory can dispel the central abiding truth: there can be no peace without a two-state solution.
