Harry lawyers must disclose ‘payment' documents in Mail publisher case
They have accused the publisher of conducting or commissioning unlawful activities such as hiring private investigators to tap phones, 'blagging' private records, and burglaries to order.
The group also includes actress Sadie Frost, campaigner Baroness Doreen Lawrence and politician Sir Simon Hughes.
ANL denies the allegations and is defending the legal action, previously describing the claims as 'lurid' and 'simply preposterous'.
At a hearing in May, lawyers for ANL asked the court in London to order the group's legal team to 'search for and disclose any documents that relate to payments, royalties or inducements paid, provided or offered, or any demands or threats made, in order to obtain documents, information or other co-operation'.
Antony White KC, for ANL, said a limited number of documents had been disclosed, which showed that 'payments were made or offered' to 'procure evidence and invoices'.
In a ruling handed down on Friday, Mr Justice Nicklin said: 'I am satisfied that documents held by the claimants that can support a case that a witness has been paid or offered other inducement for their evidence, whether directly or indirectly, should be disclosed.
'That is because there is a real prospect that Associated will be able to rely upon this evidence to attack the credibility of such witnesses.
'Ultimately, the issue of whether the payment or inducement does affect the credibility of any witness is a matter to be resolved at trial.'
Sir Elton John and his husband David Furnish are part of the legal action against Associated Newspapers Limited (PA)
He added: 'In this case, the stance adopted by the claimants has been undermined by their inconsistent and incoherent approach to disclosure of documents relating to payments to potential witnesses and/or other inducements.'
Mr Justice Nicklin also ordered that lawyers for the claimants should conduct searches to identify and hand over documents ANL could rely on 'in advancing a case that potential witnesses have been given or offered financial incentives to provide information or evidence in support of allegations' of unlawful information gathering (UIG).
The group bringing the case had asked the judge to order ANL to unredact some of the documents the company had provided for the legal proceedings.
Mr Justice Nicklin ordered that 'targeted' un-redactions be made where necessary to assess whether certain journalists had a pattern of engaging in UIG.
He said: 'In my judgment, considering Associated's denials of wrongdoing, the claimants are entitled to explore whether they can advance a case, with a real prospect of success, that the pleaded journalists have a propensity to engage in UIG.'
A trial of the claims is expected to start in January and last for nine weeks.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
David Walliams leaves pal Sir Elton John in stitches as he dances wildly during their swanky lunch in St Tropez
left pal Sir Elton John in stitches as he got to his feet to dance during their swanky lunch at the La Guerite beach club in St Tropez. The comedian, 53, couldn't contain his excitement when Whitney Houston 's I Wanna Dance with Somebody (Who Loves Me) was played, much to the amusement of the pop icon, 78. David stood at the table and swayed animatedly to the music, before moving to dance with his hands on the back of Sir Elton's chair. The Crocodile Rock legend, who looked smart in a summer shirt, appeared in great spirits and sang along before collapsing into fits of giggles. David, shielding his eyes behind shades, was loving every moment and had a huge grin on his face as the other diners laughed along. He shared the clip to X and captioned it: 'Summer holiday'. As well as Elton David was joined by Heartstopper stars Kit Connor, 21, Joe Locke, 21, and Tobie Donovan, 23, sharing snaps as they soaked up the sun together. The La Guerite beach club is the very place that Sir Elton reportedly 'said his piece' about the Beckham feud as he dined at the swanky eatery with Brooklyn and wife Nicola Peltz last month. The once close-knit Beckham family has been thrown into turmoil in recent months, amid claims Brooklyn has become increasingly estranged from his famous parents after failing to attend any of his father 50th birthday celebrations in May. It was also revealed that Brooklyn and Nicola's Instagram accounts no longer follow his younger brothers in the latest family drama. According to The Sun, Sir Elton 'briefly' spoke about the family's feud in the hope Brooklyn would patch things up with his parents, and footage of the outing shared on social media showed the pair shaking hands. Speaking about Elton's attempts to play peacekeeper in the row, a source said: 'Elton is the showbiz equivalent of Switzerland. He's utterly neutral in this row. 'Elton of old may have relished in taking sides - in this case his young godson, Brooklyn - but two years off his 80th birthday, he's a man who has seen and done it all. He just wants everyone to be happy. 'There is no side-taking as such; he simply adores his godson, and really has a laugh with Nicola who he thinks has a great sense of humour. He wants to look after them in his role as 'spiritual adviser' as a godfather, it's a role he takes seriously. 'Elton and David think the situation is terribly sad, and has gently suggested to all involved that life is short - to patch things up.' The source added Elton is 'adamant he doesn't want to stick his nose in' the feud, he just simply 'wants peace'. Sir Elton is also said to have generously picked up the entire bill, after dining on the restaurant's signature lobster linguine which comes in at an eye-watering £190. David affectionately calls the musician 'Uncle Elton' after becoming friends in his football heyday. Sir Elton was due to perform at the Beckhams wedding in 1999 before suffering a heart attack that prevented him from playing. He later sang at one of the children's christenings. Meanwhile Victoria once disclosed that it was Elton who inspired her to say goodbye to the Spice Girls, penning an emotional letter to her older self where she confessed that watching her friend perform made her realise that her true calling lay beyond singing. It comes after Elton poured cold water on rumours he's planning a flashy ABBA-style hologram concert, despite fans thinking the tech-filled spectacle could be next on the cards. Hopeful supporters began speculating after spotting trademark documents for his name covering holograms, video projections and immersive 3D virtual reality experiences. But according to reports, those close to the Rocket Man have made it clear there's no such show in the pipeline. Elton has long made his stance clear, previously admitting in 2018 that the idea wasn't for him. However, during his Farewell Yellow Brick Road tour, he did briefly dabble in the digital world with a London pop-up at King's Cross, which featured an augmented reality version of him playing the piano.
The Independent
a day ago
- The Independent
Elton John dances with David Walliams as he enjoys retirement in France
Sir Elton John danced alongside David Walliams as the pair dined in Cannes with the cast of Netflix's Heartstopper. In a clip posted to the 53-year-old actor's Instagram page on Sunday, 17 August, the "Rocket Man" singer, 78, was filmed enjoying a meal out at La Guérite restaurant. Sir Elton retired in 2023 after his "Farewell Yellow Brick Road tour" which culminated in his Glastonbury performance. The musician stayed seated as Walliams danced next to him to Whitney Houston's 1987 hit "I Wanna Dance With Somebody."
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
‘Nothing is the same': Windrush victim allowed to return to UK after 28 years
When George Lee was last in the UK, Tony Blair was the newly elected prime minister, Diana, Princess of Wales had recently died and Elton John's Candle in the Wind was being played on repeat. A pint of bitter cost £1.63 and a packet of 20 cigarettes sold for about £2.94. After 28 years of exile in Poland, Lee, an English teacher, flew back to Britain a fortnight ago, his ticket paid for by the Home Office, where staff had belatedly acknowledged that he was a victim of the Windrush scandal and allowed him to return. He first contacted MPs and Home Office workers to request assistance in summer 2018 as the Windrush scandal unfolded. He says consular officials in Poland and Home Office staff in the UK failed to help him return, despite the government's repeated proclamations that everything was being done to assist those affected. Currently accommodated in a hotel room in Birmingham, Lee travelled to London last week, stepping off the train at Euston station into a city so transformed in the past three decades that he was instantly overwhelmed by culture shock. 'Nothing is the same – the taxis are different, the buses are different,' he said, as he made his way into the tube, puzzled by the Oyster card system. 'What do I do with this? Tap and go through?' He has spent the last two weeks walking around the streets, attempting to reacclimatise to the country he moved to from Jamaica in 1961 as an eight-year-old, assessing why he does not yet feel at home, despite the 37 years he lived here before being locked out. He is relieved to be back, but startled by the intense sense of dislocation after so long away. 'So much has changed. The homelessness is horrible – much worse than in Poland,' he said. 'People here look so stressed, there's a tiredness etched on their faces, as if they don't know what to expect of tomorrow. It's a little depressing. It's clear that the quality of life is better in Poland than here, which feels very sad.' Lee, 72, is one of a number of victims of the Windrush scandal who were prevented from returning to Britain after travelling abroad for work, or holiday or funerals; some were stopped by local border staff; many were given no assistance by UK consular officials who refused to acknowledge their right to travel to the UK. Lee says he struggled to persuade Home Office staff, MPs and officials at the UK consulate in Poland that he should be given help to return home, despite repeated appeals for assistance. It was only last November when he contacted Desmond Jaddoo, a Windrush campaigner and Birmingham-based bishop who runs the Windrush National Organisation support group, that Lee was able to collect the documentary evidence needed to demonstrate that he should be allowed to return. 'His case was a straightforward one, so it was easy to get him back once the documents were gathered,' Jaddoo said, adding that he was puzzled by why Lee had not received help to return sooner. Jaddoo traced school records, a marriage certificate, and Lee's son's birth certificate, proving he had a right to live in the UK. 'We worry that there are other cases like this. We need a proper campaign to encourage people who remain stuck abroad to come forward.' Lee moved to London in 1961, the year before Jamaican independence, travelling with his younger brother on his aunt's passport, to join his mother who was working as a nurse in east London, and his plumber father who was working on the North Sea oil pipelines. On arrival he would have been classified as a citizen of the UK and Colonies. He went to Princess May primary school in north London, where he passed the 11-plus and transferred to Dame Alice Owen's grammar school. He worked as a financial analyst in the City of London for a while, opened his own barbershop, before later deciding that teaching was his vocation. He married and had a son, but by the time he went to take up a teaching job in Poland the marriage had ended. He travelled to Warsaw on a Jamaican passport because he had failed to persuade UK officials that he was entitled to a British passport, despite having arrived in the country 37 years earlier. Because he stayed slightly over two years, he inadvertently breached the terms of his immigration status as someone who had been granted indefinite leave to remain in the UK. He was advised by staff at the Polish border that he would not be readmitted to the UK. Lee argued that he should have been recognised as a British citizen, because that was his status when he arrived as an eight-year-old. Throughout his time in Poland he was undocumented, which meant it was impossible to open a bank account. He taught English to hundreds of students. In one of the many emails he addressed to the Home Office in 2018, he noted that he had helped many Polish students pass exams to study at UK universities, and had at least 10 ex-students who now held PhDs from British institutions. 'Can you imagine how it feels preparing all these people to go to the UK, when I, as a citizen of the UK, cannot even enter. Believe me it is soul-destroying,' he wrote. Lee made contact with the Windrush taskforce, which was set up as a result of the scandal in 2018, with a view to securing the necessary documentation to return to Britain, and explained he wanted help from the British embassy in Warsaw. When he went there to seek advice, a Polish employee was sent to speak to him on the pavement outside. 'They refused to let me inside the building,' Lee said. Sign up to The Long Wave Nesrine Malik and Jason Okundaye deliver your weekly dose of Black life and culture from around the world after newsletter promotion During his time abroad he lost touch with his son and two sisters. He hopes to track them down and re-establish contact, but feels nervous about reconnecting. 'I wonder if, during all the years I've been away, they have thought I abandoned them,' he said. In the next few weeks he needs to find somewhere permanent to live, reregister with a doctor, and sort out his pension. He is dismayed that officials are refusing to grant back payments of his state pension going back to 2018, when he turned 65. The barrister Martin Forde KC, who served as the independent adviser to the Windrush compensation scheme from 2018 to 2022, working to recompense those affected by the scandal that led to thousands of people who were living in the UK legally being misclassified as immigration offenders with catastrophic consequences for many. Some people lost their jobs or were evicted from their homes, or were denied benefits, free healthcare, and pensions; a few were arrested and deported to countries they had left decades earlier as children. Others were stuck for years abroad. Forde said Lee should be granted pension payments, adding: 'It seems inequitable not to give him the pension that he would otherwise have received.' When he feels more settled, Lee plans to visit the graves of his mother and younger brother in London, and revisit the London cinemas where he developed a love of French arthouse film. He is not ready to apply for compensation from the government because he does not believe ministers have acknowledged that immigration legislation which remains in place caused many of the Windrush generation's problems. A long-buried Home Office-commissioned history into the roots of the scandal, finally released last year, warned that 'during the period 1950-1981, every single piece of immigration or citizenship legislation was designed at least in part to reduce the number of people with black or brown skin who were permitted to live and work in the UK'. 'How can I claim compensation when they haven't admitted that the legislation was wrong?' Lee said. 'I don't feel angry, I'm past the stage where I can feel angry. I'm very philosophical and thoughtful about all that's happened. But I do feel deep regret that the UK government conspired to take away the rights of the Windrush generation.' Clive Foster, who was appointed as the new Windrush commissioner in July, said he wanted the government to do more to 'proactively identify and reach individuals' still stranded abroad. The problem stretches 'far beyond the Caribbean, affecting communities across Africa, Asia, and the wider Commonwealth. Yet people from these communities, in the UK and overseas, may be unaware that the injustices they've suffered are directly linked to this scandal.' A Home Office spokesperson said: 'We are doing our best to ensure that justice and compensation for victims is delivered as quickly as possible. Some cases are more complex than others, but we will always try to work with each individual to get them the support they need.'
