A Francis Admirer and a Francis Skeptic Debate the Pope's Legacy
Below is an edited transcript of an episode of 'Interesting Times.' We recommend listening to it in its original form for the full effect. You can do so using the player above or on the NYT Audio app, Apple, Spotify, Amazon Music, YouTube, iHeartRadio or wherever you get your podcasts.
Ross Douthat: The death of Pope Francis ends, or at least temporarily suspends, a tumultuous period in the life of the world's largest religious institution. A period where the pope was often pitted against his own bishops and cardinals in arguments about how much, and in what direction, Roman Catholicism should change.
My guest today and I were often on the opposite side of those debates, and so I'm hoping that our conversation can help illuminate the stakes in Roman Catholicism's conflicts, the prospects for the church's continued unity and the implications of these debates for the future of religion in the modern world.
Father James Martin is one of the most famous Catholic priests in the United States. I think the only Jesuit to ever appear on Stephen Colbert's late night TV program, and the author of many, many books. Most recently, a meditation on the New Testament story of Jesus' raising of Lazarus from the dead.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Young people looking for answers in a messy world are turning to the Catholic Church
This past April, as we gathered in Rome for the solemn duty of burying our beloved Pope Francis and electing a new Holy Father, my brother cardinals and I met for two weeks of day-long meetings to prepare for the conclave. We would discuss what was happening back home in our dioceses, what challenges we face, what qualities we thought the next Pope should possess. Despite the sadness we all felt at the loss of Pope Francis, there was a common hopeful refrain we cardinals heard over and over again. During one coffee break, one cardinal said, 'Have you noticed all the young people from around the world who are here in Rome?' Advertisement 'I walked through Saint Peter's Square today and spent time talking to a group of teenage pilgrims, here for the Jubilee Year of Hope,' another remarked. 'A group from one of the universities back home is here in Rome, and invited me to say Mass for them,' mentioned a third. Just a few weeks back, I could not help but be impressed by the sight of one million young people with Pope Leo at Tor Vergata field, just outside Rome. They came to be with the new Pope, of course, but also to be pilgrims and join in the Jubilee Year of Hope. Advertisement Since returning to New York, I've noticed a similar trend. My pastors tell me that more people are attending Mass, and they reported a definite uptick in people freely choosing to become Catholic or return to Church. A recent study by Harvard University confirmed the trend among the so-called Generation Z, which saw a 6% increase from 2022 to 2023 in those identifying as Catholic. Walking through Saint Patrick's Cathedral, I am always impressed by the number of young people there, not just as tourists, but on line for confession, in the Lady Chapel for Adoration, or attending one of the seven daily Masses. Advertisement There are likely many reasons behind this welcome development. Blessed Carlo Acutis, the Italian teenager who heroically lived out his faith and died in 2006 at just 15 years of age, has provided a great role model for young people to emulate. He's not some dim figure from centuries past, but a young man who had a cellphone, loved video games, and used his computer to build an exhibit dedicated to Eucharistic miracles around the world. His canonization by Pope Leo on Sunday, Sept. 7, is sure to make his story even better known. So will the story of Blessed Pier Giorgio Frassati, also to be canonized on Sept. 7. A young Italian student, a fervent and joyful believer, a great lover of the outdoors, politically active in social causes, he contracted polio during his care for the sick, and died at the young age of 24. His last request, written with a near-paralyzed hand, was for his friend to take his medicine and give it to another. Advertisement I like to think our outreach to young adults is also having an impact. Regular Masses at Saint Patrick's Cathedral, followed by socializing at a nearby bar or restaurant, combined with opportunities for community service and faith formation, meet the needs that I think we all desire: faith, friendship, and the opportunity to help others. Our Catholic schools — elementary, secondary, and colleges and universities — play a role as well. We've placed a renewed emphasis on ensuring that our grammar and high schools, while academically excellent, are also rooted in teaching and passing on the faith in everything they do. It's not just our Catholic colleges, like Fordham, Iona, Manhattan, and Saint John's, where faith plays a role. We have robust campus ministries programs too, at schools like NYU and Columbia, for instance, to meet the spiritual needs of undergrads and graduate students, many away from home for the first time. Then, too, the world seems a big mess! War, injustice, famine, violence, bigotry, mass shootings, political vitriol — those inclined to look to the world for meaning now know better. Finally, and most importantly, though, there is, in the human heart, an innate desire for meaning. For too long, we taught our young people that there was no objective truth, that right and wrong were outdated concepts, and 'if it feels good, do it.' As the great Archbishop Fulton Sheen so eloquently put it, 'People aren't looking for a question mark, but an exclamation point!' Advertisement We look for clarity, not ambiguity. The Catholic faith, centered on Jesus and His Church, its belief in eternal, unwavering truth, and a moral code that differentiates between good and evil, grace and sin, provides that direction. The old Baltimore catechism began with a simple question: Why did God make me? Its answer: God made me to know Him, love him, and serve Him in this world, and to be happy with Him forever in Heaven. Advertisement We still believe that, and offer that 'sure and certain hope' to all the world. Many are once again taking us up on that offer. Cardinal Dolan is the archbishop of New York.
Buzz Feed
2 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
South Park Roasts Donald Trump Again, Slams Mark Zuckerberg And Tim Cook
South Park returned on Wednesday to hit President Donald Trump below the belt with multiple depictions of his 'teeny tiny' penis. The episode also skewered tech CEOs and government leaders for bribing Trump with golden 'gifts,' again depicted Trump's bedroom lover as none other than Satan himself, and reduced Vice President JD Vance to a miniature sidekick who offers to bring his boss a 'cumrag.' That 'cumrag,' tragically, turns out to be longtime South Park fan-favorite character Towelie. Much of the episode focuses not on Trump, but on Randy Marsh ― Stan's dad ― and his marijuana farm, which struggles after his workers are hauled off in a federal raid. He sends Towelie to D.C. to lobby Trump for marijuana reclassification. Towelie finds the city overrun with military troops, as Trump has called in the National Guard, just as he has done in real life in a move critics have dismissed as a ' stunt.' Towelie also finds a statue of Thomas Jefferson in the Capitol is now a statue of Trump, with a very small penis. Likewise, the statue of Abraham Lincoln at the Lincoln Memorial is also a statue of Trump, again with a tiny penis. When Towelie reaches the White House to meet Trump, an aide warns visitors to 'avoid staring directly into his penis.' There, Towelie joins a line of CEOs and officials who offer Trump 'gifts' and assure him that his penis isn't small. Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg, for example, brings the president a gold-plated VR headset. Apple CEO Tim Cook shows up to give Trump a small sculpture ― something he did for real earlier this month. Trump takes the gift and goes to his bedroom, where he promptly tears off all his clothes and hops into bed with Satan. 'Hey Satan! Look at what some dipshit tech CEO gave me,' he tells Satan. 'I was thinking maybe we could try to shove it up your ass.' Towelie is there to lobby Trump to reclassify marijuana, but ends up as a gift to Trump instead. By the end of the episode, Satan finds Towelie in a White House bathroom, covered in white stains, begging for help. 'Please,' Towelie pleads with Satan. 'I wanna get out of here.' 'So do I,' Satan replies. 'But there is no escape from this place.' South Park has so far been biweekly since returning last month, and that pattern will continue ― at least for now ― as the next episode is set to air Sept. 3 on Comedy Central.
CNN
5 hours ago
- CNN
Kremlin-backed Max messenger app to be pre-installed on all smartphones sold in Russia
Russia Social mediaFacebookTweetLink Follow The Russian government will require the state-backed Max messenger app to be pre-installed on all smartphones and tablets sold in the country, in a move that could increase surveillance of Russian citizens. In a statement Thursday, the Kremlin said Max would be installed on devices from September 1. The RuStore app, a homegrown rival to Apple's App Store, will also be pre-installed on iPhones. In addition, from January 1, the Lime HD TV program, which provides free access to Russian state TV channels, will be automatically installed on Smart TVs in the country. Max was launched by the state-controlled social media group VK in March as a replacement for VK Messenger, which has been on the government's list of mandatory apps since 2023. The new app allows users to send messages, make audio and video calls and send money, with additional features planned in the future. These will include the integration of a travel booking app, VK said in its latest earnings report. Around 18 million people have registered with Max since its launch, Russian state news outlet TASS reported earlier this week, citing the platform's press team. Max is similar to China's hugely successful WeChat app, which gives users an all-in-one outlet to message, post on social media and make payments and reservations. User activity on WeChat is most likely under heavy state surveillance, experts previously told CNN. At the same time, Russia has moved to limit the use of some foreign messaging services. Russia has already banned Facebook, Instagram and X. And earlier this month, the country's media regulator announced restrictions on voice calls via WhatsApp and Telegram 'in order to counter criminals.' WhatsApp, in its turn, accused Russia of attempting to block access to the app for its 100 million Russian users. Unlike Max, WhatsApp and Telegram provide end-to-end encryption, preventing third parties from accessing user data. Russia has attempted to make it increasingly inconvenient to use foreign social media apps, Anastasiia Kruope, a researcher at Human Rights Watch, noted in a report in July. 'This, along with active state-sponsored promotion of Russian alternatives, forced a growing number of users to switch to Russian browsers and social media,' Kruope wrote. Similarly, Andrei Soldatov and Irina Borogan, senior fellows at the Washington, DC-based Center for European Policy Analysis, wrote last month that 'a sustained attack' on WhatsApp was part of the Kremlin's efforts 'to harass Russians into switching to Max from WhatsApp.' 'The policy is likely to work, especially if the population is given no choice,' they added. Max developer VK was co-founded by Pavel Durov, the billionaire founder of Telegram, in 2006. Durov was forced out as CEO in 2014 after several arguments with the Russian state over censorship and refusals to hand over user data. Current VK CEO, Vladimir Kiriyenko, is the son of Putin's First Deputy Chief of Staff, Sergey Kiriyenko. CNN's Caitlin Danaher, Mitchell McCluskey, Katharina Krebs and Anna Chernova contributed reporting.
