Newly qualified doctors face ‘recurring cycle of debt', BMA warns
Some doctors are driving Ubers and working in bars in order to get additional income, the union claims.
It added that students from poorer backgrounds are hit hardest and has now called on the government to address the funding gap and make a career in medicine accessible to as many people as possible.
Students in their final undergraduate year, along with those in the later years of a post-graduate medical degree, get a reduced student loan alongside an NHS bursary.
This leads to a £3,674 drop in funding on average, according to the BMA.
Sophie Mitchell, deputy co-chair (finance) of the BMA's medical students' committee, said: 'A lot of people are using these loans in previous years to either pay their rent and to live off.
'Losing out on a significant portion of that is meaning that students are struggling.
'We've got people maxing out overdrafts, we've got people maxing out credit cards.
'We've got people going into very significant debt just to actually finish this degree.'
The average medical student faces 12 months of this reduced funding.
However, some post-graduate students, along with those on six-year degree programmes, face up to three years, Ms Mitchell said.
Some are them are also faced with relocation expenses ahead of starting their first job in the NHS.
'The issue with that is most academic years or final years start in around the middle of August,' Ms Mitchell said.
'You are then having this reduced rate of funding until you then get paid at the end of August the following year.
'I know that a lot of my colleagues have had to get loans to pay their rent, or they've had to get credit agreements so that they can pay their rent.
'Also then having to relocate to a new place where you're getting this reduced rate of funding has been a struggle for a lot of people.
'A lot of my friends were already graduating, maxing out their overdrafts, and then they've had to get overdraft extensions to help them live until they get paid at the end of August.
'It's creating this recurrent cycle of debt that people are really struggling to get out of until that first paycheck.'
Ms Mitchell said she knows of new graduates stewarding football matches or taking zero hours bar work to get by.
She added: 'We have people working behind bars.
'We have people stewarding.
'One of my friends is actually working for Uber at the moment, because it was the only work that she could get that meant that she could get some employment in the area that she's in.'
Ms Mitchell is heading the BMA's Fix Our Finance campaign alongside co-chair Henry Budden.
'Quite a common thing that we've heard about the campaign is 'every student gets a job, why are you guys complaining so much?',' she said.
'But I think what people maybe aren't so aware of is actually how intense our course is.
'You're training for that role that you're about to start.
'You're in hospital Monday to Friday, nine to five.
'Some universities make their students do night shifts.
'Some universities make their students also do weekends on top of this.
'And then on top of that placement, where you're learning to be a doctor, you're also having to revise for your exams.'
The BMA is calling on the Government to ensure medical students receive full student finance maintenance for the entirety of their course.
The union claims this would cost the Treasury £24 million and just 0.12% of Student Finance England annual lending.
Ms Mitchell and Mr Budden warned the 'situation isn't sustainable' and 'does nothing to help those from poorer backgrounds or improve participation in medicine'.
'Medicine is longer than many other degrees for good reason; because we want to ensure doctors working in the NHS have the best possible training,' they added.
'It is only right then that they should receive the appropriate funding to see them through the entirety of their course.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
5 minutes ago
- BBC News
The teenager who set up a diabetes charity at primary school
Since he set up a charity to help diabetics Lochlan Murdoch's journey taken him to classrooms across the country - and even to 10 Downing well as meeting the then Prime Minister Theresa May the 16-year-old, from Cumnock, has been honoured with a British Services Citizen Award for services to the Lochlan, who launched his charity while still at primary school, is even prouder of something else, beyond the told BBC Scotland News: "We've done stuff in schools and hearing some of them say they think I'm cool, and just helping them acknowledge they can do things despite being diabetic - that's really big". Lochlan was only a week into primary school when he started experiencing a number of health was thirsty all the time, continually tired and needed the toilet much more than usual. His mother Lesley and father Scott wondered if it was because of warm weather, or maybe anxiety about starting the problems persisted, and the truth soon emerged - Lochlan was a type1 diabetic, meaning his pancreas was not producing recalls: "We handed a sample of his urine in at the surgery and within 20 minutes we were on our way to A & E, where the diabetes team were waiting on us."His blood sugar levels were through the roof." The condition means that Lochlan has to rely on other ways of taking insulin, whether through pumps - which he is now on - or manually injecting it into himself with needles, through an insulin pen there are other aspects too, from constantly monitoring levels via finger prick tests to checking what food could send levels rocketing upwards.A 2023 survey found around 36,000 Scots have the in those early years, thoughts of helping others with the condition were far from Lesley and Lochlan's minds, as they tried to adjust to a major change. "It can be a lot of pressure on your shoulders as a parent," says Lesley. "You're monitoring their blood sugars all the time, and there's a fear when you put them to bed they'll have a hypo [a sudden drop in blood sugar levels] and won't wake up."Lesley also noticed that there was a lack of knowledge about type 1 diabetes among people she included some conflating it with type 2 diabetes - a version of the condition that can often be handled through diet rather than injections."It can be quite challenging to bite your tongue sometimes," she says."When you're a parent and you're hearing things like 'did he eat too many sweeties' or 'it could be worse, it could be something like cancer' - you wouldn't say that to someone with another condition. "The big thing for me is trying to reduce that stigma. "For example, taking part in football and exercising does help type 1 diabetics, but it's nothing to do with losing weight, which you'll often hear people assume." 'You have to trust a new person to look after you' The way Lesley and Lochlan aim to reduce stigma is through Lochlan's charity has its roots in an incident that changed Lochlan's life for a second 2018 the football-daft youngster broke his leg while playing the sport with friends. Stuck indoors in what the teenager jokingly calls "the middle of nowhere", his mental health declined, something accelerated by his diabetes."When he went back to school after the summer, and you're type 1, it can be difficult", says Lesley. "You have a new teacher and you have to trust a new person that will look after you."He was doing that while recovering from a double leg break, and we noticed a decline in his personality and moods. "We thought he was either going to burst into tears or get angry at some point – luckily it was the first one, and a really good classroom assistant, Sarah Taylor, was there."She got him to talk. He was using parts of the diabetes to avoid doing stuff." One place he found an escape was going to see Kilmarnock at Rugby Park. That love of football helped turn his depression into something more positive, as Lochlan created a stadium marathon challenge for saw him walk around all 12 of the SPL's football grounds, plus Hampden Park and Townhead Park, the home of Cumnock raised over £10,000 for charity and earned him a trip to Downing there, another guest suggested to him that he keep going with helping by the time Lochlan's train had rolled back into Scotland, the charity idea was in bloom."We can't quite believe how far the charity has come," says Lesley."Our son allows us to tell the whole story, including the good, the bad and the ugly of diabetes – we don't hide the cracks." In recent years the charity has held information sessions, workshops and fun days, all aimed towards spreading awareness of diabetes and what it means.A number of athletes with type 1 diabetes, including Hibs defender Jack Iredale, Raith Rovers winger Paul McMullan and golfer Hannah McCook, serve as also offers a CPD accredited course in understanding diabetes for sports Lochlan's hard work has placed him on the shortlist for the BBC's Make a Difference awards, in the Active winners will be unveiled at a ceremony in Glasgow next month, with results then announced on BBC Radio Scotland's Mornings programme with Kaye Adams on 29 he wins in his category or not, for Lesley, the charity has been a massive benefit to Lochlan over the years."He's much more confident – he doesn't feel the need to hide this condition. "Type 1 diabetes has changed our lives completely, but in a lot of ways it has given us opportunities we would never have had otherwise. It doesn't stop you doing anything."
The Guardian
14 minutes ago
- The Guardian
I'm 15 and in love, but I have to walk on eggshells with my boyfriend
I'm 15, and in a six-month relationship with my boyfriend who has a very toxic home life. This has given him significant mental health issues. He gets upset by little things, and struggles to move on, catastrophising small disagreements, thinking I hate him and saying he'll self-harm. He has a really strong sense of self: he hates people being better than him at anything he cares about, and is obsessed with looks. The real issue for me is that I often feel I'm walking on eggshells: I can't tell him about achievements or he'll get upset; I soften any viewpoint I'm worried he won't like; I can't tell him he upset me without him getting extremely defensive. I do not want to lose him. He's really thoughtful, caring, beautiful and profound. He always checks for consent before doing anything sexual (nothing much as we're both underage); he cares for me if I'm upset, gives me advice, makes me feel confident in myself and happy. But I'm worried about the coming weeks, as I'm going on holiday and I know I'll have to reassure him I love him every two days, feeling guilty for just having a nice time. I feel so strongly in love, and don't want to break up with him. I'd really like some strategies to help him feel better, be less sensitive, and avoid triggers without it being exhausting. It's never too early or late in life to start asking the right questions and here, as my specialist this week, the UKCP-registered child and adolescent psychotherapist Sara Anton says, the questions you might want to ask are: 'What does a healthy relationship looks like? Is this a healthy relationship, and if not why not? If you are looking after your boyfriend's needs all the time, how can you take care of your needs? And how does it feel to do so much caretaking at this point in your life?' You sound incredibly mature, astute and sensitive, but the flipside is that you will attract people who look to you to fulfil things lacking in themselves. It's also never too early or late to learn about boundaries. I hear that you are really in love; as Anton points out: 'At 15 it's really usual – and developmentally appropriate [as we have to learn to separate from our parents] – to have these intense relationships.' But, and it is a significant but, this relationship raises concerns for us. No relationship should mean you are radically changing your behaviour – as you are – to appease someone else. I'm sorry for your boyfriend's home life, the details of which you asked me to withhold, but you are not responsible for his happiness or anyone else's. 'At this age,' says Anton, 'you are starting to find out who you are, what you like and don't like, how to be with others, what your boundaries are, and how to take care of your own emotions. From what you say, this relationship is more intense than is healthy and it's taking a toll on you. It will be hard to build a sense of who you are as a young person when you are so entwined.' Sign up to Inside Saturday The only way to get a look behind the scenes of the Saturday magazine. Sign up to get the inside story from our top writers as well as all the must-read articles and columns, delivered to your inbox every weekend. after newsletter promotion Aspects of your relationship sound coercive. I'm sure you've covered this in PSHE lessons, but it can be hard to see when this is happening to us. Not being able to share or having to water down good news for fear of him not liking it, him threatening to self-harm, feeling like you're constantly treading on eggshells: these are not what a healthy relationship is based on. Your boyfriend doesn't sound like he has a strong sense of self, quite the opposite; it sounds like he's outsourcing his self-esteem to you. This is not something you can delegate. I would really urge you to talk to an adult you trust. You've taken a really big step towards this by writing to me. If you are constantly keeping the peace with your boyfriend, you will get no peace yourself. You can't fix him, or anyone else. That's not your job. Your job is to look after yourself first and foremost. That's not selfish but self-aware and self-protective, and that lesson can never be learned too young. Every week, Annalisa Barbieri addresses a personal problem sent in by a reader. If you would like advice from Annalisa, please send your problem to Annalisa regrets she cannot enter into personal correspondence. Submissions are subject to our terms and conditions. The latest series of Annalisa's podcast is available here. Comments on this piece are pre-moderated to ensure the discussion remains on the topics raised by the article. Please be aware that there may be a short delay in comments appearing on the site.
The Independent
36 minutes ago
- The Independent
Major supermarket issues urgent ‘do not eat' warning for popular snack due to ‘health risk'
Co-op has issued an urgent 'do not eat' warning for a popular snack bought from its stores after discovering it contains milk, which is not disclosed on the packaging. The retailer is now recalling a large batch of its Mini Pork & Pickle Pies (4 pack) as they pose a health risk to anyone with an allergy or intolerance to milk. The Food Standards Agency (FSA) has confirmed the recall, telling customers: 'If you have bought the above product and have an allergy or intolerance to milk or milk constituents, do not eat it.' Customers can identify the affected product by the use-by date. Batches with the dates 13 August, 14 August and 16 August are included in the recall, all of which are 200g four-packs. Anyone who has purchased a product included in the recall will receive a full refund or exchange where available, the health body has confirmed. Customers who purchased the product online can arrange a refund by calling 0330 041 7737. For additional assistance, they can reach Co-op's help line on 0800 0686 727, or use the online form on the retailer's product issues webpage. The retailer has notified relevant allergy support groups about the recall to ensure members are warned about the issue. Notices have also been placed in stores to alert shoppers, and will remain in place until August 17. Allergic reactions to milk vary. They can be fast-acting, with symptoms showing within a few minutes or hours, or slow-acting, where symptoms take up to 72 hours to show. According to Allergy UK, common reactions include skin reactions, gastrointestinal issues and respiratory symptoms. In severe cases, CMA can lead to a potentially fatal allergic reaction called anaphylaxis, which requires immediate medical attention. The FSA said: 'Sometimes foods have to be withdrawn or recalled if there is a risk to consumers because the allergy labelling is missing or incorrect or if there is any other food allergy risk. When there is a food allergy risk, the FSA will issue an allergy alert.' Earlier this year, Co-op suffered a major cyber attack, which saw all of its 6.5 million members' details stolen. It came after a string of similar attacks, with fellow major retailer M&S also targeted. The National Crime Agency said in July that four young people were arrested for their suspected involvement in the cyber attacks against the two grocery retailers, as well as department store Harrods.
