Green algae found along French coastline responsible for jogger's death, rules court
The Nantes appeals court found France liable for the death of Jean-Rene Auffray, citing its "negligence" in enforcing environmental regulations to protect its waters and prevent toxic green algae (
algues vertes)
blooms.
For more than five decades, tons of green algae have washed up annually on Brittany's beaches in western France, releasing hydrogen sulphide gas as it rots - a toxin that can prove deadly in high concentrations.
Auffray, a keen trail runner, died of sudden respiratory failure while jogging in the algae-choked Gouessant estuary near the city of Saint-Brieuc.
His lifeless body had been found by his wife and daughters, in September 2016, on the beach at Hillion - 300 meters from the spot where 36 wild boar died in 2011, with their deaths being attributed to algae.
Advertisement
His family sued over his death, but in 2022 a court rejected the claim, ruling there was insufficient evidence to link the toxic algae to Auffray's death.
Tuesday's decision reversed that ruling, marking the first time France has been held liable for the health risks posed by deadly green algae blooms along its coast.
The court "holds the State liable for negligence due to its failure to implement European and national regulations designed to protect waters from agricultural pollution", which is "the main cause of the proliferation of green algae in Brittany", it explained in a statement.
The court found Auffray's death was caused by a rapid pulmonary oedema -- a condition in which there is too much fluid in the lungs -- which could only be explained by fatal poisoning from inhaling hydrogen sulphide at very high concentrations.
"For the first time, a French court has recognised the link between a person's death and the state's negligence in these green algae cases," said the family's lawyer, Francois Lafforgue.
The deceased's family will receive partial compensation, as the court found the state 60 percent liable, noting that he had taken a personal risk by jogging in the estuary.
The state has been ordered to pay €277,343 to the jogger's wife, €15,000 to each of his three children, and €9,000 to his brother.
According to a 2021 report from France's top audit court, around 90 percent of Brittany's algae blooms are caused by agriculture, where the use of nitrogen fertilisers has increased significantly since the 1960s.
Intensive farming — especially pig farming — and the resulting nitrate pollution have been linked to the spread of green algae in the western Cotes-d'Armor region.
Advertisement
It has been the subject of environmental campaigns while local authorities have displayed billboards warning of the potential risks from the algae, especially at low tide.
A board reading "Caution, Danger Nearby - Rotting algae deposit" is pictured in Hillion, near Saint-Brieuc, northwestern France. (Photo by Damien MEYER / AFP)
In 2019 an apparently fit and healthy 18-year-old oyster fisherman was found dead near algae in Morlaix Bay in Brittany, while in 2009, a 48-year-old man died after driving a van full of green algae.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
6 hours ago
- France 24
RFK Jr's medical panel to revisit debunked vaccine claims
The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), an independent body that reviews scientific evidence to recommend which groups should receive vaccines and when, rarely makes headlines. But these are no ordinary times. Kennedy, who spent two decades spreading vaccine misinformation before becoming President Donald Trump's top health official, has brought that skepticism into the federal government. Earlier this month he abruptly dismissed all 17 ACIP members before their terms had expired, accusing them of financial ties to the pharmaceutical industry -- despite a vetting process meant to minimize conflicts of interest. He then appointed eight new members, including scientist Robert Malone, widely known for spreading false claims during the Covid-19 pandemic and promoting the deworming drug ivermectin. The posted agenda includes standard topics like influenza and Covid-19 vaccines -- but the addition, on the second day of discussions, of measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella (MMRV) vaccines for young children, along with thimerosal-containing flu shots, has alarmed experts. Ahead of the meeting, US senator and physician Bill Cassidy -- a Republican whose reluctant support was key to Kennedy's confirmation -- called for a delay, citing the panelists' inexperience and bias. Debunked autism connection Thimerosal is a mercury-based preservative long used in medicines, with no evidence of harm at low doses. "Study after study showed that the ethylmercury in those vaccines never contributed in any important way to the burden of mercury that one is exposed to, living on this planet," vaccine expert Paul Offit of the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia told AFP. Still, vaccine makers agreed to remove it from pediatric vaccines in 1999 in response to public concern. It remains in some flu shots. The presenter arguing against thimerosal is Lyn Redwood, a nurse and former leader of Children's Health Defense — an anti-vaccine nonprofit once chaired by RFK Jr. According to her biography page, Redwood blames her son's autism on vaccines -- a link that has never been proven. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which is overseeing the meeting, will argue thimerosal is safe and has no effect on neurodevelopment, based on a thorough review of the evidence. Rampant measles outbreak For childhood vaccines, US parents can choose a combined measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella (MMRV) shot or two separate injections -- one for MMR, the other for varicella. The combination spares an extra jab but carries a slightly higher risk of febrile seizures, a rare and typically harmless side effect. Separating the shots is already recommended for infants' first dose at age 12-47 months, leaving experts puzzled as to why the issue is being revisited. Notably, there's no planned discussion on the benefits of measles vaccines, which have prevented millions of hospitalizations. "The discussion of MMRV vaccines, critical tools in preventing measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella, must be rooted in science, not ideology," said Syra Madad, an infectious disease epidemiologist at NYC Health + Hospitals. The United States, which declared measles eliminated in 2000, is currently experiencing its worst measles outbreak of the disease in decades, with more than 1,200 cases and three confirmed deaths. "ACIP is going to become an outlet for anti-vaccine propaganda and increasingly irrelevant to the practice of medicine," warned Amesh Adalja, an infectious disease expert at Johns Hopkins University. Still, the panel's recommendations could have broad consequences, shaping school vaccine mandates and insurance coverage.
Local France
11 hours ago
- Local France
Green algae found along French coastline responsible for jogger's death, rules court
The Nantes appeals court found France liable for the death of Jean-Rene Auffray, citing its "negligence" in enforcing environmental regulations to protect its waters and prevent toxic green algae ( algues vertes) blooms. For more than five decades, tons of green algae have washed up annually on Brittany's beaches in western France, releasing hydrogen sulphide gas as it rots - a toxin that can prove deadly in high concentrations. Auffray, a keen trail runner, died of sudden respiratory failure while jogging in the algae-choked Gouessant estuary near the city of Saint-Brieuc. His lifeless body had been found by his wife and daughters, in September 2016, on the beach at Hillion - 300 meters from the spot where 36 wild boar died in 2011, with their deaths being attributed to algae. Advertisement His family sued over his death, but in 2022 a court rejected the claim, ruling there was insufficient evidence to link the toxic algae to Auffray's death. Tuesday's decision reversed that ruling, marking the first time France has been held liable for the health risks posed by deadly green algae blooms along its coast. The court "holds the State liable for negligence due to its failure to implement European and national regulations designed to protect waters from agricultural pollution", which is "the main cause of the proliferation of green algae in Brittany", it explained in a statement. The court found Auffray's death was caused by a rapid pulmonary oedema -- a condition in which there is too much fluid in the lungs -- which could only be explained by fatal poisoning from inhaling hydrogen sulphide at very high concentrations. "For the first time, a French court has recognised the link between a person's death and the state's negligence in these green algae cases," said the family's lawyer, Francois Lafforgue. The deceased's family will receive partial compensation, as the court found the state 60 percent liable, noting that he had taken a personal risk by jogging in the estuary. The state has been ordered to pay €277,343 to the jogger's wife, €15,000 to each of his three children, and €9,000 to his brother. According to a 2021 report from France's top audit court, around 90 percent of Brittany's algae blooms are caused by agriculture, where the use of nitrogen fertilisers has increased significantly since the 1960s. Intensive farming — especially pig farming — and the resulting nitrate pollution have been linked to the spread of green algae in the western Cotes-d'Armor region. Advertisement It has been the subject of environmental campaigns while local authorities have displayed billboards warning of the potential risks from the algae, especially at low tide. A board reading "Caution, Danger Nearby - Rotting algae deposit" is pictured in Hillion, near Saint-Brieuc, northwestern France. (Photo by Damien MEYER / AFP) In 2019 an apparently fit and healthy 18-year-old oyster fisherman was found dead near algae in Morlaix Bay in Brittany, while in 2009, a 48-year-old man died after driving a van full of green algae.
France 24
16 hours ago
- France 24
Gaza rescuers say 46 killed as UN slams US-backed aid system
Civil defence spokesman Mahmud Bassal told AFP that 21 people were killed and around 150 wounded by Israeli fire near an aid point in central Gaza early Tuesday, and that another 25 were killed in a separate incident in south Gaza. "Every day we face this scenario: martyrs, injuries, in unbearable numbers," paramedic Ziad Farhat told AFP at Nasser Hospital in southern Gaza. "Hospitals cannot accommodate the number of casualties arriving," he said. The latest deaths came as Israel's opposition leader and the families of Israeli hostages being held in Gaza called on Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to widen a ceasefire with Iran to include the Palestinian territory. Pressure also grew on the US- and Israeli-backed privately run aid group Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), which was brought into the Palestinian territory at the end of May to replace United Nations agencies. The head of the UN agency for Palestinian refugees (UNRWA) called the system an "abomination" while a spokesman for the UN human rights office, Thameen Al-Kheetan, condemned the "weaponisation of food" in Gaza. According to figures issued on Tuesday by the health ministry in the Hamas-run Gaza Strip, at least 516 people have been killed and nearly 3,800 wounded by Israeli fire while seeking rations since late May. The territory of more than two million people is suffering from famine-like conditions after Israel blocked all supplies from early March to the end of May and continues to impose restrictions, according to human rights groups. The Israeli military said the reports of deaths near the Netzarim corridor were "under review." - 'Tank shells' - Gaza civil defence spokesman Bassal reported a first deadly shooting "with bullets and tank shells" near the Netzarim corridor in central Gaza where thousands of Palestinians gather each night for rations from a nearby GHF distribution point. The Israeli military later said that a crowd had been identified in an area "adjacent" to its troops. Witness Ribhi Al-Qassas told AFP that troops had "opened fire randomly" at a crowd he estimated at 50,000 people. The second incident took place in south Gaza about two kilometres from another GHF centre in Rafah governorate, Bassal said. "Israeli forces targeted civilian gatherings near Al-Alam and Al-Shakoush areas with bullets and tank shells", he told AFP. Israeli restrictions on media in the Gaza Strip and difficulties in accessing some areas mean AFP is unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by rescuers and witnesses in the Palestinian territory. "The weaponisation of food for civilians, in addition to restricting or preventing their access to life-sustaining services, constitutes a war crime," UN human rights office spokesman Thameen Al-Kheetan said in Geneva. UN agencies and major aid groups have refused to cooperate with GHF over concerns it was designed to cater to Israeli military objectives. In a statement on Saturday, GHF said it was "delivering aid at scale, securely and effectively", but it acknowledged it "cannot meet the full scale of need while large parts of Gaza remain closed". GHF has denied responsibility for deaths near its aid points. On Monday, more than a dozen human rights organisations called on GHF to cease its operations, warning of possible complicity in war crimes. Ceasefire calls After Israel agreed to a ceasefire with Iran on Tuesday after a 12-day war, Netayahu faced renewed calls to agree a ceasefire with Hamas after more than 20 months of war in Gaza. "And now Gaza. It's time to finish it there too. Bring back the hostages, end the war," opposition leader Yair Lapid of the centre-right Yesh Atid party wrote on X. Netanyahu said on Sunday that Israel's war against Iran was "contributing to the successes in Gaza, but it will still take a bit more time". The October 2023 attack on Israel by Palestinian militant group Hamas that sparked the Gaza war resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official figures. Of the 251 hostages seized by Palestinian militants in October 2023, 49 are still held in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military says are dead. Israel's retaliatory military campaign has killed at least 56,077 people, also mostly civilians, according to the Gaza health ministry. The United Nations considers its figures reliable.
