White House blames 'formatting' for errors in RFK Jr.'s MAHA report. Authors push back.
President Donald Trump signed an executive order to establish a commission that was tasked with investigating chronic illnesses and childhood diseases, which culminated in the 'Make Our Children Healthy Again' assessment that was published May 22.
However, researchers listed in the report have since come forward saying the articles cited don't exist or were used to support facts that were inconsistent with their research. The errors were first reported by NOTUS.
'I understand there were some formatting issues with the MAHA report that are being addressed and the report will be updated,' Leavitt told reporters May 29. 'But it does not negate the substance of the report.'
She also didn't say whether the report was generated by artificial intelligence, or AI, as some have questioned.
Although it's difficult to determine whether scientific articles are generated or 'touched up' by AI, there are telling signs, said Yuan Luo, professor and chief AI officer at Northwestern University's clinical and translational sciences institute.
Some of those signs may include citation gaps, factual inconsistencies and irrelevant conclusions derived from random research.
MAHA report: RFK slams processed foods, pesticides, vaccines as harmful to kids
The MAHA report erroneously said an article on the impact of light from computer monitors was published in the journal Pediatrics when it wasn't, according to the study's author Mariana Figueiro, a professor at Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai.
The report also cited Figueiro's research as evidence that electronic devices in children's bedrooms disrupted sleep onset. However, she said the study was on college students and researchers measured melatonin suppression, not sleep.
'The study is ours, but unfortunately, the conclusions in the report are not accurate and the journal reference is incorrect,' Figueiro told USA TODAY via email. 'We have other papers on the topic… but again, none of them were performed with children.'
The MAHA report also cited Columbia University epidemiologist Katherine Keyes as first author of a study on anxiety in adolescents. As first reported by NOTUS and confirmed by USA TODAY, Keyes said she did not write the paper cited by the MAHA report.
'I was surprised to see what seems to be an error in the citation of my work in the report, and it does make me concerned given that citation practices are an important part of conducting and reporting rigorous science,' Keyes told USA TODAY via email.
Keyes has studied the topic and published a recent study in JAMA Network Open that adolescent girls had higher levels of depressive symptoms than boys, but her study's figures did not match what the MAHA report cited.
She said her earlier research on depression and anxiety symptoms yielded results 'that are generally in the ballpark of the MAHA report, although I'm not sure where their exact ranges are drawn from.'
Keyes said she would be happy to send information to the MAHA committee to correct the report, but she doesn't know where to reach the report's authors.
Ivan Oransky, co-founder of Retraction Watch, a site that tracks retractions in scientific journals and research, said the MAHA report seemed to share characteristics similar to other AI-generated work.
AI papers 'tend to hallucinate references,' he said. 'They come up with references that share a lot of words and authors and even journals, journal names, but they're not real."
HHS spokesman Andrew Nixon said the report has been updated to correct "minor citation and formatting errors."
"But the substance of the MAHA report remains the same - a historic and transformative assessment by the federal government to understand the chronic disease epidemic afflicting our nation's children," he said. "Under President Trump and Secretary Kennedy, our federal government is no longer ignoring this crisis, and it's time for the media to also focus on what matters."
Oransky noted the MAHA report comes as Kennedy said he may prohibit government scientists from publishing research in major peer-reviewed medical journals such as JAMA, Lancet and New England Journal of Medicine 'because they're all corrupt.'
Kennedy proposed an HHS publication where government scientists could publish research findings.
"When scientific reform is weaponized to only denigrate science and scientists whose studies contradict your beliefs or your wishes, we get to a very dark place,' Oransky said.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: RFK Jr.'s MAHA report errors: Was it AI or 'formatting issues?'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
6 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
‘When they go low…we go lower?' North Bay official rails against California redistricting maps
Sonoma County Supervisor Lynda Hopkins had been loving Gov. Gavin Newsom's full-throated, all-caps trolling of President Donald Trump on social media. But then she plugged her rural Sebastopol address into California's newly proposed congressional maps. Her fellow Democrats' effort to counter Trump's push to gain more U.S. House seats in Texas for Republicans had proposed cleaving her Russian River community into separate districts. Sebastopol, Forestville and Santa Rosa would be lumped with Chico and Oroville in the Sierra foothills. Guerneville, Monte Rio and Jenner would be placed in a sprawling district running from Marin to the Oregon border. She was angry. 'When they go low… we go lower?' Hopkins began writing on Facebook Saturday afternoon. 'What hurts my heart the most here isn't that we're turning red districts into blue districts,' she continued in a 1,705-word post. 'It's that we're doing it by DILUTING THE RURAL VOTE.' The staunchly progressive Democrat (and former farmer who still grows vegetables and raises goats, ducks and geese) didn't stop there, rallying against inflexible government vaccine policies and government regulations that seem to lack common sense. She declared that crunchy west Sonoma County is home to the original 'Make America Healthy Again' movement, and not Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. 'We're real MAHA, not fake MAHA… I'm still waiting for RFK Jr. to grow a pair and actually get those crappy additives out of our kids' food!' she wrote. Her rant hit a nerve – or many — drawing praise and criticism. 'Preach, sister!' wrote Santa Rosa resident Deb McGauley, who criticized 'the tit-for-tat, chest beating behavior between these men in power,' and said it is 'NOT going to help anyone in the long run.' 'F that,' wrote Jeniffer Wertz, a Guerneville resident, who held the opposite view. 'They've been punching us in the face and winning, and it's time to punch back while we still have the right to vote!' 'Wow Linda, you seem to be out of touch with the crisis of the current moment,' wrote Gina Cuclis, a Sonoma County Board of Education trustee (who ran an unsuccessful bid in 2012 for a supervisory seat). The post garnered nearly 200 comments and was shared 65 times. The next day, Hopkins deactivated the account but brought it back Monday. Hopkins told the Chronicle that she temporarily took the account down after multiple suspicious login attempts. California's redistricting plan – which could bring Democrats five more seats in the U.S. House in the 2026 midterms – is not finalized. Democrats are racing to clear procedural hurdles and get a redistricting measure onto a special ballot for a November vote. As it stands, Newsom is proposing to use these new maps through the 2030 elections, after which the congressional maps are slated to be re-evaluated by the state's independent redistricting commission. Hopkins, in an interview on Wednesday, said she would vote for the redistricting plan 'because I think that we do need to fight this bigger battle against authoritarianism,' even though she is frustrated that Sonoma County had been 'carved up for parts.' 'When we have to stoop to the level of gerrymandering in order to save our country, that should give us heartburn,' Hopkins said. To get more Democrats into Congress, Newsom and his allies must dilute the populations that have elected Republican legislators including Doug LaMalfa and Kevin Kiley in northern California, said David McCuan, a professor of political science at Sonoma State University. Those Republicans' districts were redrawn to pick up Democratic strongholds further to the west, like Santa Rosa. Bruce Cain, a political scientist at Stanford University, said that Hopkins 'has a valid point' that rural interests are being sacrificed, although the arguments are also strong for Democrats to take every measure necessary to get more representatives into Congress. Cain said part of the goal of the state's independent commission to draw congressional district lines is to ensure that different community interests aren't drowned out – and that includes rural interests, such as health care wildfires, air quality, drug abuse and farming issues. 'Once you stick large rural areas together with urban areas, you're going to swamp out those interests,' Cain said. Hopkins said Wednesday she often writes paragraphs and paragraphs to solidify and express her thoughts. She doesn't always post them. But this time, she did. 'To the city Dem politicians who consider the rest of the state a nice place to visit or fly over: you're welcome for the clean water, the flood control, the food you eat, the wood that builds your homes, the gravel that makes up the roads you drive on,' Hopkins wrote. 'Because all of that, the very basis of life in cities, COMES FROM RURAL COMMUNITIES. And you know what? It's not just owls in these woods. People live here, too."
The Hill
9 hours ago
- The Hill
MAGA, MAHA split on pesticides
MAHA, a movement aimed at tackling the nation's chronic disease epidemic through food, health and environmental reforms, has been deeply skeptical of Big Pharma, Big Agriculture, and Big Chemical. MAHA groups have been strongly aligned with the Trump administration's actions to date on vaccines and food. But cracks are beginning to form. MAHA-aligned groups and influencers are raising alarms about provisions in a House appropriations bill they say will shield pesticide and chemical manufacturers from accountability — and ultimately make Americans less healthy. Meanwhile, a draft of the administration's 'MAHA Report' on children's health reportedly omits any calls to prevent pesticide exposure, also disappointing advocates. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and his disciples espouse stricter environmental protections, while also bucking mainstream science on vaccine safety. Conservatives have traditionally sided with big business, supporting fewer regulations on potentially toxic substances. So far, business interests appear to be winning. The industry-friendly draft of a report from a commission run by Kennedy shows just how much the White House has been able to rein him in. 'It's obvious that there are tensions within this newfound coalition between MAHA and MAGA, and there are some big issues there,' said Mary Holland, CEO of Children's Health Defense, an anti-vaccine group founded by Kennedy. While the pesticide issues have generated some sparks between MAHA and MAGA, the administration has taken a number of other actions to also reduce restrictions on the chemical industry more broadly. Trump himself exempted from environmental standards more than 100 polluters, including chemical manufacturers, oil refineries, coal plants and medical device sterilizers. The EPA, meanwhile, has put chemical industry alumni in leading roles and has said it wants to loosen restrictions on emissions of various cancer-linked chemicals. 'Those factions, if you will — more protective of corporate and more challenging to corporate — are both striving to get the president's ear, and I don't think they've come to a complete, sort of settlement agreement,' Holland said.
Time Magazine
9 hours ago
- Time Magazine
Public Health Workers Criticize RFK Jr. After CDC Shooting
More than 750 public health workers sent a letter to Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on Wednesday, urging him to 'stop spreading inaccurate health information' and guarantee employees' safety, in the wake of a shooting at the headquarters of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) earlier this month. The letter—signed by both named and anonymous current and former staffers at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), CDC, and National Institutes of Health who noted they signed the letter in their 'own personal capacities'—said the attack on the CDC's headquarters in Atlanta on Aug. 8 'was not random.' 'The attack came amid growing mistrust in public institutions, driven by politicized rhetoric that has turned public health professionals from trusted experts into targets of villainization—and now, violence,' public health workers said in the letter, which was also addressed to members of Congress. 'CDC is a public health leader in America's defense against health threats at home and abroad. When a federal health agency is under attack, America's health is under attack. When the federal workforce is not safe, America is not safe.' The public health workers went on to accuse Kennedy, a prominent vaccine skeptic, of being 'complicit in dismantling America's public health infrastructure and endangering the nation's health by repeatedly spreading inaccurate health information.' They cited several statements and actions that Kennedy has made in recent months, pointing to his claim that mRNA vaccines 'fail to protect effectively' against upper respiratory infections such as COVID-19—despite years of research showing that the shots are both safe and effective—and his announcement that HHS would be winding down mRNA vaccine development. They also condemned his decision to remove all the experts from a critical vaccine advisory committee. And they said some of Kennedy's past comments—such as claiming that there is a 'cesspool of corruption at CDC'—were 'sowing public mistrust' in the health agency. The public health workers expressed their wish to honor police officer David Rose, who was killed while responding to the attack on the CDC headquarters in August. HHS said in a statement to TIME that Kennedy 'is standing firmly with CDC employees—both on the ground and across every center—ensuring their safety and well-being remain a top priority.' The agency added that, after the shooting earlier this month, Kennedy traveled to Atlanta and called the CDC 'a shining star' among the world's health agencies. 'For the first time in its 70-year history, the mission of HHS is truly resonating with the American people—driven by President Trump and Secretary Kennedy's bold commitment to Make America Healthy Again,' HHS said. 'Any attempt to conflate widely supported public health reforms with the violence of a suicidal mass shooter is an attempt to politicize a tragedy.' Law enforcement officials said they found evidence that the suspect in the August shooting, who they identified as Patrick Joseph White of Georgia, blamed the COVID-19 vaccine for his health ailments. White was found dead at the scene, and authorities later said that he died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. CDC Director Susan Monarez noted the dangers posed by misinformation in a staff meeting in the wake of the attack. 'We know that misinformation can be dangerous,' she said, according to NBC News. 'Not only to health, but to those that trust us and those we want to trust. We need to rebuild the trust together.' The day after the shooting, Kennedy expressed his condolences to Rose's family in a post on X. 'We know how shaken our public health colleagues feel today. No one should face violence while working to protect the health of others,' he said. 'We are actively supporting CDC staff on the ground and across the agency. Public health workers show up every day with purpose—even in moments of grief and uncertainty. We honor their service. We stand with them. And we remain united in our mission to protect and improve the health of every American.' Kennedy was one of President Donald Trump's most controversial Cabinet nominees, and faced heated questioning by Senators during his confirmation hearings. He has drawn outrage from the medical establishment in the past for spreading disinformation, including repeating the debunked claim that vaccines cause autism. In their letter, public health workers claimed Kennedy's 'dangerous and deceitful statements and actions have contributed to the harassment and violence experienced by CDC staff.' They implored him to take three steps by Sept. 2 to 'uphold his pledge to safeguard the health of the American public,' including asking him to 'stop spreading inaccurate health information,' particularly regarding vaccines, infectious disease transmission, and the country's public health institutions. They also urged him to affirm the scientific integrity of the CDC and guarantee the safety of HHS employees, such as through emergency procedures and alerts. 'The deliberate destruction of trust in America's public health workforce puts lives at risk,' they wrote in the letter. 'We urge you to act in the best interest of the American people—your friends, your families, and yourselves.'
