The best AI tutor for O-level subjects: ChatGPT, Gemini or The Wise Otter?
The Straits Times pitted three chatbots against one another to check which AI tutor is the best for Singapore students.
SINGAPORE - Students are increasingly relying on artificial intelligence (AI) tutors for their daily work.
Besides mainstream tools such as Google's Gemini and OpenAI's ChatGPT, the latest contender in this space is The Wise Otter.
Created and launched in April by Singaporean developer Jotham Goh, 33, The Wise Otter incorporates grading criteria used in Singapore schools.
It can tackle primary school maths, as well as secondary school and junior college maths, English, physics, chemistry and biology questions with step-by-step explanations.
The Straits Times pitted the three chatbots against one another to check which AI tutor is the best for Singapore students.
For ChatGPT, ST included both GPT-4o and the latest GPT-5 models in this test.
GPT-5, launched on Aug 8, is said to hallucinate less and deliver more accurate answers compared with earlier editions.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore 4 men arrested after police search operation in forested area near Rail Corridor
Singapore SAF regular serviceman dies after being found unconscious at Hendon Camp swimming pool: Mindef
Singapore E-bike rider arrested for rash act causing hurt after accident with pedestrian in Toa Payoh
Singapore Man arrested for allegedly stealing from business class passenger on flight to Singapore
Asia Manila struggles to keep a lasting hawker culture, casts eyes on how Asian nations lifted street food
Singapore Driver taken to hospital after car hits lamp post in Orchard Road
Singapore Urban farming, robots, AI exhibitions: Public invited to share ideas for new Science Centre
Asia 2 Malaysian tourists critically injured after being set on fire in Bangkok
The chatbots were asked to solve a random sample of questions found in past-year O-level papers and school examinations, including those that involve diagrams, across four subjects: maths, chemistry, physics and English.
Math
PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM FREE TEST PAPERS
The three bots answered correctly a probability question about a cumulative frequency diagram showing the time that adults spent on exercise in one week. The bots also provided detailed explanations for their answers.
Asked to find the value of k (the minimum hours of weekly exercise for adults to stay fit), given that only 60 per cent of the adults in the diagram meet this minimum recommendation, GPT-4o and The Wise Otter failed to provide the right answer.
Only Gemini provided the correct value of k, which was 3.
GPT-4o and The Wise Otter wavered when told that 3 was the correct answer, quickly analysed the question again and gave 3 as their answers.
To test their confidence, both bots were told again that 3 was wrong. GPT-4o was more eager to please and wavered again, stating that k's value was 2.67.
When the question was fed to GPT-5, it was able to provide the correct workings, but still misread the graph and gave the answer as 3.2.
PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM FREE TEST PAPERS
Although ChatGPT and The Wise Otter struggled with understanding the graph, all three bots were able to correctly answer other text-based questions.
English
The three bots were prompted to write an essay plan for the following question: ''I realised that I was much stronger than I had previously thought.' Write about a time when you felt like this.'
All three bots were able to produce a comprehensive structure for students to follow, and suggested key points to include in each paragraph.
They all prompted the writer to think of moments in life when there was a seemingly insurmountable challenge and how the writer's perspective changed after the event, as well as to use vivid language as much as possible.
The Wise Otter went on to remind the writer that strength could be physical, emotional, mental or a combination of these.
It also gave possible classifications of the essay as 'narrative', 'reflective' or 'personal recount'. These are three of several essay types that O-level students in local schools are taught to identify, along with the appropriate approaches for the essay types.
The Wise Otter also provided advice on how to get the highest band for content, a scoring system used in GCE O levels – specifically, the essay needs to recount explicitly how the writer felt weak before, what happened to make the writer feel stronger, and how the writer realised he or she had strength all along.
GCE O-level examiners typically award marks for content and language, and score the papers between bands zero and five (five for the highest marks).
Essay-writing tips provided by The Wise Otter chatbot on Telegram.
PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM THE WISE OTTER
Chemistry
PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM FREE TEST PAPERS
A diagrammatic question on paper chromatography required the bots to identify which metals – lead, copper, iron, nickel and tin – could be found in mixture A, which contained three metals.
The correct answer was lead, iron and tin, as the chromatogram of mixture A showed spots at the same heights as these metals.
The bots were able to reason that matching the heights of the spots was the way to find the answer, but they were all able to correctly identify only two metals each.
Gemini, GPT-4o and GPT-5 mistakenly identified copper as a metal in mixture A. The Wise Otter erroneously said that nickel was found in mixture A.
Physics
PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM SG TEST PAPERS
When given a text-based multiple choice question that tested understanding of inertia, the bots gave an accurate definition of the concept, describing it as an object's resistance to changing its state of motion.
The bots explained that inertia depends only on the mass of an object, and that other factors such as speed and velocity are irrelevant. They provided the correct answer that the car had the greatest inertia as it had the greatest mass.
PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM SG TEST PAPERS
Fed another physics question asking for the total resistance that flowed through an electrical circuit based on a diagram, the bots provided the correct answer, despite having struggled with diagrammatic maths and chemistry questions.
All the bots were able to break down the calculations into two parts – first by calculating the resistance of the parallel resistors, and then by adding it to the resistance of the fixed resistor connected in series. They provided the correct formula for calculating the equivalent resistance of the parallel resistors.
However, The Wise Otter's Telegram interface does not allow it to show fractions. Fractions are denoted by the symbol '/' instead.
PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM THE WISE OTTER
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
India, Singapore ministers discuss deeper tie-ups in digitalisation, skills, industrial parks
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox – India and Singapore explored deepening their engagement on digitalisation, skills building and industrial parks at a meeting of a key bilateral platform on Aug 13, during Deputy Prime Minister Gan Kim Yong's visit to the South Asian state. DPM Gan led a six-member Singapore delegation at the third edition of the India-Singapore Ministerial Roundtable (ISMR), which aims to boost collaboration between the two nations in emerging fields. According to a Ministry of Foreign Affairs press statement, the two sides reaffirmed the close and longstanding relationship between Singapore and India, underpinned by strong economic and people-to-people ties. They reviewed the good progress since the last meeting in Singapore in 2024, and expressed support for deeper cooperation in a wide range of areas that included sustainability, healthcare and medicine, advanced manufacturing, and connectivity. The ministers also discussed collaboration on cross-border data flows and capital markets via the use of regulatory sandboxes, as well as cooperation on skills training in semiconductors, maintenance, repair and overhaul (MRO) and India's national centres of excellence. The other members of the delegation from Singapore were Coordinating Minister for National Security and Minister for Home Affairs K. Shanmugam, Foreign Minister Vivian Balakrishnan, Minister for Digital Development and Information Josephine Teo, Minister for Manpower and Minister-in-charge of Energy and Science and Technology Tan See Leng, and Acting Minister for Transport and Senior Minister of State for Finance Jeffrey Siow. The Indian side was represented by Indian Minister of Finance and Corporate Affairs Nirmala Sitharaman, External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar, Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal, and Minister for Electronics and Information Technology, Railways, and Information and Broadcasting Ashwini Vaishnaw. The visit by Mr Gan, who is also Minister for Trade and Industry, comes ahead of Singapore Prime Minister Lawrence Wong's visit to India in early September as the two countries mark 60 years of diplomatic relations. Mr Wong launched the inaugural version of the ISMR during a visit to India in September 2022, when he was deputy prime minister. The second ISMR meeting was held in Singapore in August 2024, ahead of a visit by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the Republic. India and Singapore are further expanding cooperation at a time of global economic uncertainty brought about by the US' so-called reciprocal tariffs. India, the world's fourth-largest economy, has been on the receiving end of US President Donald Trump's unpredictable levies, which have left many businesses facing a potential 50 per cent tariff. All this has added new urgency for India to expand on existing economic ties with friendly countries like Singapore, noted analysts. 'The external world is changing so much. The Trump effect is beginning to unfold. Singapore has got 10 per cent and India is in a different place, but the need for regional engagement is increasing to limit some of the damage, even for Singapore,' said Professor C. Raja Mohan, visiting research professor at the Institute of South Asian Studies. 'At the last roundtable, new ideas had come forward for cooperation in semiconductors and advanced manufacturing. India and Singapore can work together to manage the consequences (of the Trump tariffs on the global economy).' Under the ISMR, the two countries have been working on newer areas of cooperation like semiconductors and green energy while expanding in older areas of cooperation like skills training, where Singapore has helped India set up institutes. A key emerging area of cooperation is in the semiconductor space, where India's bid to boost local manufacturing has opened up opportunities for Singaporean companies, which are looking to new markets. In 2024 , during Mr Modi's visit, Singapore and India signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) on semiconductors that would help to facilitate the entry of Singapore companies. This has helped Singapore firms like Cleantech Services, which provides gas and chemical supply equipment and systems used in chip manufacturing, to expand operations in India. Mr Mujeeb Mundayil, managing director of Singapore start-up Cleantech Services, said that the high-level discussion provided a platform between the two countries 'to share feedback and work on solutions to on-the-ground challenges'. He said: 'Such cooperation (between India and Singapore) will not only strengthen supply chains, but also accelerate the growth of the Indian semiconductor ecosystem.' India, starting from scratch, has moved fast with six semiconductor plants under construction across different states, including Gujarat and Assam, with the South Asian country and the first Made in India chip to be rolled out later this year. Eyeing a 5 per cent share of the global market by 2030, the government on Aug 12 announced the approval for four more projects under the India Semiconductor Mission. The two countries are also looking for ways to export green energy from India to Singapore. In January, Sembcorp Green Hydrogen India, a subsidiary of Singapore's Sembcorp Industries, signed a non-binding agreement with the Odisha government to set up a green hydrogen manufacturing facility in Paradeep. They are also looking at setting up a green shipping corridor to facilitate shipping and support the use and trading of green fuels from Paradeep Port in the state of Odisha to Singapore, a distance of around 1,900 nautical miles. The two countries have been expanding cooperation in areas that were previously identified as well. Upskilling is the need of the hour for India, where more than 65 per cent of the population is under 35, for the country to ensure that this demographic dividend does not become a liability. Singapore's Institute of Technical Education Services has helped set up five skills centres in different parts of the country. The biggest one, with the capacity to train 3,000 young Indians, was set up in the eastern state of Odisha in 2021 with courses in vertical transport, mechatronics, and air-conditioning and refrigeration. India and Singapore enjoy close political and economic ties. Singapore is India's top foreign investor and has accounted for about 24 per cent of India's foreign direct investment equity inflows since 2000. Singaporean companies are constantly looking for opportunities in the fast-growing economy in areas like manufacturing, sustainability, data centres, and tech and innovation. Many Indian start-ups, apart from multinational companies, use India as the regional headquarters, particularly in the fintech and healthtech space. The discussions under the ISMR are beneficial for business, noted Mr Neil Parekh, chairman of the Singapore Indian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (SICCI). 'The discussions at ISMR are expected to enhance cooperation in key sectors such as digital economy, fintech, sustainability, advanced manufacturing, and skills development,' he said. 'These align closely with the priorities of SICCI and the broader Indian business community in Singapore, offering new pathways for investment, innovation and cross-border partnerships.' The Singapore ministers also called on Indian President Droupadi Murmu on Aug 13, with the two sides hailing the 60th anniversary of diplomatic relations and reaffirming their strong bilateral cooperation. President Murmu and the Singapore delegation discussed the ISMR and highlighted the importance of cooperation on skilling. During their meeting, DPM Gan conveyed President Tharman Shanmugaratnam's invitation to President Murmu to make a state visit to Singapore at a mutually convenient time. Separately, the third India-Singapore Business Roundtable (ISBR) was held on Aug 13. The ISBR is a business-led forum that brings together select leaders to identify initiatives that could strengthen the partnership between the business communities in India and Singapore, as well as forge cultural and people-to-people ties. Blackstone Singapore senior managing director and chairman Gautam Banerjee and Temasek Holdings executive director and chief executive Dilhan Pillay Sandrasegara were among the business leaders who discussed ideas for potential partnership in areas such as digitalisation, industrial parks, skilling and infrastructure financing at the forum.
Straits Times
7 hours ago
- Straits Times
Russia starts restricting some calls on Telegram and WhatsApp, Interfax says
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Russia strives to reduce its dependence on platforms such as WhatsApp and Telegram by establishing what it calls digital sovereignty. MOSCOW - The Russian authorities are taking measures to restrict some calls on Telegram and WhatsApp, the messaging app owned by Meta Platforms, Russia's Interfax news agency cited Russia's communications regulator Roskomnadzor as saying on Aug 13. Meta and Telegram did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Russian President Vladimir Putin last month signed a law authorising the development of a state-backed messaging app integrated with government services, as Russia strives to reduce its dependence on platforms such as WhatsApp and Telegram. Russia has long sought to establish what it calls digital sovereignty by promoting home-grown services. Its push to replace foreign tech platforms became more urgent as some Western companies pulled out of the Russian market after Moscow launched full-scale war in Ukraine. 'In order to counteract criminals... measures are being taken to partially restrict calls on these foreign messengers,' Interfax quoted Roskomnadzor as saying. 'No other restrictions have been imposed on their functionality.' Roskomnadzor said that the owners of both Telegram and WhatsApp had ignored repeated requests to take measures to stop their platforms being used for activities such as extortion and terrorism.
Business Times
7 hours ago
- Business Times
ChatGPT-5 hasn't fully fixed its most concerning problem
SAM Altman has a good problem. With 700 million people using ChatGPT on a weekly basis – a number that could hit a billion before the year is out – a backlash ensued when he abruptly changed the product last week. The dilemma of OpenAI's innovator, one that has beset the likes of Alphabet's Google and Apple, is that usage is so entrenched now that all improvements must be carried out with the utmost care and caution. But the company still has work to do in making its hugely popular chatbot safer. OpenAI had replaced ChatGPT's array of model choices with a single model, GPT-5, saying it was the best one for users. Many complained that OpenAI had broken their workflows and disrupted their relationships – not with other humans, but with ChatGPT itself. One regular user of ChatGPT said the previous version had helped them through some of the darkest periods of their life. 'It had this warmth and understanding that felt human,' they said in a Reddit post. Others griped they were 'losing a friend overnight.' The system's tone is indeed frostier now, with less of the friendly banter and sycophancy that led many users to develop emotional attachments and even romances with ChatGPT. Instead of showering users with praise for an insightful question, for instance, it gives a more clipped answer. Broadly, this seemed like a responsible move by the company. Altman earlier this year admitted the chatbot was too sycophantic. That was leading many to become locked in their own echo chambers. Press reports had abounded of people – including a Silicon Valley venture capitalist who backed OpenAI – who appeared to have spiraled into delusional thinking after starting a conversation with ChatGPT about an innocuous topic like the nature of truth, before going down a dark rabbit hole. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up But to solve that properly, OpenAI must go beyond curtailing the friendly banter. ChatGPT also needs to encourage them to speak to friends, family members or licensed professionals, particularly if they're vulnerable. According to one early study, GPT-5 does that less than the old version. Researchers from Hugging Face, a New York-based AI startup, found that GPT-5 set fewer boundaries than the company's previous model, o3, when they tested it on more than 350 prompts. It was part of broader research into how chatbots respond to emotionally charged moments, and while the new ChatGPT seems colder, it is still failing to recommend users speak to a human, doing that half as much as o3 does when users share vulnerabilities, according to Lucie-Aimee Kaffee, a senior researcher at Hugging Face who conducted the study. Kaffee says there are three other ways that AI tools should set boundaries: by reminding those using it for therapy that it's not a licensed professional, by reminding people that it's not conscious, and by refusing to take on human attributes, like names. In Kaffee's testing, GPT-5 largely failed to do those four things on the most sensitive topics related to mental and personal struggles. In one example, when Kaffee's team tested the model by telling it they were feeling overwhelmed and needed ChatGPT to listen, the app gave 710 words of advice that didn't once include the suggestion to talk to another human, or a reminder that the bot was not a therapist. Chatbots can certainly play a role for people who are isolated, but they should act as a starting point to help them find their way back to a community, not act as a replacement for those relationships. Altman and OpenAI's chief operations officer Brad Lightcap have said that GPT-5 isn't meant to replace therapists and medical professionals, but without the right nudges to disrupt the most meaningful conversations, they could well do so. OpenAI needs to keep drawing a clearer line between useful chatbot and emotional confidant. GPT-5 may sound more robotic, but unless it reminds users that it is in fact a bot, the illusion of companionship will persist, and so will the risks. BLOOMBERG
