Fact check: Did wind and solar really cause Portugal and Spain's mass blackout?
Spain and Portugal are still reeling from the largest power cut in recent European history, which struck just after midday yesterday. With power supplies mostly back to normal, attention is now focused on what caused the incident.
Speculation is rife, and some commentators have been quick to blame renewables, which now make up a large share of both countries' power mixes.
'Net-zero blamed for blackout chaos' proclaimed one headline from UK newspaper The Daily Telegraph, but none of the experts quoted in the article appear to draw that conclusion, and the exact
cause
remains a mystery.
Speaking on Tuesday morning, the Spanish grid operator Red Eléctrica's head of services Eduardo Prieto said that preliminary investigations have ruled out a
cybersecurity attack
- as some had initially feared.
Related
Spain and Portugal travel warning: Flight delays and crowded train stations as power returns
First victims of Iberian blackout confirmed in Spain as fallout rumbles on
Spain's national meteorological office, Aemet, also appears to have ruled out extreme weather as a trigger. 'During the day of 28 April, no unusual meteorological or atmospheric phenomena were detected, and nor were there sudden variations in the temperature in our network of meteorological stations,' it said in a statement this morning.
With these potential causes discounted, here's what experts are saying about
renewables
in the Iberian grid and what role they played in Monday's mass power outage.
What happened to Spain's renewables during the blackout?
Data from the Spanish grid operator's website showed the dramatic drop in demand yesterday, shortly after 12.30pm, when it nosedived from 25GW to 10GW in an instant.
Prieto said that two consecutive events - one at 12.32pm on Monday and another just a second-and-a-half later - pointed to a 'generation disconnection' that had cut off the supply across the peninsula.
While the system weathered the first event, it reportedly could not cope with the second.
The operator's head of services noted that the problem started in southwest Spain, which is where much of the country's
solar energy
is generated.
Some experts have previously voiced concern that Spain's grid needs to be upgraded to cope with the rapid integration of solar and wind. But others stress the unlikelihood of the mass blackout being down to the intermittent renewables, which the Spanish and Portuguese operators are by now adept at handling.
Spanish energy think tank Fundacion Renovables explains that renewable power plants with 2MW of power generation or more were disconnected because of a disturbance in the frequency of the power grid - as per national safety protocols.
Essentially, the disturbance was 'a consequence and not a cause', it said in a
statement.
'The fact that Spain has a high production of electricity from renewable sources has no link to the grid failures that occurred on Monday,' it adds. 'We regret that an extremely serious situation is being taken advantage of to spread falsehoods and generate
disinformation
in an already very complex situation for all affected citizens.'
In a press conference earlier today, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez called claims that renewable energy was to blame for the outage 'lies', attacking those who linked the blackout to Spain's use of wind and solar.
ADVERTISEMENT
"Those linking the blackout to the lack of nuclear power are either lying or demonstrating their ignorance," he said.
Sánchez announced that the government has set up a commission to investigate the incident and will be examining the role of private energy companies.
Related
Are solar farms destroyed during storms? Experts debunk the myth that panels can't handle the wind
'Solar Marshall Plan': Can Ukraine become the world's first post-war country rebuilt on renewables?
Solar helped Spain's electricity system recover
Advocates of renewable energy emphasise that solar and wind are reliable energy sources, and go hand-in-hand with
energy security
.
Stephen Jarvis, assistant professor in environmental economics at the London School of Economics and Political Science, was tracking the grid changes yesterday as Spain attempted to bring the grid back online. He observed that solar, wind and hydro were still delivering energy in Spain, at a time when nuclear, gas and coal were totally offline.
ADVERTISEMENT
Got the Spanish grid operator data on generation by source type working now too. Confirms the ENTSOE data that it remains solar/wind/hydro that is still operating. Nuclear/gas/coal remain basically offline for now - presumably tripped off when demand fell (or vice versa depending on the root cause).
[image or embed]
— Stephen Jarvis (
@stephenjarvis.bsky.social
)
28 April 2025 at 13:48
Far from being the cause of the peninsula's woes, Fundacion Renovables states that the large percentage of renewable energy in Spain and the flexibility of hydropower systems enabled the nation to react and recover more quickly.
'If Spain had not had so much renewable capacity, the return to normality of the grid would have been longer in time,' it adds.
As investigations into the main grid outage continue, CEO of Global Solar Council Sonia Dunlop noted that solar also has an important role to play during power cuts.
'If you have rooftop solar and storage on your home or business, and if it is wired up to be able to work off-grid, then you are much more resilient to blackouts,' she posted on X yesterday.
ADVERTISEMENT
'
Solar and storage
provide resilience to climate impacts, natural disasters and more. If heatwaves and freak weather are going to lead to more blackouts, it might be worth more people installing solar in such a way that it can go into island mode.'
The incident has also prompted discussion on the Iberian Peninsula's status as an 'energy island' within the EU, given it is relatively disconnected from the rest of the bloc.
It remains to be fully analysed whether closer links with Europe's grids could have aided Spain and Portugal - or put more countries at risk.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
7 hours ago
- Euronews
Is Paris Europe's most deadly capital during heatwaves?
In a recent post shared on X, France's Minister of Culture Rachida Dati stated that "Paris is the deadliest European capital during heatwaves", while in a spat with David Belliard, a Green candidate for the Paris 2026 mayoral race. While Belliard accused the French government of failing to address climate change effectively, Dati claimed that the city of Paris—led by socialist Mayor Anne Hidalgo—had failed in its duties, despite having multiple climate action plans in place. When it comes to assessing excess death rates, Dati's claims are true, to a certain extent. They can be traced back to a 2023 study, entitled "Excess mortality attributed to heat and cold", and published in the medical journal The Lancet. It assessed excess mortality rates due to heat and cold across 854 European cities, based on data from 2000 to 2019. While researchers found that London was the capital with the most excess deaths related to heavy spells of cold weather, Paris had the most excess deaths during heatwaves. The 2003 heatwave in particular led to record-breaking temperatures and thousands of deaths in Paris. It's worth noting, however, that other non-capital cities have been identified as having higher excess deaths during heat spells than Paris, such as Milan and Barcelona, according to other studies. What makes these cities vulnerable to heatwaves? Large European cities often end up becoming "urban heat islands"—a phenomenon where urban areas experience significantly higher temperatures than the rural areas surrounding them. This is because of the presence of man-made surfaces and materials, such as concrete, buildings, and pavements. They absorb and retain more heat than natural landscapes such as trees and bodies of water. Paris and other cities like it also have high population density and comparatively few green spaces, the latter of which helps to reduce temperatures. Ultimately, though, the root causes of severe heatwaves in cities are climate change and natural climate variability, according to experts. "The temperature or the heat episodes in Paris and other cities in Europe are an outcome of the weather pattern influenced by natural climate variability, and human-induced climate change", Malcolm Mistry, assistant professor in Climate and Geo-Spatial Modelling at the London School of Tropical Diseases, and one of the authors of the study, told Euroverify. "Regions in Southern Europe and close to the Mediterranean Sea (that is also warming rapidly) are more prone to heatwaves," he added. "This is evident from intense heatwaves in recent years in Spain, Portugal, Italy, Greece and France, and at times, in late Spring or early Summer. In short, these are outside the influence of a city planner or political decision." Although authorities can work on urban planning projects to address climate change, other factors have a bigger influence. "Local factors such as geography can play a role, but at the end of the day, a natural large-scale weather system can stall over a location, drawing warm dry air and making the place extremely warm for a short duration," Mistry said. The 2003 heatwave led to record-breaking temperatures, as well as thousands of deaths, but since then, governments have been working on how they deal with these crises. "Many lessons have been learned, with further meteorological and heat-health warnings, heat-action plans, etc, being implemented in France and several other European countries", Mistry concluded.
Euronews
9 hours ago
- Euronews
Spain reports nearly 400,000 hectares burned and 37 arrests in fires
The humid weather and rainfall have provided some relief to Spanish authorities in their fight against the fires that have been ravaging much of the country for weeks, at a time when more than 391,000 hectares have already been burned so far this year, according to data from the European Forest Fire Information System. Although 40 fires are still active across the country, recent rain, especially in the province of León, could help firefighters control the situation there, allowing authorities to focus their efforts on other areas. On Wednesday, the president of the Castile and León region, Alfonso Fernández Mañueco, said that firefighting efforts are progressing favourably thanks to improved weather conditions. Mañueco also presented an aid plan for those affected, which includes €500 in aid for those who have had to evacuate their homes and up to €185,000 for those who have lost their homes to the flames. The situation in Castile and León is progressing "significantly" and favourably, as indicated by the president of the autonomous community, partly thanks to the change in weather conditions, which have improved significantly. "Conditions are favourable and significant progress is being made in extinguishing the fire," Mañueco reported, emphasising that "when circumstances allow, the operation works effectively." Fires in Galicia have ravaged small, sparsely populated towns, forcing locals in many cases to step in before firefighters arrive. Firefighting units from Germany arrived in northern Spain on Tuesday to help fight the blazes, Spain's Interior Ministry announced. More than 20 vehicles were deployed to help fight an ongoing blaze in Jarilla in the Extremadura region that borders Portugal, the ministry said. In Galicia, land management has also played a role. Large stretches of unmanaged vegetation and depopulated villages in forested land have led to the buildup of wildfire fuel, said Adrian Regos, an ecologist at the Biological Mission of Galicia, a research institute. Air quality deteriorated across large parts of Spain over the past week as a result of the wildfires, data from the EU's Copernicus climate monitoring agency showed. Smoke from the Iberian Peninsula fires reached France, the UK, and Scandinavia, it said. Several fires have been caused by human activity. Police have detained 37 people for suspected arson and are investigating 89 more, Spain's Civil Guard said Tuesday. In Portugal, more than 3,700 firefighters were tackling blazes, including four major ones in the north and centre. Wildfires there have burned about 235,000 hectares, according to EFFIS — nearly five times more than the 2006-2024 average for this period. Two people there have died. Europe has been warming twice as fast as the global average since the 1980s, according to Copernicus. Scientists say that climate change is exacerbating the frequency and intensity of heat and dryness in parts of Europe, making the region more vulnerable to wildfires.
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
Spain continues to battle destructive wildfires even as heatwave eases
Spain tackled several major wildfires on Tuesday in one of the country's most destructive fire seasons in recent decades, despite temperatures dropping across the Iberian Peninsula. Thousands of firefighters aided by soldiers and water-bombing aircraft fought fires tearing through parched woodland that were especially severe in northwestern Spain, where the country's weather agency AEMET reported a still 'very high or extreme' fire risk – particularly in the Galicia region. The fires in Galicia have ravaged small, sparsely populated towns, forcing locals in many cases to step in before firefighters arrive. Firefighting units from Germany arrived in northern Spain on Tuesday to help fight the blazes, Spain's Interior Ministry announced. More than 20 vehicles were deployed to help fight an ongoing blaze in Jarilla in the Extremadura region that borders Portugal, the ministry said. Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez visited the area Tuesday, where he spoke of the recent heat that has fueled the fires. Temperatures across Spain dropped by about 4 degrees Celsius (about 7 degrees Fahrenheit) on Tuesday after a 16-day heatwave with several days above 40 degrees Celsius (104 degrees Fahrenheit), Spain's weather agency reported. 'Science tells us, common sense tells us too, especially that of farmers and ranchers, of those who live in rural areas, that the climate is changing, that the climate emergency is becoming more and more recurrent, more frequent and has an ever greater impact,' Sanchez said. 01:43 In Galicia, land management has also played a role. Large stretches of unmanaged vegetation and depopulated villages in forested land have led to the build-up of wildfire fuel, said Adrian Regos, an ecologist at the Biological Mission of Galicia, a research institute. The fires in Spain have killed four people this year and burned more than 382,000 hectares or about 1,475 square miles, according to the European Union's European Forest Fire Information System. That surface area is more than twice the size of metropolitan London, more than six times the 2006-2024 average for land burned during the same period, according to EFFIS. Air quality deteriorated across large parts of Spain over the past week as a result of the wildfires, data from the EU's Copernicus climate monitoring agency showed. Smoke from the Iberian Peninsula fires reached France, the UK, and Scandinavia, it said. Several fires have been triggered by human activity. Police have detained 23 people for suspected arson and are investigating 89 more, Spain's Civil Guard said Tuesday. In Portugal, more than 3,700 firefighters were tackling blazes, including four major ones in the north and centre. Europe has been warming twice as fast as the global average since the 1980s, according to Copernicus. Scientists say that climate change is exacerbating the frequency and intensity of heat and dryness in parts of Europe, making the region more vulnerable to wildfires.
