Athens-Limestone County Public Library Board of Trustees releases statement on ‘age-appropriate material' concerns
LIMESTONE COUNTY, Ala. (WHNT) — The Athens-Limestone County Public Library Board of Trustees released a statement Saturday to clear up reports of inappropriate material shown in the youth sections of the library.
According to the Board of Trustees for the library, there is a report going around that there are non-age-appropriate materials in the youth sections of the Athens-Limestone County Public Library.
Authorities responded to high-speed chase leading to overheated vehicle, field fire off Pulaski Pike
The statement released Saturday states that, before the tenure of Vicki Hereford on the board, a parent reached out and emailed 'unsolicited graphic images' from a book called 'Let's Talk About It.'
The board said this book is a graphic novel format marketed to teens and said, in the email to Hereford, that the parent acknowledged that the library did not own a copy of the book.
The board of trustees said other news articles said the parent mentioned another book called 'It's Perfectly Normal,' but the board said the email to Hereford did not mention that book. The board did acknowledge that the library had a copy of this book but that it was shelved in the adult collection because of its purchase in 2010.
'While the book advertises on its cover that it is for age 10 and up, because of the images and material in the book, the library believed it was inappropriate for that age level and placed it in the adult section,' the Board of Trustees said.
Authorities respond to early morning house fire on Ryland Pike
You can read the full statement released Saturday by the board below.
'Athens-Limestone County Public Library Board of Trustees
The Athens-Limestone County Public Library and its board of trustees are committed to the common-sense proposition, shared by the vast majority of citizens in Limestone County, that only age-appropriate materials be located in the youth sections of our library. Any reports that suggest otherwise are dead wrong.
The ALCPL Board of Trustees is and always has been made up of Athens and Limestone County citizens appointed by the local governments. All the board members meet this qualification. Newly appointed board member Vicki Hereford's qualifications also include an extensive, professional background in finance and academia, and she is known across our community as a conservative mother of three now-grown sons. She is a welcome addition to the board and we look forward to her championing a conservative approach to decisions concerning library operations and materials purchased for children.
Before Ms. Hereford's tenure as a board member began, a concerned parent emailed unsolicited graphic images from a book called 'Let's Talk About It', a book in graphic novel format marketed to teens. The parent's email acknowledged that Athens-Limestone County Public Library does not own a copy of this book. That is correct, and there are no plans for our library to ever have a copy of this book. The images sent to Ms. Hereford were very sexually graphic. Ms. Hereford was disturbed by opening an email to see these unsolicited graphic images and she replied by insisting that the parent not send her those kinds of images.
Some news articles have mentioned another book called 'It's Perfectly Normal'. The parent's emails to Ms. Hereford never mentioned that book and never sent images from that book. The library owns a copy of 'It's Perfectly Normal', and it has been shelved in the adult collection since it was purchased in 2010. While the book advertises on its cover that it is for age 10 and up, because of the images and material in the book, the library believed it was inappropriate for that age level and placed it in the adult section.
The selection of materials for the library is an on-going process guided by the principle that the collection reflects our community's beliefs, standards, growth and diversity. The library has clear policies and procedures to help guide purchasing and placement decisions, and it takes positive action to continually review and evaluate its Children's and Young Adult collection to ensure the collection aligns with current guidelines set by the Alabama Public Library Service.'
Craig BeasleyChairman
In the ALCPL materials selection process information guide, page 16 is titled 'Materials Selection Reconsideration Procedures.'
Here's what to know about cryptocurrency and your taxes
GOP heads into key stretch for ambitious Trump tax cut plan
Auburn University names new head coach for women's basketball team
Police: 2 arrested in New Mexico shooting that killed 3, injured 15
How long would $1.5M in retirement savings last in each state?
You can read the full ALCPL Materials Selection Process guide below.
3-Materials-Selection-Reconsideration-Process-ALCPLDownload
In this section, the library says it supports the principles of intellectual freedom in the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States.
'The Board of Trustees has endorsed the policy that while any one individual is free toreject any books or materials that don't meet their individual approval, this right ofindividual censorship cannot be used to restrict the freedom of other individuals to readthe materials they choose. The Library will make efforts to properly categorize materialsin such a way that certain materials as stated herein are not placed in Juvenile or YoungAdult sections, however, the responsibility for the choice of library material for minorsrests with their parents or legal guardians,' the section reads.
The section then says that those who are in 'good standing' with the library can request that materials be withdrawn or reconsidered. The section says that pieces of work will then be evaluated as a whole, not by 'excerpts taken out of context.'
LOOKING FOR THE EXTENDED FORECAST? Click here to learn how to download the Live Alert 19 app
The ALCPL materials selection process information guide also said that something will not be removed or relocated without proof that the item violates the ALCPL Material Selection Policy.
'An item in the collection will not be removed or relocated at the request of anyone whodisagrees with the content or format unless it can be proved that the item is in violationof the Athens-Limestone County Public Library Material Selection Policy or by finaljudgments or rulings by a court of competent jurisdiction,' the guidelines say.
To request that material be reconsidered by the library, a member can fill out a 'citizen's request for reconsideration of library material' form found below.
3-Materials-Selection-Reconsideration-Process-FORMDownload
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
21 hours ago
- Yahoo
Man accused of shooting, killing family member in altercation, police say
LIMESTONE COUNTY, Ala. (WHNT) — The Limestone County Sheriff's Office said a man is accused of shooting and killing a family member Friday. LCSO said around 7 p.m., deputies responded to a shooting incident in the 17000 block of Kelley Drive in Athens. Upon arrival, LCSO said deputies found the body of Todd Robert Jennett, who had sustained multiple gunshot wounds. Also at the scene was Michael Stephen Esposito, 63, of Athens, Alabama. After securing the scene, investigators began a thorough investigation. Preliminary findings indicate that Jennett and Esposito, his stepfather, had been involved in a verbal altercation that escalated. During the dispute, Esposito reportedly produced a firearm and shot Jennett multiple times. Michael Esposito was taken into custody at the scene without incident and was transported to the Limestone County Jail. He is currently being held pending an Aniah's Law hearing, which will be scheduled at a later date. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Judge orders man committed to state mental hospital after threat to destroy fire station
HUNTSVILLE, Ala. (WHNT) — A Huntsville man charged with making threats against a Huntsville Fire Department station has been committed to the Alabama Department of Mental Health after a judge found his mental illness makes him a threat to himself or others. Madison County Circuit Judge Chris Comer said Friday that, based on two mental health evaluations of Craig Emerson and a subsequent hearing, Emerson is mentally ill and should remain in ADMH custody for treatment and therapy. State will seek death penalty against Huntsville man charged with killing 2 women in 2023 Emerson, 58, entered a plea of not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect to a charge of making terroristic threats. According to court documents, in 2021, Emerson threatened to blow up Huntsville Fire Station #5, prompting an investigation by local authorities. Due to concerns about his mental health, he was evaluated and subsequently committed to a state mental health facility for treatment in 2023. Records show he had mental health evaluations in February 2023 and November 2024. The court ordered that Emerson remain in the custody of the ADMH without being released unless authorized by the court. State court records show Emerson was previously arrested on multiple arson charges. In February 2013, he was charged with two counts of first-degree arson and one count of attempted arson after reportedly throwing Molotov cocktails into occupied homes in Huntsville. He pleaded guilty in 2015 to a count of first-degree attempted arson. Records show he was sentenced to 10 years in prison, but that sentence was suspended to time served and five years probation. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Bishop Miege president on leave pending investigation, new KCK archbishop says
The president of Bishop Miege High School in Roeland Park has been placed on leave while an investigation is conducted into recent reports regarding his ability to manage a safe school environment, the Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas announced Friday. 'The executive committee of Bishop Miege High School's (BMHS) Board of Trustees has placed Phil Baniewicz on administrative leave, effective June 5, 2025,' newly installed Archbishop Shawn McKnight said in a statement posted on the archdiocese's website Friday morning. 'I support this action of the executive committee for the well-being of the school. Due to recent reports concerning his ability to oversee a safe environment for BMHS, a thorough investigation has been initiated.' The executive committee of the BMHS board has appointed Joe Schramp as interim president, the statement said. Schramp, the school's associate principal and athletic director, did not respond to a request for comment. Baniewicz could not be reached for comment. The archbishop's statement provided no details about the 'recent reports' that led to the action. Baniewicz, who was appointed in June 2023 as president of Bishop Miege, had come under criticism after it was learned that he was a defendant along with two Catholic priests in a 2005 sexual abuse lawsuit in Arizona. 'As this is a confidential personnel matter, no further information will be provided until the investigation is concluded,' McKnight's statement said. 'Our commitment is to make our schools and parishes places where every child feels safe, supported, and valued. This necessitates not only immediate action when concerns arise but also a continuous evaluation of our policies to ensure we are doing everything possible to prevent harm. Through our efforts of accountability and transparency, we aim to foster trust and to respect the dignity of every person.' McKnight, former bishop of the Diocese of Jefferson City, was installed May 27 as the 12th bishop and fifth archbishop of the Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas after being appointed by Pope Francis on April 8 to replace retiring Archbishop Joseph F. Naumann. 'I ask you to join me in prayers for all involved in this situation: our students, their families, Mr. Baniewicz, our school community and our archdiocesan community,' McKnight said in his statement. 'Thank you for your prayers and for your witness of faith. May Mary, Mother of Church, protect us and guide us as we strive to follow her son, Jesus.' In the 2005 lawsuit, Baniewicz was accused of sexually abusing a teen in 1985. The other defendants were the Rev. Mark Lehman and Monsignor Dale Fushek. The three were associated with St. Timothy's Catholic Church in Mesa, Arizona, at the time. Baniewicz and Fushek also were co-founders of Life Teen, a Catholic youth program that was used in hundreds of parishes worldwide. The suit, filed in Maricopa County Superior Court, alleged that Life Teen participant William Cesolini was abused by Baniewicz 'on more than one occasion' at St. Timothy's and by Lehman 'on several occasions.' It also alleged that Fushek, the church pastor, failed to stop or prevent the abuse, provided alcohol to Cesolini and watched Lehman sexually abuse the teen. It said the three threatened Cesolini if he reported them. The lawsuit was based on repressed memories that Cesolini — who later became a seminary student — said he recovered in 2003 while undergoing counseling at a parish in Gilbert, Arizona. After the case was filed, the Life Teen board placed Baniewicz on administrative leave while it investigated. He was reinstated a few months later, but resigned in May 2006. The Diocese of Phoenix and church officials were named as co-defendants in the suit for allegedly being negligent in overseeing the priests. The diocese agreed to pay Cesolini $100,000 in December 2006 to settle the suit. In 1992, Lehman was sentenced to 10 years in prison for the sexual abuse of a minor girl in a Phoenix parish and sentenced to lifetime parole for the sexual abuse of three other minor girls and one boy. He was defrocked in 2006 and died in 2018. Fushek, a onetime second-in-command of the Phoenix diocese, was charged in 2005 with contributing to the delinquency of a minor, indecent exposure and assault — all misdemeanors — stemming from incidents involving other youth in the Life Teen program. He pleaded guilty to one count of assault and was sentenced to 364 days' probation and a $250 fine. He was defrocked in 2009. Baniewicz was not charged with any crimes and started working at Benedictine College in Atchison, Kansas, in the summer of 2006, where he was vice president of college relations for more than 3 1⁄2 years. After that, Baniewicz served for nearly 14 years as president of Maur Hill-Mount Academy, a college preparatory boarding school in Atchison. The Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas told The Star in 2023 that Bishop Miege and church officials knew about the 2005 Arizona lawsuit when Baniewicz was hired. Benedictine College and Maur Hill-Mount Academy also knew of the allegations, the archdiocese said, and in each hiring process, 'the matter was resolved to the satisfaction of the hiring entities.' 'The allegations were made known not only to Bishop Miege's board, but were discussed openly by Mr. Baniewicz during the hiring process,' the archdiocese said in 2023. The archdiocese said that Baniewicz had emphatically denied any allegations of wrongdoing throughout. Early last year, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) demanded that Baniewicz be removed from his position at Bishop Miege and called on then-Archbishop Naumann to publicly address concerns about him. On Friday, David Clohessy, volunteer director of Missouri SNAP, criticized the archdiocese for releasing little information about the investigation. 'It's pathetic that Catholic officials continue to be so secretive about this man, his recent behavior and the (previous) child sex abuse report against him …' Clohessy said in a statement. 'While his suspension is welcome, he should never have been hired in the first place two years ago. 'Kids are safest when abuse allegations and concerns are reported to secular authorities like police and prosecutors, not to church officials. We hope every person who may have seen, suspected or suffered any misconduct by Phil Baniewicz or anyone at Bishop Miege High School will contact law enforcement as soon as possible. We also hope Archbishop Shawn McKnight will be more forthcoming soon and will use church resources to aggressively prod anyone with suspicions or knowledge of wrongdoing to contact law enforcement.' Hal VonWyl, then-chairman of Bishop Miege's board of trustees, announced Baniewicz's appointment as the school's president in a June 30, 2023, note on the school's website. 'Mr. Baniewicz has a wealth of experience and a passion for Catholic education, with an extensive background in fundraising and community engagement,' VonWyl said. The announcement included a statement from Naumann. 'Phil Baniewicz has been an exceptional leader for Maur Hill-Mount Academy,' Naumann said. 'Mr. Baniewicz is a man with a deep love for Jesus and His church. I am delighted that he will continue to use those leadership skills to serve Catholic schools as he begins his new responsibilities as the President of Bishop Miege High School.' Baniewicz was quoted in the announcement, saying he 'can't wait to be a part of the Miege family.' 'I have been blessed to watch the Lord do amazing things at MH-MA, and I now look forward to being a part of a great Catholic community at Bishop Miege and seeing what God has in store,' he said. In the note, VonWyl said the primary focus of the school's leadership team remained unchanged. 'The experience and expertise Mr. Baniewicz brings will undoubtedly contribute to this mission ensuring that our students continue to receive the highest quality education,' he said. In his statement Friday, McKnight said that 'In keeping with our protocols, our Office for Protection and Care is prepared and eager to listen to you, using a trauma-informed approach. Please call or text our hotline number at 913-276-8703 or visit
