&w=3840&q=100)
Karnataka HC stays GST demand of over Rs 50 cr against Mad Over Donuts
The Karnataka High Court (HC) will ponder over it and take a call in the next few days as it stayed a Goods and Services Tax (GST) demand of over ₹50 crore against the donut outlet on Friday.
Food items sold outside a restaurant setting invite 18 per cent GST, while those served in restaurants are charged 5 per cent GST.
Justice SR Krishna Kumar heard the case raising the question whether these products should be classified under restaurant services, attracting a concessional 5 per cent GST rate, or as bakery goods, which might attract a different tax treatment. A copy of the order was uploaded on Monday.
Himesh Foods ('Mad Over Donuts'), represented by Advocate Abhishek A Rastogi, told the court that the supply of food products like donuts and cakes constitute a composite supply of services, as defined under the CGST Act.
They said that the provision of food at restaurants, eateries, canteens, and messes -- whether consumed on-premises or taken away -- fall under the category of restaurant services, which are taxed at a lower GST rate of 5%.
They also referred to a recent interim order of the Bombay High Court, which said that such supplies could be considered services under GST law.
The Karnataka High Court said that since there was a prior undertaking by the tax authorities before the Bombay High Court, assuring that no coercive action would be taken while the classification issue was under consideration, the same should be applicable here as well.
The court emphasised the importance of judicial consistency and agreed that no precipitative or coercive measures could be pursued by Karnataka's GST authorities during the pendency of the case.
The next date of hearing is now on June 6.
"… in the light of the undertaking given by the respondents (tax authorities) in relation to the very same petitioner ('Mad Over Donuts') before the Bombay High Court, respondents are directed not to take any precipitative/coercive steps till the next date of hearing,' the order said.
Sandeep Sehgal, Partner of tax firm AKM Global, said, 'The company (Mad Over Donuts) pointed out that the Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI) in Mumbai had already issued a consolidated notice covering similar tax issues across multiple states, including Karnataka. Despite this, the Karnataka State GST authorities attempted to raise a separate demand. The court's decision to grant relief to Mad Over Donuts highlights the importance of businesses monitoring overlapping tax actions and taking prompt steps when faced with duplicate proceedings.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Andhra Pradesh tops South in GST growth for July 2025
VIJAYAWADA: Net GST collections in Andhra Pradesh for July 2025 stood at Rs 2,930 crore, the highest ever for the month since the introduction of the GST regime in 2017. This reflects a 12.12% increase over July 2024, signalling stronger tax compliance and effective administration. According to a release from Chief Commissioner of State Tax Babu A on Friday, gross GST collections also grew by 14% year-on-year in July 2025. Andhra Pradesh recorded the highest month-on-month growth rate among southern States and ranked third among all major States in the country. State GST (SGST) collections reached Rs 1,226 crore in July 2025, marking a robust 14.47% growth, attributed to improved consumption trends and intensified enforcement. The State also received Rs 1,704 crore through IGST settlement, a 10.69% increase over July 2024, indicating efficient fund transfers and monitoring. The surge in net GST collections has been credited to streamlined IGST processes, a broader tax base, and growing taxpayer compliance. These factors together continue to reinforce the State's revenue position. Total revenue collections across all sectors—including GST, VAT on petroleum products and liquor, and professional tax—reached Rs 4,493 crore in July 2025, compared to Rs 4,044 crore in July 2024, reflecting an 11.11% growth. Cumulatively, for the FY up to July 2025, overall collections touched Rs 17,854 crore, up from Rs 17,410 crore during the same period last year, indicating a 4.16% growth.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Volvo India's gear shift: Changes EV-only plan; ICE models to stay amid slow uptake
Volvo Cars India has revised its earlier strategy of transitioning to an all-electric portfolio, opting instead to continue selling both electric and internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles in the country. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now currently account for around 25% of Volvo's sales in India. However, the market for premium battery electric vehicles (BEVs) remains small, although the company notes signs of recovery in the last six months following a slump a year ago. The decision comes after companies' previous claims to phase out ICE models entirely. Volvo Cars India, managing director Jyoti Malhotra, speaking to Economic Times, said 'The adoption rate (of electric vehicles) is different in different countries. And even within the country (in India), it's different across states.' 'We will continue to drive in electric cars and have a launch lined up later this year itself. But at the same time, we will continue to focus on ICE,' he added. Volvo had announced plans to go fully electric by 2030 globally, but the timelines have now been extended. 'About a year back, EVs had started losing steam. We are seeing some uptick in the segment in the last six months. But customer needs are different across regions,' said Malhotra. He pointed out that state policies and infrastructure play a pivotal role in EV adoption. States like Kerala, Maharashtra, and Delhi have favourable tax regimes and more low-rise housing, are seeing better uptake, compared to cities dominated by high-rises, where home charging is a challenge. India currently levies a Goods and Services Tax (GST) of 5% on EVs, while hybrids attract a much steeper 43%. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Volvo offers plug-in hybrids in international markets, but Malhotra clarified that Indian launches would depend on more favourable tax regime. The company is preparing to introduce a new electric model later this year but will simultaneously retain focus on ICE vehicles to cater to diverse market needs. Volvo's shift aligns with similar moves by global peers such as Jaguar Land Rover and Mercedes-Benz, who are reassessing their timelines for a fully electric portfolio amid similar market realities. Industry data shows that around 22,900 luxury vehicles were sold in the first half of 2025, marking a modest 1.8% increase year-on-year. He also welcomed India's ongoing negotiations around Free Trade Agreements (FTAs), noting their potential to boost the auto sector. 'The UK FTA has set a benchmark. While the one with the EU is still some time away, free trade agreements are good for the economy,' he said.
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Volvo shifts gears, to offer both EVs & ICE models in India
Volvo Cars will continue to introduce both electric and internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles in India, pivoting its earlier strategy of going all-electric amid slow customer adoption of battery electric vehicles (BEVs). The Swedish luxury carmaker had last year said it will henceforth sell only electric vehicles in India in its bid to have an all-electric portfolio by the turn of the decade. Volvo's strategy mirrors those of other global car makers like Jaguar Land Rover, and Mercedes Benz who are revising plans to have an all-electric product range. Speaking to ET, Jyoti Malhotra, managing director at Volvo Cars India said, globally too while the company intends to go all electric, timelines have now been pushed beyond 2030. 'The adoption rate (of electric vehicles) is different in different countries. And even within the country (in India), it's different across states,' said Malhotra. He said government policies are crucial in deepening EV penetration in India, with states that have waived off road taxes seeing higher adoption rates among customers. 'We will continue to drive in electric cars and have a launch lined up later this year itself. But at the same time, we will continue to focus on ICE,' said Malhotra. EVs currently contribute about 25 per cent of Volvo's sales in India. The market for such eco-friendly luxury cars is however still small though it is growing, according to the company. 'About a year back, EVs had started losing steam. We are seeing some uptick in the segment in the last six months. But customer needs are different across regions,' said Malhotra. 'Home charging is extremely important for customer comfort when it comes to owning EVs. In cities, where there are high-rises, charging electric cars is challenging,' he said, adding Volvo is seeing stronger EV adoption in states like Kerala, Maharashtra, and Delhi where there are low-rises and state policies are conducive. He was speaking on the sidelines of the launch of the XC60 SUV model. Globally, Volvo does have plug-in hybrids in its portfolio, but Malhotra said the company will only consider launching them in India if the tax structures are more conducive. India currently levies a Goods and Services Tax (GST) rate of 5 per cent on EVs, and 43 per cent on hybrids. Overall, Malhotra said luxury car sales in India, which had been outpacing the broader car market in the last few years, slowed in the first half of 2025 as volatile stock markets, and mounting geopolitical tensions hit demand among the country's rich, aspirational buyers. He however added that Volvo is on track to meet its sales target for this calendar year though industry growth is likely to be muted. Per industry estimates, around 22,900 luxury cars were sold in the first half of 2025, a 1.8 per cent rise from a year earlier. Separately, Malhotra termed free trade agreements being inked or negotiated by the Indian government as a step in the right direction, which will help to grow the auto industry in the long run. 'The UK FTA has set a benchmark. While the one with the EU is still some time away, free trade agreements are good for the economy. India is seen as a market with growth potential. If any company were to invest in India today, they will only consider the scale available in the market here. With FTAs, the scale changes immediately as they open up access to many more markets globally,' he said, adding Volvo can also explore possibilities for expanding its footprint in India once the EU trade deal is finalised.
