logo
Bumble Bee sued by deep-sea crew who say they were forced into ‘fishing boat slavery'

Bumble Bee sued by deep-sea crew who say they were forced into ‘fishing boat slavery'

CNN22-03-2025

Muhammad Syafi'i remembers screaming in pain as hot cooking oil splashed across his stomach and dripped down his legs, his wet clothing sticking to his torched skin as it began to bubble and swell.
Like many poor Indonesian men, he had signed up to work abroad in the fishing industry, where wages are higher than back home. He was hired to work in 2021 as a cook on a ship which supplied fish to Bumble Bee Foods, one of the biggest tuna importers in the United States.
But when he got there, he says he was physically abused and forced to work in dangerous and demanding conditions. And when Syafi'i was seriously burned while working in the kitchen, he claims he was left writhing in pain on a bench and denied food, water and access to medical care.
Syafi'i's account is detailed in a new landmark lawsuit filed by four Indonesian fishermen against Bumble Bee Foods. It alleges the tuna giant 'knowingly benefitted' from forced labor, debt bondage and other forms of abuse in its supply chain.
In a statement provided to CNN, Bumble Bee Seafoods said it became aware of the filing last Wednesday and will not be commenting on pending litigation. The allegations have not been tested in court.
The four plaintiffs worked on three different fishing vessels which supplied tuna to Bumble Bee, according to the legal complaint, which was filed on March 12 in federal court in California. While at sea, the men say they were physically abused and held against their will.
This is the first known case of fishing boat slavery brought against a US seafood company, Agnieszka Fryszman, one of the attorneys for the plaintiffs, told CNN.
'Fishing vessels never really have to go port, so the men are really, really stuck. It makes it very easy to engage in forced labor and trafficking,' Fryszman said.
Human rights abuses in the fishing industry are well documented but accountability is rare. The industry is notoriously opaque because of its reliance on migrant workers, the complicated nature of global supply chains and the fact that the work occurs at sea, where workers are typically excluded from land-based labor laws.
Campaigners have long argued that US companies need to do more to ensure their supply chains are free from abuse.
'These are people who wanted to work to give their families a better life. We, as Americans are eating this tuna. We are eating the seafood that is produced off the backs of these abuses,' said Sari Heidenrich, a senior human rights advisor in the global fisheries unit for Greenpeace, which is also representing the plaintiffs.
Bumble Bee is one of the oldest canned seafood companies in the US and holds the country's largest market share for canned and pouched tuna, according to the Seafood Stewardship Index. The global tuna fishing industry is estimated to be worth about $40 billion, according to Pew Trusts.
In 2019, the company filed for bankruptcy amid a price-fixing scandal and was acquired by Taiwanese fish conglomerate FCF Co for nearly $1 billion.
The fishermen claim Bumble Bee violated US human trafficking laws by importing seafood that was caught using forced labor.
Like many migrant workers in the industry, the four were hired by recruiting firms which withheld large portions of their salaries as repayment for administrative costs in a practice known as debt bondage, leaving them with little to no pay, the lawsuit says. They were threatened with large fines if they quit.
The vessels would stay at sea for months, with supply ships coming to deliver fuel and retrieve the ship's catch – a common process in deep-sea fishing known as transshipment – leaving the men isolated and cut off from help. At times the men organized strikes to pressure their captains to let them off the ship, but they were not permitted to leave, they allege.
Fryszman said the lawyers for the plaintiffs were able to link Bumble Bee's canned tuna to the ships the men worked on through the company's own 'Trace My Catch' tool, which allows consumers to see which vessel their fish was caught by.
After Syafi'i's accident, he was forced to return to work, despite asking to leave almost every day, according to the complaint. He wore a sarong to work because putting on trousers hurt his burns. His captain beat him regularly, Syafi'i alleged.
Muhammad Sahrudin, one of the other plaintiffs, said the captain of his ship hit and lashed crew members, and stabbed them with needles. He said he was beaten so many times he lost count.
Akhmad, another plaintiff who like many Indonesians uses one name, said he was forced to continue working after a load of fish fell on his leg, gashing it through to the bone and filling his boot with blood.
Angga, who also goes by one name, said the workers were fed so little that they often resorted to eating the fishing bait.
The fishermen's claims echo the stories of other migrant workers in the seafood industry, experts say.
'Forced labor is not a one off. It's not a bug,' said Jessica Sparks, assistant professor in the division of agriculture, food and environment at Tufts University. 'It's a feature of the system.'
A 2022 report by the International Labour Organization found about 128,000 workers were trapped in forced labor aboard fishing vessels, a figure that was likely to be a severe undercount, according to the report's authors.
This case 'exemplifies the exact problem that we know is endemic in the fishing industry, because you have vulnerable people who have been recruited, who have been abused on a fishing vessel that's flagged to a country that doesn't really hold any responsibility,' said Natalie Klein, a professor of international law at the University of New South Wales.
Extensive reports on human rights abuses in the fishing industry by NGOs, international media outlets and governments, including the US State Department, have put pressure on seafood companies to take ownership over their supply chains, including the conditions on the ships which catch their fish.
Bumble Bee declares on its website that it is committed to 'environmental sustainability and social responsibility' and that the company 'addresses the health and safety of workers throughout our supply chain.'
But the lawsuit alleges Bumble Bee was aware of abuses in its supply chain and has not taken crucial steps to prevent human trafficking.
The Seafood Stewardship Index, which measures the sustainability and social practices of the world's leading seafood companies, gave Bumble Bee a score of 1.27 out of 5, noting that the company 'lacks evidence of an approach to addressing any adverse human rights impacts.'
The fishermen are seeking monetary damages for the harm they have suffered, according to the complaint. They are also asking that Bumble Bee implement and enforce several new policies to promote worker safety, such as banning transshipment and the use of recruitment agencies, requiring medical equipment on board and ensuring that ships have WiFi.
In 2020, the US halted imports from a Taiwan-based fishing vessel that reportedly supplied tuna to Bumble Bee because of human rights concerns, the Associated Press reported. A 2022 report by Greenpeace separately linked Bumble Bee tuna to Taiwanese fishing vessels that used forced labor.
Last year, Bumble Bee agreed to remove claims of a 'fair and safe supply chain' and 'fair and responsible working conditions' from its website, social media and other advertising as part of a settlement with Global Labor Justice-International Labor Rights Forum.
In a 2021 interview with Seafood Source, Leslie Hushka, Bumble Bee's senior vice president of global corporate and social responsibility, called worker abuses on fishing vessels 'an industry-wide challenge.'
'There are some real challenges in this industry just in terms of complexity, but we've tried to put in place a number of systems where we can consistently work with our fleets and seek improvements in all of their practices,' Hushka said.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

10 killed in Austrian school shooting: A rare event for the country
10 killed in Austrian school shooting: A rare event for the country

Yahoo

time38 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

10 killed in Austrian school shooting: A rare event for the country

10 people, including teenagers, were killed after a shooter opened fire at a high school in Austria on Tuesday. The shooting was one of the worst in the country's history. According to CNN, at first Austrian police said eight people were killed and then the number was raised to nine. Gerhard Karner, the country's interior minister, said that six of the victims were female and three were male. The victims also included children between 14 and 18 years old. Later in the day the Graz Regional Hospital said that a woman who was wounded in the attack died of her injuries, per NBC. There were 12 students also injured in the shooting, some of them seriously. During a press conference following the shooting, Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker described Tuesday as a 'dark day in the history of our country.' 'There are no words to express the pain, disbelief and grief felt by the whole of Austria. Our country stands still in this moment of horror,' Stocker added. The country of Austria will be holding a period of mourning over the next three days to pay respect to the victims. A minute of silence will be held on Wednesday and the flag will be flown at half-staff at all public buildings, per The Washington Post. The incident occurred at the Bundesoberstufenrealgymnasium Dreierschützengasse school in Graz, Austria's second largest city. Police first responded to reports of 'several' suspected gunshots at the school around 10 a.m. local time. Several vehicles, ambulance, a police helicopter and a special task force were deployed to the scene, per NBC. Over 300 police officers were sent to the scene to ensure an evacuation and cordon off the school. The injured students were taken to nearby hospitals for treatment, per The Washington Post. The lone suspect in the shooting was identified as a 21-year-old Austrian male who had previously attended the school but did not graduate. He carried out the killing spree using a rifle and a handgun before fatally shooting himself in a bathroom, per CNN. 'According to the current state of the investigation, the alleged perpetrator committed suicide in a toilet facility,' said Gerald Ortner, director of the police for the state of Styria. Officials did not give a motive for the gunman, but they did share that he acted alone and they believe he obtained the weapons legally. Austria has a low prevalence of gun violence and school shootings are uncommon, per The Washington Post. Not including Tuesday's attack, Austria has had two public mass shootings since 2000, neither of which occurred at a school. The U.S. has had 119 in the same time period. According to The Washington Post, the Regional Gun Violence Research Consortium at the Rockefeller Institute of Government defines a public mass shooting as those that take place 'in a public or populated location' in which at least four people were killed and some victims 'were targeted at random and/or for their symbolic value.' The country's most recent mass shooting was in 2020, when a man killed four people in Vienna, before being fatally shot by police. Credit for the attack was claimed by The Islamic State.

US teacher seized by Russia is located in prison
US teacher seized by Russia is located in prison

Boston Globe

time44 minutes ago

  • Boston Globe

US teacher seized by Russia is located in prison

Hubbard, 73, was accused of manning a checkpoint and fighting for Ukraine, and then convicted by Russia of being a mercenary in October and sentenced to almost seven years in a penal colony. After that, Hubbard's family was not able to find him in Russia's prison system. In a highly unusual move, the Russian judge removed his case file, including even basic information like his lawyer's name, from public view. Advertisement Documents reviewed by The New York Times show that Hubbard is being held in the IK-12 penal colony in Mordovia, the southwestern Russian region commonly referred to as 'prison land.' In addition, sentencing documents reviewed by the Times, which have not been previously reported, outline the Russian case against Hubbard and its contention that he was fighting for Ukraine. Recent interviews with one of Hubbard's sons and others, as well as text messages he exchanged with that son, contradict the Russian narrative. Advertisement Martin De Luca, a lawyer for Hubbard, said his team had talked to him three times since April. On May 28, Hubbard was allowed to call another son, who lives in Cyprus, according to De Luca and Hubbard's sister. 'He's had a rough 3½ years,' De Luca said. Ukrainian prisoners of war who were held with Hubbard told the Times that he had been repeatedly tortured because he was an American — beaten, forced to stand all day, given little food and poor medical care. In interviews after being released, the Ukrainians said they feared for his life. He is the only American known to have been taken from Ukraine and then jailed in Russia. Russia's Foreign Ministry did not respond to a request for comment. So far, the Russian government has made no official statement on Hubbard. US officials have raised Hubbard's imprisonment with Russian officials and asked that he be immediately released, a US official recently said. The US Embassy in Moscow has not been granted access to Hubbard, the official said, despite Russia's obligation under international law to do so. The official spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the negotiations. In a May 19 phone call, President Trump and President Vladimir Putin of Russia discussed a new potential prisoner exchange, according to Russian news agencies citing Yuri Ushakov, a Kremlin aide. Ushakov told reporters that the two leaders had agreed to prepare a humanitarian prisoner exchange of nine people from each side, calling it 'an important humanitarian action.' The United States has accused Russia of inflating and inventing criminal charges against Americans so they can be traded for Russians held elsewhere or used as international bargaining chips. Advertisement Hubbard grew up in Michigan, served in the Air Force in California, married young, and later divorced. He then married a Japanese woman he met in Washington state and moved to Japan, where he taught English. Eventually, the couple divorced. In 2012, Hubbard retired to Cyprus, the home of Joseph Coleman, a son from his first marriage. That is where Hubbard met a Ukrainian woman named Inna, following her to the eastern city of Izium. He earned money by teaching English to a few Japanese students online. Hubbard was alone at home when the Russians launched their Feb. 24, 2022, full-scale invasion. 'He was, in hindsight, too optimistic, I suppose,' said Hisashi Tanaka, 36, Hubbard's son from his second marriage, in a recent interview. 'He was going to wait it out. He thought he wouldn't get into too much trouble considering his age and being a civilian.' The day the war started, Hubbard didn't seem to be initially aware of what was happening, his son said. 'Don't get caught in the crossfires!' Tanaka, who lives in Japan, wrote him on Skype. 'I suppose that I should read the news,' responded Hubbard, who had just celebrated his 70th birthday. 'It is peaceful here, so far.' The Russians say Hubbard signed up the next day for the regional territorial defense unit at a recruitment center at a kindergarten in Izium to earn at least $1,000 a month, according to the sentencing documents reviewed by the Times. The documents claim Hubbard told recruiters he felt healthier than many younger people. 'In fact, Hubbard looked sporty and very fit for his age,' the documents say. Advertisement The Russians said Hubbard was then trained in combat and how to handle weapons and explosive devices. The documents say he was given the call signs — nicknames — 'Samurai' and 'Ninja,' and that he manned a checkpoint on a bridge over a river. The Russians also contend that Hubbard stopped working for the territorial defense unit after a few weeks because he feared for his life and that they arrested him inside the home of an acquaintance in April 2022. But messages between Hubbard and Tanaka in Japan, first on Skype and then through texts on the phones of acquaintances of Hubbard, show no evidence of Hubbard signing up for the military. He repeatedly told his son that all was well.

With reporters shot and roughed up, advocates question whether those covering protests are targets
With reporters shot and roughed up, advocates question whether those covering protests are targets

Washington Post

timean hour ago

  • Washington Post

With reporters shot and roughed up, advocates question whether those covering protests are targets

More than two dozen journalists have been injured or roughed up while covering protests against immigration raids in Los Angeles, leading press freedom groups to question whether law enforcement has been deliberately targeting reporters on the story. Journalists have been pelted with rubber bullets or pepper spray, including an Australian TV reporter struck while doing a live shot and a New York Post reporter left with a giant welt on his forehead after taking a direct hit. A CNN crew was briefly detained then released on Monday night. The advocacy group Reporters Without Borders said there have been at least 27 attacks on journalists — 24 from law enforcement — since the demonstrations started. The Committee to Protect Journalists, the First Amendment Coalition and Freedom of the Press Foundation were among the groups to express concern to Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem. In a letter, they said 'federal officers appear to have deliberately targeted journalists who were doing nothing more than their job covering the news.' Noem hasn't replied, David Loy, legal director of the First Amendment Coalition, said Tuesday. A Noem spokesperson didn't have an immediate comment for The Associated Press. Experts say the apparent hostility toward journalists, or a disregard for their role and safety, became particularly apparent during demonstrations following the death of George Floyd in 2020. A troubling indication of a decline in press freedom is the rapid escalation of threats journalists face in the United States, said Bruce Shapiro, executive director of the Dart Center for Journalism and Trauma at Columbia University. While most journalists covering wars receive training and safety equipment, it is apparent that many — particularly freelancers — don't have similar protection when assigned to events like the Los Angeles demonstrations, he said. 'It's not like covering a war zone,' Shapiro said. 'But there are some very specific skills and strategies that people need to employ. The First Amendment is only as strong as the safety of the journalists covering these events.' On Sunday, Australian journalist Lauren Tomasi was shot in the leg by a rubber bullet while reporting live, with a microphone in her hand, from protests in downtown Los Angeles. Widely circulated video shows her crying out in pain and clutching her lower leg as she and her camera operator quickly move away from a police line. She told 9News later that she was safe and unharmed. New York Post photographer Toby Canham was overlooking the 101 freeway when he was hit. He spent Monday in the hospital with whiplash and neck pain, and left with a red mark on his forehead. Shortly before he was shot, he said he saw someone throwing a water bottle with liquid at authorities. 'I completely understand being in the position where you could get injured,' Canham said. 'But at the same time, there was no justification for even aiming the rifle at me and pulling the trigger, so I'm a bit pissed off about that, to be honest.' Ben Camacho, a reporter at the local news website The Southlander, reported being shot twice. 'Unsure of what hit me both times but they hit like a sledgehammer and without immediate warning,' he wrote online. 'Elbow is wrapped with gauze and knee is weak.' Photojournalist Nick Stern was standing near some people waving a Mexican flags when he was shot in the thigh. He later had emergency surgery. 'I thought it was a live round because of the sheer intensity of the pain,' he told the AP. 'Then I passed out from the pain.' Lexis Olivier-Ray of L.A. Taco, an alternative independent media platform, thought he was safely positioned with some television crews but instead had pepper balls shot at him. Some reporters may have taken less care: one posted a clip from film he shot about 10 yards (9.1 meters) from a police officer with a rifle pointed at him. Not all of the incidents involved law enforcement. AP photographer Jae Hong was kicked and hit with sticks by protesters on Monday, his protective gear enabling him to escape injury. A Los Angeles TV reporter and her crew were forced away by demonstrators, one loudly yelling, 'get out of here.' CNN aired video of its correspondent, Jason Carroll, and his crew with their hands behind their backs being led away from a protest by officers. They were later released. In many past conflicts, journalists had a measure of protection because opposing sides wanted them to record their side of the stories, Shapiro said. Now many journalists are seen as superfluous by people who have other ways of delivering their messages, or a target by those who want to spread fear, he said. It illustrates the importance of proper training and protection, he said. For reporters in the middle of the story now, they should plan carefully — being aware of exit routes and safe zones, working in tandem with others and in constant communication with their newsrooms. 'We need everyone from major news outlets to television to citizen journalists,' he said. 'We need them on the street. But we need them to be safe.' ___ AP correspondent Jake Offenhartz in Los Angeles contributed to this report. David Bauder writes about the intersection of media and entertainment for the AP. Follow him at and

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store