Britain and its people are not safe, former Nato chief warns Parliament
He told the upper chamber: 'Bearing in mind the difficult world that we live in and have to survive in, this is what I firmly believe: we are underinsured, we are underprepared, we are not safe.
'This country and its people are not safe.
'The British people are faced with a world in turmoil, with great power competitions spilling over now into conflict, with constant grey zone attacks on our mainland, and with Russia – often with the co-operation of Iran, China and North Korea – challenging the existing world order.
'We simply in this country are not safe.'
The Labour peer wrote the review alongside the former commander of the joint forces command, General Sir Richard Barrons, and defence adviser Dr Fiona Hill.
Artificial intelligence, drones and a £1 billion investment in homeland missile defence all form part of the review's plan to keep the UK safe in the face of threats from Vladimir Putin's Russia and the rise of China.
As peers debated the review on Friday, Lord Robertson said: 'When we say in the report that we are unprepared, it is an understatement.
'We don't have the ammunition, the training, the people, the spare parts, the logistics, and we don't have the medical capacity to deal with the mass casualties that we would face if we were involved in high-intensity warfare.
'Over the years, and I suppose I must plead guilty to that as well, we took a substantial peace dividend, because we all believed that the world had changed for the better.'
He continued: 'Sadly, we were not alone in that. There may have been over-optimism, but at worst, wishful thinking, but the brutal, full-scale invasion of Ukraine by Putin's Russia three years ago was a savage wake-up call for all of us.
'This world we now live in has changed out of all recognition, and we have got to change as well.'
Lord Robertson told the upper chamber he is 'confident' the review will 'intimidate our enemies, inspire our friends, invigorate our defence industry, and make our country safer'.
Conservative shadow defence minister Baroness Goldie pressed the Government to be specific about the amount of money and timing needed for defence spending to reach 3% of GDP.
She said: 'In this exciting and brave new world for defence, the elephant in the room is money, and none of this excellent aspiration proposed by the review means anything without attaching pound signs to the proposals.
'Ambition must translate into specific financial commitment.'
Former military chief Lord Stirrup said the Government's spending would need to be restructured to be 'anywhere near 3.5% of GDP for defence by 2035'.
'There is no sign of any urgency on any side of the political divide on addressing this crucial matter,' the crossbench peer added.
Former top diplomat Lord Hannay of Chiswick said forms of soft power such as overseas aid and the BBC World Service should be prioritised alongside hard power.
'We really do need to take another look at the hard power soft power balance, recognising that we need them both,' the crossbench peer said.
Conservative former defence minister Lord Soames of Fletchling said the British people needed to be told what they should do in the event of a cyber attack that knocked out the internet and phone networks.
Lord Soames, who is the grandson of Second World War prime minister Sir Winston Churchill, called for the public to have food stocks at home.
He said: 'I believe that unless the public has some idea of the sense of urgency, the only way really to wake people up is to establish either a minister or ministry of civil defence, charged with training millions of people how to respond to an attack.'
Meanwhile, Tory peer Lord Harlech, who is a reservist, said the Government needed to pay more attention to the Territorial Army and other reserve forces.
He said: 'For too long, we have treated reserves as an afterthought. A just-in-case solution. Too often called on at short notice, handed out outdated kit, sidelined from training opportunities and then expected to deliver at the same standard as regulars.
'If we are to rely more heavily on the reserves, as the review suggests, then we must be honest about what that actually requires.
'It means giving them the same standard of equipment, no more trickle-down hand-me-downs. It means equal access to courses and training opportunities.
'Too often, reserves find themselves bumped off areas by cadets or even airsoft groups. That is not how a serious military trains.'
Labour's Baroness Goudie criticised the review for failing to mention gender, adding: 'The exclusion of women from peace process does not lead to stability. It leads to a relapse.'
Defence minister Lord Coaker said: 'We're debating things that we never thought we'd be debating again, about war in Europe and also about the threats to the homeland with respect to attacks on it.'
He added that the Government has committed to spend 5% of GDP on national security by 2035, alongside its Nato allies, but conceded 'the trajectory to get to that will need to be thought through'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
42 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Cut red tape hindering marine restoration to boost coastal towns
The group, which includes dozens of Tory MPs, called for regulation to be streamlined for projects such as the Solent Seascape Project, an initiative to restore saltmarsh, seagrass, oyster reefs, and seabird nesting sites between the Isle of Wight and mainland England. Shadow environment secretary Victoria Atkins backed the report, calling it a 'valuable conservative contribution for consideration in our ongoing policy renewal programme'. Victoria Atkins welcomed the report (PA) 'Britain's once-buzzing seaside towns are facing growing economic and environmental pressures. The Conservatives are determined to set out a plan to protect our coastal communities and preserve them for future generations,' she said. She added: 'Needless red tape continues to hamstring investment into marine restoration projects that could bring coastal communities jobs, nature-abundant habitats, and protection against the growing threats of climate change.' The network is also calling on Labour to use the flood defences budget to fund more nature-based solutions and to designate more highly protected marine areas in English waters to protect against practices like bottom trawling, in which fishing gear is dragged across the seabed destroying habitats and scooping up a wide array of species. They also want the Government to publish blue carbon codes – frameworks that define how carbon stored in marine habitats like seagrass and saltmarsh can be measured, verified and sold as credits – to unlock more funding for coastal resilience. They say these moves will boost nature recovery as well as local economies through nature tourism and job creation as more projects could get off the ground. Some 67% of English coastal towns are in the Office for National Statistics higher deprivation category and 3,500 properties are in areas at risk from coastal erosion. Kitty Thompson, head of campaigns at CEN, said offering solutions for coastal communities could also help the Conservatives challenge Nigel Farage's Reform UK. 'The teal tide is not inevitable. Reform offers an easy outlet of anger for many coastal towns who have watched their neighbourhoods fade. 'But they won't give these communities the solutions they deserve. If the Conservatives offer a pragmatic, credible alternative that can deliver for coastal communities, then they can challenge Reform in coastal target seats, stopping them in their tracks,' she said. Jacques Villemot, marine rewilding lead for Rewilding Britain, said the current marine licensing framework is outdated and called for the application process for projects to be streamlined. 'This framework urgently needs to be updated to support marine rewilding projects. Though necessary, in its current format marine licensing acts as a blocker, a laborious and costly process which was designed for approving developments like huge oil rigs and large wind farms,' he said.
STV News
an hour ago
- STV News
Musicians head to Berlin as part of 'Brand Scotland' trade mission
Young Scottish musicians will perform in Berlin this week as part of a UK Government effort to promote Scottish culture and attract international investment. Members of the National Youth Orchestra of Scotland (NYOS) and their guest soloist, Ryan Corbett, will perform at a business and government breakfast event at the British Ambassador's residence, hosted by Scottish secretary Iain Murray and UK's ambassador to Germany, Andrew Mitchell. The event, dubbed 'Symphony and Sausages', will see guests served smoked salmon, haggis, black pudding and homemade potato scones while showcasing Scottish music. It comes as part of efforts by the Scotland Office to boost 'Brand Scotland', promoting Scottish produce and culture in a bid to help economic growth. UK Government/Lauren Hurley Secretary for Scotland Ian Murray Murray said: 'Scotland's cultural excellence is one of our greatest assets in attracting international investment and driving economic growth. The National Youth Orchestra of Scotland represents some of our most extraordinary musical talent. I'm delighted that they are able to join me in Berlin, and this performance will demonstrate Scottish culture at its finest. 'My 'Brand Scotland' campaign is about selling all that is fantastic about Scotland to the world, to encourage both exports and inward investment in Scotland, and I'm very pleased that we have been able to fund this event in Berlin.' Brand Scotland is a key part of the UK Government's Plan for Change, bringing real rewards for people in Scotland.' The visit is part of Murray's 'Brand Scotland' trade mission to 'sell the best of Scotland to the world', forming part of the UK Government's Plan For Change. The orchestra is in Berlin to perform at the Young Euro Classic festival, premiering a new accordion concerto by Scottish composer Jay Capperauld under the baton of Catherine Larsen-Maguire. During his two-day trip, Murray will also meet German officials, including Michael Meister, Minister of State for Federal-State Relations, and representatives from Germany's 16 federal states. The breakfast is funded by a £2,700 grant from the Scotland Office's Brand Scotland fund, part of a wider UK Government programme to boost Scotland's trading relationship with Europe. Murray's visit follows the signing of a new UK-Germany treaty and comes ahead of a speech in Edinburgh where he will outline the role of Scottish culture in economic growth. The minister is also set to travel to India and Sweden as part of the 'Brand Scotland' initiative. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Former councillor killed on road he tried to make safer
A former Labour councillor has been killed in a car crash on a road he campaigned to make safer. John Michael Duggan, 81, died in hospital after his car collided with a skip lorry on Aug 1 as he tried to join the A19 in North Yorkshire. The former Selby district councillor was taken to Leeds General Infirmary by air ambulance but was pronounced dead a short time later. The lorry driver, a 42-year-old man from York, was arrested at the scene and was assisting officers with enquiries, according to North Yorkshire Police. Mr Duggan had previously highlighted the junction on York Rd, which connects the village of Riccall with the major road, as one of several seriously dangerous intersections along the A19. Campaigner appealed for roundabout As a parish councillor for Riccall, he told the York Press newspaper in 2007 he was 'gravely concerned' about the safety of local drivers following a number of accidents, including fatal ones. He said: 'The stretch of the A19 that runs past Riccall is one of the fastest sections of the road, and the speed of traffic using this section is totally unacceptable to local people who are trying to enter and exit the village.' Mr Duggan had called for a roundabout to be built in the area and presented plans for one to North Yorkshire County Council. Steve Shaw-Wright, the Labour leader of Selby town council, said it was 'tragically ironic' that Mr Duggan died on a stretch of road he campaigned to make safer. 'John was one who would campaign for what he believed to be right for his community, whether that was within the bounds of his political group or outside. John was very determined to support what people needed in his community,' he told ITV. 'He campaigned for the roundabout to get access and ingress from Riccall for a long, long time, it's tragically ironic that that was the place where he lost his life.' 'Tragedy makes need for improvement clear' Keir Mather, the Labour MP for Selby, said the death of Mr Duggan, who was formerly a senior representative for the Unite union, highlighted the need for road safety improvements in the area. 'John was a well-known and much-loved local man, a father, uncle and a grandfather,' he said. 'He was known too for his time as a union convenor, a Selby district and North Yorkshire county councillor and, perhaps most poignantly, as a campaigner for better road safety in Riccall. 'This tragedy makes awfully clear the need for road safety improvements at both A19 junctions in Riccall.' Mr Mather said he would press North Yorkshire council to reconsider introducing a roundabout 'or at the very least a speed reduction' on the stretch of the A19. National Highways brought in a temporary speed limit of 50mph on part of the A19 in Teesside last year after a series of collisions. The A19 runs from Seaton Burn, north of Newcastle, to just north of Doncaster, and has a 70mph speed limit for cars for much of its length.
