Bill to outlaw sex for rent and give gardaí power to remove protesters' masks approved by government
JUSTICE MINISTER JIM O'Callaghan has received Cabinet approval for legislation that includes the criminalisation of sex-for-rent arrangements, as well as measures that will impact sexual assault trials and the wearing of masks at protests.
The General Scheme of the Criminal Law and Civil Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2025 will now be referred to the Justice Committee for pre-legislative scrutiny, the Department of Justice said.
Once the Committee's report is received by Cabinet, 'work on finalising the Bill will be prioritised', the Department said in a statement.
Sex for rent
The proposed legislation would introduce two specific criminal offences concerning sex for rent.
Those offences will be offering accommodation in exchange for sex and the advertising of accommodation in exchange for sex. There will be no need for complainants to prove that sexual activity has occurred and the proposed penalty is a fine of €5,000.
The Department said the provisions would cover both rental agreements between landlords and tenants, and 'rent-a-room' situations.
'Any attempt by accommodation providers to exploit their position and prey on vulnerable individuals through these arrangements is completely unacceptable,' O'Callaghan said in a statement.
He described such arrangements as 'an appalling abuse of power by unscrupulous individuals'.
While O'Callaghan said this was 'a complex issue to legislate for' he insisted that car had been taken 'to ensure that the offences are clear, precise and limited in scope'.
'I am satisfied the provisions are workable and constitutionally sound, and do not create any unintended consequences such as inadvertently criminalising consensual relationships.'
Counsellor notes
Another element of the proposed legislation is an amendment that would affect the disclosure of counselling notes in cases involving sexual assault.
As it stands, notes from the counselling sessions of survivors of sexual assault can be released to the defence in pre-trial disclosures if the court deems the content materially relevant to the case.
'I am fully aware of the distress and re-victimisation that disclosure of counselling records can have on complainants in sexual assault trials,' O'Callaghan said.
Advertisement
He said that reforms to the law made in 2017 have 'not operated as intended'.
'I am therefore proposing to amend the existing legislation by requiring that a disclosure hearing takes place in all cases and removing the provision that allows for this step to be waived,' O'Callaghan said.
He also noted that complainants have described feeling compelled to waive disclosure hearings because 'they don't want to risk a successful prosecution or delay a trial'.
'This amendment will ensure that the original intention of the legislation will apply,' said O'Callaghan.
'However, I am continuing to look at how we might further limit release of these records as I recognise that disclosure hearings can be extremely difficult for complainants.'
Masks
The Bill will also give gardaí the power to require people to remove a face covering when they reasonably expect that it is being worn in order to intimidate or conceal a person's identity when intending to commit a crime.
The Department said this will serve as 'a deterrent against disorderly conduct and intimidation at protests and in other public places'.
The proposal has been criticised by People Before Profit and the Irish Council for Civil Liberties.
TD Paul Murphy called it a 'worrying threat to the right of people to privacy, and their right to protest'.
'While people have the right to protest and that right must be respected, it is subject to the rights of others in our community,' O'Callaghan said, adding that striking that balance was a complex task for gardaí.
'It has become apparent that some protesters are covering their faces in an obvious effort to alarm and intimidate individuals in various scenarios or to avoid detection when committing a criminal offence.'
Murphy said: 'We are seeing a general push against the right to privacy and the right to protest in the EU and elsewhere.
Murphy said this was 'Black Mirror type stuff', and pointed to 'the German state criminalising protesters for speaking as Gaeilge', and the growing use of technology like AI and facial recognition to monitor ordinary citizens engaging in demonstrations.
'Protesters are not criminals and should not be treated as such. They have the right to wear a protective mask, scarf, religious face covering or sun-glasses without facing the threat of criminal charges.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
12 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Government 'going backwards' as 42 bodies not covered by ethics legislation
The Government has been accused of "going backwards" after it was revealed that 42 public bodies are not covered by ethics legislation more than two years after a review into the issue. An update of the ethics in public office legislation was promised in the programme for government in 2020 but while a review was completed in December 2022, a bill has not been brought forward. Social Democrats deputy leader Cian O'Callaghan said the Government has no interest in undertaking reforms to strengthen legislation and has instead been giving it the "run-around" for years. In 2023, the Standards in Public Office Commission (SIPO) identified 42 public bodies that are outside of its remit, as regulations have not been updated since 2018. "Why on earth would you want some public bodies to be covered by ethics legislation and then have 42 other ones not to be? It just does not make sense," said Mr O'Callaghan. "It is setting themselves up for trouble and will cause hassle down the road. Something is going to go wrong; there is going to be a scandal in one of those 42 bodies and the Opposition are going to be on the record hammering them on why they aren't doing this. Mr O'Callaghan noted that then-minister for public expenditure Paschal Donohoe told the Dáil last year that "we are nearly done in respect of the drafting of the heads of the Bill and I hope to be in a position to bring that to Government shortly". He said the Government appears to be going backwards as the current minister, Jack Chambers, is now saying there is more work to be done and more consideration to be given. "The review by his department was concluded more than two years ago. Some of these issues have been going on for years," said Mr O'Callaghan. "How can the minister stand over that? Will he not deal with this urgently? And how is it that he is way behind where his colleague, Deputy Donohoe, was a year ago?" Jack Chambers said it is not possible at this stage to provide a specific date for publication of the scheme. Picture: Sam Boal/Collins Photos Mr Chambers said he is committed to bringing forward a general scheme but it is a complex area and there are broader operational and policy considerations to explore. "My ultimate goal is to create a fit-for-purpose and easy-to-understand ethical framework that contributes to the quality, efficacy, and transparency of our system and positively builds on the strength of our existing framework," said Mr Chambers. He said that the respective policy considerations and decision points need to be made but it is not possible at this stage to provide a specific date for when the scheme might be published. However, Mr O'Callaghan said the legislation is clearly not a priority for the Government. "Every single year, it feels like at a ministerial level and also at a department level, they are not bothered about it. It just is not a priority for them at all." Mr Chambers is the third minister for public expenditure involved since the review was first announced by Michael McGrath in 2021. At the time, Mr McGrath said he intended to bring forward proposals for legislative reform in 2022. Read More Motorcyclist dies weeks after crash that killed Garda Kevin Flatley
Sunday World
2 days ago
- Sunday World
Fed-up former gardaí reveal number one reason for leaving the force
Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan confirmed the feedback came from 39 voluntary exit interviews The woman attempted to bite a number of gardaí during the incident on Park Street. Fed-up former gardai have revealed in exit interviews their number one reason for leaving the force - they can't manage family life while pursuing a career as a cop. The revelation was made by the Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan as he released data from ex-members as to why they resigned. The two other issues have emerged: commuting and the distance between home and their assigned Garda station. The Minister confirmed the feedback came from 39 voluntary exit interviews carried out in 2024 and 60 by the end of April this year with former Garda and Garda staff members leaving. The woman attempted to bite a number of gardaí during the incident on Park Street. News in 90 Seconds - May 31st Mr O'Callaghan said, 'In 2024, 39 voluntary exit interviews were conducted among sworn Garda and Garda staff. As this is a very small sample, it is difficult to draw any firm conclusions . 'But among the issues cited by people who participated was that they found it difficult to maintain their career as a Garda while also managing their family life. "Commuting and the distance between home and the station was also a concern. 'In 2025 an exit survey was introduced to further extend the sample reached. Up to the end of April there were 60 responses. 'This survey will increase the capacity of the organisation to collate, analyse and act upon the data gathered from colleagues who have chosen to resign. 'These are still small samples but the objective is that over time it will help develop better understanding of these issues and in turn allow further adjustments where possible. 'I am aware for example that Garda management seek to locate new recruits within a reasonable commuting distance of their homes but this is not always possible to achieve in every case.' The Minister was responding to a Dail question from the Sinn Fein TD Matt Carthy. Mr O'Callaghan claimed the current rate of Garda resignations between 1-2 per cent is very low. He said this turnover rate is far below the UK level of 10 per cent, and the rest of the public sector in Ireland which is 10-20 per cent. The Minister also said resignations within the police in the United States, Canada and New Zealand are much higher than in Ireland. More than 280 gardaí have left the force within five years of joining since 2020 - 214 were male and 73 were female.
Irish Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Failed asylum seekers kept in overcrowded prisons before deportation flights
Failed asylum seekers are being held in overcrowded prisons before being put on deportation flights, Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan has confirmed. Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon has now raised concerns about more people being added to overcrowded prisons and the 'performative cruelty' of flights. On Friday, May 30, capacity in prisons across the country was at 115 per cent. Mr Gannon, who is the Soc Dems spokesman on Justice, Home Affairs and Migration, asked Minister O'Callaghan to outline the policy governing the detention of individuals pending deportation on chartered flights. The Minister confirmed that, to date this year, two charter flight operations have removed 71 people who were subject to deportation orders from the State. A further 48 were removed on commercial airlines. Some 20 people verified with the Department of Justice that they have left the State following a deportation order being issued against them. He also stated that 119 enforced deportations requiring escort have occurred so far this year, up to May 23. The Minister confirmed: 'The majority of these cases have involved periods of detention prior to Departure. 'Of the 71 people removed by charter flight, 56 were held in custody immediately prior to the flight. Any children removed were part of family groups and were not detained. 'When a person does not comply with a deportation order, they can be arrested and detained for the purposes of ensuring their deportation. 'The enforcement of deportation orders and the detention of people prior to their removal is an operational matter for the Garda National Immigration Bureau. 'Most people have been detained in Cloverhill Remand Prison or the Dóchas Centre as appropriate. People have also been detained in Cork prison, Limerick prison and Midlands prison.' On Friday, prison capacity at Cloverhill was 111 per cent. In the Dóchas Centre, the women's prison in Mountjoy, the capacity was at 127 per cent. Cork (118 per cent), Limerick men's prison (119 per cent), Limerick women's prison (141 per cent) and Midlands Prison (116 per cent) were all also overfilled, according to daily figures produced by the Irish Prison Service. Deputy Gannon told the Irish Mirror that it is 'unjust' to put failed asylum applications in these overcrowded prisons before deportation. He said: 'Our prisons are overcrowded to the point that we have recorded the highest level of deaths in the prison systems in decades. 'Adding an entirely different cohort of people into an already broken system is entirely unjust. 'These deportation flights are clearly an attempt at performative cruelty. 'For that purpose, an already broken prison system is being stretched further and the effects of that will leave a lasting impression on all of us.' Minister O'Callaghan further confirmed to Deputy Gannon that the number of deportation orders signed in 2024 increased by 180 per cent compared to 2023, rising to 2,403 from 857. He continued: 'This year, 1,816 deportation orders have been signed up to May 23 2025. 'Last year, 1,116 people departed from the State under various mechanisms (i.e. enforced deportation, voluntary return etc.), an increase of 252 per cent compared to 2023 (317). 'This year, 796 persons have had their departure confirmed through these pathways up to 23 May 2025.'
