logo
Children raised by strict parents do better at school, but is that you? Take our quiz to find out

Children raised by strict parents do better at school, but is that you? Take our quiz to find out

Telegraph6 days ago
From tiger, helicopter, snowplough and lighthouse parenting styles, to free-range, French or gentle approaches, the task of raising children has never appeared more complex.
While parents of baby boomers gave little thought to how to bring up their kids, modern families are bombarded with advice and philosophies on nurturing their youngsters in a world where rapidly evolving technology is making the job much harder.
But the raging debate about the best way to do it, fuelled by a vast industry where the parenting app market alone is estimated to be worth over £500m, could finally be settled.
A new UK study which has tracked nearly 6,000 children for more than a decade has provided solid evidence about what parenting style is associated with the best outcomes. And the answer is: 'authoritative'.
By plotting the progress of children since the age of two, the research has concluded that authoritative parenting, typified by high expectations, stricter limits on behaviour and warm relationships, is more likely to yield higher academic scores and better wellbeing.
Researchers at the National Centre for Social Research (NatCen) discovered that the approach produced better outcomes than 'permissive' styles where parents are engaged but discipline is lacking, as well as 'authoritarian' styles, where warmth is in short supply.
A challenge to the 'gentle parenting' phenomenon
Children raised in a household with an authoritative parenting approach were more likely to reach the expected standard in the reading, writing and maths tests at the end of primary school, even after taking into account variables such as parents' educational level, according to the report, published this month by the Department for Education.
'At Key Stage 1 [children aged five to seven], higher parental limit-setting was associated with a greater likelihood of children achieving the expected level in Key Stage 1 reading, maths and science,' researchers say. 'An authoritative parenting style, characterised by high responsiveness and high levels of psychological control and clearer parental limit setting was also found to have a positive impact on Key Stage 2 [children aged seven to 11] attainment.'
The findings of the Study of Early Education and Development (SEED) appear to be a direct challenge to the 'gentle parenting' phenomenon that has taken the parenting world by storm in recent years.
Social media is awash with influencers pushing the approach, beloved of millennials, which teaches that the needs of the child must come first and that raised voices and the word 'no' are verboten.
Taken to extremes, the approach can seem outlandish. Actress Mayim Bialik's children went nappy-free as babies. Bialik, star of the hit TV series Blossom and The Big Bang Theory, practised something called 'elimination communication' that involved trying to read a baby's signals, and following them around with a potty. Fellow Hollywood actress Alicia Silverstone, of Clueless fame, posted a video of herself on YouTube in 2012 feeding her then 11-month-old son, Bear Blu, by chewing food and spitting it into his mouth.
According to gentle-parenting advocate Sarah Ockwell-Smith, misbehaviour is 'a cry for help... It is a sign that all is not well in the child's world. But most of the behaviour-control methods used today penalise the child for having a problem, rather than trying to help them solve it,' she says in The Gentle Parenting Book.
View this post on Instagram
A post shared by Sarah Ockwell-Smith (@sarahockwellsmith)
Ockwell-Smith and other devotees argue that gentle parenting is a form of 'authoritative' parenting, and insist that it does involve setting boundaries, just ones that 'validate a child's feelings and employ kindness, empathy and understanding'.
But as gurus preach the gospel of 'respecting' your child, exasperated mothers who have given gentle parenting a go are reporting that, in practice, it might only work with 'gentle children', and that more feisty offspring are running rings round them.
As one frustrated mother of a three-year-old puts it: 'It's a distressingly short journey from validating a child's feelings to letting them cause mayhem in a supermarket.'
Critics claim that whatever the good intentions, in a fast-moving world where parents have little time to endlessly negotiate with their toddler, the gentle parenting approach has morphed into a permissive free-for-all and is spawning a generation of spoilt, entitled children.
Katharine Birbalsingh, founder of the hugely successful Michaela Community School, in north London, and known as the UK's strictest headteacher, is one of them. She has attacked ' middle-class gentle parenting ' for creating a culture where parents are more interested in being friends with their children than holding them to account.
Teachers argue that the impact of this approach in schools is leading to chronic disruption and misbehaviour.
'Young people are more sensitive to simple things like being moved away from a friend for being too chatty in lessons, almost as though they aren't used to consequences at all. There's an unspoken sense of entitlement,' says Nadeine Asbali, a secondary school teacher in London. 'When we give young children the impression their own feelings are superior, we create teenagers and young adults who are selfish and inward-looking and who believe they are exceptions to the rules.'
'What children want are boundaries'
Prof Vivien Hill, psychologist and programme director at University College London's Institute of Education, agrees that the real-world application of gentler parenting styles can run into problems.
'That child is going to be entering the world of school where a teacher has to be able to control and teach 30 children. Nobody has the capacity to negotiate in that environment,' says the academic, who is also a member of the British Psychological Society's Division of Educational and Child Psychology.
'There is nothing more irritating to a teacher than giving a pupil a quick direction to keep somebody safe and they ignore you or want to have a 45-minute conversation about the pros and cons of their preferred course of action. There is something about how that style of parenting translates into wider communities and certainly the world of education and schooling.'
Scaled up, that lack of discipline can bring a school to its knees. School 21, a free school in east London founded in 2012 by Peter Hyman, Sir Keir Starmer's senior adviser for education from 2022-2024, and Oli de Botton, who has just been appointed by the PM in the same role, was initially upheld as a shining example of progressive education.
It opened with one year group and was given a glowing first Ofsted report. As it grew larger, however, the wheels began to fall off. In 2023, it was judged as 'requiring improvement' by Ofsted inspectors who found lessons were 'too often disrupted by poor behaviour'.
According to the new head, Moray Dickinson, who is turning the school around after joining in 2022, behaviour at the secondary school was 'really bad'. Despite this, suspension rates were 'extremely low' and there were no permanent exclusions.
'There was a huge amount of lost learning in class. Teachers were at times frightened and they were not happy in their jobs,' he said. 'There were fights. And as a result of that, the expectations for behaviour were very low.'
His top-down approach which has 'tightened things up significantly' has just been rewarded by a 'good' Ofsted rating.
The head is adamant that establishing clear structures and limits on behaviour do not have to come at the expense of good relationships with pupils. As the NatCen research confirms, with its findings on 'authoritative' parenting, the key ingredients of warmth and stricter limits do not have to be mutually exclusive – in families or in schools.
'What children want are boundaries, but you don't have to be authoritarian to operate boundaries,' says Prof Hill. 'It is about knowing when to give them freedom to explore and do their own thing, but also knowing when they need boundaries. That should be being developed from birth through early years but it becomes essential in adolescence when getting it wrong can be quite catastrophic.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Grimsby girl is welded to a job that's not just for the boys
Grimsby girl is welded to a job that's not just for the boys

BBC News

time20 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Grimsby girl is welded to a job that's not just for the boys

A girl who has been testing her welding skills says she wants to get more hands-on in a sector which is traditionally 15, was one of 25 girls who took part in the Women in Welding Day event near girls looking to forge careers in the engineering sector used a simulator and welded with chocolate to learn the who is a pupil at Havelock Academy, said she used to wear sunglasses watching her dad fix things in the kitchen. The event was held at Catch, an industrial training provider in Stallingborough."Engineering has always been more male-dominated – like most things on this planet, unfortunately. So now that females are all getting into it, it's more exciting for everyone," said Broddle, head of welding and pipefitting at Catch, said the Humber's offshore windfarms and other energy supply chains all needed skilled workers."The renewables industry is growing fast, and it's vital to this region's future," he said."We're seeing strong demand for welders on offshore wind, hydrogen and other clean energy projects."These are careers with a future – and we want young people from Grimsby and the surrounding villages, especially girls, to see there's a place for them in it."Faith and her fellow Havelock pupils were joined by students from Ron Dearing UTC, Engineering UTC Northern Lincolnshire, Somercotes Academy, Waltham Tollbar Academy, Frederick Gough School and Baysgarth Broddle added: "We've gone from one or two female apprentices to five this year."Once the girls get a go with the torch, they realise they can do it – and do it well." Listen to highlights from Lincolnshire on BBC Sounds, watch the latest episode of Look North or tell us about a story you think we should be covering here. Download the BBC News app from the App Store for iPhone and iPad or Google Play for Android devices

About 700m years ago, the Earth froze over entirely – now we may know why
About 700m years ago, the Earth froze over entirely – now we may know why

The Guardian

time23 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

About 700m years ago, the Earth froze over entirely – now we may know why

It's hard to believe, but about 700m years ago it's thought that our planet completely froze over with little to no liquid ocean or lakes exposed to the atmosphere, even in the tropics. But what tipped Earth's climate into 'Snowball Earth' state? A new study suggests a cold climate and massive volcanic eruptions set the scene. The Franklin eruptions – about 720m years ago – spewed out vast amounts of fresh rock, stretching from what is now Alaska, through northern Canada to Greenland. Similarly large eruptions have happened at other times, but this one happened to coincide with an already cold climate. And combined with a lack of plants (they hadn't evolved yet) these eruptions exposed a huge carpet of fresh rock to intense weathering. Chemical reactions associated with weathering remove carbon dioxide from the air. By modelling the climate impact, researchers have shown that rapid erosion over such a large area could have pulled down enough carbon dioxide to tip Earth into a snowball state. The findings, which are published in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets, also show that similar-sized volcanic eruptions at other times in Earth's history failed to generate snowball conditions because they occurred when the background climate was hotter, or at times when vegetation cover slowed the rate of erosion.

Climate change driving octopus surge, says Plymouth scientist
Climate change driving octopus surge, says Plymouth scientist

BBC News

timean hour ago

  • BBC News

Climate change driving octopus surge, says Plymouth scientist

A dramatic surge in octopus numbers along the South West coast of the UK is being linked to climate lucrative octopus bloom has led to a dramatic fall in the number of shellfish such as crab, lobsters and scallops which the octopus preys long-term consequences for the region's shellfish industry are now concerning those in the fishing Bryce Stewart, a marine ecologist with the Marine Biological Association in Plymouth, said the octopus bloom was likely to be the result of unusually warm sea temperatures and shifting ocean currents, both driven by global climate change. "This year has seen an explosion in octopus numbers, particularly in Cornwall," Dr Stewart said. "Fishermen first started noticing more octopus in 2022 and while numbers dipped slightly last year, 2025 has brought a dramatic increase."The species in question, the European or Mediterranean octopus (Octopus vulgaris), is typically associated with warmer with sea temperatures in the South West reaching up to 4C above normal this year - an "unbelievably warm" anomaly, according to Dr Stewart - conditions have become increasingly favourable for their reproduction and survival, he said."Even a one or two degree rise can have a huge impact on marine life which are ectothermic and rely on the surrounding water to regulate their body temperature," he said."Octopus breed in spring and summer and warmer temperatures during those months help their eggs and young develop more successfully," Dr Stewart explained. "But what's really crucial is the winter temperature. "Normally, cold winters would kill off many of the young but this past winter was exceptionally warm, allowing more to survive." Dr Stewart thinks that octopus have now become a feature of the local warming trend is part of a broader ecological shift, he said. "We're seeing more Mediterranean species in UK waters and fewer cold-water species like cod, haddock and pollock," Dr Stewart said. "The ecosystem is changing rapidly and that is directly tied to climate change."For shell-fishermen like Alan Steer, who works out of Beesands in Devon, the impact has been immediate and severe."We'd never seen an octopus five years ago," he said. "Now, since February, it's been an explosion. "They're devastating the shellfish we rely on. Crabs and lobsters are being eaten in the pots before we can land them." Mr Steer, vice chair of South Devon and Channel Shell-fishermen, estimates his catch has dropped by at least 60% this summer, with some pots coming up filled only with empty scallop shells and fragments of crab and lobster. "It's been dramatic," he said. "We already had a slight decline over the last two years but this year, with the octopus, it's just dropped off a cliff."While some fishermen have managed to sell octopus to new markets, others are struggling. "The vessels that haven't been catching octopus but are still seeing a drop in crab and lobster are having a very, very difficult time," he said. "Some boats have already left the industry."Mr Steer and others are now experimenting with octopus-specific pots that do not require costly crab bait but uncertainty remains. "We're trying a few but we don't know if this is something we can invest in wholeheartedly without knowing the science behind whether they're going to be here for very long," he said. Dr Stewart is leading a new study funded by Defra, Plymouth City Council and Devon County Council to understand the phenomenon."We'll know more in six months but it's clear that climate change is reshaping our coastal ecosystems in real time," he now, Mr Steer is cautiously adapting, testing new pot designs aimed at catching octopus with an eye on history which has shown that blooms like this have lasted a few years and then vanished, leaving shellfish stocks depleted for years afterwards."I've been calling myself an octopus fisherman for the last six months," he said. "It's been good to us so far this year and I hope we can keep going. "But if they disappear, I think we're in for some very tough times."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store