Your questions answered on immigration and migration
BBC East Yorkshire and Lincolnshire has looked at immigration and migration across the country, and the impact it is having on communities, public services and society.
A complex topic, the BBC aims to cut through the rhetoric and get to the facts, going beyond the headlines and politics to put the issue into context.
We asked for your questions on the matter.
Here is a selection answered by Dr Madeleine Sumption MBE, who is the director of the Migration Observatory at Oxford University. It provides impartial, independent and evidence-based analysis of data on migration and migrants in the UK to inform media, public and policy debates.
Jenny Lewis, from Grantham, wants to know how many people from abroad work in heath care, and if the NHS and social care could survive without them.
In response, Dr Sumption said the NHS relied quite heavily on overseas doctors and nurses, as does the social care sector.
She said it was difficult to imagine a scenario with no overseas recruitment, but added it would depend on what else we did as a country.
"For example, whether we increase the number of domestic nurses that we train – or if you look at the care sector – whether the government improves pay and conditions."
David Bedford, 59, from Lincolnshire, wants to know what percentage of Eastern Europeans work in the NHS.
Dr Sumption says while there is no specific data on Eastern European workers, if you look at the health and care sectors together, one in six workers come from overseas - making health "slightly more reliant" on overseas workers than other industries.
Ray Bennett, from Little Carlton, asks why people are risking their lives in small boats to get to the UK, rather than claiming asylum in the first safe country they get to?
Dr Sumption says: "In terms of the risks, one thing that is quite interesting is that people are willing to take quite extraordinary risks… to make that journey."
She says if you look at the numbers coming to the UK in small boats as a share of overall migration "it's actually quite low".
However, she adds: "That doesn't mean we shouldn't be talking about it."
"What's happening on the small boats is a dangerous form of migration – the costs are higher, so I think it's reasonable there has been more of a focus on it."
Stuart, from Lincolnshire, asks what impact immigration was having on UK crime rates.
"There has been a little bit of research on this – which has so far not actually found much of a connection between immigration and crime," says Dr Sumption.
However, she says some studies from the US and UK suggest that immigration might have actually decreased crime.
"This is an area which needs more evidence," she adds.
Steve Wright, 75, from Lincolnshire, suggests migrants on benefits are "costing the country a fortune".
Dr Sumption: "If you look at the total cost of migration and the benefits in terms of the taxes that people pay, it seems migrants pay more or less the amount of taxes it would take to provide them with benefits and other public services.
"It does, of course, vary quite a lot, so those on low incomes are much more likely to be net recipients from the system. At the same time, those who are earning a lot are paying a lot of tax and subsidising others."
'We're not different to them' - migrant worker
How many people come to work and study in the UK?
How many people cross the Channel in small boats?
Migration Observatory
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
I used our honeymoon fund to pay for my husband's funeral after he died unexpectedly
Laura Burr had only been married for six months when she held her husband's hand as he died from an undiagnosed heart condition. Now, the 31-year-old from Oxfordshire is campaigning for health MOTs to be offered from the age of 30 – something she believes could have saved his life. Currently, free NHS checks are only offered to people aged 40 and over, but Laura says that's too late for many. "If Ed had been tested earlier, even a basic blood pressure or cholesterol check might have given us a warning," she says. Laura, from Banbury, married her "funny, kind, and chaotic" soulmate Edward in April 2024 in a small ceremony surrounded by loved ones. But, just 186 days later she was holding his hand as doctors turned off his life support machine. Edward Burr, a 32-year-old primary school teacher, began experiencing flu-like symptoms the day after their wedding. Initially, it seemed like a bad cold. "He was getting hot and cold sweats, and couldn't sleep,' Laura recalls. 'We thought he just needed rest and vitamin C." Within weeks, Ed was struggling to breathe. A trip to A&E led to a diagnosis of pneumonia and heart failure – two serious conditions doctors struggled to treat at the same time. "We were told he'd be easier to treat if it was just one or the other," Laura says. "But because he had both, it was more complicated. They didn't know which was causing the most damage." Ed spent seven weeks in hospital before being discharged with strict monitoring instructions. After a brief return home, he was readmitted and fitted with a biventricular assist device (BIVAD) to help his heart pump blood. He was placed on the transplant list – but he never made it to surgery. If Ed had received a health MOT at 30, even if it didn't save him, I might have had more time with him In early October, Laura sensed something wasn't right. "The chaplain came to bless him like he always did, but that time I just broke down sobbing," she says. Just hours later, she got a call to say Ed had taken a turn for the worse. "They told us his BIVAD machine was failing and they couldn't keep him going. I played his favourite music and my sister read him a poem," Laura says. "And then, I held his hand as he died." Instead of spending their honeymoon fund on a trip to Disneyland the couple had dreamed of, Laura says she used it to pay for his funeral. Now, Laura is campaigning for change. She's calling for NHS health checks (currently only offered to people aged 40 and over) to be made available from age 30 – a move she believes could save lives. "If Ed had received a health MOT at 30, even if it didn't save him, I might have had more time with him," she says. "At his funeral, I kept thinking: how did we get here? We were newlyweds. We should've been arguing over dinner plans, not saying goodbye." Laura has teamed up with friend Gabriella Evans, who also lost her husband, Tom, 34, to an undiagnosed heart condition. Together, they are campaigning for earlier, routine health screenings including blood pressure and cholesterol checks. The pair released The Podcast That Shouldn't Exist earlier this month. In the first episode, Laura told how she walked down the aisle at the wedding and the funeral to the same music, from her husband's favourite film series Lord Of The Rings. "People in their 30s think they're too young for this stuff," Laura says. "But I'm living proof that you're not." The check is a free check-up of your overall health and sees everyone aged over 40 assessed for their risk of developing a heart or circulatory condition such as heart disease, kidney disease, type 2 diabetes or stroke in the next 10 years. Everyone aged 40-74 who does not have a pre-existing condition should be offered the NHS Health Check at least once every five years. If you have any of the following pre-existing conditions, the NHS says you're not eligible as you should be seen more frequently: heart disease chronic kidney disease diabetes high blood pressure (hypertension) atrial fibrillation transient ischaemic attack inherited high cholesterol (familial hypercholesterolemia) heart failure peripheral arterial disease stroke currently being prescribed statins to lower cholesterol Each year, around 20% of people eligible for one of these checks are invited to come forward, with a view to reach the entire eligible population in a five-year cycle. Additional reporting by SWNS Read more about heart health: 4 possible benefits of alcohol as champagne may lower risk of sudden cardiac arrest (Yahoo Life UK, 6-min read) What to know about common heart defect as Emma Willis undergoes surgery (Yahoo Life UK, 4-min read) People's heart health in the UK declining rapidly in 'worrying trend (PA Media, 3-min read)
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Council tax bills set to rise at fastest rate for two decades, economist warns
Council tax bills are set to rise at their fastest rate for two decades in the wake of Rachel Reeves' spending review, according to the head of the Institute for Fiscal Studies. Paul Johnson said that local government in England did 'perhaps a little bit better than it might have expected' out of the Chancellor's statement on Wednesday, but the 'sting in the tail' is the assumption that 'council tax bills will rise by 5% a year' as part of the funding. The core spending power of councils is set to increase by 2.6% a year from next year, and 'if English councils do choose 5% increases – and most almost certainly will – council tax bills look set to rise at their fastest rate over any parliament since 2001-05', Mr Johnson said on Thursday. On Wednesday, Ms Reeves said that ministers will not be 'going above' the 5% annual increases in council tax. She told ITV: 'The previous government increased council tax by 5% a year, and we have stuck to that. We won't be going above that. 'That is the council tax policy that we inherited from the previous government, and that we will be continuing.' The biggest winner from Wednesday's statement was the NHS, which will see its budget rise by £29 billion per year in real terms. Ruth Curtice, the chief executive of the Resolution Foundation, has said that Britain is turning into a 'National Health State'. Overnight, the think tank said Ms Reeves' announcements had followed a recent trend that saw increases for the NHS come at the expense of other public services. Ms Curtice said: 'Health accounted for 90% of the extra public service spending, continuing a trend that is seeing the British state morph into a National Health State, with half of public service spending set to be on health by the end of the decade.' Defence was another of Wednesday's winners, Ms Curtice said, receiving a significant increase in capital spending while other departments saw an overall £3.6 billion real-terms cut in investment. The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) made similar arguments about 'substantial' investment in the NHS and defence coming at the expense of other departments, although Mr Johnson warned on Wednesday the money may not be enough. In his snap reaction to the review, Mr Johnson said: 'Aiming to get back to meeting the NHS 18-week target for hospital waiting times within this Parliament is enormously ambitious – an NHS funding settlement below the long-run average might not measure up. 'And on defence, it's entirely possible that an increase in the Nato spending target will mean that maintaining defence spending at 2.6% of GDP no longer cuts the mustard.' Ms Curtice added that low and middle-income families had also done well out of the spending review 'after two rounds of painful tax rises and welfare cuts', with the poorest fifth of families benefiting from an average of £1,700 in extra spending on schools, hospitals and the police. She warned that, without economic growth, another round of tax rises was likely to come in the autumn as the Chancellor seeks to balance the books. She said: 'The extra money in this spending review has already been accounted for in the last forecast. 'But a weaker economic outlook and the unfunded changes to winter fuel payments mean the Chancellor will likely need to look again at tax rises in the autumn.' Speaking after delivering her spending review, Ms Reeves insisted she would not have to raise taxes to cover her spending review. She told GB News: 'Every penny of this is funded through the tax increases and the changes to the fiscal rules that we set out last autumn.'
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
6 toilet habit changes you should always see a doctor about
No one enjoys talking about bowel movements. But ignoring the signs your body is trying to send you can mean putting off a diagnosis you really need to hear. Just ask TOWIE star Chloe Meadows. The reality TV regular recently shared on Dr Oscar Duke's Bedside Manners podcast that she'd spent a decade silently struggling with bleeding, stomach pain and extreme fatigue before finally getting a diagnosis: ulcerative colitis, a chronic condition that causes inflammation and ulcers in the colon. She lived with on-and-off symptoms for years, assuming they'd passed. It wasn't until age 26, when she became visibly unwell, that a blood test led her to A&E and finally, a diagnosis. Meadows' experience is an important reminder that when your toilet habits change – and stay changed – it's time to talk to your GP. Below, we break down six toilet-related red flags that experts say you should never ignore. And no, it's not just about your bowel movements; your wee, urgency levels, and even smells all matter, too. Whether you're suddenly constipated, dealing with constant diarrhoea, or noticing your stool looks different (narrower, paler or greasy), changes that last longer than a few weeks are worth investigating. The NHS advises that ongoing shifts in bowel habits could be linked to anything from diet and stress to Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), coeliac disease or inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). In some cases, persistent symptoms could be a sign of bowel cancer, so don't brush them off. When to see your GP: If your usual routine has changed for more than two to three weeks, especially if it's paired with stomach pain, fatigue, or weight loss. It might be bright red or dark and tarry; either way, it's not something to ignore. Bright red blood can come from piles or small tears, but darker blood might mean there's bleeding higher up in the digestive system. When to see your GP: If you see blood in your poo. You may be offered a stool test, or in some cases, a referral for further checks. If anything feels amiss and suddenly starts to sting, burn or feel uncomfortable, you might assume it's a urinary tract infection (UTI). And often, that's true. But it can also be a sign of kidney stones or bladder issues. Blood in your urine should also be taken seriously, even if it only happens once. When to see your GP: If you have pain while urinating, see blood or feel the urge to go far more often than usual. Needing the loo more often than usual (especially at night), feeling like you can't wait, or leaking a little when you cough, sneeze or laugh could signal an overactive bladder, prostate issues (in men), or pelvic floor dysfunction. These symptoms might feel embarrassing, but they're generally common and manageable with the right support. When to see your GP: If bladder leaks or urgency interfere with your daily life, or if you notice a sudden change in how often you need to go. A little mucus in your stool isn't always a worry, but frequent slimy stools can be a sign of infection or inflammation in your gut. When to see your GP: If mucus appears regularly, especially if it comes with bloating, pain or a change in bowel movements. If going to the toilet has become uncomfortable, painful, or feels like hard work, that's your body waving a red flag. Regular straining can cause or worsen hemorrhoids, but it might also signal bowel issues or even neurological problems affecting your pelvic floor. When to see your GP: If you're straining often, feel like you're not fully emptying your bowels, or notice pain during or after a bowel movement. If you're unsure, remember that everyone has their own baseline of what's 'normal'. However, there are a few simple signs to watch for as a guide. According to the Bladder and Bowel Health Service, healthy bowel movements should be soft, smooth and easy to pass; ideally at least three times a week. You should also be able to urinate without pain or discomfort. If you also notice you're often bloated, tired, straining, or notice blood or mucus, it's time to speak to your GP. Changes might be harmless, but they're always worth checking. Read more on bowel habits: This Poop Chart Will Tell You If Your Bathroom Habits Are Actually Healthy Or If You Need To See A Doctor ASAP (Buzzfeed, 4-min read) How 'blowing bubbles' and 'mooing' can help ease constipation, according to NHS doctor (Yahoo Life UK, 4-min read) Bowel cancer cases in young people rising sharply in England, study finds (PA Media, 4-min read)
