Whangārei house damaged by airborne car; owner urges council to install safety barriers
Beniston is concerned no one will ever want to buy his house, and wonders if he will continue to be able to get insurance.
His neighbour Ruby doesn't feel safe in her home. She said the police told her the car was going at least 180km/h at the time of the crash.
Jim Beniston with his neighbour Ruby Martin. Martin says she doesn't feel safe in her home. Photo / Supplied
'I was in bed when I heard this big rumbling noise, it felt like an earthquake. By the time I got out of bed and into the hall the guy had scarpered. I'm relieved Jim wasn't home, he usually sleeps in an armchair in the lounge,' Ruby said.
What they didn't know
Beniston was unaware that when he bought the house in 2019, the garage had been destroyed twice already.
The Herald talked to Shane Forman, son of the previous owner, who told him cars had smashed into the garage on two separate occasions when his mother Grace lived there.
The stolen car that became airborne and hit Jim Beniston's Whangārei home in May. Photo / Supplied.
'Thankfully the cars didn't get as far as the lounge [those first two times]. Mum was at home,' Foreman said.
Requesting a crash barrier
Beniston's partner Annette Moncur, 77, is urging the Whangārei District Council to install safety barriers to protect them.
'Council approved the development of these properties. With that comes a duty of care to ensure the safety of the residents. I'm worried someone will be killed,' Moncur said.
Annette Moncur with her partner Jim Beniston who says no one will want to buy his house. Photo / Supplied
'We pay our rates and expect our councillors to do something.'
Moncur told the Herald councillor Simon Reid visited the crash site and was visibly affected by the destruction.
Reid told the Herald he sympathises with Beniston.
'It's not easy to just put up a crash railing with the recent law changes,' he said.
'It has to absorb some of the impact rather than stop it. In my opinion - and in this case - the person breaking the law is better looked after.
Jim Beniston's house was damaged by a speeding airborne car. He wants the Council and police to take action before someone is hurt. Photo / Supplied
'It's about budget. Sometimes I feel like the Sheriff of Nottingham - you have to steal from one to give to another.'
The Council responds
An email obtained by the Herald from the Mayor's office on June 30 said: 'Staff are investigating options for installing a crash barrier. Currently this is not a funded project.'
It went on to say a decision would be made in the next financial year or as part of the 2027 Long Term Plan.
Whangarei Mayor Vince Cocurullo said he is waiting on advice from his roading team before deciding on safety barriers. Photo / Supplied
Whangārei Mayor Vince Cocurullo told the Herald protective barriers might not be the solution.
'The fact someone was speeding has nothing to do with the development of that piece of land,' he said.
'Hypothetically, if someone hits the barrier at high speed and it launches the car into the air and straight into a house, barriers aren't going to solve the problem.
'We are waiting for our roading team to see what can be done. They will present to the council and that's when we will make the decision to fund safety barriers - or it could be a complete re-design of that intersection which could take up to 2 years.
'It's a 50 kilometre area and someone was speeding so that's a police matter not a council one,' Cocurullo said.
The alleged driver
Senior Sergeant Rene Rakete, Whangārei Area Response Manager, said a 22-year-old Tikipunga man was arrested last weekend.
In a statement, Rakete said: 'Police began an investigation after a crash was reported near the corner of Mill Road and Millers Lane. A stolen vehicle allegedly collided with a fence and went through the roof of a house at high speed. The vehicle and house sustained significant damage.
'The driver had fled the scene, a warrant in lieu of summons was sought last month for the offence of dangerous driving. The man has appeared in court and will reappear on 21 July. It is fortunate that the alleged actions of this man did not result in fatalities.'
A 22 year-old man was arrested for stealing a car and charged for dangerous driving Photo / Supplied
Meanwhile, Beniston's two-bedroom unit remains under wraps and it will be at least another six months before it's rebuilt and habitable.
'I am disappointed no one seems to be able to do anything,' he told the Herald.
'I am worried about going home. There is nothing to stop this from happening again. Will the insurance company pay for damages? I can't sell this place with the cloud we're under. What will it take - someone to die before anything is done?'
Carolyne Meng-Yee is an Auckland-based investigative journalist who won Best Documentary at the Voyager Media Awards. Recently she was runner-up for Best Editorial Campaign and part of a team that won Best Coverage of a Major News Event: Philip Polkinghorne Murder Trial. She worked for the Herald on Sunday from 2007-2011 and rejoined the Herald in 2016 after working as an award-winning current affairs producer at TVNZ's 60 Minutes, 20/20 and Sunday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
16 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Wellington car dealer claims lease forged as $127k rent dispute escalates to High Court
The Herald has obtained documents filed for both sides in the High Court at Wellington. A hearing date is yet to be set. Photo / Mark Mitchell The plaintiffs are brothers Manish and Sailesh Patel, the trustees of the Patel Family Trust. Their statement of claim says Scott began leasing their site on High St in Lower Hutt in February 2012. That deal was formalised with a deed of lease signed in May that year. Rent was set at $2833 plus GST per month – just over $3250 including tax – and the agreement included a 10% default interest clause. According to the trust, Scott's rent payments were 'inconsistent' from the outset – some months were overpaid, others underpaid, and by 2013, Scott was regularly behind. They claim that by 2024, rent arrears had hit six figures, and in August, Scott was given four months to settle the bill or vacate by Christmas Day. No payment was made, and they changed the locks on December 16. Their lawyer then demanded $127,000 in unpaid rent and interest from Scott – warning the figure would continue to grow until the property was cleared and returned. In April this year, the trust filed proceedings in the High Court. The Patels have asked the court to: Confirm Scott's lease was lawfully cancelled. Grant them possession of the premises. Order Scott to pay $127,541.41 in arrears and award default interest at 10% per year. Grant damages for the lost opportunity to lease the site while Scott's vehicles and equipment remain stored there. Scott, who has been selling cars for more than 55 years, is fighting back – accusing the Patels of forging multiple lease documents and trying to 'extort' money and property from him under false pretences. The statement of defence he has filed in court outlines his position. He says that in 2012 he entered into a lease agreement with Jayanti Patel, the father of Manish and Sailesh. He presented Jayanti Patel with a 'draft' lease, which he had signed – but it was never formally actioned. 'There was no written lease. The arrangement was an unwritten short-term lease as is defined in sections 208, 209 and 210 of the Property Law Act 2007,' his statement said. 'There was no provision in the agreement for payment of interest … The document referred to [in the statement of claim] was not signed by any of the parties named [the brothers or Scott] ... Accordingly, [Scott] is not liable to the plaintiffs.' Scott alleges the lease documents being relied on in court by the Patel brothers are a manipulated version of the draft agreement he presented to the original trustees in 2012. In his court statement, he alleges his signature was 'electronically replicated' on to the document using cut-and-paste techniques, and says expert evidence filed alongside his application supports that. That evidence includes a handwriting analysis and forensic document examination. The handwriting expert believed the lease contains 'substantial and significant inconsistencies' and 'non-genuine' signatures across different versions. It concluded there was a 'strong probability' the documents had been deliberately altered or fabricated. Scott also alleges that since being locked out in December, he has been unable to retrieve business equipment and dozens of vehicles left on site – and that several of them have been damaged or stolen. He alleges unknown offenders have repeatedly entered the property, smashed windows, slashed paintwork, stolen wheels, and stripped valuable items from both vehicles and the on-site office. On one occasion, four left-hand-drive vehicles were damaged, and a fifth had a window smashed. On another, two cars were stripped of their wheels, rendering them immovable. David Scott says vehicles have been vandalised at his Park Lane premises on High St, Lower Hutt. Photo / Mark Mitchell He claims the trust failed to protect the vehicles while they controlled the site. Scott also says the trust's actions in blocking his access to the property breach the Property Law Act and have caused significant business losses. He is seeking to have the entire claim thrown out, declaring the lease invalid, and may pursue his own legal action for damage to his property. Stolen and damaged items, he claims, include five vehicle windows valued at $18,000, a mechanic's industrial toolbox worth $50,000, an air compressor, a floor jack, ladders, various power tools, batteries, and security cameras. Scott is also seeking $27,500 for panel and paint repairs to damaged vehicles and $9500 for replacement wheels and mags. Additional costs include battery chargers, car opening kits, and other workshop equipment. Beyond the material losses, the first defendant is also seeking $1.85 million in damages for emotional harm and stress. David Scott claims valuable items have been stripped from the office at his dealership. Photo / Mark Mitchell Scott told the Herald that the ongoing saga had deeply affected his health. 'I just want to sell cars … I like to help people." The Herald reached out to the Patel brothers through their lawyer, Matt Anderson. Anderson said the men would deny all 'baseless' allegations made by Scott. 'This is a simple rent recovery exercise on behalf of our clients,' he said. 'The tenant was significantly behind on rent for many years … Our clients had hoped that the tenant would vacate the property so they could relet the premises. Court proceedings were filed as the tenant refuses to vacate the premises, despite repeated requests, and our clients are left with a premises they cannot use and a tenant who was significantly in arrears and now will not give up the premises. 'Our clients deny all allegations of inappropriate behaviour referred to by the tenant in their counter-claim. 'Our clients are frustrated that the tenant is making baseless claims and using the court process as a means to delay leaving the premises.' Anna Leask is a senior journalist who covers national crime and justice. She joined the Herald in 2008 and has worked as a journalist for 19 years with a particular focus on family and gender-based violence, child abuse, sexual violence, homicides, mental health and youth crime. She writes, hosts and produces the award-winning podcast A Moment In Crime, released monthly on
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Operation Weirton: Auckland businessman Hooi Keat Chai convicted of money laundering following advice to Daniel Hannett during investigation into 613kg drug bust
The investigation had previous success, however, focusing on Hannett's money laundering. One of the dodgy transactions was the sale and purchase of a property he owned at a grossly inflated price to conceal the source of $5 million in cash. Another transaction was the conversion of $388,800 in cash to 1.5 million in Chinese currency. In a series of conversations that were covertly recorded by police in January 2022, Hannett was overheard discussing how to launder the cash with his close friend Hooi Keat Chai. The pair had recently invested in a nightclub in Malaysia together, while Hannett was also a shareholder in a New Zealand petfood business with Chai's wife. Better known as Ben, Chai was also the project manager for renovations at a brothel recently established by Hannett in downtown Auckland. In the conversations bugged by police, Hannett told Chai he would give $1 million to a mutual associate to launder. The pair also discussed the fluctuation of exchange rates with China and Malaysia, with Chai advising Hannett that the precise timing of handing the cash to their associate did not matter. Surveillance teams saw Hannett meet with Chai at a cafe in Newmarket, before Hannett took a black duffel bag to their associate who lived in an apartment in downtown Auckland. There was $388,800 inside the duffel bag, according to WeChat messages on Hannett's phone later obtained by police. In April, Hannett pleaded guilty to the two counts of money laundering, importing a Class-A drug, unlawful possession of firearms, and possession of nearly 22g of MDMA. A sentencing date has not been set. Daniel Hannett, inset, and his late-model Ferrari which was part of $7m worth of assets seized by police following Operation Weirton. Hannett was also charged with importing 613kg of methamphetamine. Photo / Supplied Chai was charged as a party to money laundering in relation to the $388,800 transaction and recently convicted following a trial. He is due to be sentenced next month. Regardless of whether Chai is sent to prison or a term of home detention, he will most likely be removed from New Zealand as soon as the sentence is served. The Herald can now reveal that Chai has been fighting deportation for years after being convicted of immigration fraud. The Malaysian citizen first arrived at Auckland International Airport in October 2003 with a passport in the name of Kok Tong Chai. Chai was granted a visitor's visa but remained in the country unlawfully once it expired, until his departure in June 2005. A few months later, he changed his name by deed poll in Malaysia to Hooi Keat Chai and was issued a new passport in that name. In November 2005, Chai returned to New Zealand and was granted a visitor visa in his new name - failing to disclose his previous name. In February 2009, Chai applied for a work visa. On doing so, he supplied a work reference letter that falsely stated that he had worked for a construction company in Malaysia between 2003 and 2005. This concealed his previously unlawful time in New Zealand under a different name. He was later granted permanent residence, and built a successful life for his family running a construction firm that subcontracted to industry giants. But Chai's backstory unravelled when his business, Team NZ Constructions Ltd, was one of 10 companies targeted by Immigration NZ in Operation Spectrum, an investigation to disrupt the flow of illegal workers from Malaysia. Construction industry boss Hooi Keat Chai was found guilty of immigration fraud in 2019 and has been fighting deportation ever since. Photo / Michael Craig Nearly 200 illegal workers were either deported, fled New Zealand or stopped at the border following the six-month inquiry in 2017. Many had registered companies in New Zealand, then recruited other unlawful workers as plasterers, painters, tilers or carpenters. They worked as third-tier subcontractors, below the radar of developers and site managers, and were paid $20 to $40 an hour in cash. By paying no tax, those running the underground crews were able to win contracts by undercutting the bids of legitimate competitors. More recently, the construction industry - along with horticulture and hospitality - have been identified as 'high risk' sectors because paying wages in cash is an effective method of money laundering. At an eventual trial in 2018, Chai was acquitted of charges relating to the unlawful labour element of Operation Spectrum. But he was convicted of supplying false information to obtain the work visa, as well as using the fraudulent visa at the border three times, and sentenced to six months' home detention. As a result of committing immigration fraud, Chai was served with a deportation notice in June 2022. He appealed the deportation notice to the Immigration Protection Tribunal (IPT) on humanitarian grounds, given that his wife is now a New Zealand resident and their two children were born here. Although the IPT agreed that a significant burden would be placed on his wife and children, the panel ruled that allowing Chai to stay would seriously undermine the integrity of the immigration system. 'It was a serious matter that [Chai] was granted a temporary work visa based on his concealment of his previous identity. This fraud led him to obtaining a resident visa, [his wife] obtaining a resident visa based on her partnership with him, and the children acquiring New Zealand citizenship,' according to the IPT ruling. 'Weighing the offending (immigration offences involving dishonesty) against the exceptional humanitarian circumstances, the Tribunal is satisfied that it is not unjust or unduly harsh for the appellant to be deported from New Zealand.' Now 41, Chai went on to appeal the IPT decision to the High Court, then the Court of Appeal last year, but the ruling was upheld on both occasions. Damon Treadaway, National Manager Compliance (Acting) for Immigration New Zealand confirmed in a statement Chai is still liable for deportation. 'To hold a New Zealand visa you must meet immigration requirements, including being of good character' Treadway said. 'Migrants convicted of criminal offending and sentenced to imprisonment or home detention, may be liable for deportation once they have finished their sentence. 'Immigration New Zealand works with Corrections and other agencies on the next steps for the person, when the person is approaching the end of their sentence.' Jared Savage covers crime and justice issues, with a particular interest in organised crime. He joined the Herald in 2006 and has won a dozen journalism awards in that time, including twice being named Reporter of the Year. He is also the author of Gangland, Gangster's Paradise and Underworld.
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
Kaikohe crash: Mum's horror moment realising 11yo daughter wasn't among survivors
For Staci and her siblings, it was meant to be a special day. She was being driven home to change out of her school uniform for a visit to her father, Rawiri Walkley. Suddenly, the people-mover was struck on the passenger side by a white Toyota that had been driven through a signposted compulsory stop. It did so at such speed that those nearby heard two bangs, they told the Herald. The first was the collision; the next came moments later when the people-mover hit the ground after spinning through the air. Medina Koni, 53, was doing some washing when she heard the impact. Her home on the corner of Hillcrest and Omapere Rds is across from where the two vehicles came to rest. Staci Walkley, 11, was killed in Kaikohe in August after a car driven by two youths struck the vehicle in which she was travelling. She was one of those who heard the two bangs and moved quickly to see what had happened. 'I looked outside and a guy just took off.' There were two teens – Koni watched them go, as did another eyewitness across the road with a long view down Omapere Rd. That eyewitness, who did not want to be named, watched the teenagers sprinting away, abandoning the white Toyota, which was stuck on a retaining wall. Koni told the Herald she thought it was just the one car at that stage. The people-mover filled with children had been flung uphill and across a vegetable garden, and was behind a tall fence in the backyard across the road. The corner of Hillcrest and Omapere Rds in Kaikohe, showing the backyard where the people-mover containing Staci Walkley, 11, came to rest. She died in the incident. Koni waited, partly unsure as to what had happened but also not wanting to be rubbernecking. As she watched, a woman emerged from behind the fence. Koni remembered the woman – it was Candice Walkley – shouting: 'Catch him, he's taken off down there.' 'The mum was just yelling the whole time, it was just the shock. She's in a panic,' Koni. And then an awful reality hit as children started tumbling out from behind the fence to the roadside, one after another. 'I saw the tamariki,' Koni said – and that was when she realised there was another vehicle involved. The Toyota involved in the fatal crash in Kaikohe in which 11-year-old Staci Walkley died. Photo / David Fisher That got Koni moving. The children had moved down from the backyard to the corner of the road, two older ones and two younger ones at first. As she watched, children kept coming out from where the people-mover had come to rest. One eyewitness reckoned there were seven children in total in the vehicle. 'Some have got grazes and blood on their face. One didn't and that's the one I went to hug. Her body was shaking. I went up and put my arms around her,' Koni said. She thought, if she could just get her arms around that girl and hold her, the shaking would stop. 'The young boy who was sitting on the ground … then he just lay down.' For a moment, it all seemed to go still – and then the awful reality struck. Gouged grass at the scene of the fatal crash on the corner of Hillcrest and Omapere Rds in Kaikohe. Photo / David Fisher 'The mum realised one was missing. It didn't dawn on her for a while there was one missing.' And then came the scream: 'Where's my girl, my girl?' Koni drew a breath. 'She was under the car.' By then, people had spilled from the houses around to help. Everyone the Herald interviewed for this story made the point – Kaikohe is a town of community and heart. Staci hadn't been missed or seen at that point because in the chaos, it was difficult to see underneath the vehicle. The call went up to lift the people-mover and those who had come to help tried to lift it. One neighbour sprinted home to get a jack. 'It took so long to access her and then there was the reality she had passed,' said Koni. When it became clear Staci had died under the vehicle, there was anguish – and along with the pain came anger. 'The rest of the whānau turned up,' Koni recalled. Some of the arriving whānau set out in cars to look for the teens who had run away. Others stayed with Candice Walkley as first responders arrived. Kaikohe accident victim Staci Walkley, 11. Father learns he's lost a child Just 10 minutes drive away at Ngāwhā prison, just outside Kaikohe, Rawiri Walkley would also soon learn he had lost a child. It was supposed to be a special day, given his absence from the family home as an inmate awaiting sentencing. Rawiri is a leader of Man Up in Kaikohe and Candice is involved in Legacy, the women's movement. He had been on bail with a defended trial in his future. The Herald was told when he surrendered to Christ through the Destiny Church and Man Up movement, he also surrendered his 'not guilty' plea. His pastor, Eric Edmonds, told the Herald that Walkley's embrace of his past meant he chose to plead guilty, thereby losing bail to wait in prison until October for sentencing on a number of charges. His was to be another Man Up redemption story – his guilty plea was acknowledgment of having walked the wrong path. But that will now be sorely tested as he grieves behind bars, away from a family who lost one member too soon. Edmonds said a phone call of support from Pastor Hannah Tamaki and the backing of Apostle Brian Tamaki recognised the Walkley whānau's connection to the church. 'She wanted to send condolences to them.' Rawiri and Candice Walkley flanking Destiny Church's Apostle Brian Tamaki. 'I'm trying to stay strong' – Mum In the hours after the crash, Candice Walkley kept whānau updated through Facebook while at the bedside of her other children in hospital. She said shortly after the crash: 'We have just lost one of (our) babies. She (is) in peace with our Lord. Staci Waireia Walkley spread her wings today. I'm still trying to take it (in). I'm trying to stay strong for rest of (my) babies …'. A family member said Staci would return to Kaikohe to lie in state at the Man Up centre at 158 Broadway. Candice and Rawiri Walkley are deeply involved in the Destiny Church-linked Legacy and Man Up movements. Police investigating crash Detective Senior Sergeant Christan Fouhy told the Herald two of the children injured in the crash were in a stable condition at Whangārei Hospital, while another was in a serious but stable condition at Starship children's hospital. He also said police were aware of the identities of both youths in the white Toyota. The Herald had been told police identified one of those boys after his mum took him to get medical treatment for injuries suffered in the crash. Fouhy confirmed: 'One of these young males received injuries as a result of the crash.' 'While we are not seeking anyone in connection with the crash, a key focus for investigators is building a picture about the lead-up to the crash.' Fouhy said CCTV footage would be studied and police wanted Kaikohe residents with any information – particularly about a white Toyota Mark X – to make contact. He said police had been told a sedan had been driving 'erratically' along De Merle St in Kaikohe and people with more information should call police. Koni didn't sleep until about 3.30am. She told the Herald every time she closed her eyes, images of the day would flash through her mind. 'I just couldn't stop thinking.' And as she lay there, she heard cars roaring down the road. 'I'm lying there thinking, 'didn't you learn anything?'' David Fisher is based in Northland and has worked as a journalist for more than 30 years, winning multiple journalism awards including being twice named Reporter of the Year and being selected as one of a small number of Wolfson Press Fellows to Wolfson College, Cambridge. He joined the Herald in 2004. Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
