‘There aren't people on Mars': Anthony Albanese criticises Sussan Ley's First Fleet analogy
The prime minister said on Monday that the analogy Ley made in her Australia Day address was 'very strange'.
'I thought when someone said that to me yesterday they were making it up,' Albanese said of Ley's comments, which were part of an Australian Day speech to a church service in Albury.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
'There aren't people that we know of in Mars,' Albanese said. 'Australia was not terra nullius when Captain [Arthur] Phillip and the First Fleet came through Sydney Cove.'
Ley had said in her speech that citizens should be proud of 26 January and denied that the First Fleet had arrived 'as invaders'.
'In what could be compared to Elon Musk's SpaceX's efforts to build a new colony on Mars, men in boats arrived on the edge of the known world to embark on that new experiment,' she said.
'And just like astronauts arriving on Mars, those first settlers would be confronted with a different and strange world, full of danger, adventure and potential. From that moment our national story stood at a crossroads.'
But Albanese said it was a 'very strange analogy to draw, and one that was disrespectful of the fact that there were people here'.
'First Nations people [were] here for tens of thousands [of years and] we have a great privilege of sharing this continent with the oldest continuous culture on Earth,' the prime minister said.
Gallagher, the finance minister, said the comparison drawn by Ley was 'nuts'.
'[It] took me a while to understand what she was trying to say there. But, you know, I'll leave that to Sussan Ley to explain,' she told reporters on Monday.
Ley's speech came a day after the opposition leader, Peter Dutton, added a new government efficiency portfolio to his shadow ministry, a role that drew immediate comparisons with the Musk-led Department of Government Efficiency (Doge) in Donald Trump's new US administration.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
20 minutes ago
- BBC News
Ex-hostage says Trump can bring home all those still captive in Gaza
An American Israeli man who was held captive by Hamas has told the BBC that US President Donald Trump has the power to secure the release of the remaining hostages and end the war in Siegel, 66, was kidnapped from Kibbutz Kfar Aza during the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on 7 October 2023. He was released this February after 484 days in captivity under a ceasefire deal that Trump helped broker just before he took was taken along with his wife, Aviva, who was held for 51 days before being freed during an earlier Siegel was speaking ahead of a meeting between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and President Trump at the White House on Monday evening. In an interview in Tel Aviv, he thanked Trump for securing his own release and said the president could now do the same for the remaining 50 hostages, up to 20 of whom are believed to still be alive."I believe he has a lot of strength, power and ability to put pressure on those that need to be pressured, on both sides in order to get the agreement, get the deal signed, and get all of hostages back and bring it into the war," he has said he hopes a new ceasefire and hostage release deal will be agreed this week, but it appears there are still significant gaps between Israel and two sides resumed indirect talks in Qatar on Sunday evening but they ended after three hours without a breakthrough, according to a Palestinian he flew to Washington DC, Netanyahu said he believed his meeting with Trump could "definitely help advance that result we are all hoping for".It is believed the plan includes the staggered release of 10 living hostages and the bodies of 18 dead hostages in exchange for Palestinians held in Israeli said on Friday that it had delivered a "positive response". But a Palestinian official said it had requested several changes, including a US guarantee that hostilities would not resume if negotiations on an end to the war failed - an idea Netanyahu has previously rejected. Mr Siegel described in vivid detail how Hamas members beat and taunted him, and said he was still haunted by the torture of a female captive he said Hamas operatives had moved him through the streets of Gaza, sometimes in daylight, to 33 different locations during the course of his asked whether he would support a deal which released the hostages but saw Hamas remain in power in Gaza, he replied: "It's of the highest priority and urgency to get all of the 50 hostages back as soon as possible."But he continued: "We cannot let Hamas continue to threaten people and to kill and murder people, and I think Hamas is responsible for death on both sides."Gaza's Hamas-run health ministry says more than 57,000 people have been killed there since Israel launched military operations in response to the 7 October attacks, during which about 1,200 people were killed in Israel and 251 others taken hostage.I asked Mr Siegel, as he continues to campaign for the release of the remaining hostages, whether his thoughts also focus on the suffering of the Gazan population."I believe that peace and security for all people and freedom... are basic human rights that every person deserves," he said."I think it's the responsibility of all leadership to ensure that that happens. Any innocent person that is hurt or killed or murdered is something that I hope or I dream will not happen."
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Tesla shares slump amid Elon Musk's America Party and president Trump drama
Tesla shares plummeted by nearly seven per cent in premarket trading on Monday, as CEO Elon Musk's plans to launch a new American political party reignited concerns about his commitment to the company. The electric vehicle manufacturer is already struggling with declining sales, adding to investor apprehension. Mr Musk unveiled the 'America Party' on Saturday, a development that follows his public spat with president Donald Trump over a tax-cut and spending bill. Their feud escalated into an all-out social media brawl in early June, with Mr Trump threatening to cut off billions of dollars in federal subsidies received by Mr Musk's companies. Musk's political move comes days after Tesla posted a second straight drop in quarterly deliveries, piling pressure on its stock as the company grapples with fierce competition and an aging vehicle line-up. "Investors are worried about two things – one is more Trump ire affecting subsidies and the other, more importantly, is a distracted Musk," said Neil Wilson, UK investor strategist at Saxo Markets. Tesla's stock, which hit a record high in December after Trump's November re-election, has lost 35 per cent since then, making it the worst-performing stock among "the Magnificent Seven" group of high-growth U.S. companies this year. Investors had in May cheered Musk's decision to scale back his political involvement and remain Tesla CEO for another five years. He had spent nearly $300 million around Trump's re-election campaign last year. "But now (they) are worried he's going to (get) sucked back in and take his eye off Tesla," Wilson said. Wedbush analyst Dan Ives, a Tesla bull, said many investors are feeling a "sense of exhaustion" over Musk's insistence on immersing himself in politics. The first signs of investor unease surfaced soon after Musk's announcement, with investment firm Azoria Partners delaying the listing of a Tesla exchange-traded fund. Trump on Sunday called Musk's plans to form the "America Party" " ridiculous", saying the Musk ally he once named to lead NASA would have presented a conflict of interest given Musk's business interests in space. Tesla board moves Azoria Partners CEO James Fishback posted several critical comments on X about Musk's new party, and called for the Tesla board to clarify Musk's political ambitions and evaluate if his political involvement is compatible with his obligations to Tesla as CEO. The new party undermines the confidence shareholders had that Musk would be focusing more on the company, Fishback said. Musk's latest political move raises questions around Tesla board's course of action. Its chair, Robyn Denholm, in May denied a Wall Street Journal report that said board members were looking to replace the CEO. Tesla's board, which has been criticized for failing to provide oversight of its combative, headline-making CEO, faces a dilemma managing him as he oversees five other companies and his personal political ambitions. "This is exactly the kind of thing a board of directors would curtail - removing the CEO if he refused to curtail these kinds of activities," said Ann Lipton, a professor at the University of Colorado Law School and an expert in business law. "The Tesla board has been fairly supine; they have not, at least not in any demonstrable way, taken any action to force Musk to limit his outside ventures, and it's difficult to imagine they would begin now."
Rhyl Journal
2 hours ago
- Rhyl Journal
Nigel Farage says he ‘can't apologise' for lack of MP vetting in general election
On Monday morning, Mr Farage arrived to overcast drizzle at Kent County Council (KCC) in Maidstone, to be greeted by expectant councillors from the Reform-led authority. The visit comes after news that Reform MP for South Basildon and East Thurrock James McMurdock has resigned the party whip amid allegations that he took out government loans during the Covid pandemic for businesses with no employees. Mr Farage was keen to distance himself from the absence of Reform candidate vetting processes for the 2024 general election, and said he 'can't apologise' for it. He said: 'I came in, I inherited this situation where hundreds of candidates who stood in the last general election had not gone through a vetting process. 'I said on July 5, the day after the election last year, that we would now professionalise. 'We put 1,630 candidates into the field on May 1, more than any other party with very, very few rows or arguments – so the vetting process worked for this year, I can't apologise for what happened before.' The Reform leader did not answer when asked whether the allegations faced by Mr McMurdock were an embarrassment for his party. 'Let's find out the truth, I know as much about this right now as you do.' said Mr Farage. He added that he would be heading to Westminster later on Monday to find out more about the situation. Addressing KCC Reform councillors on the steps inside County Hall, he outlined his expectations for them. Mr Farage said: 'Behaving with integrity is a responsibility upon all of you, although that doesn't mean you all have to become stuffed shirts or anything like that. 'You are holders of public office you are responsible and how we behave matters.' Later, he told the PA news agency: 'Yes I think, I think that when you become elected at any level you have a responsibility, 'I'm not asking for stuffed shirts, I'm not asking for boring people. I'm just saying think, think to all of these people here who were basically in 'civvy street' in political terms before May 1, just think before you act.'
