logo
NST Leader: Of CJ and other judges

NST Leader: Of CJ and other judges

There was a palpable sigh of relief when on Thursday night the Chief Registrar's Office announced the appointment of Datuk Wan Ahmad Farid Wan Salleh as the new chief justice, Datuk Abu Bakar Jais as the new Court of Appeal president and Datuk Azizah Nawawi as chief judge of Sabah and Sarawak.
The sigh of relief is understandable. For months, unease had grown across many segments of society over who would fill the big shoes of Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat.
The big shoes were not due to her being the first woman to occupy the seat, but because she was a judge extraordinaire and later, chief justice extraordinaire.
On July 2, when she retired, she left behind a legacy of judicial independence that is hard to beat.
An extension of the service of a judge of such a calibre would have pleased the country immensely, but it didn't happen. Wishes aren't horses.
For avoidance of doubt, the unease — there was even a walk for justice organised by the Malaysian Bar — wasn't about the extension of Tengku Maimun's service, but about perception of all things to do with the judiciary.
Perception of justice is a good cause to fight for, but those given to wild allegations, which at places became venomous, made the national unease worse. When it comes to the judiciary, perception ranks high.
England's chief justice Lord Hewart gave perception of justice its noble place as long ago as Nov 9, 1923, when he spelt out his dictum in Rex v Sussex Justices: "It is not merely of some importance but of fundamental importance that justice should not only be done, but should manifestly be and undoubtedly be seen to be done."
As Malaysians "manifestly" and "undoubtedly" saw justice being done during Tengku Maimun's stewardship of the judiciary, they will now expect the same under the leadership of Wan Ahmad Farid as chief justice.
It is clear that he has big shoes to fill. However, he has shown that he has just the "feet" for them as early as 2022, when he recused himself from hearing a matter concerning the admission of Queen's Counsel Jonathan Laidlaw to represent former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak.
He did that to avoid any perception that might undermine confidence in the judiciary's independence. Before being appointed a judge, he had been actively involved in politics, even serving as a senator.
Malaysian Bar president Mohamad Ezri Abdul Wahab praised the new chief justice for recusing himself: "In doing so, he made several significant statements on the importance of public confidence in the judiciary, stating that the perception of judicial independence must not be placed in doubt and that it is not a matter of trial and error."
An independent judiciary is a precious gift to any society, and once it is lost, anarchy reigns, wrote Wan Ahmad Farid as a High Court judge when recusing himself on June 16, 2022.
We hope the judiciary under the new chief justice's stewardship will do everything necessary to prevent the precious gift from being lost.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Bar Council EGM on judicial independence dissolves due to lack of quorum
Bar Council EGM on judicial independence dissolves due to lack of quorum

The Star

time44 minutes ago

  • The Star

Bar Council EGM on judicial independence dissolves due to lack of quorum

The Malaysian Bar's Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) was cancelled after failing to meet its 500-member quorum, as announced by President Mohamad Ezri Abdul Wahab in Kuala Lumpur on Saturday, July 26, 2025. — RAJA FAISAL HISHAN/The Star The Malaysian Bar's extraordinary general meeting (EGM) to debate two motions on judicial independence could not proceed after failing to gather a quorum of 500 lawyers on Saturday (July 26). Bar Council chairman Ezri Abdul Wahab said only 309 of the 24,000 members in the Peninsula attended, leading to the EGM's dissolution. "We are disappointed as every EGM requires financial resources, and we aimed to address urgent issues on judicial independence," said Ezri. This is not the first time a Bar Council EGM has dissolved due to a lack of quorum. Ezri said the Bar Council will use a resolution from the previous AGM in May, allowing the leadership to defend the judiciary. "We will use the resolution to proceed with necessary actions. I cannot explain why members did not attend. We hoped younger lawyers would support the motion on remuneration for pupils, but that was not the case," he added. Ezri believes many issues have been resolved, and members' aspirations have been addressed by the Bar Council. Bar Council Vice President Anand Raj said the quorum failure does not imply a lack of trust in the leadership. "It indicates our actions thus far have been sufficient and align with members' expectations. Those who attended wanted to contribute, but the majority have entrusted us with a broad mandate," said Anand. He noted that 1,600 lawyers participated in a recent walk for an independent judiciary on July 14. Former Attorney General Tan Sri Tommy Thomas and activist Siti Kasim were present at the event. Lawyer Vince Tan expressed frustration by saying that "500 of 24,000 lawyers could not turn up!" The first motion, titled "Judicial Independence", was to be mooted by chairman Ezri. The second motion, "Hold the prime minister accountable for undermining public confidence in the judiciary", was to be proposed by lawyers Malik Imtiaz Sarwar and Surendra Ananth. A third motion, "Implementing a Fair Rate of Minimum Remuneration for Pupils", was by Goh Cia Yee and Vince Tan. On March 15, the Bar unanimously passed two amended resolutions reaffirming its stance against interference in the judiciary by the executive, legislature, or other unauthorised individuals. The EGM was called on July 1 amid concerns over the retirement of Chief Justice Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, who was set to reach the mandatory retirement age of 66. On July 14, a large group of lawyers gathered outside the Palace of Justice to march in defence of the judiciary's integrity. Ezri then submitted a memorandum to Zamri Misman, the legal affairs department's director-general, on behalf of the Prime Minister's Office. The memorandum called for appointing judicial leaders with integrity and a track record of quality judgments and for filling judicial vacancies swiftly to prevent delays in case hearings.

Ali Baba and the filthy rich thieves
Ali Baba and the filthy rich thieves

Malaysiakini

time44 minutes ago

  • Malaysiakini

Ali Baba and the filthy rich thieves

COMMENT | The RM100 handout helps, but Malaysians will continue to struggle with their finances given the rising costs of goods, services and taxes. Harder still is keeping up with the corruption cases in our courts and the daily chorus of arrests and investigations by the MACC, making us wonder whether our B40 is the end product of corruption after all. But for those who persevere, they will be justly rewarded, jalabiyas and all, with a journey on a flying carpet to Old Baghdad in the time of Ali Baba circa 900 CE of the Abbasid Caliphate. It's where opulence, religiosity and scholarship co-existed in happy harmony with thievery, corruption and abuse of power until the rider became heavier than the horse, causing the Caliphate to totter under its own weight.

'Turun Anwar': What's next?
'Turun Anwar': What's next?

Malaysiakini

time2 hours ago

  • Malaysiakini

'Turun Anwar': What's next?

COMMENT | I can understand the frustration many liberal and ethnic-minority Malaysians feel about Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim. From Najib Abdul Razak to Ahmad Zahid Hamidi, from the Sabah mining licence scandal to the judicial crisis, from KK Mart to Teoh Beng Hock, they find Anwar more like an old Umno leader than the man who had fought 25 years to end Umno's hegemony. Many of these disillusioned voters may not come out to vote in the next general election, or if they do, they may vote for smaller parties or even Perikatan Nasional in protest. Some even hope that the 'Turun Anwar' rally this afternoon would start his downfall or at least humble him.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store