logo
BBC did not mention Adams allegation, Donaldson family's former solicitor says

BBC did not mention Adams allegation, Donaldson family's former solicitor says

Gerry Adams was not mentioned in interactions between the solicitor representing the family of a man who was killed and a BBC team making a documentary on the matter, a libel trial relating to the programme has heard.
Mr Adams is suing the BBC over accusations contained in a broadcast of the Spotlight documentary series and an accompanying online article which alleged he had sanctioned the killing of Denis Donaldson.
Mr Donaldson was shot dead in 2006, months after admitting his role as a police and MI5 agent for 20 years.
In 2009 the Real IRA admitted killing Mr Donaldson, and the Spotlight programme was broadcast in September 2016.
At the High Court in Dublin on Thursday, Mr Adams' barrister Tom Hogan brought the family's solicitor from the time of the programme as a witness.
Ciaran Shiels, a solicitor and partner at Madden and Finucane Solicitors, told the court that the BBC was not only 'barking up the wrong tree' but was in the 'wrong orchard' over the claims against Mr Adams.
Mr Shiels said he represented Mr Donaldson and his family from a period before his death until a period after the broadcast.
He said he came to act as a spokesperson for the family after Mr Donaldson's death but said he no longer does so.
Mr Shiels, who works mainly in criminal defence work, told the jury about his interactions with the BBC team in the months up to the broadcast – including journalist Jennifer O'Leary.
He said he did not represent Mr Adams and said his concern was about the relatives of Mr Donaldson.
Asked if there was any mention of Mr Adams in any of his interactions with the BBC, Mr Shiels said: 'I don't think his name was even suggested.
'Nowhere, and I would have remembered if it had.'
Asked by Mr Hogan what he would have said to Ms O'Leary if she had put forward the allegations against Mr Adams, Mr Shiels said: 'I would have said to her that not only was she barking up the wrong tree, she wasn't even in the right orchard.'
He said the idea that Mr Adams somehow authorised the murder or that it was the Provisional IRA that carried it out 'did not marry' in any way with the lines of inquiry being followed by police, the understanding of the family, or 'common sense'.
Mr Shiels said it was a 'pretty perverse statement and depiction as to what happened'.
He added that the family did not accept or believe in any way that Mr Adams had anything to do with it.
Mr Shiels added: 'Mr Adams was seen as a family friend, he was trusted by the family, the family would have felt that he had integrity, the family would be streetwise enough to know that the persons who the guards had identified as people who would be – they believed to be involved in the murder would have no truck with Mr Adams and Mr Adams would have no truck with them.'
Earlier in the proceedings, Mr Shiels said he had been contacted by Ms O'Leary from the BBC on April 4 2016 – the 10th anniversary of Mr Donaldson's death.
He said they wanted to speak to him about a number of issues, including the 'Stormontgate' affair which involved an allegation that Sinn Fein was operating a spy ring in which Mr Donaldson was arrested, how that resulted in the collapse of powersharing institutions, and the circumstances under which he had outed himself as an informant.
Mr Shiels said he was also 'concerned' after being asked if he knew why Mr Donaldson had become a British agent and there were discussions about indiscretion in his private life – that there may have been an affair or that he may have been a homosexual.
He said the family had a right to privacy and that there had been a previous 'quite sensationalist and gory' documentary which featured a reconstruction of the murder that 'hurt the family'.
Mr Shiels said that Mr Donaldson's location had been front page news in a newspaper three weeks prior to his killing, and added that the family were 'concerned about further irresponsible journalism taking place'.
He said: 'People were still grieving, people were still trying to get on with their lives.
'It was very difficult to see what possible good could come from this.'
Mr Shiels added: 'Previously when this subject was looked at in the media, this ended in disaster.'
At the same time, he said the family were demoralised that an inquest into Mr Donaldson's death was not commencing substantively.
Under questioning from Mr Hogan, Mr Shiels outlined a series of correspondence and interactions between him and the BBC about the upcoming programme.
He said it was made clear that the family did not want to take part in the documentary but it was put forward that he would be interviewed on their behalf.
He said at some point relationships between the BBC and the family 'went south'.
Mr Shiels said the family had five years prior put out a press statement outlining frustrations that Irish police, An Garda Siochana, were primarily focused on who had pulled the trigger to kill Mr Donaldson rather than the circumstances around him being 'burned as an agent'.
He said this involved him being notified there was a threat to his life, and interactions with his handler known as 'Lenny'.
Mr Shiels said the family were 'credulous' that gardai could not see a linkage between the two and that that was where the inquiry should be starting.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The Bronx's floating jail is finally getting the boot—here's what's taking its place
The Bronx's floating jail is finally getting the boot—here's what's taking its place

Time Out

time6 hours ago

  • Time Out

The Bronx's floating jail is finally getting the boot—here's what's taking its place

The infamous 'floating jail' moored off Hunts Point is finally being sent downriver. The Vernon C. Bain Correctional Center, known to many simply as 'The Barge,' will be removed from the Bronx waterfront, clearing the way for a major new infrastructure project: the Hunts Point Marine Terminal. Mayor Eric Adams announced the plans on Monday at a press conference near the site, calling the project part of his administration's broader 'Blue Highways' initiative. The initiative aims to shift freight delivery away from diesel-guzzling trucks and toward marine and electric transport, using the city's waterways to cut emissions and ease street congestion. 'This is lowering emissions, bringing jobs and creating a vibrant community here in the Bronx by boosting economic output,' Adams said, standing near a rendering of the future terminal. The floating jail, opened in 1992 as a stopgap for Rikers Island overcrowding, was only meant to be temporary. Instead, it operated for more than 30 years, housing up to 800 detainees at its peak. The barge was decommissioned in 2023, but it remained docked until now. Its removal marks a milestone in the city's long-term decarceration efforts and in the transformation of South Bronx infrastructure. According to the city's Economic Development Corporation, the new terminal will generate roughly 400 construction jobs, 100 permanent jobs and $3.9 billion in economic impact over the next 30 years. It's expected to remove 9,000 truck trips from city streets each month, particularly from communities like the South Bronx, which have long borne the brunt of traffic-related pollution. 'The vision to transform the decommissioned Vernon C. Bain Center into the Hunts Point Marine Terminal will usher in a new era for this site that will result in not only a new 'Blue Highways' facility, but bring waterfront access, greenway improvements, and much-needed good-paying jobs for the Hunts Point community,' said NYCEDC president and CEO Andrew Kimball. The marine terminal is currently entering the design and planning phase. NYCEDC will also begin environmental remediation of the land, which is expected to be finished by 2027. The terminal will serve as a key node in the city's growing Blue Highways network, including the Brooklyn Marine Terminal and other proposed waterfront logistics hubs. For Hunts Point, the change signals a long-overdue shift—from isolation and incarceration to jobs, investment and cleaner air.

The Gold loses its shine
The Gold loses its shine

New Statesman​

time7 hours ago

  • New Statesman​

The Gold loses its shine

Photo by BBC / Tannadice Pictures The BBC's second series of its crime drama The Gold, about the 1983 Brink's-Mat heist, picks up where things left off: about half the loot that the robbers stole from a security depot near Heathrow remains unaccounted for. The gold – worth over £110m in today's money – turned out to be rather more than the six lads could handle, and in the first series they all (more or less) ended up paying for their greed. The show's creator, Neil Forsyth, took a calculated risk in choosing to concentrate on the robbery's aftermath, rather than the theft itself – which was dealt with in about five propulsive minutes. Instead, he homed in on the gangsters' increasingly convoluted attempts to convert the bars into the lavish lives they'd always dreamed of. This time round, the investigation is being led again by DCI Boyce (a sturdy but rather dull Hugh Bonneville), with help from perky DIs Jennings (Charlotte Spencer) and Brightwell (Emun Elliott), plus a new addition, DI Lundy (a classy Stephen Campbell Moore). In the last series, Boyce was sceptical of the talents of his underlings but came round; now, they get along famously. Still, the investigation is under threat from paper-pushers higher up, who feel it's dragging on too long, costing too much and failing to produce any wins that can be published in the newspapers. Amid a few irritating tics is the series' insistent use of the word 'villain'. Do criminals really self-identify as villains, as they do here? Do coppers chasing such villains also refer to them as villains? It seems unlikely, but they do here, over and over. On that note, the villains in our sights are John Palmer (Tom Cullen), a gold-dealer-turned-fraudster living it large in Tenerife, and Charlie Miller (Sam Spruell), a run-of-the-mill crook who, unlike Palmer, isn't a real person but an amalgam of various people. Also in play, most enjoyably, is disgraced lawyer Douglas Baxter, a fictional character played with delicious waspishness by Joshua McGuire. Baxter has been struck off, we learn, after being caught taking cocaine at a steakhouse, and he is soon persuaded by Miller to start laundering huge wodges of cash for him. More than any other character, Baxter feels decidedly imaginary: he is, he believes, one of the finest legal minds of his generation; aged eight, he was accepted into Mensa. It's hard to believe such a clever-clogs would ever consort with a low-life so obviously doomed as Miller – but Baxter is excellent company, so his lack of credibility is quickly forgiven. The series is, like its predecessor, easy on the eye, with an invigorating soundtrack and solid performances. But the script tends towards the grandiose (DCI Boyce loves a little speech), and as the action flits between London, the Caribbean, the Isle of Man, Cornwall and Tenerife, it can be hard to follow. When a bunch of dead-eyed Russians turn up in Tenerife, wanting their money laundered too, you just want them to go away and stop complicating things. After being criticised for presenting gangsters with a rosy tint in the first series, particularly the robber and killer Kenneth Noye (played with dash by Slow Horses'Jack Lowden), the second series tries to darken Noye's portrayal. In the first, Lowden's Noye was a Robin Hood type inclined to see his trade in class terms: 'That's how England works,' he remarked at one point. 'That lot have it and us lot nick it.' Noye's killing of a police officer was covered but felt random and underpowered, and the series didn't go up to 1996, when he murdered a 21-year-old on an M25 slip road. Even so, Palmer comes across as rather appealing: a 'villain', to be sure, but a warm and handsome one, who bids his colleagues goodbye at the end of the working day, loves his kids and gives his wife thoughtful presents. Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe Forsyth has confirmed that there will not be a third series, and the Brink's-Mat lemon does feel sucked dry by the end of this one. Still, taken together, both series are a real achievement: not particularly innovative television, but dependable and made with palpable craft and commitment. The Gold BBC One [See also: The People's Republic of iPhone] Related

It's no surprise that Prevent has gone to the dogs
It's no surprise that Prevent has gone to the dogs

Spectator

time8 hours ago

  • Spectator

It's no surprise that Prevent has gone to the dogs

Conquest's Second Law states that the behaviour of an organisation can best be predicted by assuming it's controlled by a secret cabal of its enemies – and that certainly seems to apply to Prevent (although it's a 'programme' rather than an organisation). Prevent is a key strand of the counter-terrorism framework introduced after the 7/7 bombings and aims to stop people becoming radicalised. Given the historical context – and the fact that 75 per cent of MI5's counter-terrorism work involves monitoring Islamist extremists – you'd think the main focus would be radical Islam. At least, you would if you weren't familiar with Conquest's Second Law. Of the 6,817 people referred to Prevent in the year ending 31 March 2023, just 11 per cent were suspected of Islamist extremism, compared with 19 per cent in danger of succumbing to 'extreme right-wing terrorism'. And according to a Prevent Refresher Awareness Course on the Home Office website, one of the three most common subcategories of extreme right-wing terrorist ideology is 'cultural nationalism'.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store