logo
California Republicans help clinch megabill

California Republicans help clinch megabill

Politico03-07-2025
DRIVING THE DAY: If your inbox exploded this afternoon, it was the sound of the House passing Donald Trump's megabill.
Vulnerable California Republicans who helped push the legislation across the finish line were facing enormous pressure from the president and his allies.
But it was a perilous vote. Central Valley Rep. David Valadao and Orange County Rep. Young Kim ultimately supported the domestic spending package in spite of deeper Senate Medicaid reductions they criticized in a letter to Majority Leader John Thune and Speaker Mike Johnson just last week.
Now, they will confront a barrage of attacks from Democrats. More than 60 percent of Valadao's constituents are recipients of Medi-Cal, the state's version of the federal health care program for the poorest Americans.
Valadao said in a statement that the vote was 'not an easy decision for me.' While he still has concerns about some of the Medicaid changes, he was heartened to see money for rural hospitals included in the bill.
'Ultimately, I voted for this bill because it does preserve the Medicaid program for its intended recipients — children, pregnant women, the disabled, and elderly,' he said.
FUNDS LACKING: Five years after Gov. Gavin Newsom created a task force to study reparations, California Democrats still can't get an agency to administer programs off the ground.
The latest setback came this week, with lawmakers and Newsom unwilling to put money behind a state office needed to power programs for descendants of slaves — a project that's become mired in deficit woes and shifting politics.
The state budget Newsom signed did not contain funding to stand up the agency. Caucus Chair Akilah Weber Pierson's bill establishing the office continues to move through the Capitol, although without funding it will be vulnerable to a veto even if it clears the Legislature.
Caucus members and their allies insist they've made progress enacting hundreds of recommendations to address discrimination and create a more equitable state.
But Black lawmakers have struggled to advance foundational legislation that requires ongoing state dollars, especially as leaders just spent most of the year closing a $12 billion spending gap. They're also up against a backlash to the racial justice movement that took hold five years ago, as well as a presidential administration trying to rid the country of DEI initiatives.
Last year, a proposal to stand up a reparations agency stalled on the final day of session amid infighting in the Black Caucus and last-minute amendments from Newsom.
This year's attempt is now on shaky ground, hinging on a longshot effort to fund it.
Los Angeles Assemblymember Isaac Bryan, caucus vice chair, acknowledged these difficulties during an Assembly Judiciary Committee hearing this week.
'If anything is to get established, it's probably going to take some incredible lifting from the Black Caucus,' he said. 'We're not talking about one-time money. We're talking about ongoing money during a deficit.'
The budget did include the $12 million state leaders had set aside for reparations last year. Half of that will go to a California State University study determining how people will prove they're descendants of slaves, and the rest will fund an educational campaign about reparations administered by the Tides Foundation, a San Francisco-based nonprofit that supports progressive social causes.
Riverside Assemblymember Corey Jackson, a caucus member, said the group 'always knew this was going to be a long process.'
'We know we're going to get it done,' Jackson said of the agency. 'The question is when? And so every year we'll reintroduce it, because you never know what the budget situation is going to be.'
Despite the setbacks, Jackson and task force member Lisa Holder framed lawmakers' progress as significant, given the state of the reparations movement nationally.
'Since emancipation, African Americans have been calling on these governments to put money toward harm repair, reparations,' Holder told Playbook in an interview before the budget was finalized. 'This is the first time that a state has put $12 million just to create a pathway for legislation.'
Jackson called California's movement 'the only game in town in the nation,' a situation underlined in May, when Maryland Gov. Wes Moore vetoed a bill that would've created a similar reparations task force in his state. Illinois and New York previously passed bills to study reparations.
But some reparations supporters are tired of studies. One faction has gone as far as opposing Black Caucus bills, arguing they are too incremental and don't advance their cause.
Bryan said he fears the agency money won't come through because of such 'distractions,' which offer an 'easy out to not do anything budgetarily because folks are confused by spectacles like this.'
'It's important for the governor to put dollars into this effort,' he said. 'And it's important for the state to put efforts [into] this. And I'm hoping there's future budget trailer bills coming down the line that include priorities for Black Californians.'
IT'S THURSDAY AFTERNOON. This is California Playbook PM, a POLITICO newsletter that serves as an afternoon temperature check on California politics and a look at what our policy reporters are watching. Got tips or suggestions? Shoot an email to lholden@politico.com.
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW TODAY
DEPORTATION DEBATE: State senators today debated for hours over a resolution condemning ICE raids and the president's troop deployment in response to Los Angeles deportation protests.
Democrats spoke about how they had been personally affected by ICE arrests, while Republicans said federal action was the result of California policies making it harder for immigration officials to target criminals.
But with Democrats in charge in Sacramento, the resolution passed. Baldwin Park state Sen. Susan Rubio said she carries her passport with her because she's afraid of being deported. San Fernando Valley state Sen. Caroline Menjivar said immigration officials detained the father of one of her staffers, even though he's a citizen.
'What is it?' she asked. 'It's that I'm too brown. You're too brown. Your skin is not pale enough. That's what it is. That's what it comes down to.'
As we reported last week, the Latino and AAPI caucuses are pushing to fast-track a slate of immigration bills responding to the raids.
Latino Caucus Chair Lena Gonzalez told Playbook today she hopes to get them through the Legislature before lawmakers go on a month-long summer recess starting July 18. She said Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas, Senate President Pro Tem Mike McGuire and the governor are supportive of the effort.
'We're just trying to figure out what timing, but the sooner the better,' Gonzalez said. 'We're in negotiations right now about that, but we want to get these done.'
IN OTHER NEWS
NEWSOM HITS THE TRAIL: The governor is headed to South Carolina next week to meet with natural disaster victims, touching down in an early primary state ahead of a likely run for president in 2028, our Jacob Wendler reports.
The South Carolina Democratic Party announced the trip today, saying Newsom will 'speak to the urgent need for federal support and investment' in the wake of Hurricane Helene and the Los Angeles wildfires.
Newsom traveled to the state in January 2024 to stump for then-President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris in the run-up to the presidential election. He received some early interest, but also doubts about his liberal reputation, POLITICO reported at the time.
The state has held a key role in recent nominating contests as the first state in the South to vote. The Democratic National Committee — under Biden — elevated it to be the first sanctioned primary contest in 2024.
CALLING STRIKES: State Attorney General Rob Bonta released his long-awaited opinion on fantasy sports betting today, declaring that online platforms operating in California are in violation of a state law that bans betting on the outcome of sporting events.
Bonta wrote that daily sports fantasy sites, which allow gambling based on the real-world performance of individual athletes, are merely a 'modern variation' of sports betting.
'California law prohibits the operation of daily fantasy sports games with players physically located within California, regardless of where the operators and associated technology are located,' Bonta concluded.
It's unclear what enforcement action Bonta's office might take as a result. In a statement, the state Department of Justice said it 'expects companies to come into compliance with the law.'
But Newsom's office was quick to say he disagrees with Bonta's conclusion — a rare split between the state's Democratic governor and its top prosecutor. Diana Crofts-Pelayo, a spokesperson for Newsom, noted that the attorney general issued the opinion 'in his independent capacity.'
'While the Governor does not agree with the outcome, he welcomes a constructive path forward in collaboration with all stakeholders,' Crofts-Pelayo said in a statement.
Bonta's opinion is a response to a request from Republican state lawmakers, who asked him to evaluate the legality of online fantasy sports. Tribal communities — which spent tens of millions of dollars to defeat a 2022 measure to legalize sports gambling — also pushed for the opinion.
Tribal casinos want to block the fantasy industry's growth, and the California Nations Indian Gaming Association on Friday urged Bonta to enforce his opinion by cracking down on sports betting platforms.
'Untold millions if not billions have been illegally wagered over the past decade,' CNIGA Chairman James Siva said in a statement. 'Where is the enforcement? Where is the accountability?'
Fantasy sports platform operators argue that their sites shouldn't be considered traditional sports wagering because selecting players to create a fictional roster of athletes is a game of skill, not chance.
JT Foley, executive director of the Coalition for Fantasy Sports, said the industry agrees with Newsom that 'AG Bonta got it wrong.'
'We are hopeful the attorney general heeds the governor's call to find a constructive solution that preserves the games that California sports fans love,' Foley said in a statement. — Dustin Gardiner
WHAT WE'RE READING TODAY
— Some communities in the Los Angeles region have been canceling Fourth of July plans amid heightened fears and anger following recent immigration raids at farms and businesses in the city. (New York Times)
— Two of the largest school districts in and around the Fresno region expect to lose a combined $9.3 million following the Trump administration's decision to withhold billions of dollars that Congress allocated to K-12 schools in the country. (Fresno Bee)
— The El Rancho Unified School District released a video allegedly showing ICE and Border Patrol agents urinating at a school campus in Pico Rivera. (ABC 7)
AROUND THE STATE
— Federal cleanup crews from the Eaton and Palisades wildfires improperly sent truckloads of waste tainted with asbestos to nonhazardous landfills, state and local records show. (Los Angeles Times)
— A federal judge in San Diego struck down two state laws that effectively banned most non-California residents from carrying guns in the state. (San Diego Union-Tribune)
— Palmdale Mayor Richard J. Loa was stripped of his title and responsibilities pending an investigation into 'confidential allegations.' (KTLA 5)
— compiled by Juliann Ventura
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

How to achieve the balanced immigration policy Americans want
How to achieve the balanced immigration policy Americans want

The Hill

time10 minutes ago

  • The Hill

How to achieve the balanced immigration policy Americans want

Terrified employees are not showing up to work. Children who are American citizens are being deported without due process. Crops are being left to rot because farms can't find workers to pick them. The Trump administration has claimed this is the price of a secure border. But Americans are no longer buying it. A record-high 79 percent of Americans now say immigration is a good thing for the country — a growing majority clearly believes U.S. policy should address immigration's benefits, as well as its risks. A balanced policy is possible. By the end of its time in office, the Biden administration had brought order to the border. In our new research paper, we examine the successes and shortcomings of Biden's term, offering lessons for a more pragmatic migration policy — one that advances America's broad range of economic, security and humanitarian interests. We would be the first to acknowledge that the Biden administration's response to record migration flows was imperfect. The administration was slow to support cities struggling with unprecedented migrant arrivals, ceded the narrative to its critics by playing defense on communications and waited too long to ramp up its enforcement efforts. But by the end of 2024, total monthly encounters at the Southern border fell from a high of 300,000 to fewer than 100,000. In fact, the number of authorized encounters at ports of entry via programs, such as CBP One and the special program for for Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans and Venezuelans, exceeded the number of unauthorized encounters. Put another way, more than 80 percent of the current reduction we see in unauthorized border encounters occurred during the Biden administration. The Trump administration has reduced encounters from their prior levels by an additional 17 percent through costly and draconian measures. The immigration lessons from Biden's term are not always intuitive. First, enforcement and lawful pathways are not opposing strategies — they are interdependent. We have often heard the refrain of needing to crack down first, and only then consider expanding lawful pathways. But the data tells a different story. When the U.S. paired increased enforcement with credible legal alternatives, irregular crossings plummeted. It was this mix — not enforcement alone — that brought numbers down. Second, emergency parole programs were a key, if imperfect, tool. Humanitarian parole, including the CHNV process, allowed people to apply from where they were, enabling vetted migrants to join the U.S. labor force quickly, helping avoid a post-pandemic recession. That said, parole programs are not a durable solution. Congress must finally revisit decades-old visa caps and instead build a flexible and demand-driven approach that better matches migrants with labor needs across the skill spectrum. Third, regional cooperation mattered more than most Americans realize. Countries such as Colombia, Brazil, Ecuador and Peru gave legal status to over 4.5 million displaced Venezuelans, preventing an even larger surge north. The U.S. backed those efforts with foreign assistance and diplomacy. It paid off, as fewer people were forced to keep moving. It was far cheaper, too. Integration costs were estimated at $600 per migrant in Colombia, for instance, compared to the over $17,000 price tag to apprehend, detain and deport someone at the U.S. border. Western Hemisphere countries also worked together to increase migrant screening and vetting, coordinate on transit visa policies and investigate traffickers. Migration diplomacy under the Biden administration was a two-way street, with the U.S. encouraging countries to do more but also providing foreign assistance and political cover. When we recognize that migration is a hemispheric challenge, not just a U.S. one, we get better results. Finally, if we want to avoid the next migration surge, we need to understand what drove the last one. Yes, the Biden administration's shift in tone influenced flows at the border. But the deeper drivers were structural: a post-pandemic labor market desperate for workers; Title 42 expulsions that perversely encouraged repeated crossings; and the largest displacement crisis in the hemisphere's history, fueled mainly by Venezuela's economic collapse. Migration pressure doesn't simply disappear — it builds up. By slashing foreign aid, abandoning multilateralism and pouring resources almost exclusively into border security and internal enforcement, the Trump administration has bet everything on deterrence. If these tactics merely delay rather than prevent a future crisis, the administration may wish it had more tools available to respond. We share these lessons not to fight old battles but to shape a smarter way forward. Last month, a bipartisan group of House members reintroduced the Dignity Act, coupling a pathway to legal status for undocumented immigrants in the U.S. with stronger enforcement. There's a growing recognition in Congress that waiting for a 'grand bargain' has become an excuse for doing nothing. Narrow, targeted reforms — expediting work permits, closing asylum loopholes, expanding permanent and temporary lawful visas, creating a path to legal status for those who have lived here for many years, and promoting talent retention — are all achievable, necessary and in our national interest. Three decades of stalemate have made clear that inaction on immigration carries immense costs. Those who believe in a better way must seize the opportunity to pursue pragmatic policies, whenever it emerges.

Trump picks Democrat to lead energy regulatory commission
Trump picks Democrat to lead energy regulatory commission

The Hill

time10 minutes ago

  • The Hill

Trump picks Democrat to lead energy regulatory commission

President Trump has selected a Democrat to chair the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) – a surprising move that passes over the panel's one Republican member. Trump selected David Rosner, who was nominated to the commission by President Biden as its leader. Rosner is a former aide to then-Sen. Joe Manchin ( who led the Senate's Energy and Natural Resources Committee. 'I am honored to serve as Chairman and excited to continue working with my colleagues on the Commission and FERC's extraordinary staff to enable reliable, affordable, and abundant energy for all Americans,' Rosner said. FERC is an agency that regulates cross-state energy pipelines and power lines as well as gas export terminals. The commission is made up of five commissioners who are appointed by presidents but do not necessarily answer to a particular administration – though the president can select who chairs it. The chair of FERC is in charge of its administrative operations and sets its agenda, deciding what matters get votes. The panel has two Democratic members, Rosner and Judy Chang, and one Republican member, Lindsay See.

Trump's BLS Pick Fuels Fears of Rigged CPI, Social Security COLA Cuts
Trump's BLS Pick Fuels Fears of Rigged CPI, Social Security COLA Cuts

Newsweek

time11 minutes ago

  • Newsweek

Trump's BLS Pick Fuels Fears of Rigged CPI, Social Security COLA Cuts

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. President Donald Trump's nomination of E.J. Antoni, a Heritage Foundation economist, to lead the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) has triggered concerns over the potential politicization of key economic data—particularly the Consumer Price Index (CPI), which is used to calculate Social Security cost-of-living adjustments (COLA) for seniors. "Seniors should know that the COLA on their Social Security benefits is tied to the CPI," former Treasury official Bruce Bartlett posted on X this week. "If the CPI is artificially reduced, as Trump wants, your benefits will be reduced." Antoni has repeatedly described Social Security as unsustainable and has advocated for its eventual phase-out. In a 2024 radio interview, he called the 90-year-old program a "Ponzi scheme," arguing that current beneficiaries should continue receiving benefits, but future retirees should not rely on it. "Eventually you need to sunset the program," Antoni said last December. He argued that while current beneficiaries would remain protected, younger Americans should transition to private accounts. "The people who are going to retire 10, 20, even 30, or certainly 40 years from now—I'm sorry, but the program is not going to be viable at that time". Donald Trump and economist E.J. Antoni in the Oval Office after Antoni's nomination to lead the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Donald Trump and economist E.J. Antoni in the Oval Office after Antoni's nomination to lead the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The White House Even Small Data Tweaks Could Mean Billions in Cuts In an interview with Fox News Digital earlier this week, Antoni said that, if confirmed, the BLS should consider pausing the monthly jobs report because of flaws in current data collection. His proposal, along with his views on Social Security, has raised concerns about the politicization of the bureau's key statistics particularly after the president fired the previous BLS chief after a soft jobs report earlier this month. Economists consulted by Newsweek warn that underreporting inflation data—even marginally—could quietly erode retirees' purchasing power over time. "If inflation is understated, then beneficiaries will have less ability to afford the goods and services they need," said Todd Belt, professor of political management at George Washington University. Dean Baker, co-founder of the Center for Economic and Policy Research, quantified the long-term impact. "If you reduced the measured rate of inflation by 0.2–0.3 percentage points annually, then someone would be getting about 2.5 percent less in benefits after 10 years, 5 percent after 20 years and 7.5 percent after 30 years," he said. This concern extends beyond benefits. Baker noted that while a move to a lower-measuring index like the alternative known as "chained CPI" would technically require an act of Congress, "it seems the law doesn't really matter anymore." Cartons of eggs are seen for sale in a Kroger grocery store on August 15, 2022 in Houston, Texas. Egg prices steadily climb in the U.S. as inflation continues impacting grocery stores nationwide. Cartons of eggs are seen for sale in a Kroger grocery store on August 15, 2022 in Houston, Texas. Egg prices steadily climb in the U.S. as inflation continues impacting grocery stores nationwide. Brandon Bell/Getty Brian Albrecht, chief economist at the International Center for Law and Economics, added that even small distortions could be difficult to undo. "If inflation were truly 10 percent in a given year but reported as 0 percent, your check the following year would not rise at all," he said. "Even small manipulations of the data can have long-term effects that are very difficult to correct." But manipulating inflation data would not be an easy task. Albrecht pushed back on assumptions that CPI data can be easily gamed. "People dig into those numbers item by item. If you claimed everything in the basket went up 2 percent but reported CPI as 1 percent, it wouldn't add up. That scrutiny makes manipulation harder to hide." "It's just very hard to do," added Andrew Biggs, a former principal deputy commissioner at the Social Security Administration (SSA), about the prospect of manipulating inflation statistics. While the BLS could, in theory, change the methodology or sampling of the CPI-W, a subset of CPI specific to urban areas, Biggs emphasized that "outright rigging is technically demanding, especially for a political appointee working with career employees." Erica Groshen, who served as BLS commissioner under President Obama, added that such changes would require public transparency. "According to OMB Statistical Policy Directive 3, any such major changes need to be announced in advance in the Federal Register," she said. Still, the stakes are high. Groshen noted that even a 0.01 percentage point understatement of the inflation rate would reduce payments to all Social Security beneficiaries—seniors and disabled—by about $1 billion annually. Whether such changes amount to a "stealth benefit cut," she said, "depends on how it was communicated." Trust in CPI Could Erode Public and Market Confidence The CPI-W, a legacy index the measures inflation for "urban wage owners" dating back to 1972, is used only by the Social Security Administration; other agencies, including the Congressional Budget Office and the Federal Reserve, rely on the Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) index, which tends to show lower inflation. "The Social Security Commissioner is required to select a measure of inflation, but not necessarily the CPI-W," Biggs, the former principal deputy commissioner at the SSA, said. A screen shows stock prices on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, Friday, Aug. 1, 2025, in New York. A screen shows stock prices on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, Friday, Aug. 1, 2025, in New York. Yuki Iwamura/AP That distinction underscores the political and policy pressure surrounding Antoni's nomination. Critics argue that a shift in the CPI-W's methodology—if perceived as biased—could spark a crisis of credibility. "Reports like the jobs report and CPI aren't just for PR purposes—Wall Street and many markets depend on them," said Anna Tavis, academic director of the Human Capital Management Department at NYU's School of Professional Studies. She also warned that undermining the credibility of official data could drive companies toward costly private analytics. "Those alternatives won't be free." The private sector isn't the only area that could be rattled. Michael Feroli, chief U.S. economist at JPMorgan Chase, told Reuters that suspicions about manipulated CPI figures could distort the $2.1 trillion Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) market, which exists to protect investors from inflation. "There's real money on the line here," he said. The concerns are not just technical—they're about trust. "You have an economy operating in a different reality than the reported numbers," said Belt, the GWU professor. "That creates uncertainty, which is the enemy of good business behavior."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store