logo
Stamp duty crackdown: legacy of lax enforcement or legal duty ignored?

Stamp duty crackdown: legacy of lax enforcement or legal duty ignored?

From Andrew Ewe
The Inland Revenue Board's (IRB) recent focus on unstamped employment letters, service contracts, and other instruments has caused understandable alarm among employers across Malaysia.
What many are only now discovering is that the legal obligation to stamp these documents has existed since the Stamp Act 1949 – a statute that turns 75 this year.
The sudden enforcement drive, under the newly released Stamp Duty Audit Framework effective Jan 1, 2025, raises a fundamental question of fairness and principle: Can a law that was dormant for decades suddenly be brought to life, with penalties imposed on businesses that have long followed an unofficial industry norm?
A legacy of lax enforcement
For over half a century, the IRB rarely enforced the stamping of employment contracts or service agreements with periodic payments. Companies – large and small – operated under the reasonable assumption that such documents were not subject to stamping, or that even if they were, it wasn't practically required.
This long period of non-enforcement effectively shaped market behaviour. Employers routinely issued letters of appointment, fixed-term contracts, and professional engagement agreements without stamping, and the IRB neither objected nor intervened.
The role of legitimate expectation
In public law, the concept of legitimate expectation arises when a public authority acts consistently over time, and individuals or entities rely on that conduct to guide their decisions.
Many taxpayers now argue that IRB's decades-long silence constituted an implicit assurance – that unstamped employment documents were acceptable. And thus, they say, the IRB should not now impose penalties or retroactively enforce duties that were never seriously applied before.
But here lies the legal reality: while legitimate expectation is recognised in Malaysian administrative law, it cannot override express statutory obligations. The courts have consistently ruled that a taxpayer cannot rely on past lax enforcement to avoid current legal duties,especially where the law itself is clear.
So, while legitimate expectation may support an argument for fairness, grace periods, or waiver of penalties, it will not succeed as a full defence against the requirement to pay stamp duty.
A fairer way forward
The IRB is not wrong to enforce the law. But fairness demands that enforcement be proportionate and forward-looking, not punitive for past inaction that it tacitly allowed. Employers are now in a compliance bind: penalised for something they were never previously warned or reminded about.
To move forward constructively, the following approach is advisable:
1. Review all contracts – particularly employment letters, fixed-term service agreements, and any instrument involving reward payments.
2. Identify instruments that should have been stamped, especially those executed within the past three years as these are within audit range as indicated in the Audit Framework.
3. Voluntarily stamp those documents, where possible, to avoid penalties under audit.
4. Adopt a proactive stamping policy moving forward, making it part of your standard HR or legal process.
5. Engage with the IRB, where audited, to seek mitigation – citing widespread historical practice, absence of past guidance, and willingness to comply moving forward.
You may wish to wait for IRB's decision on an amnesty period during which they may not impose any late stamping penalty.
Final thoughts
This is not merely a compliance issue. It's a reflection of how tax enforcement must evolve -with transparency, predictability, and fairness. When a law has been neglected in enforcement for 75 years, it is not just a taxpayer oversight — it is a systemic policy failure.
The solution lies not in finger-pointing, but in balancing legal enforcement with administrative justice. Employers deserve clarity. And tax authorities owe it to the business community to enforce the law not just strictly, but sensibly.
Andrew Ewe is a Fellow of the Chartered Tax Institute of Malaysia and a former chairman of its Northern Branch.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Malaysia, Poland seek strengthened economic, trade ties
Malaysia, Poland seek strengthened economic, trade ties

Malaysia Sun

time2 hours ago

  • Malaysia Sun

Malaysia, Poland seek strengthened economic, trade ties

KUALA LUMPUR, June 10 (Xinhua) -- Malaysia is seeking strengthened economic and trade ties with Poland while reaffirming the importance of free and open trade, Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim and Polish President Andrzej Duda said here on Tuesday. They reaffirmed the importance of adhering to internationally accepted trade norms and multilateral engagement and cooperation, as this would be mutually beneficial, the leaders said in a joint statement during Duda's official visit to Malaysia from June 9 to 11. "The leaders reiterated their unwavering commitment to open and inclusive trade and a fair, rules-based international trading system. They strongly reaffirmed their support for the swift advancement of the Malaysia-EU Free Trade Agreement (MEUFTA) negotiations and stressed the importance of concluding the agreement at the earliest opportunity," they said. "Both sides agreed to promote balanced trade by reducing economic barriers, enhancing consultation mechanisms between relevant ministries, and fostering collaboration amongst business communities," they said, adding that friendly bilateral cooperation will facilitate cooperation in a number of new and emerging fields such as the digitalization of public services, green transition, particularly the hydrogen economy and renewable energy and the maritime economy. Anwar and Duda also agreed to cooperate on security matters, including enhancing the exchange of experiences and coordination in combating crime, including organized and international crime. Poland is Malaysia's important trading partner among EU member states. Malaysia's main exports to Poland include electrical and electronic products, rubber products and machinery, while main imports from Poland consist of machinery, equipment and spare parts, electrical and electronic products, and transport equipment.

Penang LRT issues settled, says Loke
Penang LRT issues settled, says Loke

Free Malaysia Today

time4 hours ago

  • Free Malaysia Today

Penang LRT issues settled, says Loke

Transport minister Loke Siew Fook checking out the Rapid Penang On-Demand service which is operating with 50 vans covering 13 zones. (Johnshen Lee pic) GEORGE TOWN : All outstanding issues between the federal government and the Penang government regarding the Mutiara Line Light Rail Transit (LRT) have been resolved amicably. Transport minister Loke Siew Fook said he had chaired the meeting with Penang chief minister Chow Kon Yeow at his ministry in Putrajaya last month and resolved outstanding issues, including the release letter from the state government. 'Physical work will begin soon, in one or two months. So we ask them (the state government) to ensure there is a traffic diversion plan when piling work and construction begins to ensure the project doesn't have a negative impact on road congestion,' he said during a media conference after ending his one-day working visit to Penang today. On Rapid Penang On-Demand service by Rapid Bus Sdn Bhd (Rapid Bus), Loke said the service, which began in phases from August 2024, was running smoothly with 50 vans covering 13 zones in Penang – seven on the island and six in Seberang Perai. 'The average daily users stand at 1,944 people, with an average of 39 passengers per van daily and an average travel time of 16 minutes and a waiting time of 19 minutes,' he said. He added that there were 150 additional drivers to handle the vans to ensure smooth operations and that passengers would enjoy a fare of RM1 per trip.

Capital A in final stages of PN17 exit plan, says Fernandes
Capital A in final stages of PN17 exit plan, says Fernandes

Free Malaysia Today

time4 hours ago

  • Free Malaysia Today

Capital A in final stages of PN17 exit plan, says Fernandes

Capital A fell into Bursa Malaysia's PN17 category of financially distressed entities in January 2022. (EPA Images pic) KUALA LUMPUR : Capital A Bhd is in the final stages of its regularisation plan to exit the Practice Note 17 (PN17) status, with only 15% to 20% of the process remaining, says its chief executive officer Tony Fernandes. He said the process is expected to be completed by the end of July. 'Building an airline was very tough, getting out of PN17 is tougher. We are on the last 15% to 20%, I can see the finish line. 'I think it is an exciting time for Capital A. We just have to cross that PN17 barrier, which I think we are almost there. It is out of my control, but I think our latest target is the end of July,' he told Bernama. Capital A fell into Bursa Malaysia's PN17 category of financially distressed entities in January 2022. Fernandes said the group is working through a few final tasks before concluding its PN17 exit plan – among them is to finalise the proposed disposal of its entire 100% stake in AirAsia Aviation Group Ltd (AAAGL) and AirAsia Bhd (AAB) to AirAsia X Bhd (AAX). AAAGL operates passenger airline services through subsidiaries in Thailand, Indonesia, the Philippines and Cambodia. 'Our plan requires three more things to be completed. Firstly, the Thai Stock Exchange (SET) has to agree (on the proposed disposal) – we have a backup plan if we cannot get it to agree, but I am confident we can. 'Secondly, we need five consent letters from our creditors and we already have four, and the third is the RM1 billion of equity, which we have,' he said. Fernandes said once the proposed disposal of AirAsia's aviation business is completed, the group will seek court confirmation for its capital reduction plan. Meanwhile, commenting on Capital A's plan for potential listing on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange (HKEX), Fernandes said its board of directors had given its approval and is very serious about pursuing the proposal. He also reaffirmed the group's intention to list its brand management arm, ABC International, on the Nasdaq in the United States. 'Once we get out of PN17, two things I can say, one is the Hong Kong listing and two, we will go back to listing the ABC International, which was formerly known as Capital A International in America.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store