logo
Stamp duty crackdown: legacy of lax enforcement or legal duty ignored?

Stamp duty crackdown: legacy of lax enforcement or legal duty ignored?

From Andrew Ewe
The Inland Revenue Board's (IRB) recent focus on unstamped employment letters, service contracts, and other instruments has caused understandable alarm among employers across Malaysia.
What many are only now discovering is that the legal obligation to stamp these documents has existed since the Stamp Act 1949 – a statute that turns 75 this year.
The sudden enforcement drive, under the newly released Stamp Duty Audit Framework effective Jan 1, 2025, raises a fundamental question of fairness and principle: Can a law that was dormant for decades suddenly be brought to life, with penalties imposed on businesses that have long followed an unofficial industry norm?
A legacy of lax enforcement
For over half a century, the IRB rarely enforced the stamping of employment contracts or service agreements with periodic payments. Companies – large and small – operated under the reasonable assumption that such documents were not subject to stamping, or that even if they were, it wasn't practically required.
This long period of non-enforcement effectively shaped market behaviour. Employers routinely issued letters of appointment, fixed-term contracts, and professional engagement agreements without stamping, and the IRB neither objected nor intervened.
The role of legitimate expectation
In public law, the concept of legitimate expectation arises when a public authority acts consistently over time, and individuals or entities rely on that conduct to guide their decisions.
Many taxpayers now argue that IRB's decades-long silence constituted an implicit assurance – that unstamped employment documents were acceptable. And thus, they say, the IRB should not now impose penalties or retroactively enforce duties that were never seriously applied before.
But here lies the legal reality: while legitimate expectation is recognised in Malaysian administrative law, it cannot override express statutory obligations. The courts have consistently ruled that a taxpayer cannot rely on past lax enforcement to avoid current legal duties,especially where the law itself is clear.
So, while legitimate expectation may support an argument for fairness, grace periods, or waiver of penalties, it will not succeed as a full defence against the requirement to pay stamp duty.
A fairer way forward
The IRB is not wrong to enforce the law. But fairness demands that enforcement be proportionate and forward-looking, not punitive for past inaction that it tacitly allowed. Employers are now in a compliance bind: penalised for something they were never previously warned or reminded about.
To move forward constructively, the following approach is advisable:
1. Review all contracts – particularly employment letters, fixed-term service agreements, and any instrument involving reward payments.
2. Identify instruments that should have been stamped, especially those executed within the past three years as these are within audit range as indicated in the Audit Framework.
3. Voluntarily stamp those documents, where possible, to avoid penalties under audit.
4. Adopt a proactive stamping policy moving forward, making it part of your standard HR or legal process.
5. Engage with the IRB, where audited, to seek mitigation – citing widespread historical practice, absence of past guidance, and willingness to comply moving forward.
You may wish to wait for IRB's decision on an amnesty period during which they may not impose any late stamping penalty.
Final thoughts
This is not merely a compliance issue. It's a reflection of how tax enforcement must evolve -with transparency, predictability, and fairness. When a law has been neglected in enforcement for 75 years, it is not just a taxpayer oversight — it is a systemic policy failure.
The solution lies not in finger-pointing, but in balancing legal enforcement with administrative justice. Employers deserve clarity. And tax authorities owe it to the business community to enforce the law not just strictly, but sensibly.
Andrew Ewe is a Fellow of the Chartered Tax Institute of Malaysia and a former chairman of its Northern Branch.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Rising costs top concern of Malaysian businesses: HSBC survey
Rising costs top concern of Malaysian businesses: HSBC survey

The Sun

time7 hours ago

  • The Sun

Rising costs top concern of Malaysian businesses: HSBC survey

PETALING JAYA: Malaysian businesses are grappling with rising costs and persistent supply chain disruptions, prompting them to reconsider their strategies and investment plans. According to HSBC's 2025 Global Trade Pulse Survey, the ongoing changes in tariffs and evolving trade policies continue to exert pressure on local companies, reshaping the landscape for growth and operations. Insights from the survey capture the perspectives and intentions of more than 5,700 international firms across 13 markets, including Malaysia, on the challenges and outlook related to tariffs and global trade. The survey found that, currently, the biggest concern for more than half of Malaysian businesses (55%) is rising costs due to tariffs and other trade-related factors. In response to this, 42% of Malaysian businesses have shifted their focus to domestic markets, prioritising local customers and reducing international exposure while 40% of businesses plan to do the same. In addition, the survey showed 37% of Malaysian businesses have increased their inventory levels to manage supply disruptions, with 49% planning to do so as well. Despite global uncertainties, 250 Malaysia-based companies surveyed are optimistic about their international growth but need external strategic advice on the matter, the findings showed. Furthermore, 91% of companies are confident that they can grow international trade, surpassing the 89% global average. More encouragingly, 73% believe that trade uncertainty has prompted their business to evolve and explore new opportunities, while 55% are seeking strategic advice on international expansion, restructuring or supply chain realignment. Considering current trade dynamics, Malaysia-based businesses are adapting their trade strategy to significantly increase connections with China (61%), South Asia (55%) and North Asia (44%). Beyond Asia, Malaysian businesses also plan to trade more with Europe and the United States (both 32%). HSBC Malaysia CEO and head of banking Datuk Omar Siddiq said despite the challenges posed by the uncertain tariff and trade landscape, businesses in Malaysia are demonstrating resilience and adaptability in the way they operate. 'While supply chains may be further reconfigured, there continues to be strong potential for local companies to leverage on Malaysia's strong trade ties, particularly in Asia. Having said that, it is key to note that markets like the US remain key trade destinations for Malaysia for high-value sectors such as electronics and semiconductors,' he said in a statement. While managing costs is top of mind for Malaysian businesses during this period of global uncertainty, the HSBC survey noted that companies are using the opportunity to innovate and adopt new technologies to boost operational efficiencies. It showed that 64% of Malaysian businesses have adopted new technology or digital platforms, while 48% have developed new products and services. Other growth opportunities that Malaysian businesses are considering include shifting their focus to domestic or regional growth (57%) and improving their internal efficiencies or changing their cost structures (54%). During the current period of trade disruption, Malaysian businesses find cash and liquidity management as the most helpful form of support in managing working capital (64%), followed by improved payment terms with buyers and suppliers (56%) and supply chain finance (55%). 'With over 70% of Malaysian businesses anticipating sustained cost increases from the impact of tariffs and trade uncertainty on the cost of doing business, and businesses facing an average 18% drop in revenue, the imperative for strategic adaptation is clear. 'Despite uncertainties, the world is also full of opportunities. Navigating this climate requires not only agility, but strong partnerships to ensure sustained growth in a shifting global economy,' Omar said.

Nuclear energy partnership the way forward for S'pore and M'sia, says researcher
Nuclear energy partnership the way forward for S'pore and M'sia, says researcher

Free Malaysia Today

time9 hours ago

  • Free Malaysia Today

Nuclear energy partnership the way forward for S'pore and M'sia, says researcher

Linking the border regions of Malaysia and Singapore, the JS-SEZ is nearly twice the size of China's Shenzhen – a success story that Malaysia is hoping to emulate. (File pic) PETALING JAYA : Incorporating a nuclear energy partnership into the Johor-Singapore special economic zone (JS-SEZ) will mark the way forward for collaboration between Malaysia and Singapore, argues an energy transition researcher. Victor Nian, the founding co-chairman of the Centre for Strategic Energy and Resources, said as JS-SEZ is set to become a defining project for industrial and economic collaboration between the two nations, it will need 'stable, 24/7 carbon free energy'. In a commentary published by Channel News Asia, he said current clean energy solutions could not quite keep up with the energy-intensive sectors the JS-SEZ hoped to attract. 'Solar energy cannot provide round-the-clock reliability even with battery energy storage, while hydrogen is expensive and lacks infrastructure and regulations for large industrial applications. 'Nuclear energy, on the other hand, offers a more realistic solution. It has been proven to provide reliable baseload electricity with zero emissions, such as in France, Spain, South Korea and the US,' he said. Linking the border regions of both countries, the JS-SEZ is nearly twice the size of China's Shenzhen – a success story that Malaysia is hoping to emulate. Nian pointed to the Krsko nuclear power plant in Slovenia near the Croatian border, the ownership of which is split equally between Slovenia and Croatia, with both nations sharing the electrical output and responsibility for nuclear waste. 'Krsko has delivered stable electricity to both countries for decades. 'A similar model could work for the JS-SEZ, bringing together Malaysia's land availability and regulatory readiness and Singapore's financing capabilities and intention to import clean energy from the region,' he said. Nian also said there is an opportunity for collective technology transfer and supply chain development, pointing to how Japan, South Korea and China have strengthened domestic nuclear industries through partnerships with established nuclear states. 'The JS-SEZ could do the same for Malaysia and Singapore. Talent development is already stated as a goal of the JS-SEZ. 'Nuclear energy requires a highly skilled and well-educated workforce. Both Malaysia and Singapore have the ability and the motivation to form academic and vocational training programmes supporting the nuclear energy sector,' he said. Nian said while such a partnership would not be easy to pull off, there is a clear path to success that builds on the existing relationship between the two countries and past efforts. He underlined the need to address domestic social and political sensitivities and geopolitical considerations, and called for both nations to collaborate in doing so. 'Again, there are international examples to follow. South Korea and Finland engaged with their citizens to build support for nuclear adoption. 'A Singapore-Malaysia endeavour would need to proactively be transparent in communication and initiate public consultations and educational initiatives to help shape public attitudes,' he said.

LHDN receives 328 million e-invoices from nearly 35,000 taxpayers since August 2024
LHDN receives 328 million e-invoices from nearly 35,000 taxpayers since August 2024

New Straits Times

time9 hours ago

  • New Straits Times

LHDN receives 328 million e-invoices from nearly 35,000 taxpayers since August 2024

GEORGE TOWN: The Inland Revenue Board (LHDN) has received 328 million e-invoices from taxpayers as of yesterday, since the system was launched in August 2024. LHDN tax operations department director (e-Invoice division) Dr Rasyidah Che Rosli said nearly 35,000 taxpayers had submitted e-invoices, including many who had adopted the system voluntarily ahead of their respective mandatory phases. "This is a positive response from taxpayers under the first phase, as well as those in the second and third phases who have implemented e-invoicing voluntarily. "The digital records via the e-Invoice system help prevent the loss or misplacement of documentation and will, in future, be integrated directly into taxpayers' return forms for greater efficiency and accuracy," she told reporters at the CTOS SME Biz Day 2025 Penang, held at the Setia Spice Convention Centre here today. The event was officiated by Penang Deputy Chief Minister II Jagdeep Singh Deo, and was attended by more than 1,300 participants, including government representatives, industry experts and corporate leaders. Meanwhile, Rasyidah said LHDN had granted an interim six-month relaxation period for each implementation phase involving taxpayers who are issuing consolidated e-invoices. She said the board was also supporting taxpayers during the transition by providing guidelines and frequently asked questions on its e-Invoice microsite. "LHDN also provides a transmission mechanism through an application programming interface (API) integrated with MyInvois, which allows taxpayers to either develop their own system or use the services of technology providers," she added. Taxpayers may also submit their e-invoices via the MyInvois portal free of charge, and are encouraged to refer to the LHDN e-Invoice microsite for further guidance. The e-Invoice system was implemented on Aug 1, 2024, for companies with annual sales exceeding RM100 million. The second phase began on Jan 1, 2025, for companies with annual sales between RM25 million and RM100 million. On June 5, LHDN announced that taxpayers with income or annual sales below RM500,000 would be exempted from the e-Invoice requirement for now. Implementation has been postponed to Jan 1, 2026, for those with earnings between RM1 million and RM5 million, while those with income up to RM1 million will begin on July 1, 2026.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store