Partition was ‘designed to be intractable', says Micheál Martin
Micheál Martin
has said.
The suppression of the 1925
Boundary Commission
report and the 'humiliation' of the Dublin government when the Border was left as it is today was 'a defining moment' in history, Mr Martin said.
The Boundary Commission was set up as part of the 1920 Government of Ireland Act to redraw the Border that had then been agreed, taking into account the wishes of locals, along with geographic and economic issues.
The
Free State
government had expected large swathes of land to be transferred from
Northern Irelan
d by the commission and it panicked when it realised that was not going to happen.
READ MORE
Nationalists had hoped transfers to the Free State would include areas such as south Armagh, Fermanagh and Tyrone, where there were Catholic/nationalist majorities.
Instead, the report recommended only minor changes. Once the findings were leaked, London, Dublin and the unionist-controlled Stormont quietly put the report aside and reached an agreement that left the Border unchanged.
Instead, the Free State avoided paying any part of the United Kingdom's national debt, getting out of a commitment it had incurred under the Anglo-Irish Treaty. The final text of the commission's report was not published for nearly 40 years.
Speaking at the launch of a history of the commission – titled The Root Of All Evil and written by historian Cormac Moore – the Taoiseach said the commission's report, and the reaction to it, was 'a radicalising moment'.
Describing the book as a work of 'impeccable archival research', Mr Martin said Mr Moore is 'part of a generation of young historians who have used the opening up of archives to give us a broader and deeper view of our past'.
Praising such work, the Taoiseach went on: 'If all we see of the past is a reflection of our current beliefs then we are missing out on opportunities to find new ways forward and rejecting the need to challenge ourselves.
'For those who want to move past partisan and ideological debates of previous decades, a body of work is being built up which challenges us to look for new ways of framing the questions we ask of our history,' he said.
[
Many Northern nationalists doubt Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael's commitment to Irish unity
Opens in new window
]
Quoting approvingly the words of
Trinity College Dublin
historian Anne Dolan, the Taoiseach told the book launch: 'Maybe history's job is to make it harder to be so certain and so shrill.'
He continued: 'The Boundary Commission did not create partition, but it demonstrated the entrenchment of a hardline approach defined by dominating as large a space as possible rather than constructing diverse societies.
Laying some of the blame at the door of London, he said: 'There is no way of looking at the evidence of London's behaviour and missing the consistent bad faith which it showed to both the Dublin government and majority of the Irish people.'
'Partition introduced a division on this island which had no precedence in this island's history,' he said, adding that partition ignored the reality of 'how most services and institutions worked' and the opinions of large numbers of Border communities.
'Partition broke apart a single, more diverse society and created states which were less diverse and more open to being dominated by one interest. By creating jurisdictions which were likely to diverge significantly, partition was designed to be intractable.'
Pointing to the future, Mr Martin said that for 'the first time in a hundred years we have a sustained effort under way to build understanding, engagement and mutual development' on the island.
The 'generosity of spirit with which individuals, groups and communities on both sides of the Border' are engaging together is 'one which has the potential to help us to break with failed approaches of the past'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
27 minutes ago
- Irish Times
President condemns ‘despicable attacks' on Indian people as extra Garda patrols deployed in parts of Dublin
President Michael D Higgins has condemned recent attacks on Indian people living in Ireland as a 'stark contradiction' to the values the Irish public hold dear. Mr Higgins said any person who has been 'drawn into such behaviour through manipulation or provocation is to be unequivocally condemned', as he noted that many of the alleged perpetrators of the assaults were under the age of 18. 'Whether such provocation stems from ignorance or from malice, it is essential to acknowledge the harm that it is causing,' he said. His statement came on Tuesday as An Garda Síochána began deploying additional patrols in parts of Dublin in response to the recent rise in reports of attacks on Indian nationals. READ MORE In addition to the patrols in Dublin, senior officers have been assigned to investigate the incidents reported to the force, some of which are being investigated as potential hate crimes . Garda juvenile liaison officers have also started engaging with youth and other groups in an attempt to discourage future incidents and offer support. Garda headquarters announced the measures in a statement on Tuesday. It said it 'is co-ordinating activity across the country to support the Indian community' which 'includes proactive engagement with the community, representative groups, and the Indian embassy'. Garda management is also engaging with social media companies regarding the posting of videos targeting members of the Indian community and other minorities. Mr Higgins said such attacks 'diminish all of us and obscure the immeasurable benefits the people of India have brought to the life of this country'. Of the Indian community, he said 'their presence, their work, their culture, have [all] been a source of enrichment and generosity to our shared life'. He said the people of Ireland 'are all mindful of the immense contribution this community has made, and continues to make, to so many aspects of Irish life, in medicine, nursing, the caring professions, in cultural life, in business and enterprise'. There were 78,000 Indian nationals living in the State in 2023, according to population estimates from the Central Statistics Office . Indian nurses accounted for a fifth of all registered nurses in Ireland last year, despite the community amounting to less than 2 per cent of the total population. The President said he wishes 'to express the deep sense of gratitude we all in Ireland owe to the Indian community here'. He said when he met India's minister of external affairs earlier this year and they 'discussed how much our histories share the experience of paths towards independence'. He named Irish-Indian suffragist Margaret Cousins, who established the All India Women's Conference in 1927, and 'the exchange of expertise' as Ireland and India drafted post-independence constitutions in the early 20th century as proof that 'Ireland's connections with India are neither recent nor superficial'. 'Ireland has long been shaped by migration, both outward and inward,' he said. 'Those who left our shores carried our culture and values into faraway lands, often depending on the generosity of strangers.' Mr Higgins said public spaces, including the internet, 'should never be poisoned from messages of hate or incitement to violence' which 'damage and corrode the most fundamental and enduring instincts of Irishness' such as friendship and care. 'That shared human experience should remain at the heart of how we treat those who have come to make their lives here. To forget that is to lose a part of ourselves.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Northern Ireland ‘crucial' as British chancellor looks to ‘all parts' of UK for growth
Northern Ireland is 'absolutely crucial' for the United Kingdom and will contribute to the chances of growth in the country as a whole, the British chancellor has said during a visit to Belfast. Rachel Reeves , the Labour finance minister, made her first trip to the North as chancellor and was asked whether she considers Northern Ireland to be an 'economic basket case'. As part of her trip, Ms Reeves visited the filmmaking facilities at Studio Ulster and also paid tribute to Northern Ireland's defence sector. Studio Ulster, which sits on the shores of Belfast Lough, was officially opened in June in what have been termed the world's most advanced virtual production facilities spanning 75,000 square feet. READ MORE Speaking at the studios, Ms Reeves said: 'Northern Ireland is absolutely crucial for the United Kingdom, including for our growth prospects. 'We've got here, at Studio Ulster, not just the best facilities in the UK, but the best facilities in the world, for a part of our economy that is globally growing at such a fast rate. 'This is the best place in the world to make those investments, to start a business, to grow a business, whether that's in video games, or TV, or film. 'That's really exciting and we benefit hugely from the thriving creative industry sector in Northern Ireland.' She continued: 'As we step up that defence spending to 3 per cent, and then 3.5 per cent, of GDP in due course, that will mean more good jobs, paying decent wages in Northern Ireland. 'My economic belief, my strong belief, is that all parts of the country should be able to contribute to economic growth and prosperity, and all parts of the country should benefit from economic growth and opportunities. 'That has not been the case for far too long in the UK.' Ms Reeves was due to meet deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly and Finance Minister John O'Dowd later on Tuesday. The chancellor also said that farmers with agricultural property worth more than £3 million (€3.47m) 'should make a contribution' in tax, following protests earlier this year against a change in policy. Asked whether she had 'sympathy for farmers who are now facing an inheritance tax bill', Ms Reeves told reporters her government had not increased taxes on 'ordinary working people', but went on: 'If you've got agricultural property worth less than £3 million and you own it jointly with a partner, you'll pay no inheritance tax when you pass that farm on. 'But I do believe that if you do have agricultural property worth more than £3 million, you should make a contribution... the inheritance tax on that is half the rate that anybody else pays, just 20%, and it's payable over 10 years interest-free.'–PA
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Public ‘unsure what big switch to clean energy means and how to play their part'
Ireland is in the throes of a big switch to clean energy, yet ordinary people do not know what this means and what it requires of them, a study by the National Economic and Social Council (NESC) has said. It said 'the energy transition' was technically under way, but 'its meaning and impact for individuals, households and communities remains unclear'. [ Consumers will foot bill for clean energy transition but still not clear how high bills will rise - report ] It warned that the transition would not be successfully negotiated without greater public understanding and participation. In a paper published on Tuesday, the NESC, an advisory body to the Taoiseach and Government, argued the specific 'ask' of people in Ireland in adopting clean energy had yet to be defined clearly. READ MORE It also highlighted barriers preventing participation, notably around energy affordability and persistent energy poverty among vulnerable groups. Households faced barriers to energy efficiency action including high upfront costs, complex grant processes, uncertainty and other practical issues, it noted. 'Households are largely 'in the dark' about their energy use and are not yet benefiting from some of the new opportunities from electricity usage such as dynamic tariffs and energy sharing,' NESC's report said. Meanwhile, the council said extreme weather events were highlighting the need for energy resilience at a local level. 'Energy communities are being supported, but are finding barriers to delivering projects to generate energy,' it said. NESC policy analyst Dr Jeanne Moore said: 'Individuals, households and communities can potentially play a very significant and immediate role in making energy savings, generating renewable energy and building energy resilience if enabled to do so. 'However, these opportunities and benefits are not yet available to all.' The council has called for a fundamental shift in approach with a range of actions to support a just energy transition. 'Placing people and their wellbeing at the centre of the energy transition can help to ensure [it] is just, fair, equitable and inclusive,' it said. Success hinged on deliberately strengthening connections between people and the energy system backed by 'prioritising affordability and ending energy poverty'. 'Addressing long-term costs of the transition and how they will be shared is crucial and requires a clear approach beyond consumer bills,' it said. Barriers must be removed to encourage the scaling-up of energy efficiency and transition to clean heating – such as heat pumps and district heating systems – to support increased uptake, NESC said. This included making energy efficiency simpler, 'using trusted messengers and local leaders, and supporting group delivery schemes'. Households could become more active participants through demand-side management, microgeneration and energy sharing, it said. 'Increased measures to ensure equitable access for all could be supported by secure application of digital/AI technologies.' NESC said it welcomed the growing numbers of 'energy communities' who wanted to do more, but said there was a need to provide better early-stage funding to support heat-generation initiatives and energy sharing. In a statement on the report, the Government acknowledged households and communities could potentially play 'a very significant and immediate role in making energy savings, generating renewable energy and building energy resilience if enabled to do so'. 'The council brings fresh understanding to some of the societal considerations of a longer-term energy transition and identifies actions that can help address current policy challenges in supporting households and energy communities to act,' it said.
