
SFA VAR manager 'all for' referee stadium explanations
"I'm so impressed. The guys that we work with are so professional and thorough in what they do - the preparation, the fitness.
"We talk about the fitness test, the level being raised this season. They couldn't be any more professional than they are. I'm really impressed with them. There's always a lot of talk about referees becoming professional, but no way, because the money isn't there.
"I don't think there's anything to suggest that being professional or where we are at the moment makes a difference. We're human beings. The guys are human beings. No matter who you are, no matter how many hours of training you do, you will still make mistakes when you're in there.
"It's human nature. It's the nature of the game. You can practice something so many times and still get it wrong. It doesn't matter who you are. Where we're at, I'm happy with."
Although the John Beatons and Kevin Clancys of the world might never get to give up their day jobs to take charge of football matches, they are constantly introduced to new rules, technologies, and innovations. Down south, in-game stadium VAR announcements by referees have been trialled. This allows them to explain their decisions publicly to the spectators in the stands.
Atkinson would be in favour of such an addition to Scottish football. "I'm a football fan myself," he continued. "All referees are football fans. You wouldn't do this job if you didn't love being involved in it and being part of the game. I think the communication side is something that we certainly embrace. I think it's something that we talk about. Again, this is not just the referees want this and that's it.
Read more:
"I think we're quite open to doing anything that will enhance us in stadiums. It's certainly not written off by us at all. We'd certainly be looking to implement it as soon as the clubs are ready, as soon as we get the green light to say, yes, the clubs want it, the clubs support it. We'd be all for that.
"I think any country is allowed to do it when they're ready to do it. If the clubs say, 'We're ready to go, we've got the infrastructure and the money and everything that goes with it to roll it out', then we would certainly support that and encourage it. I've obviously seen it with the guys down south. I did quite a bit of work with them, training to do that for last season. We're in place and ready to train the referees if we get the green light, if the clubs say they want this."
One thing increased in-game communications will never take away from football is contention. Regardless of modern technological advancements such as VAR and the like, weekly debates remain. Handball is a key area of dispute. "I think we're in a good place with handball in Scotland," says Atkinson.
"I say that looking as an outsider for many years and then to see the difference last season. Certainly, all the feedback from everybody in the game feels like we're in a good place with handball, and that comes as well from clubs.
"With the British game, we are always going to be slightly different, and I think everybody accepts that. That's the way that the game is, and we're always going to have that slight difference, which is what we expect. We've all been brought up on that."
Having taken charge of multiple cup finals south of the border, as well as the 2015 Europa League final, Atkinson knows the costly price of making poor decisions. In his day, VAR didn't exist. Now, it helps referees correct their mistakes. Regardless of public perceptions and numerous criticisms, it is seemingly here to stay.
"I think it's always going to be a discussion," admits Atkinson. "Some people like it. I fully get that. Some people are against it. That's football. It will always split opinion, won't it? We talk about football in the old days. We talk about football now, modern football. We're always going to get that debate about it. I go back to when I was a referee.
"On the field, you make a mistake. It's a clear mistake that influences a result. You drive home. You watch whatever television programme is on that evening, the following day, whatever is written in the media, whatever follows, and it continues for so long.
"There's no worse feeling as a match referee than knowing that you've made that mistake. Now, the guys don't go out to make mistakes. There's no reason for them to want to be perfect when they're out there. We make mistakes. If we make that mistake and we have a chance, an opportunity to make that right, then that's got to be good for the game. It's got to be good for the integrity of the game.
"It's got to be the way forward. I do think that it has improved the game. I really wish it were there in many situations in my career where I've driven home and I've just thought, why didn't I give that penalty? Why did I give that penalty when I should have done that? It's there for that reason.
"But the big decisions, we'll still always have subjective decisions that split a room. We'll always have decisions that split a room. We always get that. That's just football.
"I think when you look at UEFA in general, 46 out of 53 nations have got it [VAR]. So that speaks for itself straight away. And the other countries, you may well get an odd outlying country that is like, 'We don't want it'.
"But again, I'd just reiterate that if the referee gives a penalty when a ball hits a player in the face, it changes the whole game. We seem to forget about these big, big decisions that have influenced games and results over a number of years. Personally, I know they haunt me. Decisions that I've made over the years. I could tell you all the mistakes."
Atkinson himself refereed at the 2012 European Championships. Nick Walsh, one of the SFA's flagship whistlers, spent time at the under-21 version of the tournament this summer. "I think that's fantastic for Scottish match officials and for Scottish football, I think it's brilliant that they went there," said a proud Atkinson.
"They stayed at the tournament; they refereed in the semi-finals of a major tournament. It's brilliant for us. We can't do anything about the past. We can't change that now. We can't change what history has been. We can change the future of what's coming next.
"The targets are always the next competitions, the next tournaments that are coming. It's got to be. We've got to be doing that. That's what we thrive on. Certainly, for myself and Willie [Collum] and the team, it is identifying that and supporting that talent as well, supporting these guys to get there.
"I reiterate the success of Nick in the summer. Nick and his team were all really proud of that. We should shout about that as well. To get a semi-final in a major tournament is something to be proud of."
Walsh, his team, and countless other match officials in Scotland are used to their decisions being scrutinised every week throughout the season. Indeed, Atkinson thinks refs north of the border are lambasted much more than their English counterparts.
"It is pretty high pressure in England, but we get the feeling that here it's even more intense and even more critical on referees," he said.
'It's certainly on a par with what it is down in England. Definitely the expectation, but I think you'll find that in just about every country as well. I think each country is so passionate. It's like that. The expectations are there.
"I must say, since I've been up here, I'm really impressed with how the guys, how the match officials have taken on board a lot of the stuff. I come up bringing experience from the Premier League and implementing it here with these guys. They have really taken on board a lot of it.
"I think you'll find that from certainly the communication side of it, the way that the guys speak on the field of play. You can listen to things from the start of the season to where we are at the end of the season. The comms are far better.
"I'm delighted with that. I'm really pleased with that. I think we can continue to do that. I think we can still get better at it. But pressure-wise, that's part of the game. We all want more all the time. Every season, we want more. We want the guys to get better. Teams want to get better. We want the match officials to be better. That's football. That's the nature of it."

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Glasgow Times
25 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Two Celtic legends pictured at plush Glasgow restaurant
Paul McStay and Frank McAvennie enjoyed a delicious meal at Gost Glasgow on Bothwell Street, which is a 'premium steakhouse and cocktail bar'. The football duo visited the popular venue alongside Tam Cowan, Simon Houston, and Liam Donnelly. READ MORE: Seven celebs who support Glasgow's Celtic - including Scots comedy legend READ MORE: Glasgow restaurant's touching tribute to legendary Celtic player after death In pictures shared on Instagram by Cowan, the group looked chuffed as they enjoyed their trip to 'one of Glasgow's top restaurants'. Cowan said: "Brilliant night at one of Glasgow's top restaurants - the stunning Gost Glasgow on Bothwell Street - in the company of two genuine football legends: Frank McAvennie and Paul McStay." Scottish legend McStay is known for playing with both Celtic and Scotland's national team. The 60-year-old played with the Glasgow club from 1981 until 1997, making over 500 appearances and netting more than 50 goals. He also played with Scotland between 1983 and 1997. Meanwhile, McAvennie, 65, played with the Hoops between 1987 and 1989, and then again from 1992 until 1994. During his career, he also played with teams, including St Mirren, West Ham United, and Aston Villa.


Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
Aberdeen boss answers transfer question over ex Hibs star
The Aberdeen boss has addressed chances of possibly signing a star formerly at Hibs. Sign up to our Hibs football newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Aberdeen manager Jimmy Thelin has rated his side's chances of making a move for one star formerly of Hibs. The Dons are preparing for a Europa League play off clash against FCSB of Romania, but even if they suffer defeat in that tie, they know they will have the rigours of league phase of the Conference League to contend with. That means they'll need a squad built to cope with the demands of that and one player that may be targeted is Millwall's Kevin Nisbet. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The striker left Hibs in 2023 for The Den but headed back to Scotland on loan at Pittodrie 12 months later. He made himself a hero by forming part of their Scottish Cup winning squad, scoring 14 times in 38 games for the Dons overall. Nisbet has featured in a cameo role for Millwall against Newport County in the Carabao Cup since heading back down south. Kevin Nisbet to Aberdeen transfer question addressed Thelin has been asked about a possible move for the ex Hibs striker ahead of their European adventure beginning and cryptically said: 'The window is the window. The way we are working, there can be changes in and out. We have to think about Aberdeen Football Club in the first way then think about individuals and getting game time. We will see if we can find something more that can strengthen us. 'If that's the case they maybe, we'll see. The competition is quite strong about some players we looked at and had talks with, yes. But let's see how the future looks. That's an overall plan we have and we're trying to work on that every season, so let's see in the future what's going to happen. 'I think you will see, I believe, in the next coming years some more from our academy and more recruitment from young Scottish players to build a strong core. It has to be the right ones and the right timing to get the game time they need.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Aberdeen verdict on Europa League journey Success in Europe for Aberdeen could benefit Hearts, Hibs and the rest of Scottish football in the form of a coefficient points tally boost, with Scotland's current standings at risk for future seasons. Thelin said: I think always when you compete you want to be in the best level you can be, so our target is Europa League and that's what we focus on. 'We don't think about safety nets or this kind of thing, it's like you always want to be in the highest competition and prepare yourself for that. I know I haven't played any play-offs here before, but with not many tickets left and this being a European night, it's going to be really exciting to get into this game. The connection and the atmosphere the supporters and the fans have created during all my time I've been here, I know how much it can lift the players but also the players have to send their energy to the supporters. 'I think this connection is so, so important and that can make a difference. We're just waiting for the kick-off right now, we're done with all preparations and looking forward to the game. FCSB have some experience, they have some players with good qualities and a good coach. It will be like a cup game, we know the only way to get through is to win this round, and that's our focus.'


Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Ex Hearts boss sends Hibs good luck in Europe message and has 'no issues' with postponement
Falkirk head coach John McGlynn hopes Hibs can progress in their UEFA Europa Conference League tie against Legia Warsaw. Sign up to our Hibs football newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Hibs have been sent a message of good luck ahead of their UEFA Europa Conference League play-off tie against Legia Warsaw from a former manager of their fiercest rivals. Ex Hearts gaffer John McGlynn, currently in charge of Falkirk, was due to go head-to-head with David Gray this weekend in their latest Scottish Premiership encounter. However, the match has been postponed in order for the Edinburgh club to have the best opportunity of progressing against the Polish side over the two legs of the tie. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad It's a decision that McGlynn says he has 'no issue' with and that he hopes the Hibees can win the tie for the good of Scottish football. He also revealed that the postponement may in fact be advantageous to his Bairns' side given the timing of the decision. Former Hearts boss wishes Hibs good luck in Europe Speaking to the press this week, and addressing the postponement of Falkirk's Scottish Premiership match against Hibs, McGlynn said: "It is an odd quirk. Normally it isn't something you would want but actually it might work in our favour in terms of getting these guys in (signing targets) and getting them acclimatised to our squad. "It is what it is. You have to take the positives from it. We may be able to get one or two players back from injury too. You play the cards you are dealt and actually the break may benefit us. "We are supporting Hibs and the other Scottish teams in Europe. I had no issues with the game being called off for that reason. Good luck to them.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Hibs v Legia Warsaw latest team news Hibs will head into their UEFA Conference League play-off with virtually a full squad available to David Gray, who provided a positive injury bulletin ahead of tomorrow night's Easter Road showdown with Legia Warsaw. And the head coach has credited the SPFL for agreeing to postpone this weekend's Scottish Premiership trip to Falkirk in order to boost the Edinburgh side's chances of reaching European group/league phase football for the first time in club history. Attacking midfielder Jamie McGrath hasn't featured since the 2-2 draw at home to Kilmarnock on August 10, with the Irishman having picked up a niggling knee injury in that game. He missed the second leg of his team's Conference League third-round triumph over Partizan – and was rested for the weekend win over Livingston in the last 16 of the Premier Sports Cup. But Gray, providing an update today, revealed: 'Yeah, they're all at different stages, but in terms of availability for the squad, the only one who's technically not available is Joe Newell. Rudi Molotnikov's had more time on the grass, Jamie McGrath's trained the last two days. 'It's a big game, everybody wants to make themselves available, as you'd expect, bumps and bruises and knocks go away. I know they all feel good about themselves as well, after a really good result and performance at the weekend, and everything's geared up now. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'There's no distractions, there's no game in between, which is another real positive step. But it's certainly a very exciting time to be a Hibs player and fan and everybody connected with the club at the minute, and we need to use that to our advantage.' Your next Hibs read: Hibs European adventure so far: seven brilliant supporter photos from FC Midtjylland & Partizan Belgrade ties