logo
Air India crash: Did captain 'deliberately cut off fuel' sparking co-pilot panic

Air India crash: Did captain 'deliberately cut off fuel' sparking co-pilot panic

Daily Mirror5 days ago
According to the Wall Street Journal, sources close to the US side of the investigation have said the voice cockpit recording suggests Sabharwal turned off the switches, one after the other, exactly a second apart
American investigators probing the Air India crash are examining the captain's conduct amid revelations that two fuel switches were manually shut off moments after takeoff.

Black box recordings reveal Sumeet Sabharwal remained composed as his first officer, Clive Kunder, appeared to panic when the supply to both engines was suddenly cut. According to the Wall Street Journal, sources close to the US side of the investigation have said the voice cockpit recording suggests Sabharwal turned off the switches, one after the other, exactly a second apart.

According to American pilots who reviewed the Indian report, Kunder was flying the plane at the time and likely concentrating on keeping the Dreamliner steady. As the monitoring pilot, Sabharwal would have been free to make manual adjustments, including to the critical fuel controls.

According to the flight data, ten seconds after the levers were shut off, both switches were flipped back on. By then, the plane had lost thrust. It plummeted into the ground near Ahmedabad airport, erupting into flames and killing all but one of the 242 people on board.
The harrowing details have triggered fresh scrutiny into the mental health of the pilots, particularly the captain. Mohan Ranganathan, a leading Indian aviation safety expert, revealed that 'several' Air India pilots had allegedly confirmed that the experienced pilot had suffered from poor mental health.

The airmen claimed: 'He (Sabharwal ) had taken time off from flying in the last three to four years. He had taken medical leave for that.' Sabharwal, a senior Air India pilot, had also taken bereavement leave following the death of his mother, though Ranganathan said he was 'medically cleared' to return to duty before the doomed flight.
A former colleague described Sabharwal as 'a thorough gentleman' and said he had been considering early retirement to care for his 90-year-old father. 'He was actually considering early retirement in the next couple of years,' they said.
Air India declined to comment on Sabharwal's mental state. However, an official at parent company Tata Group insisted the captain had not taken any recent medical leave and that both pilots had passed Class I medicals, including evaluations of psycho-physical fitness, within the last two years.

Kunder, just 28, had logged more than 3,400 flight hours. He was flying the jet at the time of the crash. On Sunday, a preliminary report released by the Indian authorities led to questions about why the pilot would have manually turned the switches off, and whether it was a deliberate act or a mistake.
US officials reviewing the preliminary crash investigation told the Wall Street Journal a black box recording revealed a tense exchange in the cockpit. First Officer Kunder reportedly asked: 'Why did you cut off?' The captain then replied: 'I didn't.' Sabharwal stayed eerily calm as the aircraft plunged.

Fuel levers are not simple push buttons. To operate them, pilots must lift each lever upward against a locking guard before flipping it. At takeoff, both were inexplicably turned off, triggering speculation that the act was either a calamitous error or something worse.
Captain Ranganathan believes it was the latter. 'These selectors aren't sliding types. They are always in a slot,' he said. 'You have to pull them out or move them up or down, so the question of them moving inadvertently doesn't happen. It's a case of deliberate manual selection.'
When asked whether one pilot may have shut off the fuel levers knowing the consequences, Ranganathan replied: 'Absolutely… It had to be deliberately done.' The possibility of a pilot-induced crash has enraged relatives of the victims, many of whom suspect a cover-up to protect the airline and authorities.

Ameen Siddiqui, 28, whose brother-in-law Akeel Nanabawa died in the crash alongside his wife and four-year-old daughter, said: 'This report is wrong. We don't accept it. They want to blame dead pilots who can't defend themselves.' CCTV footage from the airport confirmed the deployment of the Ram Air Turbine (RAT) - a backup power source - shortly after takeoff. Two minutes later, a pilot transmitted: 'Mayday, Mayday, Mayday.'
In December 2018, the US Federal Aviation Administration warned airlines that fuel switches in some Boeing aircraft had been installed with locking mechanisms disengaged, raising the risk of accidental shut-off.
But Air India said it did not carry out inspections because the FAA advisory was not mandatory. Miraculously, one passenger survived. Vishwash Kumar Ramesh, seated in 11A by the exit, escaped with his life. His brother, Ajaykumar, 35, seated across the aisle in 11J, perished in the crash.
The aircraft was en route from Ahmedabad to Gatwick. Among the dead were 11 children, including two newborns. An Air India spokesperson said: 'Air India stands in solidarity with the families and those affected by the AI171 accident. We continue to mourn the loss and are fully committed to providing support during this difficult time. We acknowledge receipt of the preliminary report released by the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau. Air India is working closely with stakeholders, including regulators… We continue to fully cooperate with the AAIB and other authorities as their investigation progresses.'
The airline said it could not comment on specific details due to the ongoing investigation.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Air India plane veers off runway in horror landing with three tyres burst & engine damaged in latest terrifying incident
Air India plane veers off runway in horror landing with three tyres burst & engine damaged in latest terrifying incident

Scottish Sun

timean hour ago

  • Scottish Sun

Air India plane veers off runway in horror landing with three tyres burst & engine damaged in latest terrifying incident

It comes as Air India is under scrutiny due to the tragic plane crash that killed 260 people on June 12 JET PANIC Air India plane veers off runway in horror landing with three tyres burst & engine damaged in latest terrifying incident AN AIR India plane skidded off the runway and sustained damage as it landed at Mumbai International Airport amid heavy rain on Monday. Three tyres on the Airbus A320 burst, the underside of an engine was damaged and the runway had to be shut, according to reports. 4 Damage to the engine covering after an Air India jet veered off a runway on Monday Credit: X 4 Damaged wing of the Air India jet Credit: X 4 Grass and debris seen on the plane's wing Credit: X On the day of the plane's dodgy landing, the suburbs of Mumbai were drenched in 4.5 inches of rain, according to the India Meteorological Department (IMD). Air India flight AI2744, which had flown from the Indian city of Kochi, veered off the main runway onto an unpaved area before coming to a stop at a taxiway, Times of India reports. The outer casing of the plane's engine - known as the cowling - was damaged and three tyres burst, the newspaper adds. TV footage from NDTV and India Today reveals a number of dents on the cowling. An Air India spokesperson said: 'Flight AI2744, operating from Kochi to Mumbai on 21 July 2025, experienced heavy rain during landing, resulting in a runway excursion after touchdown. "The aircraft taxied safely to the gate and all passengers and crew members have since disembarked. The aircraft has been grounded for checks. "The safety of passengers and crew remain our top priority." The Mumbai airport said in a statement that there were "minor damages reported to the airport's primary runway" as a result of a "runway excursion". It said that a secondary runway had been "activated" to ensure operational continuity. Though the Mumbai airport has two intersecting runways, only one operates at a time - making it effectively a single-runway airport and one of the busiest in the world. Airline pilot forced to pull off 'aggressive' move to avoid catastrophic midair collision with Air Force B-52 bomber All passengers and crew were safe following the incident, the airport added. It comes as Air India has faced scrutiny after a Boeing 787 Dreamliner crashed in the Indian city of Ahmedabad last month and killed 260 people. All but one of the 242 passengers and crew died, with Vishwash Ramesh, 40, the only survivor. Another 19 people were killed on the ground in Ahmedabad. A 15-page preliminary report into the crash, released by Indian authorities, indicates switches to the engines' fuel supplies were moved from the "RUN" position to "CUTOFF". "The Engine N1 and N2 began to decrease from their take-off values as the fuel supply to the engines was cut off," the report said. This may have triggered a loss of thrust, which resulted in the jet crashing into a medical college.

Where the souk meets the soi
Where the souk meets the soi

Time Out

time5 hours ago

  • Time Out

Where the souk meets the soi

While plenty of people have at least a working knowledge of takeout-style Indian food, Pakistani food has nowhere near the international profile, which is a shame. Heartier and meatier, with more obvious influence from the Arab world, Pakistani food is just waiting to be discovered, and Ibrahim provides a starting point. Mutton and fish dishes generate some of the most buzz online, but our heart belongs to chicken karahi – named for the wok-like dish it's cooked in, it hails from the Afghan border regions, and goes heavy on the ginger. We also love the haleem (shredded meat blended with bulgur into a rich, creamy porridge), which is almost like a South Asian take on congee, warm and comforting.

Gordon & MacPhail has bottled the world's oldest single malt Scotch whisky - an 85 year old Glenlivet
Gordon & MacPhail has bottled the world's oldest single malt Scotch whisky - an 85 year old Glenlivet

Scotsman

time8 hours ago

  • Scotsman

Gordon & MacPhail has bottled the world's oldest single malt Scotch whisky - an 85 year old Glenlivet

Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... On 3 February 1940 in a quiet corner of the north-east of Scotland, George Urquhart and his father, John, had the extraordinary foresight and vision to lay down spirit from Glenlivet Distillery in a Gordon & MacPhail American oak cask to be enjoyed after his lifetime by future generations. George Urquhart, or 'Mr George' as he was fondly known by those who knew him best, knew he would never taste it. Only when the whisky was deemed ready would it be shared. Leaning on the family's unique skills and experience, the time for Cask 336 came to be 85 years – longer than any other single malt Scotch whisky in history Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad On 5 February 2025, the decision was taken to finally empty the cask. A total of 125 decanters of the 85 years old whisky were bottled in line with Gordon & MacPhail's family expertise to produce liquid of the highest quality. 'This whisky is truly exceptional due to its remarkable history and unique maturation process. The influence of the cask, combined with the rarity and scarcity of the liquid, creates a whisky with a strength of 43.7% ABV that is not only extraordinary in its taste but also a living piece of history,' explained Stephen Rankin, director of prestige at Gordon & MacPhail, and member of the fourth generation of the family that owns the company. Cask 336 laid down on 3 February 1940 | Gordon & MacPhail For 130 years, Gordon & MacPhail has been bottling old, rare and interesting single malt Scotch whisky. Through four generations of family ownership, the company has matched its own casks with spirit from over 100 Scottish distilleries. It is this long experience of cask curation that allows Gordon & MacPhail to consistently deliver a range of quality whiskies, found nowhere else in the world. With all whisky releases, timing is everything. The team said that Gordon & MacPhail will only release a whisky when over a century of experience determines it is appropriate to do so. Leaving each cask to mature, undeterred by commercial necessity, is a long-held, unnegotiable mantra, a fitting way to honour the integrity of each release. Because of this, Gordon & MacPhail's whiskies are often the oldest expression ever to be released from a particular distillery. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Gordon & MacPhail This is true of their earlier release this year, the fifth and final release in the Mr George Legacy Series – an ultra-rare 70-Year-Old whisky celebrating 'The father of single malt Scotch whisky', Mr George Urquhart, and his lifelong quest in pursuit of the perfect dram. And, in 2021 the firm released an 80-Years-Old from Glenlivet Distillery - in partnership with Sir David Adjaye OBE. To celebrate the 85 year old Glenlivet release, Gordon & MacPhail has collaborated with internationally acclaimed American architect Jeanne Gang, to create a unique decanter to house the world's oldest whisky to date. The product design – themed around 'Artistry in Oak' - will be revealed later this year. Known for a distinctive design approach that expands beyond architecture's conventional boundaries, Ms Gang was a natural choice as a creative partner, sharing the company's commitment to leave a legacy for future generations. Of the collaboration, Ms Gang said: 'I was excited to learn about everything involved in whisky's creation. Each careful step lends something to a whisky's unique flavour. Then, there are years of protecting the casks so they can age. In architecture, these elements of materiality and time also play a critical role in the design process. Both are about creating something enduring, so this is what I found inspiring about this opportunity to design a decanter for Gordon & MacPhail's 85-year-old single malt whisky.' Jeanne Gang's stunning decanter will be revealed in October 2025, with decanter #1 auctioned by Christie's New York in November 2025. To continue the legacy theme, auction proceeds (minus costs) will be donated to the oldest national non-profit conservation organisation in the United States, American Forests, a leader in forest restoration. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Mr Rankin said: 'Given the importance of oak in our craft, this partnership was a natural fit, aligning with our mission to leave a meaningful legacy for ongoing generations, via fundraising for the sustainable future of American oak trees.' Those who would like to learn more about the whisky ahead of its release are encouraged to register their interest at the brand's official website at the Gordon and MacPhail website. Gordon & MacPhail As well as being Scotland's oldest independent bottler, Gordon and MacPhail also own Benromach and The Cairn distilleries in Speyside and 2023 announced that they'd no longer be purchasing stock for the bottling side of the business in order to focus on these distilleries. A statement on their website reads: 'The practice of filling spirit into casks at distilleries not owned by Gordon & MacPhail will stop in 2024 as the company's long-term future will focus on whiskies from Benromach and The Cairn. The company retains extensive maturing stocks so whiskies carrying the Gordon & MacPhail name will continue for decades to come.' Speaking to Whisky Magazine , Gordon & MacPhail's outgoing managing director Ewen Mackintosh said: 'We've always had the philosophy of to complement and not compete. When I started in the business 30-plus years ago, we were bottling whiskies which weren't available from the distillery owner because they were very much used for blending... But 30 years on, every distillery is generally available in whisky retail with multiple expressions, so our space as an independent bottler to complement and not compete is dramatically changed. And then we don't want to be offering things which are directly in competition with official bottlings – that's never been part of our ethos and our relationships with the distillery companies.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store