High Court orders turbine to shut down at certain windspeeds overnight due to sleep disturbance
THE HIGH COURT has ordered that a wind turbine in Co Wexford be shut down at night for certain windspeeds due to its potential to disturb sleep.
The turbine will also have to operate on a lower mode during quiet waking hours at certain windspeeds.
Last year, the High Court ruled that one of two wind turbines at Ballyduff Windfarm at Kilcomb, near Enniscorthy, Co Wexford, amounted to an 'unreasonable interference' with the enjoyment of two couples' properties.
This action was taken by Margret Webster and her partner Keith Rollo, whose home is close to the wind farm that has been operational since 2017.
A second action was taken by Ross Shorten and Joan Carty, who owned another property close to the turbines but sold it after commencing their proceedings in 2018.
The wind farm is operated by Meenacloghspar (Wind) Limited.
The cases were the first private nuisance claims from wind turbine noise to run in Ireland or the UK, the judge said.
At the conclusion of module 1 of the trial last year, the High Court deemed that 'one of the two turbines caused a nuisance to the plaintiffs during night hours and quiet waking hours'.
The judge, Ms. Justice Emily Egan, then directed the parties involves to 'attempt to agree appropriate mitigation measures to abate the nuisance in advance of module 2'.
The Court noted that the defendant trialled just one potential mitigation measure – the operation of the turbine in a lower power mode.
This reduces the rotational speed of the turbine blades and marginally reduces the wind turbine noise.
The plaintiffs said this lower power mode did not mitigate the noise nuisance and sought an order to shutdown the turbine during 'sensitive', quiet waking hours.
The judge agreed that the lower power mode trialled by the defendant 'does not ameliorate the nuisance'.
However, the defendant's claimed that the wind turbine noise did not create a noise nuisance even in its 'full' power mode and that no mitigation is required.
Advertisement
The defendant also sought to bring forth new evidence to persuade the Court to review the findings made last year after module 1 of the trial.
It was contended by the defendant that the new evidence showed that the wind turbine noise was lower than the limit currently fixed in Irish planning guidance.
The judge rejected the data provided by the defendant and said it did not provides a 'scientifically robust guidance on what level and nature of wind turbine noise causes unacceptable interference with residential amenity'.
She added that the new evidence 'does not comprise a useful or complete baseline assessment for the purposes of crafting abatement measures'.
'Even if admitted, the defendant's new evidence would not substantially impact or alter my finding on liability', said the judge, who declined to admit the evidence or revisit last year's findings on liability.
The judge remarked on the benefits of renewable energy but added that the plaintiffs are 'entitled to an injunctive remedy'.
The Court ordered that the It seems that noise levels therefore had to be reduced by a 'clearly noticeable degree'.
She remarked that five decibel reduction would be an 'easily noticeable noise differential'.
The defendant was ordered to implement this noise reduction and to operate on a lower mode 'during quiet waking hours at certain wind speeds and wind directions'.
The judge added however that this would not be an acceptable solution during night hours.
The judge said this is partly because she is 'not satisfied' that the predicted noise level reductions by lowering the power mode 'can be reliably and consistently achieved at night'.
She also noted that 'constant sudden changes to the wind turbine noise at night would have a jarring effect, disturb sleep and thus cause ongoing nuisance'.
As a result, the judge ordered the shutdown of the turbine at night for 'windspeeds of 5m/s to 11 m/s inclusive in those wind directions associated with high AM values and thump AM'.
AM (Amplitude Modulation) relates to the variance of wind turbine noise, which can cause more annoyance than constant, stable noise of a similar level.
A 'high AM value' is a noticeable variation in the sound, often described as a 'swish' or a 'thump'.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
3 hours ago
- Irish Post
Last orders for Irish pubs?
WHAT'S happening to the pub? Over the last twenty years more than 2,000 pubs have closed. Here in Ireland. A country so synonymous with pub culture that we exported the very idea of an 'Irish' pub across the globe. And these bare statistics are a very real thing. From where I'm writing this right now a two-minute drive in opposite directions would once have taken me to a choice of three rural pubs. There's now one. Pubs in Ireland are closing and that is a big change in the very nature of Irish life. Of course, health advisers might see this as a good thing but that seems to confuse the pub simply with alcohol. The pub is more than that. The pub is a mirror of society. Now it might seem ridiculous to say that but I've always been a fan of the pub and I've always seen it as more than the pint in your hand. To paraphrase Brendan Behan, I like the pub because I like people. Or in my case I particularly like listening to people talking and in the pub that talk is often of the most fantastical nature. Of course, the pints feature but if it was just about that we'd only have off licences, wouldn't we? And if the pub wasn't some kind of mirror of Irish society why do we try so hard to sell tourists the pub as an essential experience? As to why the pubs are closing, well, there must be, in all honesty, many reasons as these things tend to be complicated. Two seem to jump out to me though. One is just a personal experience. In the closest town to where I am, a small rural town, there was a pub that I loved to frequent. It had a long counter and a fireplace and was a great place for a pint. When I was last in there the television that was on for sporting events had now become two screens continually on with the noise turned down. There was a radio playing loudly and it had gone from being a great place for a pint to a place that was an assault on the senses. Now, perhaps, I'm suddenly an old man with old man's complaints but it seemed the pub had decided it needed modernising and so was introducing things like televisions just in case there was someone who didn't have one at home and thought a treat would be to watch two. While listening to the radio. This Americanisation of our shared spaces, our public houses, actually destroys what the pub is supposed to be. So why would you go there — to watch the telly? To watch the news or a soap opera or a ticker tape sports news channel? Would you not just stay at home in a much more comfortable seat to do that? And is that perhaps what people are doing? If the pub is not really the pub anymore then why go to it? But it's possible it's something much more socially profound. There has been a lot of talk that we are all much more socially isolated than we ever were. A report in 2022 claimed Ireland was the loneliest country in Europe. The European Commission's Joint Research Centre conducted the first EU-wide survey on loneliness, which found that over 20% of respondents in Ireland reported feeling lonely most or all of the time—significantly higher than the EU average of 13%. It seems unlikely those figures have changed much in the intervening years. This statistic is astonishing in a country that prides itself on its friendliness and the art of having the craic. We might appear on the surface more connected than ever, with many people constantly updating every aspect of their lives to people on social media, and we certainly seem to be one of the most photographed populations there has ever been. B ut are we lonely as well? Bertie Ahern was talking about this nearly twenty years ago. The idea that with all our advancements and all our communications that we were, in fact, getting more distant from each other. Many people have talked about this in relation to the pub. How the pub is a meeting place, a gathering centre in a community, how it is about much more than the drink. That it is one of the few places that is a refuge for isolated people. So, if the pubs are closing is it because we are no longer meeting up, no longer gathering together. Have we given up? Surrendered to our loneliness. Are we at home now, in Cork or Kerry or Donegal, in front of our outsized televisions, sipping a glass of wine, looking at photographs of other people's nights out. Is it that the pub we would have gone to is closed or that the pub isn't really the pub anymore? Does anyone know? I think I'll go for a pint. See More: Ireland, Irish Pub
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Leaving Cert Irish: Exam tips with Múinteoir Séadhan
Study Hub 2025 guest Séadhan De Poire from the Dublin Academy of Education is here with tips and guidance for students sitting Higher Level Leaving Cert Irish. An accomplished author of Irish-language school textbooks and a regular contributor to RTÉ Study Hub, Séadhan is passionate about making Irish accessible and engaging. You can watch his contributions to the show in the videos above and below. For more tips, resources, and expert guidance on Irish exam preparation, follow him on TikTok here. Make Every Minute Count in Your Irish Study With the State Exams just around the corner, it's more important than ever to ensure that every minute of study is focused, efficient, and productive. A structured and strategic approach to preparation can make all the difference for students aiming to excel in Higher Level Irish. Here are three essential tips to help students maximise their marks: 1. Get to Know the Past Papers Familiarity with the structure and style of past exam questions is key. By regularly reviewing previous papers, students can gain insight into common question types and recurring themes. This not only helps narrow their focus to the most relevant parts of the studied texts but also builds confidence in understanding the language and phrasing used in the exams. Tip: Don't just read the questions - actively engage with them. Highlight patterns, practise answering under exam conditions, and review examiner marking schemes where possible. 2. Mimic Real Exam Conditions Effective preparation involves more than just passive revision—it requires simulation. Practice answering exam-style questions under timed conditions that replicate the real exam environment. Take Irish Paper 2 as an example. For the poetry question, you'll face three parts: a 15-mark question, a 9-mark question, and a 6-mark question. Allocate your time accordingly: 20 minutes for the 15-mark question 10 minutes combined for the 9-mark and 6-mark questions Stick rigidly to these time limits during practice sessions. Developing time management now will prevent stress and ensure stronger performance on the day. 3. Prioritise the High-Value Questions Many students fall into the trap of focusing on their favourite topics or lower-weighted sections. A smart strategy is to target the questions that carry the most marks. Now that the Irish oral is complete, all remaining attention should shift to the written papers, which hold a total of 360 marks. Two of the most valuable components are: The Essay on Paper 1 – worth 100 marks The Reading Comprehensions on Paper 2 – also worth 100 marks These sections should be the foundation of your revision. Allocate more time to mastering them as they offer the greatest return on investment when it comes to boosting your final grade. Stay focused in these final two weeks. At this stage, quality matters more than quantity. Stick to your plan, stay consistent, and revise with purpose. If you come across a word you don't recognise in a question, don't panic. Trust in your preparation and your ability to work through it. You know more than you think. Wishing you all the very best of luck. More about Séadhan Séadhan De Poire is a fluent Irish speaker with over a decade of experience in education and language instruction. He has held several leadership positions, including serving as Deputy Principal in The Dublin Academy for four years, where he played a key role in academic and administrative development. Séadhan brings invaluable insight to students preparing for State Exams, having worked closely with the State Examinations Commission as a corrector for the Leaving Certificate Higher Level Irish exam. His deep understanding of exam standards and expectations makes him a trusted guide for both Junior Cycle and Leaving Certificate students.
Agriland
17 hours ago
- Agriland
Study aims to improve gender balance in agri and rural reporting
A research project is aiming to promote better gender balance when it comes to coverage of agricultural and rural issues in the media. Over the coming 12 months, the 'Time to be Seen' project will work to identify how both women and men are represented in the media when it comes to these topics. It will raise awareness in cases where women are omitted from this coverage or misrepresented and how this can be addressed. The project is also aiming to develop resources to promote women's participation and representation in Irish mainstream media coverage of farming and rural matters. Dr Muireann Prendergast (third from left) with farmers and journalists who took part in the Agri Rural Media Forum in Limerick Dr Muireann Prendergast, a postdoctoral researcher based at the South East Technological University (SETU) in Waterford is the principal investigator of the study. She previously worked as a journalist in Latin America and has recently been working on the Grass Ceiling project in Waterford which is focused on women innovators in farm and rural areas. Funded through Research Ireland, the Time to be Seen study is being carried out in conjunction with Macra and the University of Limerick. As part of the project an Agri Rural Media Forum took place in Limerick yesterday (Thursday, June 5) which brought together journalists and women working in agriculture and living in rural areas. The in-person forum, which was attended by Agriland, will be supplemented by interviews with journalists and rural women. There will also be a focus group held with farm and rural men to hear their views on the topic. Media analysis will be carried out to examine specific issues such as how female leaders in farm organisations are represented in the media. Gender balance Dr Muireann Prendergast told Agriland the project is hoping to develop guidelines and recommendations for journalists to promote gender balance when it comes to reporting on farm and rural issues. Training materials will also be made available through Macra Skillnet to help women develop their media skills and encourage their participation in stories. 'There a lot of social and cultural norms that are present in media in terms of how farming and entrepreneurship in rural areas is more associated with men than women, which is inaccurate. 'Women also make a huge, fantastic contribution to these areas as well. We just want to promote that their voices are seen and heard,' Prendergast said. During yesterday's forum, the rural women present suggested that a gender balanced media directory be developed to allow more women to feature in farming and rural stories on media outlets. Prendergast described this as a fantastic recommendation, adding 'we do find that more men than women tend to be quoted as expert sources'.
