Waymo's former CEO is not impressed with Tesla's Robotaxi
Business Insider sought the former Waymo CEO's thoughts on Tesla's Robotaxi Bay Area launch. Krafcik led Waymo from 2015 to 2021. He now sits on the board for Rivian, a Tesla rival in the electric vehicle space.
"If they were striving to re-create today's Bay Area Uber experience," he told Business Insider over email, "looks like they've absolutely nailed it."
Tesla rolled out a ride-hailing service in the San Francisco Bay Area in July, about a month after it began its pilot of Robotaxi. A human safety monitor sits behind the steering wheel since Tesla has yet to apply for permits that would allow the company to test and deploy fully driverless taxis in California.
The service remains invite-only. CEO Elon Musk said on August 10 that Tesla's Robotaxi will be "open access" by next month.
In Austin, where rules around autonomous vehicle deployment are less stringent, a human safety monitor sits in the front passenger seat of the Model Y.
For Krafcik, the presence of an employee inside the car is proof that Tesla has yet to show off a real robotaxi service.
"Please let me know when Tesla launches a robotaxi — I'm still waiting," he told Business Insider. "It's (rather obviously) not a robotaxi if there's an employee inside the car."
Krafcik told Business Insider he has no interest in trying Tesla's Robotaxi.
Waymo's initial rollout in 2017 shared a few similarities to Tesla's Robotaxi launch.
At the time, Waymo began what it called an " early rider program" in Arizona, allowing a select group of people to try the company's service. Safety drivers were present in the cars, and riders were temporarily put under a nondisclosure agreement.
While there's no industry standard definition of a robot taxi, the Society of Automotive Engineers outlines six levels of autonomous driving, ranging from 0 to 6. The SAE taxonomy defines Level 4 and Level 5 as autonomous driving that does not require a human to physically take over the wheel when requested.
Business Insider reported in May that Tesla has yet to use a permit that allows testing for cars that are Level 3 and above. It's not yet clear if Tesla's Robotaxi in the Bay Area would be considered Level 3, which only requires a driver to take over the vehicle when the autonomous driving system requests an intervention.
Waymo began offering fully driverless paid rides in Phoenix near the end of 2020 and has since expanded the service in several US cities, including SF, Los Angeles, and Austin, with more than 1,500 robotaxis on the road.
In 2019, when Waymo had a program that allowed select members of the public to try the service with a safety driver in the car, two riders told Business Insider at the time that the rides were nearly flawless but encountered several situations where the safety driver had to intervene.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Entrepreneur
12 minutes ago
- Entrepreneur
How Much Do AT&T Employees Make? Salaries Revealed
The filings revealed that AT&T's compensation is competitive, with software engineers and principal software engineers earning $167,098 to $207,425. AT&T is one of the world's biggest telecommunications companies, with the largest wireless network in North America. With a market capitalization of over $207 billion at the time of writing, AT&T is among the top 75 most valuable companies globally by market value. But how well does this telecom giant pay its employees? New federal filings, seen by Business Insider, reveal how much AT&T pays its employees. AT&T submitted these filings with the U.S. Department of Labor in the first half of the year as part of an effort to hire highly skilled foreign workers for specialized roles through the H-1B visa program. So far this year, AT&T has filed 345 H-1B applications, up from 266 at the same point last year, according to BI. Related: How Much Does Apple Pay Its Employees? Here Are the Exact Salaries of Staff Jobs, Including Developers, Engineers, and Consultants. The H-1B data only includes base annual salaries and omits add-ons, like signing bonuses and stock options. Other tech companies employ greater numbers of foreign workers. Google, for example, submitted 6,800 H-1B applications in the first quarter of the year alone, mainly in tech roles like software engineering and data science. The filings show that AT&T competitively compensates its software engineers, with principal software engineers taking home $167,098 to $207,425. That range has a higher starting point than companies like Meta and Microsoft, but a lower maximum. For example, Meta pays $120,000 to $480,000 and Microsoft pays $82,971 to $284,000 for software engineers. Related: Here's How Much Money Amazon Employees — From Software Engineers to Product Managers — Make in a Year Here's how AT&T compensates other members of its staff, per the filings: Lead System Engineer: $139,750 to $180,000 $139,750 to $180,000 Principal Data/AI Engineer: $163,737 to $197,464 $163,737 to $197,464 Senior Data/AI Engineer: $138,699 $138,699 Senior Data Analyst: $134,322 $134,322 Senior Data Scientist: $148,043 $148,043 Senior Tech Product Manager: $124,689 to $156,000 AT&T also submitted a proxy filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission in May that offered a glimpse into the company's overall compensation. According to the proxy statement, a mid-level employee at the company made $122,611 last year. In comparison, AT&T CEO John Stankey made over $26.4 million that same year, or 215 times more than the median worker. AT&T CEO John Stankey. Photo byfor Advertising Week New York AT&T made a push to return to the office this year, implementing a five-day-a-week return-to-office schedule in January. Earlier this month, Stankey sent a memo to staff urging them to commit to a fully in-person schedule or find work elsewhere. Related: AT&T CEO Tells Employees to Comply With 5-Day Office Rule or Leave According to AT&T's careers website, the telecom giant had more than 1,600 jobs listed globally, with the majority of jobs (1,578) based in the U.S. Some of the categories with the highest number of postings were technology and sales. AT&T's stock was up over 27% year-to-date at the time of writing. Join top CEOs, founders and operators at the Level Up conference to unlock strategies for scaling your business, boosting revenue and building sustainable success.
Business Insider
13 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Trump releases new rules to limit a major student-loan forgiveness program for public servants
Student-loan forgiveness for public servants is on the line. President Donald Trump's administration published its new rules to narrow eligibility for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program on Monday. The public comment period — during which anyone can submit comments on the new regulations to the administration — is officially open through September 17. PSLF, which is intended to forgive student debt for government and nonprofit workers after 10 years of qualifying payments, has allowed for the discharge of over a billion dollars in student debt for public servants. Trump is seeking to alter the program — he signed an executive order in March asking the education secretary to redefine what "public service" means to remove PSLF eligibility for employers engaging in "anti-American" activities. The proposed rule to limit PSLF, published in the Federal Register, said that "in cases where an employer is deemed to have engaged in activities that breach federal or state law or established public policy, affected borrowers would no longer receive credit toward loan forgiveness for months worked after the effective date of ineligibility." "While this may delay or prevent forgiveness for a subset of borrowers, the overall design of the regulations—including advance notice, transparency around determinations, and employer recertification pathways—helps mitigate unexpected harm," the rule said. Compromising behavior by an employer, according to the rule, could include violation of the federal disabilities act; violation of federal immigration law; what the department characterizes as "chemical castration or mutilation," like the use of puberty blockers or hormones to help a transgender person transition; and acts of terrorism. The Department of Education held negotiation sessions with stakeholders in early July, and some members of the committee expressed concerns with the department's intent to limit the program. Please help BI improve our Business, Tech, and Innovation coverage by sharing a bit about your role — it will help us tailor content that matters most to people like you. What is your job title? (1 of 2) Entry level position Project manager Management Senior management Executive management Student Self-employed Retired Other Continue By providing this information, you agree that Business Insider may use this data to improve your site experience and for targeted advertising. By continuing you agree that you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy . "The intent of Congress was not to narrow the eligibility," Betsy Mayotte, the president of The Institute of Student Loan Advisors and a representative of student-loan borrowers, said during a session. "It was to make it as expansive as possible under the statute that they wrote." Representatives of the administration argued that the education secretary has the authority to interpret regulations and statutes and can legally refine PSLF. Student-loan borrowers enrolled in PSLF previously told Business Insider that Trump's plans to change a program they rely on for debt relief are a major concern. "I'm so close to the finish line," Jeff Hughes, a government employee with student debt, said. "I really hope that the program continues as is because we need some more good people out there doing good work." Undersecretary of Education Nicholas Kent said in a statement that "the federal government has a vital interest in deterring unlawful conduct, and we're moving quickly to ensure employers don't benefit while breaking the law."
Business Insider
43 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Mining is back as the battery boom ratchets up demand. Redwood Materials says it can make the industry sustainable.
Heavy industry meets battery recycling as Redwood Materials strikes a deal with Caterpillar to recycle the lithium-ion batteries powering CAT's electric mining equipment. Caterpillar's R1700 XE is a zero-emission underground loader that's powered by electricity rather than diesel fuel. Its 213-kWh battery pack, roughly equivalent to 3 to 4 Tesla battery packs, stores enough energy to run the loader in demanding conditions while eliminating on-site exhaust emissions. For miners, this means improved air quality underground and reduced ventilation costs. What makes the partnership with Redwood noteworthy is the cyclical nature of this new value chain: the very metals Caterpillar's equipment extracts, such as lithium, are now being recovered from the R1700 XE's batteries and fed back into the supply chain. When these batteries eventually run out, Redwood ensures that high-value materials, including lithium, cobalt, and nickel, are extracted, refined, and ready for reuse. This reduces reliance on freshly mined resources and keeps valuable metals in circulation. Dustin Krause, VP of sales and business development, described the somewhat ironic nature of mining with electric equipment and the fact that Redwood can recycle some of that equipment and the material it pulls from the ground, infinitely. "Redwood usually does grave to cradle. We bring end-of-life materials from batteries and bring them back to life again," Krause told Business Insider. "With CAT, this is both grave to cradle, and cradle to grave. We're helping this company get these materials out of the ground, too." This highlights how practical, realistic approaches are needed to support the transition from carbon-emitting fossil fuels to cleaner electric solutions. According to Redwood, global demand for batteries is expected to soar by more than 1,000% in the coming decade. It's not enough just to recycle this stuff — we still need to dig it out of the ground. Redwood and CAT aim to make that mining process as sustainable and financially viable as possible. The deal mirrors Redwood's existing arrangements with automakers and other companies that deal with a lot of batteries reaching the end of their useful lives. Redwood often pays to access this supply, betting it can make more money by turning this unwanted, hazardous scrap into the new black gold. The company says it recycles the equivalent of 250,000 electric vehicles ' worth of batteries annually. While neither company disclosed the exact commercial terms, Redwood confirmed that the arrangement ensures recovered materials return value to Caterpillar — whether as direct value recovery or reduced raw material costs — while giving Redwood a new source of batteries to funnel into its giant recycling operation. This means that while some of the recovered material could eventually find its way back into CAT's equipment, it will also serve other battery manufacturing needs in the broader market. Electrifying underground equipment offers environmental and economic advantages. Diesel-powered machinery requires complex and costly ventilation systems to remove exhaust from underground tunnels. Ventilation is needed; otherwise, workers would inhale nasty fumes underground. Electric loaders, such as the R1700 XE, eliminate that need, reduce carbon emissions, and can lower operating costs over time. By combining Redwood's expertise in large-format battery recycling with Caterpillar's mining innovation, this partnership signals a future where the materials that power heavy industry are continuously recovered, reused, and reintegrated — closing the loop on mining's electrification journey.
