It's Time to Let Go of ‘African American'

New York Times

10-07-2025

I'm no fan of performative identity politics, and I think racial preferences are long past their expiration date. Yet I don't think the New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani did anything wrong when, as was reported last week, he checked off 'Black or African American' on a college application. As a man of South Asian descent who spent the first part of his life living in Uganda, he was within his rights to call himself African American. The problem is that the term appeared on the application, or anywhere else. Plenty of Black people have never liked it, and ever more are joining the ranks. It's time to let it go.
'African American' entered mainstream circulation in the late '80s as a way to call attention to Black people's heritage in the same way that terms like 'Italian American' and 'Asian American' do for members of those groups. The Rev. Jesse Jackson encouraged its usage, declaring: 'Black does not describe our situation. In my household there are seven people and none of us have the same complexion. We are of African-American heritage.' In 1989 the columnist and historian Roger Wilkins told Isabel Wilkerson: 'Whenever I go to Africa, I feel like a person with a legitimate place to stand on this earth. This is the name for all the feelings I've had all these years.'
Since that time, the United States has seen an enormous change in immigration patterns. In 1980 there were about 200,000 people in America who were born in Africa; by 2023 there were 2.8 million. So today, for people who were born in Africa, any children they have after moving here and Black people whose last African ancestors lived centuries ago, the term 'African American' treats them as if they are all in the same category, forcing a single designation for an inconveniently disparate range of humans.
Further complicating matters is that many Africans now living here are not Black. White people from, for example, South Africa or Tanzania might also legitimately call themselves African American. As for the community that Mamdani grew up in, it dates back to at least the late 19th century, when South Asians were brought to Uganda to work as servants for British colonizers. 'Mississippi Masala,' the movie for which Mamdani's mother, the filmmaker Mira Nair, is perhaps best known, tells the story of South Asian Ugandans expelled from the country in 1972 by the dictator Idi Amin. Feeling just as dislocated from the only home they had ever known as I would feel if expelled from the United States, they would be quite reasonable in viewing themselves as African Americans after settling here.
A term that is meant to be descriptive but that can refer to Cedric the Entertainer, Trevor Noah, Elon Musk and Zohran Mamdani is a little silly.
And not just silly but chilly. 'African American' sounds like something on a form. Or something vaguely euphemistic, as if you're trying to avoid saying something out loud. It feels less like a term for the vibrant, nuanced bustle of being a human than like seven chalky syllables bureaucratically impervious to abbreviation. Italian Americans call themselves 'Italian' for short. Asian Americans are 'Asian.' But for any number of reasons, it's hard to imagine a great many Black Americans opting to call themselves simply African.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.