Galway villagers seek to bring challenge against housing of asylum seekers at hotel
Several residents of a Co Galway village want to bring High Court proceedings in a bid to stop the Government's decision to house international protection applicants at a local hotel.
Kinvara residents Ruth Sexton, Mary Boyce, Chris Hartnett Dalton and Paul Collins are seeking permission to challenge the recent decision to place up to 98 people in the Merriman Hotel, which is currently home to about 50 Ukrainian people.
Advertisement
According to court documents, the hotel has been used to accommodate people seeking international protection since 2019. The residents say the hotel has 32 rooms.
The residents want to bring the judicial review proceedings against the Minister for the Department of Children, Equality, Disability and Integration and the Minister for the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration. It is proposed that MLC Hotel Ltd, the hotel owner, be made a notice party in the action.
According to the residents, a meeting of Kinvara Community Council was in March informed of the Minister for the Department of Integration's decision to designate the hotel as accommodation for 98 international protection applicants.
In making that decision, the residents claim the Minister failed to assess or evaluate the suitability of the Merriam Hotel to accommodate those people.
Advertisement
They also say the Minister failed to assess or evaluate the availability of amenities in the local area, like school places and medical services.
They claim the use of the hotel as an accommodation centre since 2019 has resulted in losses of up to €13.3 million to the local area.
None of the €9 million paid to MLC Hotel Ltd through its contract to provide accommodation has benefited the local community, the residents claim, leading to the closure of restaurants and reducing opening hours at local pubs.
They say the Minister has failed to assess or evaluate the economic impact of his decision.
Advertisement
Moving the application to bring the judicial review proceedings this week, Mary Moran-Long BL, for the residents, said her clients were representing the community of Kinvara.
Ireland
High Court judge to rule on Athlone asylum centre...
Read More
Ms Sexton, of Sexton's Bar, Main Street, Kinvara, is a publican; Ms Boyce, of Cathercon, Kinvara, is a homemaker; Mr Hartnett Dalton, of Northampton, Kinvara, is a financial broker; and Mr Collins, of Crushoa, Kinvara, is a publican.
Ms Justice Marguerite Bolger said she felt there was insufficient material before the court to make a decision on whether or not to give Ms Moran-Long permission to bring the proceedings.
She permitted Ms Moran-Long to amend her court documents, and file additional sworn statements as required.
Ms Justice Bolger adjourned the case to next month. She directed that the respondents, the Minister for Integration and the Minister for Justice, be put on notice of the application for permission to bring the judicial review proceedings.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Move to ban airlines charging parents extra to sit next to children welcomed
Fine Gael MEP Regina Doherty has welcomed a move by the EU to ban airlines from charging parents extra to sit next to their children who are under the age of 12. Ms Doherty, who is a member of European Parliament's Internal Market and Consumer Protection Committee, said Irish airlines typically do not charge parents to sit next to their young children. Advertisement However, a number of other European airlines impose a charge in relation to seating of this type. Ms Doherty told Newstalk Breakfast that she had long been 'incensed' by the cash grab of airlines that opt to charge parents additional money to sit next to their children. 'Children under 12 shouldn't be without their parents. Airlines, I felt, were taking advantage of the fact that if they wanted to sit their families together, they had to pay extra charges. 'No more now; the Committee voted yesterday that airlines will not be able to charge families extra for sitting together.' Advertisement Ms Doherty described the charge as an 'abhorrent' practice and said legislation would end it once and for all. On Tuesday the Transport Committee of the EU voted through a series of measures which will increase the rights of passengers. The proposals will be voted on by the European Parliament in the coming weeks. If approved by MEPs, they will then be discussed by the European Council. Ms Doherty said the proposals were met with 'little or no resistance.' 'I think everyone knows this is a commonsense approach,' Ms Doherty said. 'The second thing is, we've seen in recent months a controversy where people were getting charged extra for bags. 'One of the things we voted on yesterday was that people will have a right to have a 7kg carry-on roller bag with them as a right, once it gets through the Parliament.' Ms Doherty added that she expects the changes to happen 'very soon.'
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Tánaiste to include services from Israeli settlements in trade ban
The Tánaiste has vowed to include the provision of services to legislation that will ban imports from Israeli settlements if it stands up to legislative scrutiny. Simon Harris also said he wants to put pressure on the other 26 European countries to consider banning trade with occupied Palestinian territories, and called on opposition parties to contact their counterparts in the bloc. Advertisement Mr Harris said Ireland is the only country to publish legislation to ban imports from the occupied Palestinian territories, saying it is 'pretty lonely out there', adding it would be 'a hell of a lot better' if Europe moved together on it. The legislation was approved by the Cabinet on Tuesday morning. Mr Harris brought forward the renamed Israeli Settlements (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill 2025. The Government opted for fresh legislation instead of progressing the Occupied Territories Bill, first tabled in 2018. Advertisement It will now go before an Oireachtas committee for examination. Mr Harris said that every Government TD will be expected to back the legislation as it forms part of the Programme for Government. 'Let's not forget one thing before we get into the detail of the legislation, there isn't another country in the European Union that you can visit today and ask a government minister about their Bill to ban trade and the detail of it, because they don't have one,' he added. 'We're the first country in the European Union to take this step. We're the first country in the European Union say, yes, trade is a European competency, and it'll be a hell of a lot better if Europe moves together, and a hell of a lot more impactful. Advertisement 'But in the absence of Europe moving together, we're going to go ahead with our own domestic legislation. 'I would really ask the opposition here not to do this lazy politicking of you know, opposition good, government bad. Everybody in this country is sickened to the pit of their stomach with the genocide they see in Gaza. 'They don't care, the people of Ireland, who they vote for in an election in relation to this, they just know in their gut what is happening, particularly children in Gaza, is genocide is wrong, and everyone has to do everything they want. 'I have no policy difference, zero policy difference with the opposition in relation to the inclusion of services, but we do have a Constitution, we are members of the European Union, and I'm not in the business of putting together legislation that would fall at the first legal hurdle. Advertisement 'I presume everybody here wants to pass a law that is impactful, a law that is in compliance with the laws of our land.' Earlier this week, a number of countries, including Ireland, asked the European Commission to examine how goods produced in illegal Jewish settlements 'can be brought into line with international law'. Mr Harris said he does not believe the European Union has made itself compliant with the ICJ advisory opinion. 'We will do our own legislation, (I am) open to services, absolutely open to working constructively with the opposition, but also keep the pressure on at the European level,' he added. Advertisement 'What I hope the opposition will be doing today, every opposition leader should be picking up the telephone, and they should be ringing their counterparts in European countries and saying, 'hey, have you seen here in Ireland we're bringing forward a domestic legislation, would you think about doing it yourself? 'Because so far, it's pretty lonely out there. There's not one other country in Europe that has published any legislation to ban trade, and I'd really appreciate the opposition's help with their counterparts in the 26 other European states.'
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Councillors' job is to build houses and not object to them
The Tánaiste has taken a swipe at county councillors, saying they 'need to realise' their job is to build houses, and not object to them. Simon Harris also said every part of the State needs to treat the housing crisis as an emergency, including the chief executives of Uisce Éireann and ESB. Advertisement Mr Harris made the comments as he and the Minister for Housing James Browne visited the site of new cost rental apartments in Tallaght, Dublin. The Department of Housing said it is the first local authority funded, standalone, cost rental development in Ireland. Tánaiste Simon Harris said every part of the state needs to treat the housing crisis as an emergency, including the chief executives of Uisce Éireann and ESB (Liam McBurney/PA) Both ministers said that 'key' to eliminating homelessness is supply of housing. 'Supply of a whole variety of homes, including social homes,' Mr Harris added. Advertisement 'I know one of the issues that the minister (for housing) is working on, and that we fully support across government, is making it even easier for local authorities to go through the approval process for new social homes more quickly, and looking at how we can improve a standardisation in terms of how we develop social homes so they can be delivered more quickly. 'We're in the early stages of this new government. 'That's why we're making big and bold decisions, including decisions that will be unpopular and difficult at times in relation to housing, including decisions that, quite rightly, people will be able to parse and analyse and critique, if they look at each decision individually. 'But actually, as the Minister (Browne) has rightly said, it is about putting together pieces of the jigsaw that will get us to those 300,000 incomes. Advertisement 'I don't in any way anyway underestimate the scale of the housing crisis. It is a housing emergency. 'It's very real and acute emergency for people, particularly families and challenge in relation to housing today, and that's why we need to break down every silo that exists in the state. 'Housing can't just be an emergency for the Minister for Housing, the Department of Housing, or people in need of housing, it has to be an emergency every part of the state. 'It has to be an emergency for the CEO Uisce Eireann, the CEO of the ESB, every chief executive of every local authority, every county councillor who needs to realise their job is not to object to houses, but build houses. Advertisement 'This is where we've got to get to break down the silos.' Last week, emergency legislation that saw rent pressure zones extended nationwide was signed into law. The system, which caps rent increases at the rate of inflation or 2 per cent, whichever is lower, have also been extended until the end of February after originally being due to expire at the end of the year. Mr Browne said more time is needed to assess the impact of the changes in law. Advertisement He said that landlords have been leaving the system in 'substantial numbers' for years because of the previous laws around Rent Pressure Zones. 'We wanted to bring in stronger tenants' rights, that's really important,' Mr Browne added. 'And also be able to activate supply because of when it comes to the prices of homes, the only way we're going to get the prices to stabilise is through the increase of supply. 'That increase of supply will bring down rents, will increase the supply of homes to stabilise those and help eliminate homelessness as well. 'It is all about supply, supply, supply, supply, and that's what we're all aiming at towards now while protecting our renters and ensuring people can live in their local communities.' He said that around 40 per cent of people going into homelessness is a result of notice to quit in tenancies. He claimed the new legislation will bring in security of tenure. 'We know internationally, where you have higher homelessness, it is where you also have higher rents,' he added. 'By getting that supply up, you get rents down, and we'll also help to get homelessness down, but also the measures we've made around Rent Pressure Zones, around security of tenure, will help prevent people going into homelessness as well. 'With this legislation in that we have security of tenure. 'We also have a large population moving from Ipas centres, who have had their situation regulated, but don't have somewhere to live, coming into our homeless situation as well. 'I'm very conscious that well over 70 per cent of everybody who's homeless is also in Dublin. 'So there was a lot of moving parts in terms of the homeless situation. 'We're trying to address them all. 'But for those coming into homelessness to prevent them, we have record prevention as well, with people going into homelessness and getting people exited out as quickly as possible.'
