Court weighs parole ineligibility for foreign worker in Leamington 'crime of passion' murder
Warning: contains graphic content
David Espinoza Montes, 41, has already pleaded guilty to second-degree murder for killing his common-law spouse, Shermaine Carling, 33.
Both were working in Leamington as temporary foreign workers and living together in a rooming house on Mill Street.
On Sept. 29, 2022, Carling was stabbed to death with a knife and a pair of scissors, by Espinoza Montes.
'It may have been a momentary lapse in judgement by the accused, but it was a brutal and sustained act of violence against Ms. Carling,' Assistant Crown Attorney Nicole Stortini said Thursday. 'She was defenceless and attacked in the sanctity of her own home.'
Court learned Carling suffered 48 'sharp force wounds' to her body, including 21 in her back and 17 in her neck and upper torso.
Victim Impact Statements
Stortini described two victim impact statements read into the record as 'powerful'.
They were both read into the record by Assistant Crown Attorney Jayme Lesperance, on behalf of family that does not live in Canada.
'The brutality of my sister's murder - committed in the very home she once called her sanctuary -has shattered our sense of safety and left us living in constant fear,' Rhea Pulido told the court.
Pulido said her sister immigrated to Canada to provide a better life for her two children and to provide for her extended family in the Philippines.
'Her death has thus inflicted a dual loss: the irreplaceable presence of a devoted daughter, sister, and mother, and the broad-reaching financial foundation she so selflessly built for our entire family.'
Jhoy William-Sipol, another relative of Carling's, told the court both of Carlings' children have now dropped out of school due to stress.
'As the main point of contact for authorities, doctors, victim's services, and others, I'm usually the first to hear the news or any updates and then comes the difficult task of sharing it with family members who are more in deep pain than I am,' William-Sipol wrote.
William-Sipol explained the emotional toll of the court process since 2022.
'I felt vulnerable and feared retaliation from friends of the accused, knowing I'm the executor.'
Accused apologizes
Espinosa Montes apologized to the Carling family, the court and to Canada when given a chance to speak Thursday.
'I came to this country for the purpose of working. I did not come to create problems to this country,' Espinosa Montes said. 'I have never been in prison in my life. I have never been in prison in my own country. This is my first time.'
Espinosa Montes didn't speak specifically about Carling but did say he is remorseful for his actions that took her life.
'I apologize again to her family, her children, her mother. And I only pray now that God will guard them and protect them so they can get ahead,' Espinosa Montes said.
'I have lost so much for a moment of anger.'
No excuse for actions
'This is a crime of passion,' defence lawyer Patricia Brown said Thursday during a sentencing hearing. 'The victim was seeing another man.'
Brown said her client had a 'momentary lapse' in judgment.
'When he discovered those text messages on that fateful day, he caused the death of the victim. There is no excuse,' Brown said.
She said her client was struggling from declining mental health, insomnia and alcohol abuse.
'Even the victim, earlier that day, was in support of him going to the clinic to get medication,' Brown said, noting however alcohol was not a factor the day of the killing.
Joint submission on sentence
Espinosa Montes pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, which carries a life sentence in prison.
The defence and both Assistant Crown Attorneys presented a joint submission on sentencing.
They would like Espinosa Montes to be sentenced to a period of parole ineligibility of 12 years.
Judge reserves decision
Justice Joseph Perfetto was prepared to return with his decision late Thursday afternoon.
At the request of the Crown however, decided to defer to Wednesday July 23.
Carlings' family members were watching the court proceedings remotely Thursday, where they are 12 hours ahead.
He decided instead to return with a decision starting at 9 a.m.
Immigration concerns
At the time of her death, Carling was seeking refugee status so she could stay in Canada and continue to support her family in the Philippines.
Espinoza Montes immigrated to Canada from Honduras because he was 'being targeted by a gang', according to Brown.
She says her client fears for his safety once he's served his sentence in Canada.
There was discussion Thursday about Espinoza Montes' fate once he is granted parole, with Brown noting he is likely to be deported but will attempt to remain in the country for safety reasons.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
Montreal lawyers see troubling increase in teens accused of homicide
Social Sharing Prosecutors and defence lawyers in Montreal are calling attention to the rising number of young people accused of homicide. "What we've seen is an increase — those files and numbers are increasing in our office," said Crown prosecutor Louis-David Bénard. And it's not a small increase, said defence lawyer Tiago Múrias. "It's very, very, very obvious," he said, recalling a time when it was rare for young people to be either accused of or victims of homicide. "Now it's like tenfold." The spike began during the pandemic and has grown serious enough that a dedicated team of prosecutors now handles homicide cases in youth court in Montreal. While many factors contribute to the trend, one stands out: access to firearms. "For young teenagers, it's easier for them to possess or buy firearms on the streets of Montreal," said Bénard. WATCH | Increasing number of youth-related homicides, lawyers say: Rise in Montreal teens accused of homicide sparks creation of special prosecutors team 7 minutes ago Rise in violent youth crimes In recent years, several high-profile cases have involved teen suspects or victims. Amir Benayad, 17, was shot and killed in an alley in the Plateau-Mont-Royal borough at the start of 2022 during a dispute. Two youths pleaded guilty in that case. In July 2024, police arrested a 16-year-old in connection with a fatal shooting in a Dollard-des-Ormeaux parking lot. The victim in that case was 42. More recently this summer, a 17-year-old survived multiple gunshot wounds in Côte-des-Neiges–Notre-Dame-de-Grâce. "How did it come to that?" asked Múrias, noting that teenagers used to get in trouble for stealing chips from convenience stores — not carrying guns. "That's something that is very troubling." And it's not just firearms. In April, 16-year-old Makhai Bennett-Ruddock was fatally stabbed in Côte-des-Neiges–Notre-Dame-de-Grâce. A 17-year-old was charged with manslaughter in that case. A year earlier, a 35-year-old man was stabbed outside the Lionel-Groulx Metro station. The attack, described by police as random, led to the arrest of five teens aged 13 to 18. Bénard said teens are particularly vulnerable and easily influenced as they look to build a name for themselves on the streets or social media. He was unable to provide exact numbers, but he said the increase in youth violence is clear. "We're seeing a proliferation of guns and youth firing guns," he said. Youth murder cases are complex, lawyers say Lawyers say murder cases involving minors are legally complex — especially when it comes to sentencing. When an adult is convicted of first-degree murder, the sentence is automatic. But that's not the case for youth. "To sentence those young teenagers with a sentence adapted for them — it's not an easy task," said Bénard. Múrias described the sentencing phase as "a trial after the trial," focusing on maturity and accountability. "It becomes a trial about just and proportionate consequences in regards to cerebral development. So it's really a challenge," he said. That challenge may soon grow. A Supreme Court of Canada decision last week will make it harder for minors convicted of murder to be sentenced as adults. The decision says youth court judges shouldn't consider the seriousness of the offence when deciding whether to impose an adult sentence. Instead, they must focus solely on the accused's development and moral judgment. It also states that prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a youth had adult-level maturity. The ruling reaffirms that young people are presumed to have diminished moral blameworthiness under the Youth Criminal Justice Act.
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
Toronto police officer's drunken crash followed shift spent drinking with colleagues, tribunal docs allege
Social Sharing More than two years after a Toronto police officer pleaded guilty to impaired driving, disciplinary charges against his superior are raising questions about the night of the collision and the integrity of one of the force's investigative drug teams. Then-Det.-Const. Jason Boag was arrested after a collision north of Toronto early in the morning of Jan. 31, 2023. He pleaded guilty to impaired driving that April. Then, in November 2023, he pleaded guilty to one count of professional misconduct before the Toronto Police Service's disciplinary tribunal, where a hearing officer described the case as an "off-duty" incident. But that's not the case, according to pending disciplinary charges against Boag's superior, Det. Mark Beson. CBC News attempted to contact Beson by phone and email. A representative for the Toronto Police Association said Beson was aware of this story before its publication, but the officer had no comment. Beson — who is not currently suspended and next appears before the tribunal on Aug. 26 — faces seven disciplinary charges for allegedly spending Jan. 30, 2023 at a Buffalo Wild Wings, where he and the five detective constables under his supervision drank alcohol on-duty. More concerning though, say criminal defence lawyers, are the allegations that Beson later falsified records to conceal his team's misconduct. A finding that Beson altered paperwork would "be substantial fodder for any criminal defence lawyer" who encounters the detective, defence lawyer Craig Zeeh said. "You have an officer who's willing to lie — why not willing to lie under oath? Why not willing to lie in court?" said Zeeh. "If you have an officer willing to fudge records to support his narrative, that can undermine many investigations, depending on his role in them." Adam Weisberg, vice-president of the Criminal Lawyers' Association, agreed. "If there's a lot of meat to this allegation … I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of charges get stayed wherever this officer's evidence is key," Weisberg said. The Public Prosecution Service of Canada declined to say how many charges, if any, have been dropped because of the allegations against Beson. Toronto police are "not aware of any" cases that ended as a result of Beson's charges, spokesperson Nadine Ramadan said via email. Officers spent 8 hours at Wild Wings, docs suggest On Jan. 30, 2023, Beson, supervisor for a "Clandestine Lab Team," arrived at the Wild Wings inside an arena at 11:59 a.m., according to Toronto police tribunal records. His team was scheduled to work from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m., according to tribunal documents. Beson and the five detective constables under his supervision allegedly drank alcohol. "Surprise, surprise," said James Lowry, a former Toronto police officer who investigated allegations of drug squad corruption. Lowry, now a Winnipeg defence lawyer, said officers in specialized and plainclothes units have more autonomy than their uniformed colleagues. "You should be professional, and you've got a fair bit of service, so you shouldn't need to be babysat," he said. However, that freedom can entail opportunities for misconduct. "You'd never do it in uniform," Lowry said of the alleged on-duty drinking. "Not that it hasn't happened, but I'd be very surprised." Beson and Boag left the restaurant shortly after 8 p.m and drove in a police vehicle to the drug squad building, according to tribunal documents. Around 10:25 p.m., a "highly intoxicated" Boag left the drug squad building and drove away. A Newmarket court heard that OPP officers dispatched to a collision in Township of King, north of Toronto, shortly after midnight on Jan. 31 found Boag in a sedan against the centre barrier of Highway 400. According to tribunal records, Boag had struck a dump truck. Boag, who identified himself as a police officer, had urinated on himself, according to a court transcript. When an officer asked for Boag's licence, he presented his debit card. Knowing the TPS professional standards unit would investigate following Boag's collision, Beson allegedly changed his and his teammates' shift times on a sign-in sheet to indicate the group started and finished work earlier than they actually had, so it would appear the group had not been drinking on duty. Beson initialed the sheet for his entire team, according to tribunal documents. Only 1 disciplinary case mentions drinking 'on duty' It's not clear why Boag's impaired driving disciplinary charges were treated as an "off-duty" incident given the accusation that Boag, Beson and four others were drinking on duty. The sentencing decision, written by Supt. Shane Branton, does not mention when, where, or with whom Boag became intoxicated. Branton did not respond to requests for comment. "In any case brought before the tribunal, the prosecutor evaluates the available evidence and lays the charges they determine to be most appropriate," Ramadan said in an email. A summary of the prosecution submissions in the same ruling also does not mention the time Boag spent drinking on duty, as described in documents outlining Beson's pending charges. Reached by phone and asked why Boag did not face discipline for on-duty conduct, Insp. Lisabet Benoit, who prosecuted the case, said she would review her notes. "I will endeavour to get some clarity for you," Benoit said. Hours later, she texted a CBC News reporter declining further comment. Boag's lawyer Sandip Khehra declined to comment specifically on the tribunal's decision to treat the officer's misconduct as off-duty. "When you're working out resolutions with prosecutors, there's a little bit of give and take," he said. "Sometimes they massage the facts." 'Too early to tell' possible sanctions It's not clear if any of the other four officers on Beson's team have faced discipline in connection with the case. "Only disciplinary matters that appear before the tribunal are made public," Ramadan, the Toronto police spokesperson, said. Officers found guilty at the disciplinary tribunal can be fired, but a hearing officer will weigh several factors when deciding on a penalty, according to Ian Johnstone, a lawyer who has prosecuted cases for police services, including Toronto's. "It's too early to tell with just the charge," Johnstone said.
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
Rise in Montreal teens accused of homicide sparks creation of special prosecutors team
Montreal prosecutors and defence lawyers say the jump in criminal cases involving youth started during the pandemic. They say gun violence is one of the main reasons for the increase.
