Scottish Ministers call in hotel demolition decision
East Lothian councillors voted to approve plans to tear down the Golf Hotel, in North Berwick, and replace it with 14 flats at a meeting earlier this year.
The decision went against planning officers recommendations and objections from Historic Environment Scotland who are a statutory body.
In a letter to the local authority Scottish Ministers have confirmed they will consider the application themselves and issue a decision.
It comes after the Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland (AHSS) also called for Government intervention describing the unlisted building as 'architecturally distinguished' adding it occupies a 'key position in the North Berwick conservation area.
The Golf Hotel closed commercially in 2006 and had been used by its owners for staff accommodation until it was bought by its current owners during the pandemic.
However plans to demolish the building and build 14 flats on the site, on Dirleton Avenue, were recommended for refusal by planning officers who said it had not been proven that the hotel could not continue to operate as a commercial venture.
And Historic Environment Scotland (HES) objected to its demolition after describing the building as having historic and architectural significance in the town.
At a planning committee meeting in March East Lothian councillors heard the former hotel had initially been a house for a single family who used it in the last century as a holiday home evening bringing their own cattle with them so the children did not have to drink local milk.
Caledonian Heritable bought the building in 2021 and applied for permission to demolish it and build 14 luxury flats on the site.
Objectors to the demolition said the building should be given listed status and was an important part of the town's conservation area.
A council spokesperson said: 'Scottish Ministers have called in the application for the demolition of the former Golf Hotel meaning it will now be for them to determine.
'We have submitted the necessary information required to begin the process and made all local members, the community council and objectors aware of this action.'
By Marie Sharp Local Democracy Reporter
Like this:
Like
Related
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
Edinburgh emerges as one of UK's top co-working markets
Scotland is home to 279 flexible workspaces as of Q2 2025 — with Glasgow (61), Edinburgh (55), and Aberdeen (26) all ranking among the UK's top 15 coworking markets. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Together, these three cities anchor Scotland's position as a key player in the UK's expanding flexible office landscape. That's according to CoworkingCafe's Q2 2025 State of the Coworking Industry Report, which draws on proprietary data as of July. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The report provides a detailed breakdown of flexible workspace supply at both national and local levels — highlighting the top 15 coworking markets, the largest operators, and median pricing for monthly memberships, day passes, virtual office packages, and meeting rooms. Median Subscription Prices by Country Q2 2025 Median Subscription Prices by Country Q2 2025 Scotland is home to 279 co-working spaces as of Q2 2025, with more than half of them concentrated in the country's three largest markets: Glasgow (#4), Edinburgh (#5), and Aberdeen (#11) in the UK-wide rankings. This urban clustering highlights the regional demand for flexible work solutions, particularly in cities with strong business, academic, and innovation ecosystems. Across Scotland, co-working pricing remains competitive compared to UK averages. The median monthly membership is £150, notably below the UK median of £180. Day passes average £23/day, and virtual office packages are priced at a median of £95/month, aligning with the national median. Meeting rooms in Scotland cost £25/hour on average. Among operators, Wasps is a key player in the region, with 18 co-working locations across various Scottish cities. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Distribution of Coworking Spaces — UK & Ireland Q2 2025 With 61 flexible workspaces, Glasgow ranks #4 in the UK and leads Scotland in co-working availability. It offers a balanced pricing profile: monthly memberships are priced at £160, above the Scottish median but still below the UK benchmark. Day passes cost £23/day, tying Glasgow for the most affordable rate in the UK alongside Newcastle, Nottingham, and Brighton. Virtual office subscriptions, however, are relatively high at £119/month, well above both Scottish and UK medians. Meeting rooms are priced affordably at £23/hour, one of the lowest rates nationwide and comparable to Cardiff. Edinburgh ranks #5 in the UK and second in Scotland, offering 55 co-working locations across the city. As Scotland's capital, it commands some of the highest pricing in the region. Monthly memberships average £192, well above both the Scottish and UK medians. Day passes are priced at £30/day, placing Edinburgh among the UK's top-tier markets, alongside Greater London, Oxford, and Belfast. Virtual offices cost £99/month, slightly above the national median of £95, while meeting rooms are priced at £40/hour, among the highest in Scotland and the UK overall. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Aberdeen ranks #11 in the UK and third in Scotland, with 26 co-working spaces as of Q2 2025. Pricing in the city reflects a mid-range profile: monthly memberships are £160/month, above the Scottish average but still below the national median. Day passes cost £28/day, higher than both Scottish and UK medians, while virtual offices are priced at £95/month, matching the national figure. Meeting rooms in Aberdeen are typically £30/hour, aligning with the UK-wide median. As of Q2 2025, the UK and Ireland collectively host 4,199 co-working spaces, reflecting a broad and mature flexible office landscape. The UK accounts for 3,949 of these locations, with 3,456 in England, 279 in Scotland, 124 in Wales, and 90 in Northern Ireland. Greater London remains the epicenter of activity, with 1,202 coworking spaces, followed by other major hubs such as Manchester (118), Birmingham (68), Glasgow (61), and Bristol (61). In Ireland, there are 250 co-working spaces, with nearly half concentrated in Dublin (119) — firmly positioning the capital as the country's dominant flex office market. You can read the full report at
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
Scottish ministers overrule advice and approve Cairngorms hotel plans
A letter published by the Scottish Government's Planning and Environmental Appeals Division (DPEA) reveals that ministers have opted to green-light proposals for 22 self-catering apartments, shops, a hotel, and underground parking at 111 Grampian Road in Aviemore. It comes more than two years after SNP ministers took the decision to 'call in' the planning application and rule on it themselves – which happened on May 3, 2023. Later that month, the Cairngorms National Park Authority said it had been minded to approve the proposals. However, a Government planning reporter then recommended that the proposal be refused, submitting their initial report on the development on November 23, 2023, with a supplementary report following on January 17, 2025. The primary issues of concern were flood risk, transport impacts on B9152 Grampian Road, and design. However, SNP ministers have gone against the recommendations and approved the development, recognising that it will be on 'brownfield land set within a built up area'. Work on development will be allowed to go ahead after a series of conditions have been met. These include: Developers must contribute fairly (cash or in-kind) to active travel measures to offset traffic impact on B9152 Grampian Road. Updated reptile and otter surveys must be completed before starting work. An updated Flood Risk Assessment (FRA) must be conducted based on latest Scottish Environment Protection Agency climate data. Owners must install and maintain bat and bird boxes across the site. Four ensuite rooms must be kept permanently as hotel staff accommodation. The DPEA letter outlining the SNP ministers' decision states: 'On balance, and subject to conditions and planning obligation, the Scottish Ministers are satisfied there is sufficient development plan support to outweigh the conflict with flood policies, and they consider that the proposed development overall is in accordance with the development plan, and there are no material considerations which would outweigh that. 'In reaching this conclusion, the Scottish Ministers have given due consideration to the aims of the National Park as required by Section 9.6 of the National Parks (Scotland) Act 2000.'
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Councillors told not to object to solar site size of 146 football fields
The 50MW battery storage system and 60MW solar energy park is the latest renewable energy development proposed for the Coupar Angus area. Perth and Kinross Council's (PKC) Planning and Placemaking Committee will meet to consider the application, as a statutory consultee, on Wednesday, August 6. Sirius EcoDev (Stirling) Ltd has submitted an application to the Scottish Government's Energy Consents Unit (ECU) to develop an energy plant capable of producing, exporting, importing and storing 110MW of power on 105 hectares of [[Perth]]shire farmland. READ MORE: Scottish pupils' exam results to be delayed due to Storm Floris, SQA says Planning applications for energy plant proposals of 50MW or more have to be considered by the ECU, and the local council is asked whether or not it objects to the application as a statutory consultee. The Perthshire project is 600 metres north-west of Caddam Cottage, Keithick – between Burrelton and Coupar Angus – and has been called Stirling Battery and Solar Energy Park. In its supporting statement, Herefordshire-based Sirius EcoDev (Stirling) described the development as being of 'significant importance in safeguarding the supply to the region and reducing the reliance on carbon heavy alternatives'. There are four proposed access points to the site: one off the A923 and three off an unnamed road which dissects the southern part of the site. The latest proposed energy development for the Coupar Angus area is close to the consented Keithick Solar Energy Park and would use 11.5MW of solar area from the consented site, plus 48.5MW of solar land from the west and north. Stirling Battery and Solar Energy Park would provide enough energy for around 37,520 homes which Sirius EcoDev (Stirling) has said would save 37,173 metric tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) every year and 1,486,910 metric tonnes of CO2 over its 40-year lifespan. On July 24 Stop Oversized Solar launched a campaign claiming UK 'farmland the size of Derbyshire is now under threat of solar power development'. The group has raised concern UK solar sites in the pipeline would cover around 655,000 acres – up to five per cent of crop land. Last month, Perth and Kinross opposition councillors responded to residents' concerns about arable land being turned over into an industrial site. On July 9, PKC's Planning and Placemaking Committee councillors voted – against officers' recommendation – to refuse planning permission for a 22MW solar farm on prime agricultural land near Coupar Angus. At the July 9 meeting, objector Dave Ritchie told councillors: 'There's only eight per cent of Scotland that's prime agricultural land, so there must be plenty more room on other land to put these solar farms on. We've got brownfield sites, rooftops and plenty of unproductive sites.' READ MORE: Which MPs have received the most donations and from whom? See the full list Scotland's National Planning Framework 4 permits development on prime agricultural land for 'essential infrastructure' and if 'there is a specific locational need and no other suitable site'. Council officers have recommended Perth and Kinross Council does not object to this latest proposal but have suggested requesting several planning conditions be imposed. Suggested conditions include the provision of passing places, visibility splays, access to a public footpath and protecting the soil. Councillors will meet to discuss the application on Wednesday, August 6.
