Irish survivors to tell UN session why they want a ban on use of counselling notes in rape trials
Ciara Mangan and Leyla Simsek of Beyond Surviving will be joined by human rights and equality researcher Lisa Murray in Geneva for a session of the Committee on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women.
During the session — which runs from Monday to July 4 — the committee will review Mexico, Thailand, Ireland, Afghanistan, San Marino, Chad, and Botswana on how the countries are implementing the UN Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination against Women.
New bill stalled by Government
The session comes just days after the Criminal Law (Prohibition of the Disclosure of Counselling Records) Bill 2025 brought forward by Ruth Coppinger was stalled by the Government for a year.
The bill aims to ban outright the use of counselling notes in sexual offence trials.
Ciara Mangan described as 'gut-wrenching' Thursday's decision not to progress the bill beyond second stage for 12 months, which a Government amendment said was 'to allow for consideration by the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration to consider and bring forward provisions relating to Counselling Records".
Justice minister Jim O'Callaghan secured Government approval last month to draught legislation which would result in complainants' counselling notes only being disclosed in sexual assault trials if the court decides they are relevant.
However, in a submission to the UN, Beyond Surviving described the minister's proposal as legislating to continue the practice of disclosure of counselling notes, 'rather than cease it'.
Practice 'removes the victim's agency'
The group says that the use of counselling notes in sex offence trials are 'disproportionately discrediting a truthful victim'.
The submission added: 'Further, it removes the victim's right to non-disclosure, claiming it to be a solution to victims being 'fearful that if they do not agree to furnish the records, the prospect of a successful prosecution may be put in jeopardy'.
It thereby removes the victim's agency entirely, denying any option to exercise the right to nondisclosure.
The survivors' group argues that allowing counselling notes in court cases is a breach of human rights 'when such information is non-evidentiary and perpetuates harm through re-victimisation".
The submission says: 'Beyond Surviving contends that the current legislation and proposed amendment is a violation of our rights.'
Calling the use of counselling notes a violation, the submission also says: 'We assert that this practice is discriminatory and a breach of women's rights to access health and justice. It is a violation of our privacy and deeply harmful. This violation must be eradicated.'
Arguing that their use does not lead to a fair trial, the submission continued:
"We do not agree that emotional records from therapy bear relevance to the trial or help to determine the facts of the case.'
The submission added: 'Significant harm and suffering caused by such interference [in using counselling notes] outweighs what is suggested as its purported benefit.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
21 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Ireland's govt hit with €46k rent hike as taxpayer forced to foot €508k ambassador bill after ‘unsuccessful' negotiation
The Dept is also looking to buy a residence outright ON THE UP ON THE UP Ireland's govt hit with €46k rent hike as taxpayer forced to foot €508k ambassador bill after 'unsuccessful' negotiation ANNUAL rent for the Irish Ambassador's residence in London was increased by more than €46,000. And the Department of Foreign Affairs said it had little choice but to agree to the hike — even though it brought the cost of the pad close to €10,000 per week. The new lease of €508,925 per annum — a rise of ten per cent — was agreed in September 2022 because no better options were available, according to records released under FOI. The Irish Ambassador to the UK, formerly Adrian O'Neill and now Martin Fraser, had been living in the property since September 2019. And in late 2022, when the Dept of Foreign Affairs sought to extend the lease, the landlord said they wanted a 'substantial increase' in rent of over 11 per cent. Officials tried to negotiate but 'after several months, the landlord indicated that they would not accept any offer below £8,400 (€9,787) per week'. A spokesperson said: 'It was clear that a move would have no added benefit and would incur an additional cost to the Irish Exchequer. 'Accordingly, the Department decided to renew the lease to September 2026.' The Dept is also looking to buy a residence outright. Last year, sky-high lease costs included payments of €485,000 for Ireland's official residence in Tokyo. We also fork out €291,000 for an apartment in New York, and €204,000 for a pad in San Francisco. The rental bill in Tel Aviv, Israel, was almost €200,000, around €176,000 in Boston, and €135,000 in the South Korean capital Seoul. The Department also ran up 15 separate hotel and accommodation bills in excess of €5,000 last year, according to FoI figures. This included a spend of €30,480 at the five-star Intercontinental Hotel in Dublin 4 to host a delegation during the state visit by To Lam, the former President of Vietnam, last October. HUGE COSTS There was another bill of €9,300 from the same hotel for a visit by the Egyptian President, Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, in December. And €5,241 was spent on accommodation at the Seven Alpina Hotel as part of Ireland's participation in the annual World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland. The Department said an €8,408 bill at the four-star Fifty Sonesta Hotel in New York was for a staff member taking up a new posting. Among the other bills last year were €24,054 paid to the Dublin Airport Authority for platinum services for visiting dignitaries. Around €64,000 was spent on chauffeured cars with €11,600 paid out for a BMW in Washington DC. And €3.7million went on major maintenance of our residences overseas.
Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Indian community celebrates independence day in Dublin
The free event at Merrion Square came despite a separate celebration being called off following concern over recent attacks on the Indian community Hundreds of people have participated in an event marking India Day in Dublin, as gardai and the Government sought to assure the community it was taking action against racially motivated crime. The free event at Merrion Square came despite a separate celebration being called off following concern over recent attacks on the Indian community. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has expressed concern over 'totally unacceptable' attacks on the Indian community, adding that the majority appear to have been carried out by young people. Mr O'Callaghan said he engaged extensively with the Garda commissioner on the matter, and senior investigating officers had been assigned to investigate all reported incidents. Event organizer Sanjeeb Barik with a statue of the Indian deity Jagannath as people attend the India Day Festival at Merrion Square Park, Dublin (Niall Carson/PA) Sunday's celebration, organised for India's 79th independence day, featured music, dance, food stalls, exhibition stands and a range of cultural activities. Sanjeeb Barik, the secretary of organising group the Federation of Indian Communities in Ireland, said the event had gone well amid 'fantastic and beautiful weather'. 'Lots of people are here, there's food and dancing and lots of fun.' Asked about the engagement with Government and gardai, Mr Barik said the event had received 'good support'. Speaking to the PA news agency, he said: 'Naturally, because there has been so many incidents there was some concern. 'We have been actively discussing with ministers, junior ministers and the Minister of Justice and they have all assured us that appropriate safety measures would be in place – and they are. 'We're working very closely to make sure everyone would be safe and, importantly, that it would be enjoyable for everyone.' Mr Barik said they wanted to go ahead with the celebrations to send a message about the importance of standing together. 'It has been a challenging time but the main thing is to come together as a community and celebrate our heritage 'There are people from all backgrounds here – Indian, Irish and others – from all over the the island. 'It is about the strength of bonding and sowing the richness of India and Ireland's multicultural spirit.' From left, Areet Kaur Chandi, seven, Japleen Kaur, 10, and Preety Singh, eight, join the festivities for India Day in Dublin (Niall Carson/PA) He added: 'We are saying come together, stand together. Celebrate unity and diversity – and I hope that will continue.' Inspector Ciaran Nunan from the Garda diversity unit said hate crimes are attacks on the whole community. 'The mission statement of An Garda Siochana is keeping people safe, and this refers to individuals, families, communities and society as a whole. 'It also now includes hate crime. Hate crime is not just an attack on a person, it's an attack on the community. 'An Garda Siochana is very aware of the impact that hate crime has upon individuals and communities, and we take it very, very seriously. 'Since our last India Day celebration last year, we now have hate crime legislation in force and we're applying that legislation at every opportunity – but we need people to report incidents of hate crime to us so that we can then take them on board and react to those.' Entertainment was part of the festivities in Merrion Square Park (Niall Carson/PA) He added: 'So I would encourage everybody or anybody that perceives to be a victim of a hate crime to please report it to An Garda Siochana, and allow us to continue what we're doing and work with our communities to keep people safe. 'The Dublin event was attended by Akhilesh Mishra, ambassador of India to Ireland, and Minister of State Emer Higgins. The Ireland India Council, a separate group, said there had been an organised social media campaign against the Indian community in the country and the number of violent attacks has intensified since January. Last week, it said it took the 'difficult' decision to postpone its planned event at Farmleigh House over concerns for the safety of the community. People celebrating at the India Day Festival at Merrion Square Park, Dublin. Photo: Niall Carson/PA Today's News in 90 Seconds - 17 August
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Irish ambassador's rent sees €46,000 hike after latest London lease extension
The Department of Foreign Affairs was hit with a hike of more than €46,000 on the annual rent they pay for the Irish ambassador's residence in London. The department said it had little choice but to agree to the sharp increase even though it brought the cost of the property close to €10,000 per week. The new lease of €508,925 per annum — a rise of 10% — was signed off on because no better options were available, according to records released under the Freedom of Information Act. An internal submission said that the Irish ambassador to Britain had been living in the property in leafy Chester Square since September 2019. In late 2022, the department said it was interested in extending the lease. While the landlord was happy for the department to stay on, they said they wanted a 'substantial increase' in rent of over 11%. Department officials tried, 'actively but unsuccessfully,' to negotiate a much smaller increase in rent. The submission said: 'After several months, the landlord indicated that they would not accept any offer below £8,400 (€9,787) per week.' Suitable alternatives At the same time, the department had asked a property adviser to see if there were any other suitable properties in London. A report said the type of residence needed for the ambassador was only likely to come on the market half a dozen times each year. The property advisers examined eight properties in the area that had been let over a two-year period. They said only three of them had been leased for less than £7,000 (€8,156) per week, adding that the majority ranged from £8,000 to £12,000. A spokesman for the Department of Foreign Affairs said: 'Having given the matter careful consideration, and on the balance of market evidence available at the time, it was clear that a move would have no added benefit and would incur an additional cost to the Irish exchequer. 'The department decided to renew the lease for a three-year period to September 2026, with the option to break at relatively short notice should a more suitable alternative become available.'
