
The Salt Path and the sins of memoir
It is not, to put it mildly, a good look. At a time when household finances are stretched and the government is cutting benefits for the sick and disabled, author Raynor Winn stands accused of exaggerating her husband's illness and misrepresenting the circumstances of their destitution in her 2019 memoir The Salt Path – and getting rich via book sales and film rights in the process. Cue fury from betrayed readers (and, undoubtedly, a few jealous writers) on X, and a spate of solemn op-eds on the line between fact and fiction.
As the author of a memoir myself, I admit the story left me unscandalised. Yes, the allegations, if accurate, make a mockery of The Salt Path's claim to be nonfiction. But to tell you the truth – and would I, dear reader, do anything else? – I've come to have low expectations of the average memoir. The genre defined by fidelity to the facts is, on average, a poor guide to deeper truths about human beings. If you want to understand people, you're better off reading fiction.
To be sure, few books beat a brilliant memoir. The best – Primo Levi's Auschwitz testimony If This Is a Man, James Baldwin's searing race chronicle Notes of a Native Son, Annie Ernaux's spare sociological masterpieces – combine the artistry of a great novel with the electric frisson of self-exposure. But for every thrilling confession by a Thomas De Quincey or a Tove Ditlevsen, there are countless frauds and duds.
Naturally, the frauds get the headlines. Winn joins a long and ignoble list of autobiographers accused of deception. The canonical modern example is James Frey, unmasked on Oprah after fabricating parts of his addiction memoir A Million Little Pieces (and recently profiled by the New York Times, unrepentantly recalling the scandal from a house full of Matisses and Picassos bought with his royalties).
Before Frey came Binjamin Wilkormiski, author of a feted Holocaust memoir who turned out to be neither a survivor nor Jewish. Wilkormiski was defended by fellow 'survivor' Laura Grabowski, who swore she remembered him from Birkenau – until it transpired she was in fact Laurel Wilson, author of her own hoax memoir of ritual abuse, Satan's Underground. But frauds are much rarer than duds. Since the 'memoir boom' of the late Eighties and Nineties – led by superb originals like Mary Karr's The Liar's Club and Frank McCourt's Angela's Ashes – the demand for truly revelatory personal narrative has outstripped supply.
A deluge of mediocrity has filled the gap. The journalist Will Storr recently detailed how AI has already perfected the bland tone and nebulous detail that makes for a viral Substack confessional. So much for the hope – floated by David Shields in his manifesto Reality Hunger – that autobiography might offer an answer to the artifice of modern life. Of course, in all literary forms the dross outweighs the gold. But the paradox of memoir is that the form premised on truth is usually so poor at delivering it. That's because we are, on the whole, thoroughly unreliable narrators of our own lives.
One problem lies with the fallibility of memory. It isn't just that we repress unbearable truths, as Freud taught. Psychologists have shown how memory is itself a storyteller, weaving together experience, imagination, beliefs and memories of memories into a plausible version of what might have happened – and then selling it to us as the truth. Even if memory were trustworthy, a host of factors militate against truthful autobiography. The story of your life is the story of your most important relationships. And a good story, as every creative writing teacher knows, requires conflict and moral nuance. To tell your life story, you have to reveal unflattering things about the people you love: parents, lovers, siblings. Few have the stomach for that.
Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe
Nor are most people willing to write unflatteringly about themselves. When I tell people I've written a memoir, they sometimes tell me about some episode from their own life they'd like to write about. These stories are often fascinating – but not always for the reasons their tellers think. Often the most interesting parts are the ones they're unwilling or unable to see. People want to tell their life story with all the moral and psychological nuance stripped out, leaving them as virtuous victims or heroic survivors (or, seemingly in Winn's case, both).
All good memoirs find solutions to these problems. A certain ruthlessness with the feelings of others can help: I admire the cold honesty of Rachel Cusk's memoir of motherhood A Life's Work, even as I wince for her children. Some depend on a kind of masochistic self-exposure: see Karl Ove Knausgaard. Another solution is to be French. Their less censorious literary culture than ours licences greater self-disclosure, producing the Nobel-winning Ernaux as well as the undeniably narcissistic but peerless Emmanuel Carrère.
It can help if you've already cut ties with family members before you write about them. One reason many classic memoirs – like Jeanette Winterson's Why Be Happy When You Can Be Normal? – are about escaping religious upbringings is that their authors are relatively free from the usual ties of filial loyalty. Or you can wait until the people you're writing about are dead, as Edmund Gosse did before writing his immortal account of childhood Father and Son.
Some of my favourite memoirs find creative formal ways of engaging with the slipperiness of self-narration. In Night of the Gun David Carr applies the methods of investigative journalism to reconstruct his own past as a crack addict. Lauren Slater's Lying: A Metaphorical Memoir is a stunning Nabokovian experiment that recounts the author's struggle with a rare variant of epilepsy characterised by compulsive fabulism.
But successful memoirs are exceptions. We're much better at seeing through other people's hypocrisies and contradictions than our own. That insight underpins the narrative revolution pioneered by Jane Austen: the blending of a character's innocent perspective with the author's more knowing one. If Elizabeth Bennett had written her own story, it would be a banal tissue of vanity and delusion. But when Austen told it, she invented 'free indirect speech' – and the modern novel.
The messy truth behind the Salt Path may well turn out to be neither Winn's inspiring redemption story nor the cynical fraud imagined by her online critics. Perhaps it's something more interesting: a case of two people backed into a corner by bad luck and terrible decisions, who stumbled onto a slightly too perfect escape – and found themselves trapped in their own distortions once it succeeded beyond their wildest dreams. Whatever actually happened, it would make a gripping story. Just don't expect Raynor Winn to be the person to tell it.
[See also: The Salt Path is Scientology for the middle classes]
Related
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Herald Scotland
7 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Hunter Biden says Joe Biden was taking Ambien before Trump debate
The former president's son also unleashed expletive-laced attacks targeting actor George Clooney, Democratic strategists James Carville and David Axelrod and other prominent Democrats who publicly called for Biden to drop out of the race after the debate. More: President Biden pardons his son Hunter Biden despite pledges not to "I know exactly what happened in that debate," Hunter Biden said in the interview. "He flew around the world - basically the mileage that he could have flown around the world three times. He's 81 years old. He's tired as s--t. They give him Ambien to be able to sleep. He gets up on the stage, and he looks like he's a deer in the headlights, and it feeds into every f---ing story that anybody wants to tell." Ambien, also known by its generic name, zolpidem, is used to treat insomnia by helping individuals fall asleep quicker and stay asleep. Joe Biden, now 82, and his former White House aides have previously blamed the president's particularly busy schedule that stretch for his poor June 27, 2024 debate performance but have not publicly mentioned the use of Ambien. A spokeswoman for the former president did not respond to a request by USA TODAY when asked about Hunter Biden's remarks about the sleeping drug. During his lone 2024 debate with Trump, then-President Biden struggled to finish complete thoughts, fumbled over words and made several embarrassing gaffes. Over the next several days and weeks, Democratic lawmakers and other party insiders pushed Biden to withdraw from the election despite his insistence he wasn't stepping down. Biden ultimately dropped out and endorsed his vice president, Kamala Harris, as the Democratic nominee less than four weeks later on July 21, 2024. Hunter Biden rips George Clooney, Democrats who doubted dad In the lengthy interview that aired July 21 on YouTube, Hunter Biden ripped Clooney, a prominent Hollywood donor for Democrats who wrote a New York Times op-ed last year urging Biden to withdraw over concerns with his age and fitness. "F--- him and everybody around him" Hunter Biden said, dismissing Clooney as "a brand," not an actor who has a mansion in Lake Como, Italy and is friends with Barack Obama. "What do you have to do with anything? Why do I have to f---ing listen to you? What right do you have to step on a man who's given 52 years of his f---ing life to the service of this country?" Hunter Biden said Carville, a longtime Democratic operative also called for Joe Biden to drop out, "hasn't won a race in 40 f---ing years." More: Joe Biden didn't recognize George Clooney at 2024 campaign fundraiser, new book says The president's son then hit Axelrod, who raised questions about Joe Biden's age long before the disastrous debate with Trump. "David Axelrod - who had one success in his political life and that was Barack Obama. That was because of Barack Obama, not because of David f---ing Axelrod," Hunter Biden said. Hunter Biden also sounded off on former Biden White House adviser Anita Dunn, accusing her of making "$40 million to $50 million" off the Democratic Party and the former Biden aides who run the liberal podcast, Pod Save America. Hunter Biden said the Pod Save America hosts are "junior f---ing speechwriters" for Obama's Senate staff who made "millions" on their ties with Obama. Dunn, unlike Hunter Biden's other targets, was a key member of Joe Biden's inner circle and never called on the persident to drop out of the race. More: President Biden publicly acknowledges 4-year-old granddaughter for the first time Leading up to the debate, Joe Biden had returned to Europe for a G-7 summit in Italy after being in France for an event days earlier honoring Allied veterans in France on the 80th anniversary of D-Day. In between the European trips, Biden swung back to the United States to be at home in Wilmington, Delaware, for the verdict of Hunter Biden's guns case trial. Upon returning to the U.S. from Italy, Joe Biden then flew across the country to a star-studded fundraiser in Los Angeles co-hosted by Clooney and actress Julia Roberts. The president then flew to the Camp David presidential retreat in Maryland, where he spent six days preparing for the debate with top advisers. Before departing the White House, Joe Biden in December 2024 issued a full and unconditional pardon that cleared Hunter Biden of three federal gun felonies and federal tax charges. The broadly-worded pardon also gave the president's son a blanket reprieve for any other crimes "he committed or may have committed" between Jan. 1, 2014 and the end of 2024. Reach Joey Garrison on X @joeygarrison.


The Guardian
10 hours ago
- The Guardian
Hunter Biden takes on George Clooney and presidential debate in interview
Hunter Biden has given a profanity-laced, three-hour interview to the US outlet Channel 5 that is remarkable for its no-holds attack on actor George Clooney, denial that he was the source of cocaine found in the White House and thoughts on why his father bombed in his debate with Donald Trump before dropping out of his presidential re-election run. 'Fuck him!' the younger Biden said of Clooney, whose remarkable New York Times opinion piece last July called on the Democratic party for which the actor is a financial donor to find a new presidential nominee. 'Fuck him and everybody around him. I don't have to be fucking nice.' Referring to comments from the well-known film director that Clooney is not a 'movie star', Biden continued: 'I agree with Quentin Tarantino. Fucking George Clooney is not a fucking actor. He is fucking like … I don't know what he is. He's a brand.' Biden questioned why anyone had to listen to Clooney despite his friendship with Barack Obama, a former Democratic president, and his 'really great place in Lake Como'. 'What do you have to do with fucking anything?' Biden said, speaking rhetorically about Clooney. 'What right do you have to step on a man who's given … his fucking life to the service of this country and decide that you, George Clooney, are going to take out basically a full page ad in the fucking New York Times.' Hunter Biden shared with the Channel 5 outlet his belief that Clooney was upset at Joe Biden, 82, because the former president had criticized the international criminal court (ICC)'s decision to obtain an arrest warrant for the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, on war crime charges. The human rights lawyer Amal Clooney, who is married to the actor, was one of the legal experts who recommended that the ICC seek that warrant. 'He was bitching to the White House staff, the senior staff that he was so angry that the president would criticize the arrest warrant,' Hunter Biden said. 'He was very, very angry that my dad did not pay homage to her or something.' Biden's interview to Channel 5, a popular YouTube channel created by Andrew Callaghan, comes as US House Republicans pursue investigations into his father's presidency. Congressional Republicans have been claiming that the former president's closest advisers covered up a physical and mental decline during his presidency, and criticizing his pre-emptive pardons of family members, including Hunter, after Trump threatened to prosecute his opponents as he captured the Oval Office again in November. 'It's good to see that Hunter has taken some time to process the election, look inward, and hold himself accountable for how his family's insular, dare I say arrogant at times, approach to politics led to this catastrophic outcome we're all now living with,' said Tommy Vietor, a former Obama White House official, posted on Twitter/X. Hunter Biden acknowledged that Joe Biden had an 'absolutely horrible' debate against Trump before his father dropped out of the 2024 presidential race exactly a year ago on Monday and endorsed Vice-President Kamala Harris to succeed him. Hunter Biden said his father had to drop out or see fellow Democrats fight him 'every step of the way'. Among the reasons for the poor debate performance were that his father – 81 at the time – was 'tired as shit', Hunter Biden said. 'They give him Ambien to be able to sleep. He gets up on the stage and looks like he's a deer in the headlights, and it feeds into every fucking story that anybody wants to tell.' Sign up to Headlines US Get the most important US headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning after newsletter promotion After Trump's second presidency began in January, the FBI reopened an investigation into who left cocaine in a White House locker in 2023. Suspicions have fallen on Hunter Biden, whose past struggles with substance abuse have been well documented. But Hunter Biden denied the cocaine found in the White House was his, asserting he has been clean and sober since June 2019. 'Why would I bring cocaine into the White House and stick it into a cubby outside … the situation room in the West Wing?' he asked. The 55-year-old's Channel 5 interview comes weeks after his father embarked on a series of interviews, including with the New York Times, aimed at convincing the public that Harris's loss to Trump in 2024 was not his fault. Asked about his business dealings, which resulted in federal tax evasion charges and illegal handgun possession that were later vacated by his father's pardon, Biden pointed to his work as a board member at the national rail network Amtrak and the US-UN World Food Program.


The Independent
15 hours ago
- The Independent
Hunter Biden curses out George Clooney for pushing dad Joe out of race: ‘Not a f---ing actor'
Scandal-plagued former first son Hunter Biden ripped into actor George Clooney in a foul-mouthed tirade aired Monday. The 55-year-old son of former President Joe Biden went on an expletive-filled rant against the Hollywood megastar in an interview with Andrew Callaghan, an independent journalist and former host of the podcast, All Gas No Brakes. He railed against the Goodnight, and Good Luck auteur's demand that Joe Biden drop out of the 2024 presidential race, which the younger Biden and others in the family's inner circle have made clear they believe is to blame for the Democratic Party's loss to Donald Trump. But he also took aim at Clooney's acting chops, suggesting hurt feelings were at play. 'F*** you. What do you have to do with f***ing anything? Hunter Biden seethed about the ER star. 'Why do I have to f***ing listen to you? What right do you have to step on a man who's given 52 years of his f***ing life to the service of this country and decide that you, George Clooney, are going to take out basically a full page ad in the fucking New York Times to undermine the president at a time in which, by the way, what do people care about the most?' Biden claimed that the division within the Democratic Party led to Republicans having an insurmountable advantage ahead of November. He also claimed that the disastrous performance of his father at his one and only debate with Trump was due to his father taking Ambien in order to sleep on foreign trips. "I know exactly what happened in that debate. He flew around the world, basically mileage that he could have flown around the world three times, he's 81 years old, he's tired as s---, they give him Ambien to be able to sleep, he's gets up on the stage and he looks like he's a deer in the headlights," Hunter told Callaghan, adding: '[I]t feeds into every f***ing story that anybody wants to tell." Of Clooney's acting, he said of the From Dusk Till Dawn star: "I agree with Quentin Tarantino. F***ing George Clooney is not a f***ing actor. He is f***ing like… I don't know what he is. He's a brand.' Biden's rant was nearly duplicated in a second podcast appearance — this time, a buttoned-up conversation with Jaime Harrison, former chair of the Democratic Party. Even here, Biden told the At Our Table host he didn't give a 's***' about Clooney's political opinions. 'We lost the last election because we did not remain loyal to the leader of the party,' he said during that appearance. 'That's my position. We had the advantage of incumbency, we had the advantage of an incredibly successful administration, and the Democratic Party literally melted down.' His father's performance at a June presidential debate with Donald Trump alarmed voters on all sides of the political spectrum and drew immediate fears from Democrats that the party was preparing to hand the election over to Republicans. Clooney was a prominent part of that avalanche, penning an op-ed for the New York Times titled, 'I Love Joe Biden, But We Need a New Nominee'. Pod Save America co-host Jon Favreau, a former speechwriter for Barack Obama, said that internal polling conducted by the Biden campaign showed the former president losing by a landslide were he to remain in the race. The elder Biden dropped out of the race a month later, after an agonizing few weeks of calls for him to step down by backbencher Democrats and the less-than-delicate hinting from the likes of former Speaker Nancy Pelosi and others seemingly urging the same. Kamala Harris, his vice president and running mate, ascended to the top of the ticked after party officials shot down the idea of a last-minute primary election playing out at the Democratic National Convention. Democrats had already blown their own chance to hold a real primary earlier in the year. Tim Walz, the governor of Minnesota, was drafted as her running mate after a short candidate search. Hunter Biden's own shenanigans were a major weight around his father's neck for the entirety of 2024. The recovering crack addict's prosecution on tax and gun charges led to speculation that Joe Biden would pardon his son, which he denied — then did anyway. Many of the Democratic president's detractors argued that Hunter's treatment by law enforcement was far lighter than others accused of the same crimes, including drug offenses for which he was never charged, would have faced. According to 2024: How Trump Retook the White House and the Democrats Lost America, Joe Biden was mentally preoccupied with his son's federal gun trial, and the possibility of Hunter going to prison, at the height of election campaigning last summer. Hunter was convicted on three federal gun charges for unlawfully purchasing and possessing a firearm in 2018 while battling substance use disorder. Despite claiming he would not pardon Hunter if found guilty, Joe Biden granted his son a full pardon shortly before leaving office. He became a de facto senior adviser to his father's re-election campaign early in the year, which according to news reports complicated efforts by the president's allies to communicate with him directly as his son shielded him from criticism.