Lehrmann inquiry head's leak 'transparent, not corrupt'
Walter Sofronoff KC has asked the Federal Court to toss a March finding by the ACT Integrity Commission that the former judge engaged in serious corrupt conduct.
The commission's probe stemmed from Mr Sofronoff's leaks to a journalist.
But the watchdog's adverse finding was a "serious offence against the administration of justice", Mr Sofronoff's barrister Adam Pomerenke KC said during a hearing on Monday.
Mr Sofronoff was not corrupt, malicious or dishonest, the barrister told Justice Wendy Abrahams.
Rather, he genuinely believed he was acting in the public interest by sending documents like witness statements to the media.
"Even if Mr Sofronoff was wrong in his view, the fact remains that he genuinely and honestly held it," Mr Pomerenke said.
"At worst it could be characterised as an erroneous attempt to ensure accuracy and transparency in the public discourse."
Mr Sofronoff chaired a board of inquiry into the ACT's criminal justice system after Lehrmann's controversy-plagued prosecution.
The former Liberal staffer was accused of raping then-colleague Brittany Higgins in a ministerial office at Parliament House in 2019.
A 2022 criminal trial was abandoned without a verdict due to juror misconduct.
Lehrmann lost a defamation lawsuit he brought over media reporting of Ms Higgins' allegations but has appealed a judge's finding the rape claim was true on the balance of probabilities.
The Sofronoff-led inquiry found the ACT's top prosecutor, Shane Drumgold, had lost objectivity over the Lehrmann case and knowingly lied about a note of his meeting with broadcaster Lisa Wilkinson.
Mr Drumgold resigned and launched a legal challenge to the findings in the ACT Supreme Court.
It found the majority of the inquiry's findings were not legally unreasonable, but it struck down an adverse finding about how Mr Drumgold cross-examined then-Liberal senator Linda Reynolds during Lehrmann's criminal trial.
In March, the ACT Integrity Commission also found the majority of the inquiry's findings were not legally unreasonable.
But it found Mr Sofronoff's behaviour during the inquiry gave rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias and he might have been influenced by the publicly expressed views of journalist Janet Albrechtsen.
Mr Sofronoff repeatedly messaged the News Corp columnist and eventually provided her an advance copy of his probe's final report.
Mr Pomerenke told the Federal Court on Monday the ACT corruption body had admitted it made an error in finding Mr Sofronoff might have engaged in contempt.
The claimed contempt stemmed out of leaks to the media despite directions made to parties during the inquiry to suppress certain documents.
But the notion that the head of an inquiry could be in contempt of himself was "absurd and irrational", Mr Pomerenke said.
This concession was enough to toss the findings against his client, he told the court.
Any individual error could not be "disentangled" from the final finding that the former judge engaged in serious corrupt conduct, the barrister said.
The hearing continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Aussies warned over major national park hazard to tackle 'big threat' from this week
Australians are being reminded that in just a matter of days, an expansive fox baiting program is due to commence on the east coast, aimed at reducing the growing population of the highly adaptable and invasive predator. Across the country, foxes kill hundreds of millions of native animals per year, and in New South Wales, the pest is widespread. It's estimated they cost governments millions annually in eradication efforts, livestock losses, and environmental damage, meaning regular control efforts are critical to ensure their management remains possible. The NSW Evrionment Department carries out fox control several times a year. But despite this, they're still found across up to 90 per cent of the state. From August 1 until January next year, another round of baiting will be conducted across NSW national parks and reserves, by the National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS). The announcement prompted a callout from a number of local vets, warning that toxic bait is also harmful to domestic pets. They urged owners to be aware of the signs of ingestion, and to avoid areas where the poison will be laid. In NSW, it's actually illegal to walk pets in most national parks, but despite this, evidence suggests it regularly occurs — either among people flouting the law or doing so unwittingly. Speaking to Yahoo News, a NPWS spokesperson detailed the true scale of the threat foxes pose to both the state, and the nation. They explained that a "range of strictly controlled methods" are used to manage feral animals in national parks, with "decisions about control methods" for a particular species and circumstance made in consideration of humaneness and effectiveness. "Invasive species are one of the biggest threats to native plants and animals and cause extensive damage to the environment, along with billions of dollars' worth of damage to Australian agricultural production each year," they said. "Sodium fluoroacetate (1080) is the most effective landscape fox control method. 1080 is a naturally occurring compound found in some native plant species that rapidly breaks down in the environment." They said extensive research has shown that native animals — including lace monitors, quolls and birds — have a high tolerance to 1080 at the concentrations used to control foxes. Typically, 1080 fox baits resemble small chunks of meat or meat-like material, often dyed a distinct colour (usually green or red) to help identify them as toxic and discourage accidental handling. In the state, without large-scale control efforts, foxes can quickly recolonise areas where populations were reduced, due to their mobility and territorial behaviour. Is 1080 poison humane? While 1080 poison remains a key tool in controlling invasive pests like foxes and wild dogs across Australia, it continues to stir debate over animal welfare. Critics, including some animal welfare organisations, environmentalists, and vets, argue the poison causes prolonged and distressing deaths, citing symptoms like vomiting, convulsions and frenzied behaviour. They label it inhumane and push for tighter restrictions or alternatives. On the other hand, many scientific experts, particularly in conservation biology, defend the use of 1080 as a necessary evil in protecting native species. Australia's native wildlife has no natural defence against introduced predators like foxes and cats, which kill millions of animals annually. Without effective control, many endangered species face extinction. ☠️ Plea to Aussies over controversial substance found in bush 🦊 Aussie council under pressure as iconic species ravaged by invasive predator 🐜 Aussie mum's brutal injuries as property owners warned of painful threat Supporters argue that while 1080 isn't perfect, it's currently the most effective broadscale option, especially in remote or rugged areas where trapping or fencing isn't feasible. Research from institutions like the Invasive Species Council and CSIRO states that native animals are more tolerant to 1080 due to the presence of the chemical in some native plants. While concerns about cruelty remain, proponents say the ecological damage from unchecked predator populations would be far worse — and that alternatives either aren't viable at scale or pose greater risks to the environment. And across NSW, population decline is strongly dependent on sustained, coordinated control efforts, highlighting the need for urgent and consistent action. Why are foxes such a big problem in Australia? Foxes were introduced to Australia in the 1860s by Europeans for recreational hunting. But since then, their numbers have exploded exponentially across the country, largely due to a lack of natural predators. They feed on native species, particularly small mammals, reptiles, and ground-nesting birds, many of which are already vulnerable or endangered. Their introduction has significantly contributed to the decline of several native species, particularly small mammals like the bilby, numbat and bettong. Foxes' hunting behaviour is opportunistic and highly efficient, often killing more than they need. Beyond their environmental impact, they pose risks to agriculture by preying on lambs and spreading diseases such as hydatid tapeworm. Wildlife that benefit from fox control programs include brush-tailed rock-wallabies, malleefowl, bandicoots, little terns and plains wanderers, the NPWS said. It conducts feral animal management in partnership with the Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development, Local Land Services, and other landholders and managers. From August, bait will be laid in numerous locations, including the Garigal, Lane Cove, Ku-ring-gai Chase and Sydney Harbour National Parks. Love Australia's weird and wonderful environment? 🐊🦘😳 Get our new newsletter showcasing the week's best stories.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Pensioner, 82, convicted of not paying car tax while in hospital having toe amputated
An 82-year-old pensioner has been convicted of not paying car tax while he was in hospital having a toe amputated. The OAP, who is in assisted living in Liverpool, was pursued through the criminal courts by the DVLA when the bill went unpaid last December. When prosecuted in the scandal-hit Single Justice Procedure, a secretive fast-track court system, the octogenarian wrote in to explain his medical woes – even including a copy of a hospital treatment record. But it was not enough to avoid a criminal conviction for keeping an unlicensed vehicle. Elderly and vulnerable people are regularly harshly convicted over unpaid household bills in the Single Justice Procedure, a system dogged by scandals in which magistrates sit in private to deal with low-level criminal cases. The Ministry of Justice is considering reform, having promised last November a 'fair and effective' system while hinting at 'fundamental reform'. But eight months later, no significant changes have being made. The Liverpool pensioner was caught out over tax on his 16-year-old Mercedes which expired at the end of October last year. 'I was in hospital getting my toe amputated in November, and completely forgot to tax my car', he wrote, in a note to the court. 'I apologise.' One of the flaws in the Single Justice Procedure is that, unlike open court, there is no prosecutor present when a magistrate deals with a case. The fast-track design of the system means prosecutors – like the DVLA – do not see mitigation letters, which sometimes contain vital information on a defendant's circumstances, unless a magistrate specifically requests that they look at it to consider the public interest of the prosecution. The DVLA itself has called for a change in the system, so that all mitigation letters are considered before a case goes into court. But the government has not yet decided whether to act on that suggestion, and faces pressure from the BBC not to follow through on that reform. The pensioner, who continued to receive medical treatment for weeks after the big toe on his right foot was amputated, pleaded guilty to the offence in writing. He was given a discharge last week by a magistrate sitting in Ipswich, with an order to pay £64 in unpaid car tax. Since the case was not withdrawn, he will also have a criminal conviction. Magistrates called for changes to the Single Justice Procedure as long ago as March 2024, putting forward a 12-point plan for change. But the Conservative government under Rishi Sunak failed to act, while Labour has conducted a consultation which ended in early May. The Standard's long-running investigation into the system has uncovered criminal convictions recorded against dementia patients, care homes residents, people with severe mental health difficulties, and even dead people. Tens of thousands of rail fare evasion convictions had to be quashed after rampant abuse of the courts was uncovered, while unlawful convictions against children have also emerged. Despite the mounting scandals, the Ministry of Justice insists that there have been no recorded miscarriages of justice due to the Single Justice Procedure. It also makes the curious claim that prosecutors play the same role in the fast-track system as they do in open court, despite being completely absent from Single Justice Procedure hearings.
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
18-Year-Old Dancer Found Dead in Her Home Remembered as the 'Most Vibrant Girl': 'Her Time with Us Was Far Too Short'
Layla-Maria Grubb's loved ones said she "brought so much joy, light, and love into the lives of everyone who knew her" An 18-year-old dancer is being remembered by her loved ones following her tragic death. Layla-Maria Grubb was found dead in her home in Australia on Saturday, July 19, according to the Daily Telegraph. Her family told the outlet that the teenager died just hours after she was sent home from a hospital following a suspected seizure. "We all want to know what happened. We are searching for answers," Grubb's mother, Beth Ashton, told the Daily Telegraph. Grubb studied at the dance company Village Nation. The company's director, Briden Starr, described her as a "healthy, positive, focused girl," per the Daily Mail. In a heartfelt social media post shared after her daughter's death, Ashton wrote, "Our baby girl left us far too soon." "Layla-Maria brought so much joy, light, and love into the lives of everyone who knew her. A gorgeous dancer, who moved through life with the same beauty and passion she brought to the stage," she continued. "Her laughter, kindness, and beautiful spirit will be deeply missed and forever remembered." "Though her time with us was far too short, her impact will remain in our hearts, forever 18. ❤️," the grieving mother concluded. "We kindly ask for your thoughts and prayers for our family during this incredibly difficult time." The JLC Dance Company — which Grubb belonged to in Western Australia — also shared a tribute. The organization said the teen left for Sydney in 2023 to pursue a professional career in dance. "Layla was on a trajectory to stardom and had immense potential," the JLC Dance Company wrote on Facebook. "Layla was an amazing student, and friend, with a great personality and huge smile that lit up any room." The group continued: "Layla was an amazing friend to a lot of our staff and students and this devastating news has affected the entire JLC family and everyone that knew Layla for no matter how long, or short. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. In a GoFundMe page, Grubb's friends said they wanted to "give Layla the send-off she truly deserves" and celebrate her life in a way "that reflects the incredible love and joy she brought into our lives." "Layla was pure light — an amazing dancer with an infectious laugh!" the friends continued, also remembering Grubb as "the funniest, goofiest, most vibrant girl you could ever meet, lighting up every room with her laughter and fun." A funeral service for the dancer will be held in Sydney on Friday, Aug. 1. Grubb's death investigation has been referred to the New South Wales coroner, local police told PEOPLE. "Due to the early stage of the matter, we cannot provide further detail at this time," a spokesperson said. Read the original article on People
