Paul Hatton says wife Julie took her own life at Darreen Station; no inquest
Paul Hatton said his first wife, Julie, had severe postnatal depression and shot herself with a rifle in despair at Queensland's Darreen Station in 1978.
'I was months, years, getting over this,' Mr Hatton said, making his first public comments on the death after a coroner formally ruled out an inquest.
'I went through hell. You wouldn't wish what happened to me on anybody.'
Former Labor attorney-general Shannon Fentiman ordered a coronial investigation in April 2023 at the request of Natalie Hatton, the daughter of Julie and Mr Hatton, who was a 10-week-old baby when her mother died.
Coroner Donald MacKenzie has now told Ms Hatton that a thorough police reinvestigation found no evidence to suggest the death of her 22-year-old mother was suspicious.
An inquest was not in the public interest, the coroner ruled, with some records and evidence that could have shed light on the tragedy no longer available.
The gun was recorded as being a Winchester .22 rifle but could not be found.
Police advised the coroner that a lack of information about the gun and ammunition, and about the exact height and arm span of the deceased, meant it was not possible to do a viable re-enactment.
Ms Hatton is appealing to the state coroner to overrule the refusal to hold an inquest.
She has cited ongoing concerns about issues including a lack of evidence of powder or burn marks around the gunshot wound that she believes would have been expected from a shot at point-blank range.
Darreen Station, near Eidsvold, remains in the hands of the Hatton family. Mr Hatton and second wife Ingrid have spent years restoring a century-old homestead there.
'Ask the attorney-general, 'what evidence did they have to open this inquiry?',' he said.
'This is an absolute tragedy turned on its head. My wife (Julie) was in a very, very bad way. She was diagnosed with … postnatal depression. She couldn't even mix the (baby) formula. That's how bad she was. But you don't realise what's going to happen.'
Born and raised on the Gold Coast, the only daughter of bookmaker Kevin Clifford and wife Lillias, Julie married Mr Hatton when she was 19.
Mr Hatton says she asked how to use a gun, and he showed her.
'In those days, you never locked the guns up because of snakes and crows and all that sort of thing,' he said.
'You can blame us. Maybe we should have put the gun (away). We didn't think. You don't think of those bloody things.'
Until the age of 10, Ms Hatton believed her stepmother, Ingrid, was her biological mother.
Mr Hatton said his parents and other elders in the family had stopped him telling his daughter sooner about her birth mother.
'I wanted to tell her from day one but nobody would let me. They all made me wait until she grew up, to make it easy on her. That's what they thought. All her life, we tried to protect her, tried to let her grow up without hurting her. All it's done is come back and bite us.'
After the shooting Mr Hatton went without eating, he said, to the point his sister warned his health was in danger.
'It's the worst thing I've ever seen. I nearly took my own life,' he said.
Julie 'was a lovely person' who could ride a horse, was very active and loved the property, he said.
'She didn't want to go into this state of mind. Today, they would have more help for her. They understand it today. In my day, they didn't understand it, that was the problem.'
As a result of the renewed questions about his wife's death, he demonstrated to his family and police how it was possible for a person to take their own life using a similar rifle.
'It's as easy as falling off a log. I've handled guns all my life. I didn't realise how easy it was,' he said.
Since the case was reopened, Ms Hatton has launched a separate civil claim seeking a declaration she is entitled to possession with her father and stepmother of one of the family properties, Delubra.
As of 2019, the Hatton family ran about 20,000 head of cattle across 10 properties spanning more than 40,000 hectares.
'If I had no money, mate, this wouldn't even be happening,' Mr Hatton said, adding that he had the support of the rest of the family.
Ms Hatton said her civil case was 'totally different' to her questions about her mother's death.
She has been supported in her call for an inquest by a policeman who attended the death scene.
When he was a young constable, John Raatz wrote in a 1978 police report that 'it would appear that the deceased was in depressed state of mind'.
Now 79, Mr Raatz says a sergeant he went to the property with on the day Julie Hatton died decided not to call in detectives.
'I wanted him to follow up and get the CI (criminal investigation) branch out there. He just said, 'no f..king way anyone's going to come here' and 'I'm handling the case' and 'no suspicious circumstances',' Mr Raatz said.
'He was out there for half an hour. Hopped in the ambulance with the now deceased, and didn't do anything. Why wouldn't there be an inquest into the … full circumstances as to what happened?'
Mr Hatton angrily rejected the comments, saying they were in direct conflict with what a young policeman told him the day after the shooting.
'Is this the same copper that said to me … 'you're lucky you're still here, that you haven't been taken out, you and your baby'?,' Mr Hatton said.
On the day of the shooting Mr Hatton was out riding a lawnmower. He says it's possible his wife, in a disturbed state of mind, also fired at him.
'When I was mowing, something went past my head, and it's come back a couple of times in my life. We'll never know,' he said. David Murray National Crime Correspondent
David Murray is The Australian's National Crime Correspondent. He was previously Crime Editor at The Courier-Mail and prior to that was News Corp's London-based Europe Correspondent. He is behind investigative podcasts The Lighthouse and Searching for Rachel Antonio and is the author of The Murder of Allison Baden-Clay. Nation
Sarah Hanson-Young has left the door open to the Greens using its numbers in the Senate to block Labor's agenda to push for stronger action, declaring voters handed the minor party the sole balance of power to act as a 'backstop'. Nation
What does it take to be a Labor giant-killer and take out an opposition leader, Greens firebrands or long-serving incumbent MP? For the class of 2025 it meant hard work, grit and months on the hustings.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

News.com.au
19 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Bodycam footage of mum learning babysitter allegedly murdered her infant
Harrowing police bodycam footage has emerged showing a mother's primal scream after learning her 10-month-old daughter had died while in the care of her babysitter. The emotional scene unfolded in Pekin, Illinois, on June 26, 2024, when Branda Nichelle learnt the tragic news outside the home of her infant daughter Sylvie Zacovic's babysitter, 22-year-old Makenna Rhodes. Rhodes is due to stand trial for the alleged murder in October, with the disturbing bodycam footage expected to play a key role in the case. In the clip, Ms Nichelle can be seen coming home from work after Rhodes called her to let her know Sylvie was allegedly unresponsive in her cot. Police and paramedics were already at the home, and as they let the mum know her daughter was in a gravely serious condition and was being taken to the hospital, she began screaming. 'Oh my god, oh my God,' she cried in the heartbreaking footage. 'She's just … oh my God.' Rhodes, who was in the house with her boyfriend, then tried to comfort the mum, but Ms Nichelle brushed her off before getting into the back of the police car to go to the hospital. Tragically, Sylvie was pronounced dead 30 minutes later. Elsewhere in the footage, a police officer is seen on the phone relaying information. 'The babysitter is hysterical,' he said. 'She said she laid the kid down at 10 something … came up at like 12:45 and the child was blue. 'Babysitter's boyfriend is super calm … there's some things that are kind of up in the air right now.' In separate footage from the same day, Rhodes and her boyfriend were interrogated by police in separate rooms. Rhodes denied she had any involvement in the death, but told police that the infant had been 'fussy' and refused to sleep. She was caring for four children that day, including her infant son, and told investigators she had left Sylvie with her boyfriend for about 10 minutes before the child was found unresponsive. However, he insisted he had been sleeping until Rhodes woke him in a panic. When faced with accusations from police about lying, he referenced text messages Rhodes had sent from the police station, attempting to align their stories. 'I told (the investigator) you had Sylvie for 10 mins,' Rhodes messaged him. He replied: 'I told her I didn't have her or seen her today'. 'Just say you did,' she responded. 'I'm not lying, Kenna,' he sent back. The couple were allowed to leave, but just two days later, an autopsy revealed the cause of death was asphyxiation. Sylvie suffered abrasions on the inside of her upper lip, which are injuries consistent with pressure being applied to her face. Rhodes was arrested and told police she was 'scared' as she was handcuffed and charged with murder. Rhodes later admitted in a probable cause affidavit to suffocating the infant with a small blanket attached to a stuffed animal, as she forced a dummy into her mouth. Rhodes allegedly admitted to holding the blanket over Sylvie's face until she closed her eyes and stopped crying. She also admitted that her claims that her boyfriend had been with the infant at the time were made up and she was the only one in the room. The boyfriend was never charged with any wrongdoing. Rhodes' trial is scheduled to start on October 7, and she has pleaded not guilty. If found guilty, she could face up to 100 years in prison. On the first anniversary of Sylvie's tragic death, Ms Nichelle posted a heartfelt tribute on social media, describing the moment she was caught on bodycam footage screaming as 'the worst day of my life'. 'There are no words for how much I miss her. I will never get to see my baby girl's smile again, hear her laugh, or watch her take her first steps,' she said. 'I hate that someone else's actions caused this. My daughter is gone because of what someone else did – and all we can do now is hope that justice is served.'

News.com.au
4 hours ago
- News.com.au
Motor rally accident kills three spectators in France
Three spectators died in central France on Saturday after a car driven by a 22-year-old woman racer veered off the road during an auto rally, authorities said. The driver of the modified Peugeot 208 that hit the spectators and her 51-year-old woman co-driver were taken to hospital but without life-threatening injuries, prosecutors said. Two men died at the scene and prosecutors later announced that a third man, airlifted to hospital, succumbed to his injuries. The three killed were two brothers, aged 70 and 60, and a 44-year-old man, according to the public prosecutor's office, which opened an investigation. Several people who witnessed the accident near the town of Ambert in central France were in shock, a local official told AFP. In total, a dozen people were taken to a psychological support unit set up in the nearby village of Saint-Just. The accident occurred around 11 am (0900 GMT) on Saturday. "This is a tragedy for the world of racing," said Joel Mathurin, the local prefect, or top government official for the area. Regional prosecutor Laure Moisset said the accident was "very violent". In a short statement, the rally organisers said that the race was halted at 10:49 am. All spectators were asked to leave the scene and the event's award ceremony was cancelled. Dozens of firefighters and police were dispatched to the scene. The investigation was "in its early stages," the prosecutor said. The Peugeot 208 car was to be examined. The road where the accident took place, almost a straight line according to authorities, has been closed. Prosecutors said they would have to determine whether the spectators were in an authorised area during the rally. "I prefer to remain cautious," Moisset told reporters. "It is still a little too early to be precise," she added. Organised since 1965, the motor rally attracted 167 teams for its 32nd edition. In the rally held last year, a race marshal died.

ABC News
6 hours ago
- ABC News
Teenage boy in custody after alleged Darwin Show stabbing of another teenage boy
A teenager is in serious condition after he was stabbed at the Royal Darwin Show, with the alleged offender in custody, police say. The Northern Territory Police said the boy, aged 15, was assaulted with a knife by another 15-year-old boy at the showgrounds after an altercation. A spokesperson said the alleged offender fled the scene after the incident took place at around 8.20pm on Saturday. "Police and St John Ambulance attended, and the victim was conveyed to Royal Darwin Hospital in a serious condition," the spokesperson said. Police later posted a Facebook update at 10pm, saying the alleged offender was located. "The 15-year-old alleged offender has been arrested by police and is currently in custody," the statement said. Police are urging anyone with information to contact 131 444 and quote reference number P25199834.