logo
As ASEAN touts unity, Philippines seeks consensus on South China Sea

As ASEAN touts unity, Philippines seeks consensus on South China Sea

Japan Times27-05-2025

The Philippines has called on ASEAN nations to wrap up negotiations on a code of conduct in the disputed South China Sea, a move experts say reflects Manila's growing frustration with Beijing's attempts to exploit the Southeast Asian bloc's diverging priorities as well its consensus-based model for decision-making.
Speaking at an Association of Southeast Asian Nations' summit in Kuala Lumpur that touted bloc unity, Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. on Monday underscored the 'urgent need' to accelerate the adoption of a 'legally binding' code to safeguard maritime rights and prevent 'miscalculations at sea.'
Manila's call on the 10-member bloc comes as the situation between China and the Philippines has turned particularly tense, with the resource-rich waters now being the scene of regular ship collisions and rammings, and as the Chinese side repeatedly deploys flares and water cannons.
'Manila has every reason to feel frustrated with ASEAN,' said Zachary Abuza, a Southeast Asia expert and professor at the U.S. National War College.
China, he said, tends to pick on one country at a time for fear of making the South China Sea a multilateral ASEAN issue.
'Over the past few years, the Philippines has borne the brunt of Chinese aggression, while most other countries have been sitting back, breathing a sigh of relief that they are not being targeted by China,' Abuza added.
ASEAN and Beijing have been working for two decades to conclude a substantive code of conduct based on the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea to help lower the risk of confrontation. But the two sides have been at loggerheads mainly due to differences over which maritime areas the code should cover, who should be regarded as an extraregional player and whether the code would be legally binding.
A China Coast Guard ship (left) fires a water cannon at a Philippine Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources ship (center) near Sandy Cay reef in the disputed South China Sea in this screen shot from video taken on May 21. |
Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources and Philippine Coast Guard / VIA AFP-JIJI
Philippine Foreign Secretary Enrique Manalo said that Manila is targeting 2026 for the code's completion, when it takes over the rotating ASEAN chairmanship from Malaysia. The top Philippine diplomat, who is set to visit Tokyo on Wednesday, also said that Manila is open to more arrangements with Beijing to help maintain peace in the strategic waterway.
But concerns remain.
There have already been calls in the past for an expedited conclusion, none of which have panned out. Experts say that, given the diverging interests within ASEAN — as well as the close ties of Cambodia and Laos to China — the 2026 deadline may not be feasible.
'Outstanding issues appear to be insurmountable at this point,' said Ian Chong, an associate professor of political science at the National University of Singapore. 'If there is an acceleration of negotiations to a conclusion, that end agreement is likely to leave key issues insufficiently addressed.'
At the same time, the rising number of flare-ups has drawn growing regional and global attention, making it more difficult for Beijing to follow its preferred approach of solving these disputes bilaterally.
This means that China's preference of dealing with these issues one-on-one makes an ASEAN-led solution seem increasingly unlikely.
Frustrated with the slow progress on the code of conduct, the Philippines has begun turning to individual claimants to push for bilateral or minilateral engagements.
This push has prompted questions about ASEAN's effectiveness in addressing regional flash points, particularly when one of the parties isn't a bloc member.
Philippine coast guard and military personnel hold the country's flag during an inter-agency maritime operation on Sandy Cay in the disputed South China Sea on April 27. |
National Task Force on West Philippine Sea / VIA AFP-JIJI
The latter is important as individual Southeast Asian governments have a strong record of handling disputes on a bilateral basis, albeit not through ASEAN. Vietnam and Indonesia, for instance, recently moved forward on a maritime delimitation agreement.
It's a different story at the ASEAN level. Experts warn that the organization's dialogue mechanisms may not be sufficient to prevent or manage a broader regional crisis involving major powers.
They say that except for some basic principles or issues where agreement is relatively easy — such as promoting economic cooperation — the bloc has difficulty finding formal common cause.
With the exception of Vietnam, most mainland ASEAN members largely avoided the code of conduct issue. Maritime countries, either as claimants or states that use the waterway, have been reluctant to publicly back the Philippines, despite a 2016 international arbitral tribunal ruling invalidating Beijing's claims to most of the disputed waters.
'Not all ASEAN claimant states face the same kind of pressure from China, or have as many of their claimed features occupied,' said Thomas Daniel, of the Institute of Strategic and International Studies Malaysia, noting that this influences national positions and appetites for risk.
Even more of an impediment to cooperation is ASEAN claimant states' history of distrust — many are also involved in disputes with each other, not just with China.
Southeast Asian claimant states 'once believed that using the collective heft of ASEAN to negotiate with Beijing on the South China Sea might yield more favorable outcomes, but that has clearly not played out as intended,' Daniel said.
Instead, China has managed to successfully exploit 'both diverging priorities within ASEAN and the group's consensus-based decision-making to its own advantage,' he added.
Manila's frustration with the latter was voiced earlier this month by Philippine national security adviser Eduardo Ano, who urged ASEAN to be the 'strongest defender' of the concept that 'might does not make right.'
In the region, the demand for consensus has sometimes become an 'instrument for inaction and inertia,' Ano said, warning that the search for an agreement by all has become 'an obstacle to arrive at important and unified mechanisms.'
Over the past few decades, ASEAN has grown diverse in terms of interests, government types and levels of economic development, creating more decision-making challenges, given that any member state also has veto power.
'The Philippines has long recognized that some ASEAN member states are unlikely to offer outright support due to their close economic ties with China,' said Dindo Manhit, president of the Stratbase ADR Institute, one of the Philippines' leading research consultancies.
Manila's growing frustration lies in the 'lack of recognition' that China's aggressive actions in the South China Sea waters closest to the Philippines are not solely its concern, but rather a regional threat that undermines stability and the broader rules-based order, he added.
Still, it's important to note that ASEAN was never intended to be a security-focused bloc.
'ASEAN's inherent limitations must be acknowledged as it was not primarily established to address political and sociocultural issues,' Manhit said, adding that the grouping's core focus remains economic cooperation.
Given these limitations, he added, the Philippines' best course of action would be to pursue partnerships with maritime ASEAN states and like-minded countries — including Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam — to ensure freedom of navigation and overflight, as well as economic rights within their exclusive economic zones.
Aware of the limitations, Manila has in recent years begun taking matters into its own hands.
It has boosted military spending, deepened defense partnerships with countries like Japan, while also expanding security ties with outside partners such as New Zealand, Canada, India, France and Germany — moves that suggest Manila is not pinning all its hopes on the elusive code-of-conduct agreement.
These actions 'should not be seen as a reaction against any particular nation,' Manhit said, but 'rather as part of its broader strategy to strengthen its security posture and contribute to regional stability.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

China's Xi urges South Korea's Lee to protect free trade in first talks
China's Xi urges South Korea's Lee to protect free trade in first talks

Japan Times

time2 hours ago

  • Japan Times

China's Xi urges South Korea's Lee to protect free trade in first talks

New South Korean President Lee Jae-myung held his first talks with Chinese leader Xi Jinping, the official Xinhua News Agency said Tuesday, as Lee looks to balance ties between Beijing and Seoul's ally, Washington. Xi told Lee that China and South Korea should work to take their strategic cooperative partnership 'to a higher level' amid rising concerns over the future of global free trade, Xinhua said Xi had told Lee during talks over the telephone. 'China and South Korea should inject more certainty into (the) regional and international landscape,' Xi was quoted as saying, adding that the two countries 'should jointly safeguard multilateralism and free trade, and ensure stable and smooth global and regional industrial and supply chains.' Xi's remarks were widely seen as a jab at U.S. President Donald Trump, who has targeted multilateral groupings with fiery criticism while also unleashing unilateral tariffs on countries across the globe, including allies like South Korea and rivals such as China. Chinese leader Xi Jinping waves to spectators as he leaves after a military parade on Victory Day, marking the 80th anniversary of the victory over Nazi Germany in World War II, in Red Square in central Moscow on May 9. | REUTERS Lee took office on June 4 with a vow to end the 'politics of division' and carry out a 'pragmatic' approach to foreign policy after riding a wave of anxiety about the economy and political instability to victory in an election a day earlier. In a speech following his swearing in, Lee called for dialogue with archenemy North Korea, while stressing South Korea's commitment to its security alliance with the U.S. and growing ties with Japan. But any mention of China — South Korea's largest trading partner — was conspicuously absent. Lee's election came exactly six months after his predecessor, Yoon Suk Yeol, briefly declared martial law — a move that ultimately saw him removed from office. During his time in office, Yoon openly antagonized Beijing and worked to align South Korea with Washington in the growing Sino-U.S. rivalry. In the run-up to his election, Lee pledged to mend relations with China to help spur economic growth. The Xi-Lee call came a day after the South Korean leader and Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba agreed during a telephone call to strengthen bilateral ties amid concerns that relations between Seoul and Tokyo could falter under Lee, who has a history of hard-line remarks aimed at Japan. Lee's first leader-to-leader call was with Trump last week, with the two agreeing to work toward a swift tariff deal. In addition to the tariffs, Trump has also pressed South Korea to pay more for the 28,500 U.S. troops stationed there.

Two Chinese aircraft carriers conduct simultaneous drills in Pacific for first time
Two Chinese aircraft carriers conduct simultaneous drills in Pacific for first time

Japan Times

time6 hours ago

  • Japan Times

Two Chinese aircraft carriers conduct simultaneous drills in Pacific for first time

China's two operating aircraft carriers have been spotted conducting simultaneous operations in the Pacific for the first time, according to Japan's Defense Ministry, as Beijing continues to highlight its growing military prowess ever farther from its shores. The ministry said late Monday that the Shandong had been spotted along with four other Chinese warships in Japan's exclusive economic zone about 550 kilometers southeast of Miyako Island in Okinawa Prefecture on Saturday. The fleet was then spotted Monday in the EEZ north of Okinotorishima, Japan's southernmost island, where it conducted flight operations with fighter jets and helicopters. The other aircraft carrier, the Liaoning, had been spotted operating off Minamitorishima, Japan's easternmost island, on Saturday and Sunday, making it the first Chinese aircraft carrier to cross the so-called second island chain, which covers a stretch of islands from Japan to Guam and the islands of Micronesia, the Defense Ministry said. 'They are trying to enhance the operational capabilities in far territories,' Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshimasa Hayashi said Monday when asked about the move. Beijing said that the Chinese vessels' activities were fully consistent with international law and international practices. "China pursues a national defense policy that is defensive in nature. We hope Japan will view those activities objectively and rationally," Foreign Ministry spokesman Lin Jian said Monday. Officials say the moves highlight the Chinese Navy's growing ability to punch through the second island chain. China's Shandong aircraft carrier is seen in the Pacific Ocean. The Defense Ministry in Tokyo said late Monday that the vessel had been spotted in Japan's exclusive economic zone north of Okinotorishima, where it conducted flight operations with fighter jets and helicopters. | JAPAN JOINT STAFF OFFICE China routinely sends its vessels through the first island chain, which strings together the southern Ryukyu Islands and the Philippines. The island chain is home to numerous U.S. and Japanese military bases. Both island chains are seen by Beijing as Cold War relics being used to contain China and limit its access to the Pacific. Late last month, the Defense Ministry in Tokyo announced for the first time that China had sent the Liaoning into the East China Sea, some 200 km from the Japanese-administered Senkaku Islands, for practice deploying fighter jets. The Senkakus are also claimed by China, which calls them the Diaoyu. In another first, the Liaoning passed through a narrow waterway between Yonaguni and Iriomote islands in Okinawa Prefecture last September. Though that sailing was legal under international law, the Japanese government called it 'unacceptable from the perspective of the security environment of Japan and the region.' Yonaguni, Japan's westernmost island, sits just 110 km east of flash point Taiwan. China claims Taiwan as a renegade province that must be united with the mainland, by force if necessary. It routinely sends warships and warplanes around the island for large-scale military drills that the Defense Ministry in Tokyo says have 'demonstrated at least part of Beijing's invasion strategy.' Beijing has poured funds into its aircraft carrier program, with its third and most advanced aircraft carrier, known as the Fujian, set for commissioning in the near future. The carrier began sea trials in May 2024 and embarked on an eighth round of trials last month. Beijing has characterized the Fujian as 'one of the most important' pieces of military hardware it is working on — and one that will take it closer to its goal of projecting its military far beyond its shores as leader Xi Jinping aims to build a 'world-class military' by the middle of the century.

U.S.-China trade and minerals talks in London set to extend to second day
U.S.-China trade and minerals talks in London set to extend to second day

Japan Times

time7 hours ago

  • Japan Times

U.S.-China trade and minerals talks in London set to extend to second day

U.S.-China trade talks were set to extend to a second day in London as top economic officials from the world's two largest economies sought to defuse a bitter dispute that has widened from tariffs to restrictions over rare earths, threatening a global supply chain shock and slower economic growth. Talks at Lancaster House, an ornate U.K. government mansion, wrapped for the night on Monday and were set to resume at 10 a.m. BST (0900 GMT) on Tuesday, a U.S. source familiar with the negotiations said. Washington and Beijing are trying to revive a temporary truce struck in Geneva that had briefly lowered trade tensions and calmed markets. Since then, the U.S. has accused China of slow-walking its commitments, particularly around rare earths shipments. U.S. President Donald Trump on Monday put a positive spin on the talks, saying that they were going well and he was "only getting good reports" from his team in London. "We're doing well with China. China's not easy," Trump said, offering no details on the substance of the discussions. Asked about lifting export controls, Trump told reporters at the White House: "We're going to see." White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett had said earlier on Monday that the U.S. team wanted a handshake from China on rare earths after Trump said Chinese President Xi Jinping agreed to resume shipments in a rare call between the two leaders last week. Hassett told CNBC in an interview that the U.S. would expect export controls to be eased and rare earths released in volume immediately afterwards. The London talks come at a crucial time for both economies, which are showing signs of strain from Trump's cascade of tariff orders since his return to the White House in January. Customs data showed that China's exports to the U.S. plunged 34.5% year-on-year in May in value terms, the sharpest drop since February 2020, when the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic upended global trade. In the U.S., business and household confidence has taken a pummeling, while first-quarter gross domestic product contracted due to a record surge in imports as Americans front-loaded purchases to beat anticipated price increases. So far, the impact on inflation has been muted and the jobs market has remained fairly resilient, though economists expect cracks to become more apparent over the summer. Attending the talks in London are U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer. The Chinese contingent led by Vice Premier He Lifeng includes Commerce Minister Wang Wentao and the ministry's chief trade negotiator, Li Chenggang. U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent leaves Lancaster House in London after trade talks on Monday. | Bloomberg The inclusion of Lutnick, whose agency oversees export controls for the U.S., is one indication of how central rare earths have become. Some analysts saw it as a sign that Trump is willing to put recently imposed Commerce Department export restrictions on the table. China holds a near-monopoly on rare earth magnets, a crucial component in electric vehicle motors. Lutnick did not attend the Geneva talks at which the countries struck a 90-day deal to roll back some of the triple-digit tariffs they had placed on each other. Meanwhile, the U.S. court fight over an effort to invalidate Trump's tariffs on goods from China and other trading partners advanced on Monday with the Trump administration filing arguments in its appeal of a U.S. trade court's ruling that the levies exceeded Trump's legal authority. The federal appeals court could rule at any time on the Trump administration's request to keep the tariffs in place while the appeal proceeds. It could go all the way to the Supreme Court. Positive conclusion Trump and Xi spoke by phone last week, their first direct interaction since Trump's January 20 inauguration. During the call, Xi told Trump to back down from trade measures that roiled the global economy and warned him against threatening steps on Taiwan, according to a Chinese government summary. But Trump said on social media the talks focused primarily on trade led to "a very positive conclusion," setting the stage for Monday's meeting in the British capital. The next day, Trump said Xi had agreed to resume shipments to the U.S. of rare earths minerals and magnets. Reuters reported that China granted temporary export licenses to rare-earth suppliers of the top three U.S. automakers. Export restrictions China's decision in April to suspend exports of a wide range of critical minerals and magnets upended the global supply chains central to automakers, aerospace manufacturers, semiconductor companies and military contractors. Kelly Ann Shaw, a former White House trade adviser during Trump's first term and now a trade partner at the Akin Gump law firm in Washington, said she expected China to reaffirm its commitment to lift retaliatory measures, including export restrictions, "plus some concessions on the U.S. side, with respect to export controls measures over the past week or two." But Shaw said she expected the U.S. to only agree to lift some new export curbs, not longstanding ones such as for advanced artificial intelligence chips. In May, the U.S. ordered a halt to shipments of semiconductor design software and chemicals and aviation equipment, revoking export licenses that had been previously issued. The preliminary deal in Geneva sparked a global relief rally in stock markets, and U.S. indexes that had been in or near bear market levels have recouped the lion's share of their losses. But Ian Bremmer, president of the Eurasia Group, said while a temporary truce was possible, there was little prospect for the bilateral relationship to become constructive given broader decoupling trends and continued U.S. pressure on other countries to take China out of their supply chains. "Everyone around Trump is still hawkish and so a breakthrough U.S.-China trade deal is unlikely, especially in the context of other deals that are further along and prioritized," he said in an analyst note.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store