‘Elio' Review: Pixar's Fantastical, Familiar World

New York Times

5 hours ago

Colors pop, lines flow and an alien world shimmers like the Vegas strip after dark in Pixar's latest, 'Elio,' a lackluster science-fiction adventure about a lonely boy and extraterrestrials who come in peace, except when they don't. By turns appealing and drearily familiar, the movie offers the expected visual pleasures and characters who range from the gently exaggerated to the hyperbolic. Some have rubbery countenances and curious appendages; others have enormous eyes that water with emotion. Yours may glaze over in boredom.
A morality tale with far-out friendlies and a glowering, growling Marvelesque villain, 'Elio' has predictable Pixar bright spots, but the story is a drag. It tracks the title character (voiced by Yonas Kibreab), an 11-year-old who's been recently and mysteriously orphaned. He now lives with his aunt, Olga (Zoe Saldaña), an Air Force Major who monitors space junk at the coastal California base where she's stationed. Loving yet clueless, she is at a loss on how to raise a child, especially one who's unhappy and feels out of place with her or anywhere. (Her parenting book is studded with a rainbow of sticky notes.) Less comically, Olga is especially ill-equipped to deal with a grieving child, a failing that she shares with the filmmakers.
Orphans are a storybook staple — from Disney's original 'Snow White' to 'Lilo & Stitch' — though not on Planet Pixar. Yet to judge by this movie's at times abruptly fluctuating tones and eagerness to dry every tear, Elio's greatest issue isn't that his parents are dead but that the filmmakers are uncomfortable with his grief. Early on, while out with his aunt, he hides under a table and weeps. Soon, though, the story has revved up, and he's humorously sending messages into space begging to be taken away from Olga, Earth, everything. 'Aliens abduct me!!!,' Elio scrawls on a beach, before lying down and grinning hopefully at the sky.
After some more narrative busyness, character development and scene changes, the filmmakers grant Elio's wish and send him off on his hoped-for cosmic adventure. One evening, while Olga is at work and Elio waits for deliverance, he is pulled from the beach on a beam of light, an image of alien abduction with a suggestively rapturous religious undertone. Once he achieves liftoff, the movie starts to as well. It grows more vividly hued and nicely unbound, and Elio is soon careering through bursts of color and graphic forms, much like the astronaut in the oft-copied lysergic star gate sequence in '2001: A Space Odyssey.'
Elio predictably exits our solar system and ends up in the Communiverse, a sparkly, kaleidoscopic alternative realm where the directors Madeline Sharafian and Domee Shi modestly cut loose. (The script is by Julia Cho, Mark Hammer and Mike Jones.) A jumble of landscapes rich in lightly phantasmagoric embellishments, it functions as a kind of hangout and otherworldly United Nations for extraterrestrials. There, Elio zips past terrains with an array of biomorphic and geometric forms. He also, via a translator, chats up others, including a talking, floating blue supercomputer, Ooooo (Shirley Henderson), a kind of A.I. Jiminy Cricket, if one that tends to look like a dialogue bubble with eyes and a mouth.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.