Meta, TikTok can be sued by mother of NYC teen killed while 'subway surfing'
FILE PHOTO: Printed Facebook and TikTok logos are seen in this illustration taken February 15, 2022. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo
NEW YORK (Reuters) -Meta Platforms and TikTok owner ByteDance must face a wrongful death lawsuit by the mother of a 15-year-old Manhattan boy who died while "subway surfing" on a moving train, a New York state judge ruled.
Justice Paul Goetz ruled on Friday that Norma Nazario can try to prove Meta and ByteDance "goaded" her son Zackery into subway surfing by addicting him to Instagram and TikTok, where he viewed content about "dangerous challenges."
Meta, ByteDance and Snapchat parent Snap have faced thousands of lawsuits saying their platforms are addictive, causing harm to children, schools and governments.
Zackery Nazario died on February 20, 2023, after he and his girlfriend climbed atop a Brooklyn-bound J train as it crossed the Williamsburg Bridge.
His mother said a low beam struck Zackery, causing him to fall between subway cars, which ran over him.
She said she later found several videos related to subway surfing on Zackery's social media accounts.
Meta and ByteDance called Nazario's death "heartbreaking," but claimed immunity from user content under Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act, and the free speech clause of the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment.
But the Manhattan judge said Norma Nazario could try to prove her son was targeted because of his age.
"Based on the allegations in the complaint," Goetz wrote, "it is plausible that the social media defendants' role exceeded that of neutral assistance in promoting content, and constituted active identification of users who would be most impacted."
Goetz said Norma Nazario may pursue wrongful death, product liability and negligence claims.
He dismissed her claims against New York City's Metropolitan Transit Authority, saying common sense and "the realities of life in this city" should have signaled to Zackery that subway surfing was dangerous.
Meta, ByteDance and their lawyers had no immediate comment. Norma Nazario's lawyers did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The MTA did not immediately respond to a similar request.
At least six people died from subway surfing in 2024, New York City police have said.
The case is Nazario v ByteDance Ltd et al, New York State Supreme Court, New York County, No. 151540/2024.
(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New YorkEditing by Mark Potter)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
6 hours ago
- The Star
Suspect in deadly Idaho firefighters ambush identified, motive a mystery
FILE PHOTO: Law enforcement officers gather at Cherry Hill Park after multiple firefighters were attacked when responding to a fire in the Canfield Mountain area outside Coeur d'Alene, Idaho, U.S. June 29, 2025. REUTERS/Young Kwak/File Photo (Reuters) -The man who shot dead two firefighters and wounded a third after setting a blaze near a popular mountainside trail in Idaho was described by authorities on Monday as a young transient whose motives remained a mystery a day after the attack. Kootenai County Sheriff Bob Norris identified the suspected gunman in Sunday's attack as Wess Roley, 20, who was found dead at the scene of an apparent self-inflicted gun wound. Authorities have not identified the two firefighters who were shot and killed, nor have they given the name of a third firefighter who was shot and survived. Roley had some sort of interaction with the firefighters he shot and killed when they arrived on the scene of the fire, Norris said, though he provided no details on what occurred. The suspect was known to have expressed interest in becoming a firefighter himself, the sheriff said. Norris said that Roley, who was born in California, had been living for the past year in Coeur d'Alene, about 260 miles (420 km) east of Seattle, where the shooting took place at Canfield Mountain, a nature area popular with hikers and bikers. Over 300 law enforcement officers responded to the scene on Sunday. Early reports indicated there were multiple shooters attacking firefighters. But Norris on Monday said it appeared that Roley acted alone and that he had no known connection to any sort of group that may have motivated the violence. The sheriff said that Roley had no known criminal record. Local police had five recent minor and non-violent interactions with Roley, who appeared to be living out of his vehicle and whom officers during those interactions had told to move from spots where he was parked and residing. On Sunday, Norris said they believed Roley was armed with at least one rifle. But on Monday he said that the weapon recovered near Roley's body at the crime scene was a shotgun. "We know that some rifled slugs were used, and a rifled slug is a pretty big projectile," Norris said, adding that investigators were still trying to determine if other weapons were involved. When firefighters responded to the blaze on Sunday afternoon, they came under fire almost immediately, Norris said. When police officers and sheriff's deputies arrived later, they, too, came under fire from trees that Roley had apparently climbed and shot from. Scores of officers from the city, county, state and federal level responded, including two helicopters with snipers aboard. The suspect was located using cellphone information and his body was removed by a SWAT team as the fire approached. Gun ownership is widespread in the U.S., where the Constitution protects the rights of Americans to "keep and bear arms." Deaths related to gun violence are common - 17,927 people were murdered with a gun in 2023 in the U.S., according to the most recent available data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (Reporting by Brad Brooks in Colorado and Steve Gorman in Los Angeles; Editing by Rosalba O'Brien)
The Star
14 hours ago
- The Star
Asean News Headlines at 10pm on Monday (June 30, 2025)
Malaysia: * Govt open to factual criticisms of taxation system, says Anwar * PM Anwar's Italy visit focuses on strengthening bilateral ties * No interference in judicial matters as govt respects the Constitutional process, says PM * Malaysia and Singapore unveil first RTS Link train * Teacher ordered to enter defence for sexual assault of student * Melaka restaurant assistant faces court over child molestation charge * Queen shares heartfelt memories on Tunku Mahkota Ismail's birthday * Perhentian boat tragedy: Critically injured young girl now stable * MCMC to summon TikTok over concerns about 'Player Knockout Battle' trend * Chief Justice retirement: Malaysian Bar calls for immediate announcement of replacement * Bank Negara: Malaysia's banking system liquidity remains healthy in May * Mining bribery case: Sabah reps vow to continue serving constituents while clearing their names * Two Sabah assemblymen, businessman claim trial over RM350,000 mining bribe case * MOF: RM11bil deployed under GEAR-uP to drive high-growth sectors * Federal Court to deliver verdict on final appeal of six men convicted in DPP Kevin Morais murder tomorrow * Putra Heights inferno: No foul play, negligence found, say cops / PETRONAS finds same issue like in Putra Heights along its 2,680km pipeline * Under-18 national squad eye a place in Asian Cup semis / MHC stand by coach Sarjit despite poor Nations Cup display Singapore: * Singapore to enforce new anti-scam law on Tuesday (July 1 ); move protect individuals targeted by scammers * Dalai Lama celebrates 90th birthday; suggests institution to continue at launch event * Jail and caning for man linked to fatal Orchard Road brawl in Singapore * Over five years' jail for Singapore driver who caused teen's death during highway race, said she 'deserved it' * Over 950,000 Singaporean households to get U-Save, S&CC rebates in July * Singapore firms seek delay on yougher climate disclosures * Asia shares track Wall St gains before payrolls test / Asian stocks, futures rise as trade talks progress * :( Microsoft's 'blue screen of death' is going away * Oil falls on prospect of more OPEC+ supply, easing risks in Mideast * Emerging Market: Forex firm, stocks mixed as investors monitor US trade progress * US strike on Iran highlights China's need for strategic bombers, analysts say Indonesia: * Indonesia evacuates 97 citizens from Iran, 26 from Tel Aviv, Jurusalem, and Arabah * China to keep anti-dumping steel duties on EU, UK, S. Korea and Indonesia * Indonesia begins US$5.9bil EV battery project despite environmental fears * Asean urged to infuse gender lens in human rights agenda * Indonesia imports over 1,500 dairy cows to boost milk production * Indonesia to ease import restrictions ahead of US tariff deadline * Indonesian islanders lose ground as islets put on sale * Time to explore the undiscovered wonders of Timor-Leste People play a skipping rope game with giant dolls named Young-hee and Chul-su from Netflix series - Squid Game - during a promotional event of -Squid Game 3 - final season at City Hall Square in Bangkok, Thailand, on Monday, June 30, 2025. -- REUTERS/Chalinee Thirasupa Thailand: * Thai economy slows in May on weaker tourism and production, says its central bank * Bangkok building collapsed after Myanmar quake due to construction, design flaws, probe shows * Eda Ezrin's drug case moved to Songkhla Court of Appeal * Phumtham rules out coup, says military never entertained idea * Thai travellers still require Schengen visas, says Foreign Ministry * Thailand warns of hand, foot and mouth disease outbreak * Thai PM's crisis of confidence deepens as public demands fresh direction * Bangkok Festival set to draw 10,000 visitors, bolster Malaysia's 2026 tourism drive Philippines: * Lithuania and Philippines sign a pact to build an alliance against aggression * Philippines says military leaders working to set-up 'one-theatre' approach in East, South China seas * Plane becomes sauna and passengers were told to 'meditate' – so they stewed even more * Drugs worth 700mil pesos seized in Philippines; cops probing link to 'floating' shabu * Manila court declares Alice Guo a Chinese national * Philippines - 'Involuntary hunger' rose to 20% in April A Buddhist devotee holds a golden Buddha figurine as she waits for the arrival of Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama, before the start of a Long Life Prayer offering ceremony at the Main Tibetan Temple in McLeod Ganj, near Dharamsala on Monday, June 30, 2025. -- Photo by Sanjay BAID / AFP Vietnam: * Trump deals poised to fall short of sweeping trade reforms * Vietnam approves plans for international financial centre amid US trade pressure * United Nations chief warns of 'decimated' aid budgets at development conference * Vietnam rolls out key tax reforms from July 1 to support fairer system * Vietnam unveils new local government authorities * China and Vietnam hold border meeting on judicial cooperation Myanmar: * Interpol warns of surge in human trafficking linked to online fraud * KL cops launch manhunt for Myanmar national over murder of co-worker * Tremors detected near Thai border in Myanmar and Nicobar Islands * Kunming-Mandalay flights resume after quake repairs in Myanmar * 14 water supply projects planned in southern Myanmar in fiscal 2025-26 * Yangon approves eight new investment projects, creating over 6,000 jobs Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama (right) arrives to attend a Long Life Prayer offering ceremony at the Main Tibetan Temple in McLeod Ganj, near Dharamsala on Monday, June 30, 2025. Exiled Tibetan spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, gave on June 30, the strongest indication yet that the 600-year-old institution would continue after his death, at prayer celebrations for his 90th birthday. The leader, who turns 90 on July 6, is according to Tibetans the 14th reincarnation of the Dalai Lama. - Photo by Sanjay BAID / AFP Cambodia: * Malaysian investors explore Cambodian SME sector * Ten cases of bird flu reported in Cambodia so far in 2025 * Health workers in Cambodia on standby to support military, citizens on Thai border * Mother, son contract H5N1 bird flu in Cambodia * Coach Conor says Cambodian women footballers deserve encouragement after Hong Kong draw Laos: * As rain keeps falling, Laos braces for rising flood risk * Joint Mekong patrol sends strong signal to criminals * Lao Rocket Festival fills sky with joy Brunei: * Brunei, Sarawak artists unite in cultural exchange * Roadshow raises Asean awareness among Brunei students * Protesters demand debt cancellation, climate action ahead of UN summit Rice paddy artwork showing baseball star Los Angeles Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani and his dog Decoy is seen in his hometown of Oshu, Iwate Prefecture, Japan. - AP Photo/Gregorio Borgia AseanPlus: * It was rock all the way as a packed house grooved all night at the rollicking 'Konsert Jiwa Kacau 3.0' in Bukit Jalil * RWNYC officially submits bid for New York casino licence * Bursa Malaysia rises on growing geopolitical stability * Skola Gambar Ilham is a mobile art gallery on a mission to bring art to the people * Invest Asean-Malaysia 2025 Conference to run from tomorrow to July 3 * No Malaysians involved in Bangladeshi militant group * Snakes on a plane bound for India, again * Chemical factory blast kills eight workers in Southern India * China's scorching heat poses summer test for electricity grid * Hong Kong's last active pro-democracy group says it will disband amid security crackdown * Trump says car trade with Mr Japan is unfair as deadline looms * China's envoy urges Australia to resist US pressure on military spending * Indian official says political constraints led to jet losses * China's humanoid robots generate more soccer excitement than their human counterparts * Telegram increases cooperation with South Korean police in criminal investigations * China's June manufacturing activity shrinks for third month * Quarter of South Koreans aged 20 to 50 invest in crypto assets * Taiwan says 'constructive progress' made in US trade talks * China reiterates opposition to any trade deals at its expense * South Korea -- Fans march for Squid Game's final round * Taiwanese girl group S.H.E reunite – for Hebe Tien's concert * China's scorching heat poses summer test for electricity grid * Digital embryo gives China a powerful tool to decode secret of life: scientists * Economists call for structural reforms to shift China's focus to consumption * Hong Kong public universities get 850 transfer inquiries amid shifting US policies * China lifts a nearly 2-year ban on seafood from Japan over Fukushima wastewater * Taiwanese TV host and author Wang Hao-yi dies of heart attack, just 5 days after his mother's passing * Over 230,000 Afghans left Iran in June ahead of return deadline * Bangladesh ISPs worried about Starlink's entry * Matcha: the Japanese tea taking over the world * Jo Yu-ri says she didn't expect her 'Squid Game' role to be this difficult * Jury retires to decide verdict in Australia's mushroom murder trial * Nepalese start-up deploys drones to remove rubbish from Mount Everest * With a push-notification about 'F1: The Movie', Apple did what no company should ever do * Mongolian President congratulates women's 3x3 basketball team on historic World Cup achievement * Surfing - 'Pickles' relishes first win of 2025 in Brazil * Golf - Cool as ice - South Korean super duo Lee and Im win first LPGA titles after bagging the team-format Dow Championships in a playoff
The Star
14 hours ago
- The Star
Meta, TikTok can be sued by mother of NYC teen killed while 'subway surfing'
FILE PHOTO: Printed Facebook and TikTok logos are seen in this illustration taken February 15, 2022. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo NEW YORK (Reuters) -Meta Platforms and TikTok owner ByteDance must face a wrongful death lawsuit by the mother of a 15-year-old Manhattan boy who died while "subway surfing" on a moving train, a New York state judge ruled. Justice Paul Goetz ruled on Friday that Norma Nazario can try to prove Meta and ByteDance "goaded" her son Zackery into subway surfing by addicting him to Instagram and TikTok, where he viewed content about "dangerous challenges." Meta, ByteDance and Snapchat parent Snap have faced thousands of lawsuits saying their platforms are addictive, causing harm to children, schools and governments. Zackery Nazario died on February 20, 2023, after he and his girlfriend climbed atop a Brooklyn-bound J train as it crossed the Williamsburg Bridge. His mother said a low beam struck Zackery, causing him to fall between subway cars, which ran over him. She said she later found several videos related to subway surfing on Zackery's social media accounts. Meta and ByteDance called Nazario's death "heartbreaking," but claimed immunity from user content under Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act, and the free speech clause of the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment. But the Manhattan judge said Norma Nazario could try to prove her son was targeted because of his age. "Based on the allegations in the complaint," Goetz wrote, "it is plausible that the social media defendants' role exceeded that of neutral assistance in promoting content, and constituted active identification of users who would be most impacted." Goetz said Norma Nazario may pursue wrongful death, product liability and negligence claims. He dismissed her claims against New York City's Metropolitan Transit Authority, saying common sense and "the realities of life in this city" should have signaled to Zackery that subway surfing was dangerous. Meta, ByteDance and their lawyers had no immediate comment. Norma Nazario's lawyers did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The MTA did not immediately respond to a similar request. At least six people died from subway surfing in 2024, New York City police have said. The case is Nazario v ByteDance Ltd et al, New York State Supreme Court, New York County, No. 151540/2024. (Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New YorkEditing by Mark Potter)
