Politician told to leave parliament after calling New Zealand 'laggard' in Palestine debate
An urgent debate was called after the centre-right government said on Monday it was weighing up its position on whether to recognise a Palestinian state.
Close ally Australia on Monday joined Canada, the UK and France in announcing it would recognise a Palestinian state at a UN conference in September.
Swarbrick, who is co-leader of the Green Party, said New Zealand was a 'laggard' and an 'outlier' and the lack of decision was appalling before calling on some government members to support a bill to 'sanction Israel for its war crimes". The bill was proposed by her party in March and is supported by all opposition parties.
'If we find six of 68 government MPs with a spine, we can stand on the right side of history," said Swarbrick.
Speaker Gerry Brownlee said that statement was 'completely unacceptable' and she had to withdraw it and apologise. When she refused, Swarbrick was ordered to leave parliament.
Brownlee later clarified Swarbrick could return on Wednesday but if she still refused to apologise she would again be removed from parliament.
New Zealand has said it will make a decision in September about whether it would recognise Palestine as a state.
Foreign Minister Winston Peters told parliament that over the next month the government would gather information and talk to partners, which would inform cabinet's decision.
'We'll be weighing this decision carefully rather than rushing to judgement,' Peters said.
Along with the Green Party, opposition parties Labour and Te Pati Maori support recognition of a Palestinian state.
Labour parliamentarian Peeni Henare said New Zealand had a history of standing strong on its principles and values and in this case 'was being left behind".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
‘I felt useless and needed to do something': UK MP on letter to triggering Palestine recognition move
A call from a friend in Gaza to an influential Labour MP was instrumental in Britain's historic move towards recognising the Palestinian state, she has told The National. Just days before the UK government announced its first steps in recognising the state, Sarah Champion received a phone call from a friend who told the politician that after months of struggling to find food in Gaza 'my family are just waiting to die', and everyone they knew felt the same. 'To lose hope is a horrific thing, I felt useless and knew I needed to do something to try and restore it,' Ms Champion told The National. The next steps she took were to have a decisive impact on Britain recognising Palestine as a sovereign nation and influencing President Donald Trump's view that starvation was genuine in Gaza. Had to act quickly The call taken by Ms Champion, chairwoman of Parliament's international development committee, was on Wednesday, July 23. The situation in Gaza was visibly deteriorating, with pictures of starving children shared on social media. There was a growing consensus to rein in Israel's actions, she felt, including its plans to further annex occupied West Bank territories. With parliament heading into summer recess Ms Champion had to act quickly if she was to maximise pressure on the government. She knew that very senior cabinet members − including the Foreign Secretary David Lammy − were dismayed by Israel's dismissal of their concerns and had been quietly lobbying Prime Minister Keir Starmer for Palestine recognition. If she could garner enough cross-bench parliamentary support then that could provide the impetus for a major political step. Message blitz Ms Champion and her team went to work sending WhatsApp messages and emails to fellow MPs to sign a letter that called on Mr Starmer to recognise Palestine. 'I was amazed how many we got, and in such a short space of time – just 30 hours – but I think it is a clear representation of the strength of feeling in Parliament in support of the Palestinian plight,' she said. The following night, France suddenly announced it would recognise Palestine, and by 5pm on the Friday she had amassed a record number of 221 signatures from MPs representing nine different parties. 'UK recognition would have a significant impact due to our historic connections and our membership on the UN Security Council, so we urge you to take this step,' the MPs said. Key to the gathering of signatures was the respect held by fellow MPs from all parties for Ms Champion, who has been consistently outspoken on the plight of Palestinians. With this in mind, Mr Starmer knew he had to respond quickly and while he did not immediately agree, he did use new language condemning Israel's 'disproportionate military escalation in Gaza' that was 'indefensible'. 'Set the agenda' However, with US President Donald Trump landing in Scotland just a few hours later, now was not the time to initiate a political earthquake. But having the American leader in Britain was useful as he would be meeting Mr Starmer on the Monday, by which time after continued weekend reports of the grim situation in Gaza, 255 MPs had now signed the letter. The letter, according to Ms Champion, had 'set the agenda for journalists when Trump came to the UK', and this made the President more aware of the dire situation. In the press conference with Mr Starmer, Mr Trump stated 'that's real starvation stuff, I see it, and you can't fake that,' adding 'we have to get the kids fed'. The letter had been 'a significant factor in his comments around believing starvation was occurring in Gaza', claims Ms Champion. Indication of urgency More important was the letter's impact on the British government's decision on July 29, just after Mr Trump left Scotland, to set out its steps towards recognition. 'The letter gave them an indication of the urgency, and I am glad they listened,' Ms Champion said. While Britain's move was met with fury from Israel, she argued that it sent a 'clear signal' that the UK believed 'Palestine is a viable state and needs to be treated as such; with all the protections and rights afforded to other nations'. 'To have a two-state solution, you have to have two states,' she added. 'And the Israeli cabinet needs to understand the status quo is neither acceptable nor going to continue.' Israel also needed to secure a ceasefire and work for a lasting peace that 'enables both countries to feel safe and respected', added the MP for Rotherham, in northern England. Britain, unless Israel meets certain conditions will now be joined by France, Canada, Australia and Malta at the UN General Assembly next month in recognising Palestine, taking the total of countries that do so to 152.
Middle East Eye
2 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Saudi Arabia executes eight people in single day
Saudi Arabia executed eight people in a single day, the majority of them foreign nationals on drug-related charges. On Saturday, the Saudi Press Agency reported that four Somali and three Ethiopian nationals were executed in the southern region of Najran for 'for smuggling hashish into the kingdom'. One Saudi man was executed for murdering his mother. The latest deaths come amid a surge in executions mostly targeting foreign nationals for drug-related offences, in what the UK-based organisation Reprieve and the European Saudi Organisation for Human Rights (ESOHR) describe as an "unprecedented execution crisis". Since the Saudi authorities lifted an unofficial moratorium on capital punishment for drug-related offences in 2021, the kingdom has turbocharged executions. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters In 2024, Saudi Arabia executed a record 345 people, almost half of them on charges of non-lethal crimes, according to Reprieve. This year it is set to break that record, having executed 230 so far in 2025, according to an AFP tally, 154 of them on drug-related charges. Photo of Saudi Arabia's crown prince inside Jeffrey Epstein's mansion fuels criticism online Read More » Foreign nationals are particularly at risk, accounting for 92 executions in 2024. According to monitoring by Reprieve and ESOHR, between 2010 and 2021, Saudi Arabia executed almost three times as many foreign nationals for drug-related offences as Saudi nationals. That was despite foreign nationals representing just 36 percent of Saudi Arabia's population. "In the failed global war on drugs we see the same pattern repeating itself - authorities respond to concerns about drug use by killing poor and marginalised groups," Reprieve's head of MENA death penalty projects, Jeed Basyouni, previously told MEE. To make matters worse, they rarely receive basic due process rights such as legal representation or interpreters during their trials," Basyouni added.
Middle East Eye
2 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
France freeze on Gaza evacuations 'predates alleged antisemitic incident'
A freeze by France on evacuations of Palestinians from Gaza precedes a claimed incident of antisemitism by a Palestinian evacuee, according to media reports. On 1 August, French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot announced the suspension of evacuations from Gaza following the discovery of alleged antisemitic posts by a Palestinian student who had been evacuated by French authorities. The student, who was due to pursue studies at Sciences Po Lille next year, was deported to Qatar. Middle East Eye has not been able to independently verify the alleged posts in question. Left wing politicians and human rights groups condemned the decision to freeze all evacuations as a result. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters In an op-ed, more than 1,600 academics denounced a "chilling cynicism", accusing "France [of] exacerbating its participation in the Israeli project of erasure and extermination of Palestinians underway in the Gaza Strip". However, according to French outlet Mediapart, the suspension of evacuations predates the incident involving the Palestinian student. The French outlet contacted Palestinians who had been selected to participate in PAUSE, a program to bring artists and scientists in exile to France. Candidates were offered positions at higher education institutions or universities in France. France freezes Gaza evacuations after evacuee's alleged antisemitic posts Read More » The Palestinians on the scheme told Mediapart that French authorities, through their consulate in occupied East Jerusalem, had told them they would be evacuated before the summer. They learned afterwards - well before the alleged antisemitic incident - that their evacuations had been postponed without explanation. "We initially thought it was because of the war between Israel and Iran", one of the respondents told Mediapart. 'Then there was a resumption of evacuations, around 20 June, but only of students leaving alone, without their families." In response to their requests for clarification, French authorities urged the students to "be patient" and said they were encountering complications securing visas for family members. French officials told the Palestinians affected that they were nevertheless trying to resolve the complications. Cogat, the Israeli military agency responsible for civil affairs in the occupied Palestinian territories, denied in a statement to Mediapart that Israel had been restricting the departure of Gaza residents. 'Ad hoc or political' evacuations Seperately, the French foreign ministry has stopped responding to inquiries about the evacuation of sick Palestinian children. A number of children have been awaiting transfer since May, Mediapart reported, citing Doctors Without Borders (MSF). The outlet spoke to Hani Isleem, a project coordinator at MSF who handles medical evacuations from Gaza. France's recognition of Palestinian state: A 'symbolic' move with questionable effectiveness Read More » According to Isleem, French hospitals have the capacity to accommodate these patients but the country had not moved to evacuate them. A diplomatic source said "France carries out medical evacuations for the benefit of injured or sick children from Gaza within the framework of a criteria that has been put in place by and is managed by WHO [World Health Organisation". The WHO estimates that at least 12,000 sick and wounded Palestinians are awaiting evacuation from Gaza. Paris announced on 20 March that it had taken in 25 Gazan patients since the beginning of 2024. President Emmanuel Macron had promised in November 2023 that France would evacuate up to 50 if necessary. In total, since the beginning of 2025, Paris has evacuated 292 Palestinians, according to the ministry of foreign affairs. Isleem denounced French evacuations as "ad hoc or political" and intended for public relations purposes. France is one of several western states that has announced it will recognise a Palestinian state at the upcoming UN General Assembly in New York next month.
