Ahmedabad plane crash: Air India, Boeing may face ‘unlimited' liability if found negligent
Air India
or
Boeing
could be liable for 'unlimited' damages if found negligent under international aviation law, according to UK legal experts. While Air India holds $1.5 billion in liability insurance, reinsured through the London market, claims could exceed standard limits in such an event, they said.
The
Air India Boeing 787
plane that crashed in
Ahmedabad
on June 12, killed 241 people on board, including 12 crew, and 33 on the ground. Air India has already announced ₹1 crore each as compensation for those killed.
Under the Montreal Convention, the airline is presumed liable and needs to pay a prescribed minimum compensation of 151,800 special drawing rights (SDRs) — an International Monetary Fund-defined unit tied to a currency basket— for death or serious injury in a crash. With one SDR valued at about ₹120, that's as much as ₹1.82 crore per person.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
New Container Houses Indonesia (Prices May Surprise You)
Container House | Search Ads
Search Now
Undo
ET Bureau
This airline is liable for this base compensation, regardless of fault. Beyond this, if negligence is proven, additional compensation can be sought.
ALSO READ:
DGCA gives clean chit to Boeing 787 fleet, flags maintenance concerns at Air India
Live Events
Families of the victims may also file claims in their home countries, including the UK, where courts typically consider future earnings and personal circumstances. The passengers included 181 Indians, 53 Britons, seven Portuguese nationals and one Canadian.
Air India did not comment.
Complex, Long-winded Legalities
Boeing may also face unlimited liability if a fault with the 787 aircraft is discovered. Payouts could vary based on victims' nationality and income, the experts said.
If there is any evidence of faults with the Boeing 787, Boeing will also face unlimited liability, in the US and English courts, said James Healy-Pratt, aviation specialist on UK-based Keystone Law's international aviation legal team.
Keystone and Chicago-based Wisner Law Firm have commenced an independent investigation into the disaster. Wisner specialises in aviation-related litigation and also advised clients in the 2020 Air India Express crash.
Torts
Negligence-related claims are subject to the jurisdiction of UK courts under tort law, said Ashish Kumar Singh, cofounder and joint managing partner of Capstone Legal. Tort law covers injury or loss caused to a person. 'After adducing evidence, cross examination etc, the court can award compensation which is way beyond the insurance limits under the Montreal Convention,' he said. 'However, this exercise is a tedious one and involves complex questions of fact and law.'
'Air India is liable to the families for unlimited damages, unless they can prove they were not negligent, and only then can they limit their liability to 151,800 SDRs,' said Healy-Pratt. 'The legal presumption is that Air India is liable without limit until there is evidence that it can prove to the contrary.'
Air India has $1.5-billion insurance cover for widebody aircraft, which industry experts believe is sufficient to absorb payouts, though legal battles could push claims higher. 'Investigations can stretch for months to years and, in such cases, claims are settled in tranches — starting with initial compensation, followed by negotiated settlements or litigation outcomes,' said a senior insurance industry executive. 'Even after paying full SDR-based compensation and some additional settlements, the liability pool is not likely to be exhausted.'
However, people in the know said the $1.5-billion liability policy should be sufficient to cover even catastrophic events, unless there are multiple large-scale claims in a single year. 'The liability on the operator, Air India, will have multiple angles — the nationality of the passengers on board will define the minimum liability that is applicable to the operator as per the Montreal Convention,' said Hitesh Girotra, vice president, aviation and specialty lines, Prudent Insurance Brokers. 'Since the aircraft crashed into a residential apartment, there is third-party property damage liability on the operator.'
In 2010, ₹7.6 crore was awarded to the family of a passenger in the Air India Express crash at Mangalore airport that killed 158 people. 'No amount of money can ever compensate families who have lost loved ones, but our international team will be seeking the fullest compensation from all potentially responsible parties,' said Healy-Pratt.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
15 minutes ago
- Time of India
Amazon layoffs to continue; CEO Andy Jassy to employees: I could go on, but you get the idea
Amazon CEO Andy Jassy have told employees that artificial intelligence will reduce the company's corporate workforce over the next few years as it integrates more AI tools and agents across its operations. "We will need fewer people doing some of the jobs that are being done today, and more people doing other types of jobs," Jassy wrote in an internal memo. "It's hard to know exactly where this nets out over time, but in the next few years, we expect that this will reduce our total corporate workforce as we get efficiency gains from using AI extensively across the company." The announcement affects Amazon's 1.56 million global workforce, though Jassy didn't specify which departments or how many positions would be eliminated. The company has already laid off more than 27,000 employees since 2022, including recent cuts to its devices and services units. Amazon CEO says AI revolution already underway at company by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Switch to UnionBank Rewards Card UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Amazon is deploying generative AI across virtually every business unit, from its Alexa+ personal assistant to shopping features and advertising tools. "In our fulfillment network, we're using AI to improve inventory placement, demand forecasting, and the efficiency of our robots," Jassy explained. The company currently has "over 1,000 Generative AI services and applications in progress or built," but Jassy emphasized this represents just "a small fraction of what we will ultimately build." He described AI agents as software systems that can perform complex tasks, from web research to code writing, predicting "billions of these agents, across every company and in every imaginable field." Jassy to employees: Adapt or risk obsolescence Jassy advised workers to embrace the transformation, writing: "Be curious about AI, educate yourself, attend workshops and take trainings, use and experiment with AI whenever you can." He emphasized that employees should learn "how to get more done with scrappier teams." "Those who embrace this change, become conversant in AI, help us build and improve our AI capabilities internally and deliver for customers, will be well-positioned to have high impact," Jassy stated. Amazon joins other tech companies making similar workforce predictions. Shopify CEO Tobi Lütke recently told employees they must prove they "cannot get what they want done using AI" before requesting additional resources, while Klarna has reduced its headcount by 40% partly due to AI investments. Jassy called generative AI "the most transformative technology since the Internet" and "a once-in-a-lifetime reinvention of everything we know," signaling Amazon's commitment to AI-driven operational changes despite potential job losses. AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Time of India
15 minutes ago
- Time of India
Akshat Shrivastava on exam race in India: 'There is life outside IIT/ UPSC/ CAT/ NEET. Your talent could be used to...'
In a country where academic milestones like IIT , UPSC , CAT , and NEET are often valued more, a growing chorus of voices is urging young Indians to look beyond entrance exams for validation and purpose. Financial educator Akshat Shrivastava recently sparked a thought-provoking conversation on LinkedIn , highlighting the often-unspoken reality of India's exam-centric culture — and the personal toll it takes on countless aspirants. Shrivastava recounted meeting a student who had spent four years preparing for the UPSC, only to fail. The same student then invested two more years chasing the CAT dream — and failed again. After nearly six years of relentless preparation and crushing setbacks, he is now struggling to rebuild his confidence and career. But instead of blaming the student, Shrivastava pointed to a deeper systemic flaw. In his view, the odds today are so steep that even talented, hard-working individuals are being filtered out, not because they lack merit, but because the competition is brutally disproportionate. With limited seats, the presence of reservations, and millions chasing a handful of spots, these exams are no longer a true measure of capability, according to him. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Godrej Majesty | Luxurious 3 & 4 BHK Homes at ₹2.39 Cr* Godrej Majesty Learn More Undo — Akshat_World (@Akshat_World) He believes there's a better path: using that same energy to build real-world skills, start small ventures, learn on the job, or explore emerging career paths that don't require beating impossible odds. Shrivastava argues that preparing endlessly for exams is not the only—or even the most reliable—route to success. His message is clear and empowering: You're not a failure if you don't clear an exam. Your value isn't tied to a rank. There is life and success beyond IIT, UPSC, CAT, and NEET. Netizens react Several users resonated deeply with the message that preparing for an exam is not a job. One pointed out how government exams today are incredibly competitive, with lakhs of applicants vying for a handful of vacancies. Coupled with systemic issues like reservation complexities, corruption, and scandals such as the SSC scam, many felt it was not worth spending years chasing such uncertain outcomes. Another user highlighted a broader concern — not just an exam crisis, but an imagination crisis. They argued that the current system rewards rote memorisation and punishes those who don't succeed with lifelong shame, even though the real world values adaptability and innovation over academic ranks. Many agreed that the focus should shift from just passing exams to building real, market-ready skills. Others emphasised the importance of developing practical capabilities. The modern job market , they said, no longer favors toppers alone, but rather those who can problem-solve, create, communicate, and execute. In a world driven by results, resumes packed with marks matter less than demonstrable skills and real-world impact.
Time of India
16 minutes ago
- Time of India
Battery makers sweat as antimony shortage hits after China's export curbs
MELBOURNE: When China restricts exports of a key mineral, sometimes the pain is sudden and even crippling - enough to spur a major outcry almost immediately. Other times, it takes longer to be felt. For the world's makers of lead-acid batteries, China's restrictions on critical mineral antimony that were put in place late last year have become a major headache - one that their customers also now have as sky-high procurement costs are passed on. "We consider it a national emergency," said Steve Christensen , executive director at the U.S.-based Responsible Battery Coalition, whose members include battery maker Clarios, Honda and FedEx. Play Video Pause Skip Backward Skip Forward Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration 0:00 Loaded : 0% 0:00 Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 1x Playback Rate Chapters Chapters Descriptions descriptions off , selected Captions captions settings , opens captions settings dialog captions off , selected Audio Track Picture-in-Picture Fullscreen This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Opaque Semi-Transparent Text Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Caption Area Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Drop shadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Soluciones para subir escaleras sin obras ni esfuerzo Stair Lifts Haz clic aquí Undo He noted the key role batteries play in industry and civilian life, how antimony is used in military equipment, as well as the surge in spot prices. Antimony now costs more than $60,000 per metric ton, having more than quadrupled over the past year. "There are no quick solutions... We were completely caught off guard collectively, as an industry," he said. Live Events China likely produced 60% of all antimony supply in 2024, according to the United States Geological Survey. Much of antimony mined in other countries is also sent to China for processing. Beijing added the mineral to its export control list last September, requiring companies to gain licences for each overseas antimony deal. It then followed up in December with an outright ban on shipments to the U.S. - an action seen as retaliatory after Washington further restricted exports of advanced semiconductors to Chinese companies. China's global exports of antimony are now just a third of levels seen this time last year. Christensen said U.S. companies are hugely reliant on China for their supply of antimony and buyers are increasingly having to procure from an emerging "grey market", where sellers that have stocked up on the material are charging extremely high prices. China's restrictions on antimony precede its controls on rare earths and rare earth magnets that were imposed in response to U.S. President Donald Trump's tariffs and do not appear to have been discussed in last week's efforts to stabilise a truce in trade tensions between the two countries. Last week's talks between China and the U.S. also did not include any agreement on specialised rare earths such as samarium needed for military applications. Vulnerable Lead-acid batteries, commonly found in gasoline-engine vehicles, are mostly used to start the engine and to power low-voltage instruments. They are also used as sources of backup power in various industries and to store excess energy generated by solar and wind systems. In addition to batteries, antimony is also essential to military equipment such as night vision goggles, navigation systems and ammunition. Overall antimony demand is some 230,000-240,000 tonnes a year with lead-acid batteries accounting for about a third of that, according to consultancy Project Blue. While many battery makers may have access to antimony-lead alloy from recycled materials, Project Blue estimates they collectively need around 10,000 tonnes a year of higher purity antimony to top up the alloy to reach the right battery properties. Securing that additional portion could be challenging. Project Blue director Nils Backeberg said there is enough antimony outside China to satisfy non-Chinese demand but buyers need to compete with Chinese purchasers such as the country's huge solar industry, and China's smelters are able to offer better terms. "With antimony prices at nearly 5x normal market conditions, the cost becomes a factor and with supply limited on the Western market, a shortage is being felt," he said. For now, it seems that battery makers' antimony woes have not yet led to cuts in output, with companies like Germany's Hoppecke saying they have managed to pass on higher costs. Japan's GS Yuasa said it has passed on costs to some customers and is negotiating with more of its customers to do so. One source at an Indian battery maker said antimony represented only a small cost of a battery and price increases were being passed onto customers, but any more price rises could spell trouble. "If the price does increase further, everyone (in the industry) will be vulnerable," said the source who was not authorised to speak to the media and declined to be identified. The companies and the source at the Indian battery maker declined to disclose the size of their product price hikes. In a sign that profits are being affected, India's Exide Industries blamed high prices for antimony when it logged smaller-than-expected income for its fourth quarter. Christensen of the Responsible Battery Coalition said policymakers should treat the issue as one of national security, arguing that Western countries had become "overly reliant on a single geopolitical adversary for minerals foundational to both national defense and civilian life." "For the U.S., the path forward must include onshoring processing capacity, scaling domestic recycling, and building strategic mineral alliances with trusted partners. Otherwise, this crisis will repeat itself again and again," he added. Some baby steps towards building an antimony supply chain outside of China are being taken. Clarios, owned by global investment firm Brookfield, said last month it was scouting locations for an up to $1 billion critical minerals processing and recovery plant in the U.S. that will extract antimony among other minerals. Nyrstar, owned by global commodity trader Trafigura, also said last month it could produce antimony at its South Australian metals processing plant but would need government support to do so.
