Country dialysis patient faces choice of moving to Adelaide or stopping treatment
These are the options Chris Thomas, a 68-year-old Crystal Brooke resident in the mid-north of South Australia, faces.
The retired farmer has been receiving treatment in the Lyell McEwin Hospital in Adelaide since May after he had two major cardiac arrests while undergoing rehabilitation following the amputation of a leg.
This is in addition to him needing regular dialysis, treatment he had been receiving in Port Pirie for the past four years.
Given his complex medical conditions, Mr Thomas was told he was not medically fit to be discharged from hospital or for transfer to Port Pirie.
So now he and his family are facing the tough choice: move to Adelaide or effectively give up medical support.
His daughter Alex Thomas was disappointed more effort hadn't been made to find alternative options for her father given he had lived in the country his whole life and didn't want to move to the city.
"And that when you're vulnerable and when you reach your 11th hour of life that you're going to be able to stay within your home no matter what your postcode is."
Ms Thomas has made an impassioned plea to SA Health to investigate options that would allow her father to return home and keep receiving treatment.
"I want them to honour his desire to go home," she said.
"I want them to cease discriminating against him because he lives in a regional area."
SA Health Minister Chris Picton said his office had reached out to Mr Thomas's family, and there would be a senior medical review of his case to "see what options could be available".
"We provide dialysis services right across the state, but there are obviously some levels of medical conditions that people have where they do need to be in a tertiary hospital setting," Mr Picton said.
"Ultimately, in a state like South Australia, we can't provide the quaternary level of hospital care and the sub-speciality level of hospital care in each locality of everywhere across regional South Australia.
Satellite dialysis units and home dialysis services are available across a number of the state's metropolitan and regional health services, but are designed to care for less complex and lower-risk patients.
In a statement, SA Health extended its "sincerest sympathies to Mr Thomas and his family, who are navigating an incredibly difficult time".
"Due to Mr Thomas's ongoing, high-risk medical issues, he is not medically fit for discharge from Lyell McEwin Hospital, or for transfer to Port Pirie," the statement said.
"The health and wellbeing of our patients is always our priority.
Ms Thomas however said that it was important to her dad, who had worked as a farmer and pastoralist as well as at Roxby Downs, that he spend the rest of his days living and receiving treatment in the bush.
"It's his choice, no-one is more acutely aware of his mortality than he is," Ms Thomas said.
"If he moves to Adelaide he is going to be grossly isolated from everything he has ever known.
SA Health staff said at no stage had Mr Thomas or his family been advised that he should withdraw from medical care.
The Port Pirie Satellite Dialysis Unit offers expert care in renal dialysis; like other satellite dialysis units, Port Pirie offers care for stable, lower-complexity patients.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Battling flu season and sick kids? Here's what the experts say you should do
Every parent has been there — your child is sick with a nasty virus, you're worried and not sure what to do. Do you call your GP? A health line? Or do you drive them straight to the hospital emergency department? We've asked the experts for their tips for parents as cold and flu season gathers pace. Let's get straight to the most important stuff to look out for. GP and president of the Australian Medical Association (AMA), Danielle McMullen, has a crucial message for parents. "The first thing is that there's no such thing as overreacting. As a parent you know your child best," Dr McMullen said. "If your child has had a fever for more than five days, we always want to check in. Or if your child is less than three months old and has any fever — 38 degrees and above — we recommend actually taking them either urgently to the GP or to the emergency department," Dr McMullen said. She said children who have had a seizure, are in severe pain or are struggling to eat or breathe because of mucus need to see a GP or head to emergency. The same applies for new rashes or behavioural concerns. "If they're either more sleepy than you would expect and you're really having difficulty rousing them or … if your child is so unwell and irritable that you really can't calm them down and you're worried about how they're behaving, then get some medical advice. Earaches are common at this time of year and experts recommend seeing a GP if your child has been complaining of a sore ear for 24 to 48 hours. "We don't expect parents to know and be able to tell the difference between a minor illness and a severe one. So, if you're worried you bring them in and then it's my job to help work [it] out," Dr McMullen said. Parents should feel empowered to call for help if they're worried about their unwell child, medical experts said. "Ultimately, I very much trust families. If you're worried, it's good to seek medical help," paediatrician Sarah McNab, director of general medicine at the Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne, said. "If your child seems to be getting worse rather than better, if you're worried about their breathing, or that they're drowsy or confused, then seeking medical advice is what you should be doing." Dr McNab said if a child was "pale and mottled" they should get medical help. "Or if you don't feel that they're drinking enough to stay hydrated, then I would seek medical advice and in that case I would consider going to your GP, organising a telehealth or some states have a virtual emergency department that is really helpful at letting you know whether you should come in person or not," she said. You can call Health Direct on 1800 022 222, your GP, or take you child to the emergency department. For emergencies, call 000. Don't hesitate to give regular pain relief to sick kids. "The mainstay of treatment of coughs and colds in childhood and in viral illnesses is rest, plenty of fluids, because the main risk is dehydration, and paracetamol or ibuprofen helps alleviate their symptoms so that they can sleep and keep their fluids up," Dr McMullen said. And for kids with low fevers, who are a bit grumbly and snotty but are still alert and playing, love is also an "excellent medicine". "These viral illnesses, there's not much we can do to get them better quicker and so it is about giving them a cuddle, some reassurance … to get them feeling a little bit better. "It's rest and love and nurturing that is really all that will get them through it. "The good news is that icy poles count as fluids, so if you can't get them to be drinking water or watered down juice, then those icy blocks are a good way to keep their fluids up." Not exactly, Dr McMullen said. "Cold and flu respiratory illnesses spread through the air and droplets and so when it's cold outside and we've huddled indoors with all the doors and windows closed, we're more likely to spread illness between people. "So that's why we get that seasonal spread." And of course staying up to date with vaccinations is also important.
SBS Australia
2 hours ago
- SBS Australia
Is Australia's tall poppy syndrome the same as the Philippines' crab mentality?
Tall poppy syndrome in Australia punishes success by cutting down high achievers, while crab mentality in the Philippines involves pulling others down out of envy. Though culturally distinct, both discourage ambition and foster negativity. A study from ANU shows nearly 50% of professionals in Australia have experienced tall poppy syndrome. Meanwhile, 63% of overseas Filipinos surveyed by SWS reported experiencing envy or sabotage from fellow Pinoys. Dr Torres-Villanueva advises building strong support networks and understanding local workplace culture. 📢 Where to Catch SBS Filipino
News.com.au
3 hours ago
- News.com.au
Woman attacked by lion at Darling Downs Zoo undergoes second round of surgery
The woman who lost her arm to a lion at a Queensland zoo will undergo another round of surgery, days after the attack. Joanne Cabban lost her arm in a lion attack shortly before 8.30am on Sunday at Darling Downs Zoo near Toowoomba. The NSW teacher, the sister of Stephanie Robinson, who owns the zoo with her husband Steve, was rushed to Princess Alexandra Hospital in Brisbane to undergo emergency surgery. On Thursday, Ms Cabban will undergo another round of surgery for her arm, which was mauled by the lioness. Mr Robinson told reporters the incident was not 'an attack' and believed the lion was 'just playing'. He explained his sister-in-law was not holding the lioness during the incident and was familiar with the big cats over the zoo's 20-year history. 'We've raised these lions ourselves,' he told reporters on Tuesday. 'Their temperaments are excellent. We can still interact with them through the mesh of the cage.' He said a staff member was nearby when the incident occurred and acted quickly to treat the woman. 'She actually took my wife's leather belt off and applied a tourniquet,' he said. 'Very quickly, the first aid kit was there, we wrapped her up in a thermal blanket and the paramedics locally were here very, very quickly.' He told reporters the zoo had never experienced a lion attack before. 'We've got theories but until we get fact, I'm not going to be speculating or running with any what ifs or maybes or anything like that,' he said. 'We're still processing in our minds and coming to grips with not just what happened but what happens next.' The zoo shared a statement on Monday announcing that it would reopen as normal and confirmed the lioness 'would not be put down or punished in any way'. Darling Downs Zoo opened in 2005 and specialises in captive husbandry and breeding of critically endangered and vulnerable species.
