Bring back Rwanda scheme to end small boats crisis, says architect of Australia's successful migrant crackdown
Alexander Downer called on the Prime Minister to 'eat a bit of political humble pie' and resurrect the scheme, which was scrapped last year in one of Starmer's first acts after being elected into No 10.
Sir Keir insisted the deportation scheme was a £700million 'gimmick' which did nothing to cut migrant Channel crossings.
But Mr Downer, who was Australia's minister for foreign affairs from 1996 to 2007, claimed the move was a 'tragedy' and believes it could have worked if the legal issues surrounding it 'could be properly addressed'.
'It would have worked assuming the legal issues could be properly addressed — and they were being,' he told the Sun.
'So the easiest thing for them to do would be to eat a bit of political humble pie and reinstitute the Rwanda scheme.'
Just earlier this week, Downing Street admitted the situation in the Channel was 'deteriorating' as the number of migrants reaching the UK topped 2,000 in a week for the first time in 21 months.
The 2,222 arrivals over seven days meant an average of one migrant reached Britain every four-and-a-half minutes.
Mr Downer has previously expressed his belief in having a zero-tolerance policy when it comes to illegal migration.
The former foreign minister was one of the masterminds behind Australia's crackdown on illegal immigration in the early 2000s, which sought to punish migrants who arrived on the country's shores by boat.
This meant sending them by boat to detention centres in Papua New Guinea and the Pacific island of Nauru, where migrants would be offered to return to their home countries and refugees were told they could resettle in another.
'Once word got round that if you tried to get into Australia by boat you would not be allowed in and would be sent to Papua New Guinea instead, they ran out of customers. The smugglers' businesses closed down,' he previously said.
The Tony Abbott government claimed a 90 per cent reduction in maritime arrivals of asylum seekers once the policy was introduced in 2013. There were 207 arrivals in November that year, opposed to 2,629 in November 2012.
Starmer has pledged to crack down on smuggling gangs that bring people into the UK in small boats, including by targeting criminal networks overseas.
Last month he said the Government would start talks with other countries on 'return hubs' for failed asylum seekers, which would see failed asylum seekers sent for processing in third countries prior to deportation.
The PM admitted these would not be a 'silver bullet' for halting the crossings, but the proposal is expected to act as a deterrent.
Last week's crossing total was the most since September 2023, when the former Tory government's Rwanda policy was still in legal limbo.
It tipped the total since Labour came to power at last July's general election past the 40,000 mark, hitting 40,276.
Since the start of this year, 17,034 migrants have reached Britain, up 38 per cent on the same period last year. The figure does not include hundreds more who reached Dover yesterday.
Reform leader Nigel Farage said it was 'about time' Britain faced up to the fact it was 'our fault' – rather than France's – that so many migrants head here. 'We will never stop the boats from leaving France,' he told broadcaster Talk.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
11 minutes ago
- The Independent
Rise in no-fault evictions despite Labour's pledge to ban them
Thousands of people have had their homes seized after receiving controversial 'no-fault' eviction notices despite Labour pledging to abolish them, new data shows. Labour said in its election manifesto it would abolish Section 21 eviction notices 'immediately' after winning the election. A year on, and the relevant legislation still progressing through parliament means that the ban is still not in effect. According to Ministry of Justice figures released on Thursday, 11,400 households received no-fault evictions by bailiffs in the year to June. The number of bailiff evictions is an eight per cent rise on the previous year, continuing a trend of a heightened use of the notices. Housing charity Shelter said it is 'unconscionable' that renters 'continue to be marched out of their homes by bailiffs' a year after Labour 's election victory. It warned that nearly 1,000 households could be evicted from their homes by bailiffs every month until the ban on the notices is finally put in place. Section 21 notices grant landlords the power to evict tenants from their properties at two months' notice without needing to give any reason. Former prime minister Theresa May first announced the Conservatives' intention to abolish Section 21 notices in April 2019. Shelter described no-fault evictions as one of the leading causes of homelessness. Mairi MacRae, its director of campaigns and policy, said: "It is unconscionable that more than a year after the government came to power, thousands of renters continue to be marched out of their homes by bailiffs because of an unfair policy that the government said would be scrapped immediately. 'For far too long, tenants' lives have been thrown into turmoil by the rank injustice of 'no-fault' evictions. At the whim of private landlords, thousands of tenants are being left with just two months to find a new home, plunging them into a ruthless rental market and leaving many exposed to the riptide of homelessness.' The government's Renters' Rights Bill, sponsored by the Ministry of Housing, is currently in its final stages. It is expected to pass before the end of the year, or early 2026 at the latest. Alongside abolishing Section 21 notices, it would give tenants a 12-month protected period at the beginning of their tenancy, alongside increasing the notice requirement for landlords to evict on other grounds from two to four months. The bill would also provide protection against 'backdoor eviction ', where tenants are effectively pushed out by above-market rent increases, by giving them greater powers to challenge them. Housing charity Crisis has called on the government to bring forward the legislation and name a date when it will be implemented. Matt Downie, chief executive at Crisis, said: 'Despite good intentions from the Westminster government, thousands of people are still being unjustly evicted from their homes and threatened with – or even forced into – homelessness.' The new data comes after Labour MP Rushanara Ali recently resigned her role as homelessness minister following reports she gave tenants in a property she owned four months' notice to leave, before relisting the property with a £700 rent increase just weeks later. Such a move would likely not be allowed under the Renters' Rights Bill, which is set to introduce new protections for tenants, including banning landlords who evict tenants in order to sell their property from relisting it for rent for six months. A Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government spokesperson said: 'No one should live in fear of a Section 21 eviction and these new figures show exactly why we will abolish them through our Renters' Rights Bill, which is a manifesto commitment and legislative priority for this government. 'We're determined to level the playing field by providing tenants with greater security, rights and protections in their homes and our landmark reforms will be implemented swiftly after the bill becomes law.'
Daily Mail
12 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Charity which asked children as young as five to write Valentine's Day cards for asylum seekers is reported to watchdog
A charity which asked children as young as five to write Valentine's Day cards for asylum seekers has been reported to a watchdog. Schools of Sanctuary, a small refugee-sector charity, launched the programme in primary schools across Britain last year. On February 14, 2024, children were asked to send messages of 'love and solidarity' by making handmade cards for asylum seekers. Slogans inside cards included, 'You're welcome here!', and 'I love refugee rights, stop the Rwanda scheme.' In another card, an accompanying poem read: 'Roses are red, violets are blue, refugees are people, just like me and you.' Schoolchildren were also encouraged to discuss topics such as 'kindness, humanity, and equality', and to raise money for local charities with their class or wider school. Some cards featured an orange heart, which represents compassion for those fleeing war and is inspired by the refugee nation flag, according to Together With Refugees. Regarding the matter, Laura Trott, the shadow education secretary, previously said 'children as young as five shouldn't be used to push political agendas'. And now, Sir Gavin Williamson, former Tory Education Secretary, has asked the Charity Commission to probe the branch of the City of Sanctuary charity. He alleged Schools of Sanctuary were 'engaging in political activity', and acting in a way that was not 'consistent with its charitable purpose', The Telegraph reported. And while a Commission spokesperson confirmed has received a complaint of 'alleged political activity' concerning City of Sanctuary, it has yet to make any decision. On its website, the Schools of Sanctuary described itself as 'a registered charity and therefore apolitical. 'Our primary focus is the dignity and humanity of individuals seeking safety and the creation of a kinder, more compassionate society – not the politics surrounding immigration policies.' However, the MP said there were 'numerous' examples where the charity acted politically, including their Valentine's Day Card scheme. He argued such initiatives encouraged people to participate in 'overtly political activity', noting a post including a card which read: 'Stop the Rwanda Scheme'. The former education secretary also claimed the charity's literature referred to the UK's asylum system as 'deliberately hostile' to those fleeing to Britain. Its resource pack also said government legislation fed into 'anti-immigrant sentiment, racism, and stressing community cohesion.' The Charity Commission has yet to reach a conclusion on the report, but if it decides to launch an inquiry and misconduct is found, it can instruct a charity to take action. Among the local authorities to partner with the Schools of Sanctuary Network is Labour-run Birmingham City Council. While teachers cannot promote political views in the classroom there is no suggestion that writing the Valentine's Day cards broke the law. A City of Sanctuary UK spokesperson said: 'We follow all Charity Commission guidelines and are confident that we are working within our charitable aims, we will fully cooperate with any Charity Commission investigation.'
The Guardian
12 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Minns unveils plan to fight anti-Muslim hate: ‘Naked racism and Islamophobia have no place in our state'
The Minns government will establish a $1m program to combat anti-Muslim hate, including establishing a support hotline for victims and a program to build awareness of Islamophobia. The initiative will fund a support hotline for those experiencing Islamophobia and a case management system for victims of abuse so authorities and the community have better information about what behaviours are being experienced. The funds will also be used to build support services for people who are impacted and to provide training programs to police responding to Islamophobic attacks. The grant comes after a huge turnout for a pro-Palestine march across the Sydney Harbour Bridge. Police estimated 90,000 people turned out, but organisers estimated the figure was closer to 300,000. The march was opposed by the premier, Chris Minns, on public safety grounds but was permitted to go ahead after organisers successfully appealed to the supreme court. Minns' stance caused internal dissent within the NSW Labor party, particularly among MPs whose seats have large Muslim populations, who saw Minns' response as tone-deaf to the concerns of the community. 'Anecdotal evidence presented to me indicates that Islamophobia is far higher than what is reported, we don't want Australians suffering in silence or enduring racism without help or support,' Minns said as he announced the program. 'Naked racism and Islamophobia have no place in our state or our country and it is abhorrent that people perpetuate this sort of behaviour,' he said. Sign up: AU Breaking News email The Action Against Islamophobia program, which will administer the grant, is run by the Australian National Imams Council (ANIC). The ANIC president, Imam Shadi Alsuleiman, said there had been a rise in anti-Muslim hate which had left many Muslims anxious about engaging in their daily religious activities, such as praying in mosques or leaving the house wearing the hijab. 'Islamophobia manifests itself in the community in several different ways, and we've seen an increase in micro aggressions that are often brushed off as ignorance or rude behaviour,' he said. 'Understanding how Muslims experience Islamophobia will help guide our approach to combating the issue on a holistic level.' The Scanlon Foundation's most recent 2024 Mapping Social Cohesion report showed negative attitudes towards Muslims remain by far the highest towards any single faith group for more than 10 years. Negative attitudes towards Muslims rose from 27% in 2023 to 34% in 2024, according to the survey. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion The Islamophobia Register Australia has recorded a surge of over 530% in Islamophobic incidents being reported since 7 October 2023 to July 2025, with more than 1,500 cases reported to the body. 'This program will play a critical role in providing support to those who have been affected by this hatred while also spreading awareness of the importance of rejecting racism in all its forms,' the minister for multiculturalism, Steve Kamper, said. 'To safeguard our vibrant multiculturalism, we must ensure we're putting the plans in place to stamp out hatred, like that faced by our Muslim community,' he said. The NSW government has already taken steps to combat the rise in antisemitic incidents in NSW that escalated in the wake of the conflict in the Middle East. In February it passed controversial new laws cracking down on hate speech, offensive Nazi symbols, and desecration and harassment at places of worship. Minns said that these laws would protect not only Jewish people but members of all faiths and their places of worship. The Executive Council of Australian Jewry has reported that in the 12 months that followed 7 October 2023, there was a 316% increase in the overall number of reported antisemitic incidents in Australia compared to the same period in the previous year.
